Lecture 1-3: No New Thing, and No One Left to Remember It
Contents 27
- Lecture 1-1: The Words of Qohelet, and the Word He Names First
- Lecture 1-2: A Poem That Never Finishes Moving
- Lecture 1-3: No New Thing, and No One Left to Remember It
- Lecture 2-1: The Wisdom Experiment
- Lecture 2-2: The Pleasure and Building Experiment
- Lecture 2-3: One Fate, and a First Refrain
- Lecture 3-1: Fourteen Times, One Word Repeated
- Lecture 3-2: Eternity in the Heart, the Whole Out of Reach
- Lecture 3-3: A Fixed Order, Strained by What Is Actually Seen
- Lecture 4-1: The Tears of the Oppressed
- Lecture 4-2: Envy, Idleness, and the Solitary Laborer
- Lecture 4-3: Two Are Better Than One
- Lecture 5-1: Guarding Your Steps, Guarding Your Vow
- Lecture 5-2: The Sleep Money Cannot Buy
- Lecture 5-3: A Fate Worse Than Never Having Lived
- Lecture 6-1: A Chain of Uncomfortable Proverbs
- Lecture 6-2: Between Two Excesses
- Lecture 6-3: What the Search Found, and What It Did Not
- Lecture 7-1: Keeping the King's Word
- Lecture 7-2: A Vanity Named Outright, and a Limit Stated Flatly
- Lecture 7-3: A Living Dog, and the Third Refrain
- Lecture 8-1: The Poor Wise Man Nobody Remembered
- Lecture 8-2: A Proverb Collection on Folly, Kings, and Careless Speech
- Lecture 8-3: Casting Bread on the Waters
Ecclesiastes 1:9-11 closes the book's opening unit by drawing out the conclusion its nature poem (Lecture 1-2) has already shown in grammar: if the sun, the wind, and the rivers each return endlessly to where they started, then perhaps human affairs are caught in the same kind of loop. "There is no new thing under the sun" (1:9) is one of the book's most quoted lines, and it is easy to hear it as a sweeping claim about reality itself. This lecture reads the phrase in its actual place, connects it back to "under the sun" as introduced in Lecture 1-1, and follows the unit's final move — from "nothing is new" to "no one is remembered" — as a single continuous argument rather than two separate complaints.
What these 14 minutes give you
- State what 1:9-11 claims, verse by verse, and how the claim about "no new thing" connects logically to the claim about "no memory."
- Explain why this course treats "under the sun" as a phrase that limits the scope of 1:9's claim rather than a claim about the whole of reality.
- Identify the repeated Hebrew root ה-י-ה (*h-y-h*, "to be") across 1:9-10 and explain what its repetition contributes to the verse's argument.
- Explain how this lecture's reading of 1:9-11 connects back to Lecture 1-2's participial nature poem as a single, continuous unit rather than three unrelated observations.
That which has been is that which shall be; and that which has been done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun. — Ecclesiastes 1:9
World English Bible
Is there a thing of which it may be said, "Behold, this is new?" It has been long ago, in the ages which were before us. — Ecclesiastes 1:10
WEB
There is no memory of the former; neither shall there be any memory of the latter that are to come, among those that shall come after. — Ecclesiastes 1:11
WEB
The Hebrew of the same three verses (Westminster Leningrad Codex):
מַה־שֶּֽׁהָיָה֙ ה֣וּא שֶׁיִּהְיֶ֔ה וּמַה־שֶׁנַּֽעֲשָׂ֔ה ה֖וּא שֶׁיֵּעָשֶׂ֑ה וְאֵ֥ין כָּל־חָדָ֖שׁ תַּ֥חַת הַשָּֽׁמֶשׁ׃
יֵ֥שׁ שֶׁיֹּאמַ֥ר רְאֵה־זֶ֖ה ה֑וּא כְּבָר֙ לְעֹֽלָמִ֔ים אֲשֶׁ֥ר הָיָ֖ה מִלְּפָנֵֽנוּ׃
אֵ֥ין לָרִאשֹׁנִ֑ים וְגַ֨ם לָאַחֲרֹנִ֜ים שֶׁיִּהְי֗וּ לֹֽא־יִהְיֶ֤ה לָהֶם֙ זִכָּר֔וֹן שֶׁיִּהְי֖וּ לָאַחֲרֹנָֽה׃ פ
Hebrew text: Westminster Leningrad Codex (WLC), public domain. The final mark (פ) after verse 11 is a Masoretic paragraph divider (petuchah), not part of the wording, indicating a break in the traditional text after this unit.
1. "That which has been is that which shall be": the root ה-י-ה repeated
Verse 9 opens with a statement built almost entirely on one repeated root: מַה־שֶּׁהָיָה הוּא שֶׁיִּהְיֶה, "that which has been [הָיָה, hayah] is that which shall be [, yihyeh]." Both verbs come from ה-י-ה (h-y-h), "to be" — the same root behind God's self-identification to Moses in Exodus 3:14, אֲשֶׁר אֶהְיֶה ("I Am Who I Am" / "I Will Be What I Will Be"). Here the root is used to collapse past and future into a single continuous state: what has been and what shall be are described with the identical verb, differing only in tense, as though the passage of time between them changes nothing essential about what exists. The verse continues with a parallel construction using a different root, ע-ש-ה (asah, "to do, to make"): וּמַה־שֶׁנַּעֲשָׂה הוּא שֶׁיֵּעָשֶׂה, "that which has been done is that which shall be done." The pattern doubles — being and doing are each folded into the same continuous loop — before the verse states its conclusion directly: וְאֵין כָּל־חָדָשׁ תַּחַת הַשָּׁמֶשׁ, "and there is no new thing under the sun."
2. "Under the sun," returning
"Under the sun" (תַּחַת הַשָּׁמֶשׁ) appeared first in 1:3, introduced in Lecture 1-1 as a phrase that marks the scope of a claim rather than stating the claim itself. Its return here, six verses later, is the phrase's first real test: does "there is no new thing under the sun" mean that nothing new has ever happened or ever will happen, in any sense whatsoever — a metaphysical claim about the entire universe — or does it mean something narrower: that nothing new appears within the world as it is observable from inside ordinary, mortal, sun-bound human experience? This course reads it as the second. Qohelet is not claiming to have surveyed all of reality, including whatever may lie outside the world available to human observation; he is claiming that everything he can actually examine — every human circumstance, every event, every pattern of behavior — turns out, on close inspection, to be a variation on something that has already occurred. That is already a striking and, on Lecture 1-2's evidence, well-supported claim; it does not need to be inflated into a claim about the whole of existence to carry its full weight.
3. A world too old to surprise you (1:10)
Verse 10 anticipates an objection: what about something that genuinely looks new? "Is there a thing of which it may be said, 'Behold, this is new'? It has already been, in the ages that were before us." The Hebrew כְּבָר (kevar, "already") does real work here — the verse does not argue that apparent novelty is an illusion or a lie, only that whatever looks new has, in fact, already occurred at some earlier point the observer simply was not alive to witness. This is a claim about the limits of a single human lifespan's field of view, not a claim that requires denying the reality of what looks new. A discovery, an invention, a political upheaval — each can feel unprecedented to the generation that lives through it, while still, on Qohelet's argument, being a recurrence of a pattern that has already played out in an age no living person remembers. The verse's logic depends directly on verse 11's next move: if no one remembers the earlier occurrence, no one is in a position to recognize the repetition when it comes around again.
4. No memory of the first, none of the last (1:11)
Verse 11 closes the unit: "there is no memory [זִכְרוֹן, zikaron] of the former, and also of the latter that shall be, there shall not be for them memory [זִכָּרוֹן, zikaron again], with those who shall be at the last." The root ז-כ-ר (z-k-r, "to remember") is struck twice in one verse, framing both ends of time — those who came before, and those who will come after — inside the identical denial. This is the argument's real conclusion, and it follows directly from what has come before: if nothing that happens is actually new (1:9), and if what looks new is simply an earlier pattern no living person remembers (1:10), then the absence of memory in 1:11 is not a separate, additional complaint about human forgetfulness. It is the same observation, restated from the other direction. Novelty depends on memory to be recognized as novelty; without memory of what came before, every recurrence looks, to the generation living through it, exactly like a first occurrence — which is precisely the illusion 1:9-10 has just dismantled.
5. Closing this chapter's unit
Lecture 1-1 named the book's central word and its central limiting phrase. Lecture 1-2 showed, through the Hebrew's own participles, a natural world caught in unceasing, unfinished motion. This lecture has followed that motion to its human conclusion: a world with no new thing in it, observed by generations with no lasting memory of one another. Chapter 2 of this course turns from this opening description to an experiment — Qohelet, using his position as king (1:12, resuming the superscription's claim from 1:1), sets out to test whether wisdom, pleasure, or labor can produce something that escapes the pattern this chapter has just described. This chapter's task was only to state that pattern clearly and fairly before watching someone try to outrun it.
6. Try It Yourself
Reread Ecclesiastes 1:9-10 in the WEB translation quoted above. Before checking the answer, try to state in one or two sentences why verse 10's response to "look, this is new" is not actually a denial that anything ever looks new to the person experiencing it.
Check your answer
Verse 10 does not claim that nothing ever appears new to the person living through it — it grants that something can genuinely look and feel unprecedented in the moment. What it claims instead is that this appearance of newness is a fact about the limits of one observer's field of view, not a fact about whether the thing itself has truly never occurred before. The Hebrew כְּבָר ("already") concedes the feeling of novelty and then relocates the real occurrence to "the ages which were before us" — a time before the current observer existed to notice it. This is why the argument needs verse 11's point about memory to complete itself: something can feel new precisely because no one alive remembers its earlier occurrence, which means the feeling of newness is, on this argument, actually evidence of forgetting rather than evidence of genuine unprecedented novelty. The two verses work together — 1:10 explains why something can feel new, and 1:11 explains why that feeling will keep recurring for every generation, since each one loses its own memory in turn.
In short
- Verse 9 uses the root "to be" for both past and future ("what has been is what shall be"), and a second root for doing, folding being and doing into one loop.
- "Under the sun" returns in 1:9. The course reads it as limiting the claim to what can be observed in ordinary human experience, not as a statement about all reality.
- Verse 10 does not deny that things feel new. It says whatever looks new already happened in an age no living person witnessed.
- Verse 11 says there is no memory of the former or the latter. Novelty needs memory to be recognised, so this is the same observation from the other side.
- Chapters 1-3 form one argument that leads into Qohelet's experiment in chapter 2.
Topic: This lecture reads Ecclesiastes 1:9-11, moving from "no new thing under the sun" to "no memory," as one connected argument.
Remember: Something can feel new because no one alive remembers its earlier occurrence, so the feeling of newness is evidence of forgetting.
Caution: The lecture does not read verse 9 as a claim about the whole universe, and it does not say that nothing ever looks new.
One line to carry into ministry: Before calling something unprecedented, ask what earlier generations faced, since forgotten history can make old patterns look new.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- This lecture argues that 1:9's "no new thing under the sun" is a claim bounded by "under the sun," not an unqualified metaphysical statement. Does that distinction change how strong or how troubling you find the claim?
- Verse 11's argument depends on the idea that novelty requires memory to be recognized as novelty. Can you think of an example — personal, historical, or cultural — where something widely treated as unprecedented turned out to be a recurrence of something forgotten?
- This chapter opened with a word (*hevel*) whose meaning is disputed, and now closes with a claim about memory failing. What connection, if any, do you see between a word whose meaning cannot be pinned down and a past that cannot be remembered?