FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

STEL1E · Chapter 11

Lecture 11-1: Cultural Apologetics - Story, Art, and Imagination

Story, art and imagination open a hearing for the faith, and the arguments of earlier chapters earn what follows.

Christian Apologetics

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what "cultural apologetics" means and how it differs from, and complements, the propositional apologetics this course has built up to this point.
  • Describe C. S. Lewis's move from formal apologetic argument toward fiction and myth, and state the reasoning behind it in his own terms.
  • Summarize the contribution of at least two contemporary voices in cultural apologetics, drawing on the work of Makoto Fujimura and Andy Crouch.
  • Explain, from Matthew 13:34-35, why Jesus taught habitually in parables rather than in the argumentative form this course has otherwise used, and state one limit of the parable form worth being honest about.
  • State one substantive limit of cultural apologetics on its own, and explain why this course treats imaginative and propositional apologetics as partners rather than as competitors.
A key idea

A second kind of persuasion

Cultural apologetics is the deliberate use of story, art, image and imagination to open a hearing for the faith. It works alongside reasoned argument and never replaces it. A story can make a listener feel the weight of an idea before any argument has been offered. The lecture says the earlier chapters supplied the premises, and this lecture is about the door they must be carried through.

Key idea Imagination opens a hearing for the argument.
Lewis

From syllogism to story

C. S. Lewis wrote formal arguments in Mere Christianity and then spent much of his career writing fiction and myth. He described the Narnia books as an imaginative "supposal": what Christ's redemptive work might look like in a world not our own. In "Myth Became Fact," he argued that story carries truth to the whole person, and that the Gospel is where myth and historical fact coincide.

Key idea Lewis did not stop writing argument when he began writing fiction.
Contemporary voices

Fujimura: culture care

Makoto Fujimura is a working visual artist who argues that a culture in crisis needs "culture care," the patient making of beauty. His practice draws on the Japanese technique of nihonga, using minerals ground by hand. He treats this slow process as theologically significant, because beauty made slowly and at cost resists a habit of consuming truth quickly.

Key idea Some truths are held more honestly in art that sits with difficulty.
Contemporary voices

Crouch: culture making

Andy Crouch argues that Christians too often take only three postures toward culture: condemning it, critiquing it, or copying it. He says the creation mandate of Genesis 1:28 calls for a fourth posture, making something new. A Christian who makes something genuinely good, such as writing, an honest business or a more livable neighborhood, has made an argument of a kind.

Key idea Making is a form of apologetic argument in its own right.
Scripture

Jesus taught by parable

Matthew 13:34 says that "without a parable, he didn't speak to them." Jesus told stories about a sower, a lost sheep and a prodigal son, and let them do work a stated argument might not do. A parable invites the hearer to enter the story and often to give a verdict on a character before seeing that it applies to them. Nathan's story to David in 2 Samuel 12:7 is the same pattern in miniature.

Key idea Matthew treats the parable as a deliberate method, not a concession.
At a glance

Strength and limit of the parable form

Strength

A story draws the hearer in and can produce recognition that a stated argument rarely does.

Limit

Matthew 13:10-15 records that parables also conceal as much as they reveal. The same story that opens one hearer can leave another where it found them.

A caution

Beauty is not evidence

A work of art does not, by itself, establish that a truth-claim is true. Imaginative work can move feelings without giving the hearer anything true to believe. A Christianity reduced to beautiful stories, with the historical and philosophical claims dropped, would not be the faith the course has defended. The lecture's claim is additive, not substitutive.

Key idea Imagination opens a hearing, and argument earns what follows.
Think about it

A door that opened

The lecture asks about a story, film, painting or piece of music that made a Christian claim feel worth taking seriously.

What did it do that a stated argument alone might not have done?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Story, art and parable can open a hearing, as Lewis, Fujimura, Crouch and Jesus show. They are partners with reasoned argument, not rivals. Pair good stories and good work with honest reasons, and expect that not everyone will be moved by the same door.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12