FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-1: The Quest for the Historical Jesus

The quest for the historical Jesus has had three waves, and two working tools help historians weigh what the sources report.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe, in outline, the three "quests" for the historical Jesus and name what changed between them.
  • State and apply, in your own words, the criteria of multiple independent attestation and embarrassment.
  • Explain why this course treats "third quest" scholarship as its historically careful baseline, and name at least one limit of that choice.
  • Distinguish a historical claim about Jesus from a theological claim about Jesus, while explaining why the two are not unrelated.
The old quest

Schweitzer's verdict

The phrase "quest for the historical Jesus" comes from Albert Schweitzer's 1906 book. The first quest, from roughly the 1770s to 1906, tried to separate the Jesus of history from the Christ of faith. Schweitzer concluded that each scholar's reconstructed Jesus tended to reflect that scholar's own ideals.

Key idea His critique landed hard enough that serious work stalled for a generation.
The new quest

Reopening the question

In a 1953 lecture, Ernst Käsemann reopened the question against his teacher Rudolf Bultmann's near-total skepticism about recoverable detail. This smaller, cautious revival proposed more disciplined criteria. The most important was dissimilarity: material that fits awkwardly with both Jesus's Jewish context and the early church's interests is less likely to have been invented by either.

Key idea The new quest began in the 1950s.
The third quest

Taking Jewish context seriously

The third quest, from the late 1970s, is the largest wave. E. P. Sanders's 1985 Jesus and Judaism is often treated as a landmark. Its scholars include committed Christians, a Jewish historian of religion and a prominent skeptic. What unites them is method: reading Jesus as a Jew addressing other Jews about the future of Israel.

Key idea Ignoring Jesus's Jewishness had been a methodological error in earlier quests.
Debate

Same method, different Jesus

Sanders

His Jesus is an eschatological prophet expecting Israel's imminent restoration.

Wright

His Jesus consciously enacts and reinterprets Israel's story around himself.

Ehrman

His Jesus is an apocalyptic preacher whose followers reinterpreted his death after the fact.

Tool one

Multiple independent attestation

A saying or event reported in more than one source that did not copy from each other carries more historical weight. Scholars typically count at least four broadly independent strands behind the Gospels: Mark, the hypothetical sayings source Q, material unique to Luke, and material unique to John. Paul's letters, earlier than any Gospel, form a fifth, non-narrative strand.

Key idea A claim attested across several strands is historically stronger.
Tool two

Embarrassment

A detail that would have been awkward for the early church to invent is more likely to be authentic. The standard example is Jesus's baptism by John. All four Gospels report it despite the theological difficulty, and Matthew visibly works to explain the awkwardness (3:14-15) rather than removing the event.

Key idea A community inventing material has no motive to invent what works against its purposes.
A caution

Neither tool gives certainty

Multiple attestation can be satisfied by material that several early Christians independently believed for non-historical reasons. Embarrassment needs real judgment about what would have embarrassed a first-century audience, not a modern one. Historians who use these tools well treat them as raising or lowering probability.

Key idea They do not settle a question by themselves.
Course baseline

Method, not conclusion

The course uses third-quest scholarship as its baseline because it takes Jesus's first-century Jewish setting most seriously. That is a claim about method, not that every third-quest conclusion is correct. It does not settle the theological questions that lectures 6-2 and 6-3 go on to ask.

Key idea Historical method is the necessary first step, not the last one.
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

There have been three quests, and a shared method is not a shared conclusion. Multiple attestation and embarrassment raise or lower probability without producing certainty. Distinguish what history can say about Jesus from what faith confesses, and be honest that serious scholars reach different conclusions.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12