Lecture 4-1: The Kalam Cosmological Argument
The kalam argument says the universe began and so has a cause, and the lecture states carefully how far that conclusion reaches.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The kalam argument says the universe began and so has a cause, and the lecture states carefully how far that conclusion reaches.
Christian Apologetics
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
In William Lane Craig's formulation, the kalam argument runs: everything that begins to exist has a cause; the universe began to exist; therefore the universe has a cause. It is a valid syllogism, so if both premises are true the conclusion follows. The whole weight rests on defending the two premises.
Nobody seriously expects a horse, a house or a headache to appear out of nothing. Craig argues this is not just an observed pattern but close to a properly basic intuition, grounded in the principle that being cannot come from absolute non-being. The principle goes back to Parmenides: ex nihilo nihil fit, "out of nothing, nothing comes."
Al-Ghazali argued that an actual infinite cannot exist in the physical world, even though infinite sets are coherent in mathematics. Hilbert's Hotel, with infinitely many rooms all full, can still take a new guest by shifting every occupant down one room. Craig argues this yields absurdities, so the past cannot be an infinite regress and must have a beginning.
Hubble's observation that distant galaxies are moving away pointed to an expanding universe, and running the expansion backward leads to a hot, dense start a finite time ago. In 2003, Borde, Guth and Vilenkin proved a theorem that an average-expanding universe cannot be past-eternal. It applies to many models proposed as alternatives to a beginning.
The scientific evidence corroborates premise two but does not by itself prove it. Cosmological models change, and the theorem has caveats debated even by its co-authors. A student should resist claiming that science proves the Bible right more strongly than working cosmologists would claim it.
A cause of all space and time is reasonably described as spaceless and timeless, and a cause of all matter and energy as immaterial. Bringing a universe into being makes it unimaginably powerful. Craig adds that a timeless impersonal cause would produce a changeless effect, so the cause is plausibly a personal agent who freely chooses.
That conclusion maps onto several classical divine attributes. It is not yet an argument for the Trinity, the incarnation, the God of the exodus or the resurrection of Jesus. Those need separate arguments, several of which come in chapters 5 through 7. Students should state exactly what the argument delivers and stop there.
The lecture asks you to state the argument from memory.
Which of the two premises do you find more intuitively obvious, and why?
The kalam argument is a valid two-premise syllogism, so everything depends on whether the premises are true. Science corroborates a beginning but does not prove it, and the conclusion is not yet the Christian God. State what it delivers, a powerful and plausibly personal first cause, and then stop.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.