FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT201E Advanced Biblical Theology

Lecture 9-3: Israel and the Church — Three Positions, Stated Fairly

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 37
BT201E Advanced Biblical Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Advanced Biblical Theology
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Advanced Biblical Theology
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Architecture of Biblical Theology
  1. Lecture 1-1: Three Axes for Reading the Whole Canon
  2. Lecture 1-2: Tracing a Theme Without Inventing One
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Eight Storylines This Course Traces
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Kingdom of God
  1. Lecture 2-1: Creation Kingship and the Human Vocation
  2. Lecture 2-2: Israel's Monarchy and the Prophetic Hope
  3. Lecture 2-3: Jesus's Kingdom Proclamation
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Covenant Theology
  1. Lecture 3-1: Covenant Form — Treaty Structure and Its Biblical Adaptation
  2. Lecture 3-2: Covenant Signs and the Conditional/Unconditional Tension
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Three Maps — Covenant Theology, Dispensationalism, and Progressive Covenantalism
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Messiah - King, Priest, and Prophet
  1. Lecture 4-1: Anointing and the Formation of the Threefold Office
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Royal Messiah — Reading the Davidic Psalms
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Suffering Servant and the Integration of the Threefold Office
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Atonement
  1. Lecture 5-1: Blood, Sacrifice, and Substitution — Genesis to Leviticus
  2. Lecture 5-2: Ransom and Substitution — Passover to the Cross
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Atonement Models Debate — Victory, Substitution, or Kaleidoscope
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Temple Theology I - Presence and Dwelling
  1. Lecture 6-1: Was Eden a Sanctuary? The Evidence and Its Real Limits
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Loss of Presence and the Patriarchal Theophanies
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Tabernacle and Solomon's Temple — Presence Localized, and Its Real Danger
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Temple Theology II - Expansion and Fulfillment
  1. Lecture 7-1: "The Word Became Flesh, and Lived Among Us" — Christ as the Temple Storyline's Fulfillment
  2. Lecture 7-2: Jesus and the Temple System — Action, Prediction, and the Torn Veil
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Church and the Believer's Body as Temple, and the Templeless City of Revelation 21-22
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Spirit Through Redemptive History
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Spirit in Creation and the Old Testament's Occasional Empowering
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Promised Spirit and the Spirit in the Life of Jesus
  3. Lecture 8-3: Pentecost and the Continuationism-Cessationism Debate
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: The Theology of the People of God
  1. Lecture 9-1: The Call of Abraham and Israel's Missional Election
  2. Lecture 9-2: Covenant Signs and the Reinterpretation of the Boundary Markers
  3. Lecture 9-3: Israel and the Church — Three Positions, Stated Fairly
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: New Creation Theology
  1. Lecture 10-1: The Curse and Its Promised Reversal
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Formation of Resurrection Hope
  3. Lecture 10-3: New Creation Begun and Consummated — Continuity or Replacement?
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Integrating Biblical and Systematic Theology
  1. Lecture 11-1: Two Disciplines, One Text — Historical Unfolding and Topical Synthesis
  2. Lecture 11-2: A Real Case — Biblical Theology Correcting a Static Reading
  3. Lecture 11-3: A Real Case — Systematic Theology Correcting Biblical Theology, and What the Creeds Actually Are
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Synthesis - Reading the Whole Bible as One Story
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Eight Storylines, Rearranged as One Converging Picture
  2. Lecture 12-2: Eight Storylines Over Four Acts
  3. Lecture 12-3: Ruth, Read Whole — and This Course's Own Limits

Jump to the key points ↓

19 min

Lecture 9-1 traced Israel's election as missional from its first sentence. Lecture 9-2 traced how the boundary markers that made Israel visibly distinct were renegotiated once Gentiles began entering the same covenant people directly, without becoming ethnically Israel first. Both lectures deliberately stopped short of the question this one now takes up: given all of that, how do Israel and the church actually relate? Are they one people under two names at different points in one continuous history? Two peoples, kept theologically distinct, with real biblical promises to each that do not simply transfer from one to the other? Or something else — a relationship neither simple identity nor simple separation?

This is, by wide agreement among the scholars this course cites, one of the two or three most consequential live debates in contemporary theology — consequential not only for how a systematic doctrine of the church gets written, but for how Christians have actually related, and in some historical periods badly mistreated, actual Jewish communities living alongside them. Chapter 3 already introduced this same three-way disagreement from the side of the covenants as a system — covenant theology, dispensationalism, and progressive covenantalism, tested there against Galatians 3:15-17 and Romans 11:29. This lecture meets the identical three positions again, now from the side of a people rather than a promise, and deliberately does not re-run chapter 3's full argument; if you have not yet read lecture 3-3, its account of each position's core commitment is the fuller version of what this lecture summarizes briefly before applying it here.

What these 19 minutes give you

  • State the supersessionist (replacement) position on Israel and the church in terms a fair-minded proponent would recognize, and identify what historical and textual grounds its proponents typically cite.
  • State the dispensationalist position on Israel and the church in terms a fair-minded proponent would recognize, and identify what historical and textual grounds its proponents typically cite.
  • State the "one people of God" / progressive-covenantalist position on Israel and the church in terms a fair-minded proponent would recognize, and identify what historical and textual grounds its proponents typically cite.
  • Explain how each of the three positions would read Galatians 6:16's "Israel of God" and Romans 11:11's argument that Israel's "stumbling" did not mean its "falling," showing that each has a genuine textual case.
  • Identify at least one historical consequence of supersessionist readings that a fair treatment of this debate cannot pass over in silence, without thereby treating the position's contemporary, carefully-argued proponents as identical to that history.

As many as walk by this rule, peace and mercy be on them, and on God's Israel. — Galatians 6:16

World English Bible

I ask then, did they stumble that they might fall? May it never be! But by their fall salvation has come to the Gentiles, to provoke them to jealousy. — Romans 11:11

WEB

3.1 Why this is the chapter's central debate

Every element this chapter has traced so far converges on this single question. Israel was called for a missional purpose (9-1); Gentiles now enter the same Spirit-marked people without the same ethnic and ritual boundary markers (9-2); the New Testament describes that people using language — "God's Israel" (Galatians 6:16), "a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation" applied to a mixed Jewish-Gentile church (1 Peter 2:9, echoing Exodus 19:6's own language from lecture 9-1) — that sounds, on its face, like Israel's own vocabulary being reused for something larger. Whether that reuse means continuation, replacement, or something else again is the question this lecture states three ways rather than answering once.

3.2 Position one: supersessionism (replacement)

The supersessionist or "replacement" position holds that the church is Israel's new- continuation — that the promises, , and identity once belonging to ethnic Israel now belong to the church, understood as the true, spiritual Israel, without a continuing distinct national program remaining for ethnic Israel as such. This has been, historically, the dominant reading across much of church history, articulated in various forms from the patristic era (Justin Martyr's Dialogue with Trypho argues explicitly that the church has become "the true Israelite race") through the medieval and much of the Reformation period. Its strongest textual ground includes exactly the kind of language this lecture opened with: Galatians 6:16's "God's Israel," read by many supersessionist interpreters as applying "Israel" directly to the church (Jew and Gentile united in Christ, the immediately preceding subject of Galatians 6:15's "new creation"); Romans 2:28-29's redefinition of true circumcision and true Jewishness as a matter "of the heart, in the spirit" rather than physical descent; and Galatians 3:29's claim that "if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's seed" without qualification by ethnicity. On this reading, the church does not steal Israel's identity so much as fulfill it — the promises were always, at bottom, about a people defined by faith rather than physical descent, and the church simply is that people now that faith in Christ has become the defining mark.

This is a point where readers will not agree, and a fair treatment cannot pass over what a full accounting of supersessionism's history includes: readings of this kind have, at real and documented historical points — from certain patristic rhetoric through medieval Christian anti-Jewish violence to elements of later European antisemitism that drew on theological "replacement" language for cover — contributed to or been invoked to justify serious harm against actual Jewish communities. Naming that history honestly does not mean every contemporary scholar who holds a version of this position bears responsibility for that history, and this lecture does not treat them as though they do; serious contemporary proponents of continuity readings distinguish carefully between the theological claim (the church shares fully in Israel's promises through Christ) and any implication of contempt or violence toward actual Jewish people, which the theological claim itself does not require and which its careful defenders explicitly reject. But a fair statement of this position's history cannot leave that record unmentioned.

3.3 Position two: dispensationalism (a distinct future for Israel)

The dispensationalist position, already introduced in lecture 3-3 through the tradition of John Nelson Darby and the Scofield Reference Bible, holds that Israel and the church are kept as two distinct peoples with two distinct programs — the church a genuinely new entity beginning at Pentecost, not simply Israel renamed, and Israel's own national, ethnic, and land-based promises remaining to be fulfilled with ethnic Israel specifically rather than being absorbed into or transferred onto the church. Its strongest textual ground, restated here from a different angle than lecture 3-3's covenant-focused treatment, is Romans 11 read in full narrative sequence: Paul's rhetorical question in this lecture's own scripture passage — "did they stumble that they might fall? May it never be!" (Romans 11:11) — followed several verses later by the promise that "all Israel will be saved" (Romans 11:26) after "a partial hardening" and "the fullness of the Gentiles" (Romans 11:25), read by dispensationalist interpreters as describing a future, large-scale, national turning of ethnic Israel to Christ that has not yet occurred and that the church's existence has not already absorbed or rendered unnecessary. On this reading, Galatians 6:16's "Israel of God" is read narrowly — as a reference to believing Jews within the Galatian churches specifically (a genuine minority reading among translators and commentators, reflected in the Greek's ambiguous "and" that could be read as adding a distinct group rather than restating the same one) — rather than as a blanket renaming of the whole church as "Israel." 's proponents argue that a promise made explicitly to a specific ethnic people, stated in explicitly national and territorial terms in texts like the Abrahamic and Davidic covenants already traced in chapter 3, cannot honestly be fulfilled by transferring its content to a different, later, largely Gentile body without doing real violence to what the original promise actually said.

3.4 Position three: one people of God, converged in Christ

A third position, associated with Peter Gentry and Stephen Wellum's progressive covenantalism already introduced in lecture 3-3 (and with related "one people of God" arguments made by other scholars working from similar typological premises), holds that the church is Israel's organic fulfillment rather than either its simple replacement or a separate parallel program. On this reading, Christ himself is true Israel — the singular seed Galatians 3:16 already identified — so that the church's relationship to Old Testament Israel runs through Christ first, not directly: the church does not take over Israel's promises by simple substitution, and Israel's own story does not run to two separate finish lines, but both converge because Christ, as true Israel, is the one in whom Jewish and Gentile believers alike now stand. On Galatians 6:16, this position typically reads "Israel of God" broadly (agreeing with supersessionism's reading of the phrase itself as applying to the whole believing community) while resisting the label "replacement," because nothing on this account has been replaced — Christ has fulfilled what Israel was always pointing toward, and the church is united to that fulfillment rather than substituted for the thing fulfilled. On Romans 11, this position typically affirms, with dispensationalism, that Paul is describing a real and significant future work among ethnic Jewish people specifically (Romans 11:26's "all Israel" read as a genuine, not merely symbolic, expectation) — while denying that this requires a separate national-political program running alongside, rather than within, the one people constituted in Christ.

3.5 Testing the three against this lecture's own texts

Put plainly, side by side: supersessionism reads Galatians 6:16 as the church directly inheriting the name "Israel," full stop, and reads Romans 11:11's "stumble... not fall" as describing individual Jewish salvation continuing within the one existing people of God, the church, rather than pointing to a separate future national event. Dispensationalism reads Galatians 6:16 narrowly (believing Jews within the church, not the church itself renamed) and reads Romans 11:11 as the opening move of an argument that culminates, fifteen verses later, in a still-future, still-national "all Israel will be saved" that the church's own existence has not exhausted or replaced. Progressive covenantalism reads Galatians 6:16 broadly like supersessionism but without the "replacement" framing, and reads Romans 11:11 as pointing toward a real future turning among ethnic Jewish people specifically — closer to dispensationalism's expectation here — while insisting that turning happens within the one people constituted in Christ rather than alongside it as a separate program.

None of the three readings ignores either text outright, and each is held today by serious, biblically literate scholars fully aware of the other two positions' textual arguments. A quiz question, or an essay, that treats only one of the three as this course's own settled answer would misstate both the actual state of the scholarly conversation and this lecture's stated purpose — exactly the caution chapter 3's parallel debate over the covenants as a system already modeled.

3.6 What is actually at stake

The practical stakes of this particular debate reach further than most of this course's other named disagreements, because this one bears directly on how Christians relate to a living community rather than only on an abstract theological system. How a reader answers this question shapes what they expect, theologically, of the modern state of Israel and of Jewish people generally; how they read Paul's sustained, emotionally invested argument across the whole of Romans 9-11 (a passage this lecture has only sampled, not exhausted); and whether "the church has replaced Israel" is a phrase they would use comfortably, cautiously, or not at all. This lecture has not told you which of the three positions is correct, and has tried, in each case, to state the position in terms its most careful contemporary proponents would recognize as a fair account of their own view — including supersessionism, whose difficult history this lecture named honestly rather than passing over, without collapsing that history onto every scholar who holds a version of the position today.


Israel and the Church: Three Positions Three currently-held positions, stated in their own terms Supersessionism Historically dominant Church = Israel's new- covenant continuation No separate future national program Key text: Gal. 6:16 - "Israel" applied to church Rom. 11:11: individual Jewish salvation within the one existing people Difficult history noted, 3.2 Dispensationalism Darby; Scofield tradition Two distinct peoples, two distinct programs Israel's national promises still future, still ethnic Key text: Rom. 11:26 - "all Israel will be saved" Gal. 6:16 read narrowly: believing Jews within the church, not the church One People of God Gentry and Wellum Christ = true Israel; church converges in him Fulfillment, not simple replacement Key text: Gal. 3:16, seed is Christ, church united Rom. 11:26: real future Jewish turning, within the one people in Christ All three engage the same two texts seriously Galatians 6:16 ("God's Israel") and Romans 11:11 ("did they stumble that they might fall?") are read differently by each position — none ignores the other's key text outright. This is the same three-way disagreement chapter 3 named for the covenants as a system.

In short

  • Supersessionism reads Galatians 6:16's "God's Israel" as applying directly to the church and cites Romans 2:28-29 (true circumcision "of the heart") and Galatians 3:29 (Christ's people as "Abraham's seed") as its strongest textual ground, with roots as early as Justin Martyr's Dialogue with Trypho.
  • The lecture names supersessionism's difficult history honestly — theological "replacement" language invoked at points from patristic rhetoric through medieval anti-Jewish violence to later European antisemitism — without treating its careful contemporary proponents as bearing that history's guilt.
  • Dispensationalism (Darby, Scofield) reads Romans 11:25-26's "fullness of the Gentiles" and "all Israel will be saved" as a still-future, national turning of ethnic Israel, and reads "Israel of God" in Galatians 6:16 narrowly as believing Jews within the church rather than the church renamed.
  • Progressive covenantalism (Gentry and Wellum) holds Christ himself is true Israel — the singular seed of Galatians 3:16 — so the church converges on Israel's promises through him as fulfillment, not simple replacement or a separate parallel program.
  • All three positions engage the same two texts, Galatians 6:16 and Romans 11:11 ("did they stumble that they might fall? May it never be!"), reading them differently rather than ignoring either outright — mirroring the three-way covenant debate chapter 3 already introduced.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Three positions answer how Israel and the church relate. Supersessionism holds the church is Israel's new-covenant continuation, reading "God's Israel" (Galatians 6:16) as the church itself — a reading with a documented history of being invoked to justify harm against Jewish communities, which this lecture names honestly without indicting its careful modern defenders. Dispensationalism (Darby, Scofield) keeps Israel and the church as two distinct peoples with two distinct programs, anchored in Romans 11:26's still-future "all Israel will be saved." Progressive covenantalism (Gentry and Wellum) holds Christ himself is true Israel, so the church converges on Israel's promises through him rather than replacing or running parallel to them. All three take Galatians 6:16 and Romans 11:11 seriously; none is this course's settled answer.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • State each of the three positions in one sentence each, phrased the way a fair-minded proponent of that position would phrase it. Which was hardest to write fairly, and why?
  • This lecture names supersessionism's difficult history without treating every contemporary proponent as bearing responsibility for it. Do you think that distinction is one a fair treatment of this debate can actually sustain? Why or why not?
  • Compare this lecture's three-way disagreement to lecture 3-3's covenant-theology, dispensationalism, and progressive-covenantalism disagreement. What is genuinely the same underlying disagreement approached from a different angle, and what, if anything, is a distinct question this lecture had to add that 3-3 did not need to address?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.