FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-3: The Cross as God's Answer

A sound argument can fail to comfort, so the problem of evil needs both philosophical defense and pastoral presence.

Christian Apologetics

13 cards 19 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why a logically sound answer to the problem of evil can still fail to comfort a suffering person, and why that failure is not a mark against the argument's validity.
  • State the theological claim behind Hebrews 4:15–16 — that God in Christ has actually experienced human suffering and temptation — and explain how this differs in kind, not just in degree, from the philosophical defenses of 8-1 and 8-2.
  • Describe John 11:35 in its narrative context and explain what the shortest verse in the Bible contributes to this chapter's argument.
  • Identify at least one concrete difference between how an apologist should speak in a seminar and how a pastor, friend, or fellow believer should speak at a hospital bed, and explain why that difference is not a retreat from truth.
A change of register

From argument to presence

8-1 and 8-2 stayed in the register of argument: premises, objections and replies. This lecture changes register on purpose, without abandoning philosophy. A philosophically sound answer is not the same as a comfort adequate to a person who is actually suffering. Christianity's most distinctive response is a claim about who God is and what God has done: in Jesus Christ, God entered human suffering.

Key idea The earlier lectures remain true and necessary.
Limits

What a good argument cannot do

Even the best philosophical answer does very little for a person in the room where suffering is happening. Telling a parent at a child's hospital bed about a possible world with free creatures says nothing false, but it is almost cruelly beside the point. An argument answers a question of the intellect. A person in acute grief is usually enduring something the will and heart must carry.

Key idea This is not a defect in the arguments. It is a fact about what arguments are for.
At a glance

Two registers, both necessary

Philosophical defense

It answers a question of the intellect: is belief in God rationally defensible given evil? It does not, by itself, comfort a person in acute grief.

Pastoral presence

It answers a need of the will and heart, which is not to suffer alone. It does not, by itself, resolve a genuine intellectual objection.

Hebrews 4

A God who has been there

Hebrews 4:15 speaks of a high priest who has been "in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin." The word "tempted" is read broadly, as testing and trial. The claim is that God the Son entered creaturely limitation and suffering as such, such as hunger, betrayal, pain and grief. A defense says it is possible God has a good reason. Hebrews 4 says God in Christ has paid a cost of that same kind.

Key idea This answer differs in kind, not just in degree, from a defense or a theodicy.
Careful limits

What the claim does not say

The claim is not that Jesus experienced every particular form of suffering any person has faced. Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions work out differently how the divine and human natures relate in Christ's suffering. That belongs to Christology, not to this chapter. All agree the suffering was genuinely experienced by the incarnate Son, not merely observed by an unaffected deity.

Key idea The lecture rests on the basic claim that the Son truly suffered.
John 11:35

"Jesus wept"

In John's account Jesus already knows he is about to raise Lazarus, and yet he weeps before Mary's grief and the tomb. This rules out the reading that his suffering was only apparent, a performance by someone who knew the ending. Hope for the future does not erase the legitimacy of grief in the present. A theology that used future resurrection to wave away grief today would misread its own central story.

Key idea Even knowing the resolution, Jesus grieves the present loss.
Lament

Lament is not a failure of faith

Roughly a third of the Psalms are laments, and the Bible does not treat naming pain honestly to God as a lapse in faith. Psalm 34:18 says Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart. Lamentations holds the "new every morning" hope of 3:22-23 beside largely unresolved grief. Romans 8:28 is a claim about God's faithfulness across a whole life, not a formula for the first hour of grief.

Key idea Scripture lets hope and grief sit side by side.
In practice

What the apologist owes

A student who has worked through Plantinga, Rowe, skeptical theism and soul-making theodicy is better equipped to sit with a grieving friend. They will not reach for a hollow answer under pressure. Knowing when to offer an argument and when to offer only presence and prayer is a skill the philosophy alone does not teach. Paul says the comfort we offer is modeled on comfort we ourselves received (2 Corinthians 1:3-4).

Key idea Sometimes the most faithful thing a reasoned defense can do is stay.
Think about it

Argument or presence?

The lecture asks you to imagine judging, in the moment, what a grieving person needs.

What cues would you look for, and what is the cost of guessing wrong in either direction?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

The problem of evil needs both philosophical argument and pastoral presence, and neither replaces the other. God in Christ has personally entered human suffering, and Jesus wept even knowing the resurrection was coming. The lecture does not say the earlier arguments are weak or that comfort can replace them.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13