Lecture 5-2: Four Ways of Reading, and the Blends
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What an Apocalypse Is
- Lecture 1-2: Three Genres in One Book
- Lecture 1-3: The Grammar of Symbols, Numbers and Images
- Lecture 1-4: Visions: Order, Repetition, Heaven and Earth
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: An Invented Apocalyptic Fragment
- Lecture 2-1: Echo, Not Quotation
- Lecture 2-2: Daniel 7 and Revelation: Beasts and the Son of Man
- Lecture 2-3: Ezekiel, Zechariah, Isaiah and the Exodus: the Materials of the Pictures
- Lecture 2-4: Psalms, Worship and the Temple in Revelation
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Tracing an Echo
- Lecture 3-1: The Design of the Book
- Lecture 3-2: The Seven Letters: Form and Cities
- Lecture 3-3: Heaven's Worship and the Lamb (Revelation 4-5)
- Lecture 3-4: Letters to Real Churches: Reading Tone and Warning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Analysing a Letter to a Church
- Lecture 4-1: Reading Seals, Trumpets and Bowls
- Lecture 4-2: The Dragon, the Beasts and the Number
- Lecture 4-3: Babylon and the Wedding of the Lamb
- Lecture 4-4: Witness, Martyrdom and Victory
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading an Image
- Lecture 5-1: The First Readers' World: Asia Minor under Rome
- Lecture 5-2: Four Ways of Reading, and the Blends
- Lecture 5-3: Revelation in the Churches: Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant
- Lecture 5-4: Reading with Others: Humility and Honest Disagreement
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Readings
Put four thoughtful Christians in a room with the Book of Revelation and ask when the visions are about. You may hear four answers. One says: mainly the world of the first readers, and what was close to them. A second says: the whole course of church history, from John's day to the end. A third says: mostly events still to come, just before the end. A fourth says: none of these in particular, but the great struggle between the Lamb and the powers of evil, in every age.
These are the four classic ways of reading Revelation. They have names: preterist, historicist, futurist and idealist. Each has been held by serious, prayerful people, and each is held today. Each has real reasons in the text. Each also has real difficulties, which its own followers know well.
This lecture sets the four side by side with equal weight. It does not tell you which to choose. What it asks is smaller and, we hope, more useful: that you can state each reading so that a person who holds it would say, "Yes, that is fair," and that you know where each is likely to be weak. The week's principle is that knowing each tradition's reasons and weak points makes us humbler and more honest with the text.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Name the four classic readings and say in one sentence how each understands the visions.
- Give, for each reading, at least one textual reason in its favour and at least one difficulty.
- Say what each reading is trying to protect.
- Explain what a blended reading is and why many readers use one.
- State fairly why this course does not choose among the readings.
This is the Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave him to show to his servants the things which must happen soon, which he sent and made known by his angel to his servant, John, who testified to God’s word, and of the testimony of Jesus Christ, about everything that he saw. Blessed is he who reads and those who hear the words of the prophecy, and keep the things that are written in it, for the time is at hand." — Revelation 1:1-3
World English Bible
They told me, “You must prophesy again over many peoples, nations, languages, and kings.”" — Revelation 10:11
WEB
The first passage speaks of things that "must happen soon" and of a time "at hand". The second speaks of prophesying "again" over many peoples and kings. Readers of different kinds lean on one or the other, and often on both. Notice how much each short phrase can bear, and how little we should claim for it alone.
1. A question of "when", and a question of "what for"
The four readings are often introduced as answers to when: when do the visions happen? That is a fair way in, but it hides something. Behind each answer is a worry about what for. What does a reading want to protect? Why would a careful reader hold it? Keep both questions in mind as we go.
2. The preterist reading
Preterist comes from a Latin word for "past". This reading holds that most of the visions concern events in or near the time of the first readers: the Roman world, the pressure on the churches, and of powers that opposed God in that age. Some preterist readers connect much of the book with the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70; others look more to the Roman empire and its emperors. Many preterist readers (often called partial preterists) hold that the last chapters, which speak of Christ's return and the new creation, still look ahead to the end.
Textual reasons. The book opens by speaking of things that "must happen soon" and a time that is "at hand" (1:1, 3). It is addressed to seven real churches in real cities, in a real empire, and its images of beasts, a great city and a ruler's number are close to things its hearers knew. A book sent to people to encourage them would have been understood, at least in part, by them.
Difficulties. Some passages, such as the return of Christ in chapter 19, the last judgement in chapter 20 and the new creation in chapters 21 and 22, appear to speak of an end that no event of the first century matches. Preterist readers answer in different ways, some by saying these still lie ahead, others by finding in them the fulfilment in the age of the church. The reading also depends partly on the date (lecture 5-1): if the book is late, some of the proposed matches become harder. And "soon" may carry other senses, as in the way the prophets spoke of God's day.
What it guards. The conviction that Revelation was a real letter to real people, meant to be understood by them.
3. The historicist reading
Historicist readers hold that the visions sketch the whole sweep of history from John's day to the end, in order: the seals, trumpets and bowls, and the figures of the beast and the harlot, are matched with successive periods and powers of the church's history. For many centuries this was a common reading, and it was especially strong in some Protestant circles from the Reformation on.
Textual reasons. The book speaks of long spans and many nations: John is told he must prophesy "again over many peoples, nations, languages, and kings" (10:11), which these readers take to widen the scene beyond the first century. The pattern of successive powers also echoes Daniel, where a sequence of kingdoms leads to God's rule (see lecture 2-2). And the book does seem to move forward toward an end.
Difficulties. The first readers could not have recognised the later events. Historicist interpreters have disagreed about which events match which visions, and schemes have needed revising as history moved on. At times, each age has tended to find itself near the end of the scheme, and the figure of the beast has been assigned in turn to the enemies of whoever was reading, on more than one side of the church's divisions. That history gives readers a reason for care. It is told here about past ages only, and without mockery: the people who did it were trying to be faithful.
What it guards. The conviction that God rules history and that the church's long story is not outside the book's concern.
4. The futurist reading
Futurist readers hold that, after the letters to the seven churches, most of the book from chapter 4 on (or from a later point) concerns events that lie just before and at the end of history: a final period of trial, the return of Christ, the judgement and the new creation. This reading is very widely held today, especially among evangelical and Pentecostal Christians, and some of its elements are old: certain early writers expected a coming final enemy and a literal reign of Christ.
Textual reasons. The book's most striking claims, the visible coming of Christ, the resurrection of the dead, the judgement of the nations and the renewal of heaven and earth, are things that, on the face of it, have not yet happened in the sense the text describes. The book calls itself prophecy (1:3), and prophecy often looks ahead. And the cry at the end, "Yes, come, Lord Jesus", is a prayer for something still to come.
Difficulties. The first readers receive little from a book whose main subject lies far beyond them. The words "soon" and "at hand" need explaining. The reading has often been tempted to match its verses to events in the news, and charts of future events have been revised many times. The genre also matters: if the images are symbols (lecture 1-3), then taking each one as a literal forecast asks more of the text than the genre allows. Careful futurist readers know this and treat the symbols with care, but the danger is real.
What it guards. The conviction that Christ will truly return, that God will truly judge and renew, and that the Christian hope is a real future, not only a present mood.
5. The idealist reading
Idealist readers (sometimes called symbolic or spiritual readers) hold that the visions are not a timetable of any kind. They show, in pictures, the great and lasting struggle between the Lamb and the powers of evil, which goes on in every age and ends in the Lamb's victory. The beast, the harlot and the dragon stand for powers that recur in many forms; the saints who conquer are the church in every century.
Textual reasons. The book is full of symbol, and many of its images repeat from one vision to the next (see lecture 1-4), which these readers take as the writer circling the same truth. It explains some of its own pictures as symbols (1:20). The book also speaks to churches in more than one situation, and it has comforted Christians in very different times and places.
Difficulties. Critics ask whether the reading makes the book too general. It can seem to lose the particular Roman setting, and the promise of a real return, a real judgement and a new creation, which the book states strongly. If every image can mean any struggle, it may be hard to say what the text rules out. Careful idealist readers answer that they keep the future hope and the first-century setting; the point is that neither exhausts the pictures.
What it guards. The conviction that Revelation is for every generation of the church, and that it should never be turned into a map of one's own era.
6. Putting them side by side
| How it reads the visions | Strengths (textual reasons) | Weaknesses | What it guards | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preterist | Mainly the world of the first readers | "Soon", "at hand" (1:1, 3); seven real churches; Roman images | The return, judgement and new creation seem to go past the first century | The book as a real letter to real people |
| Historicist | The sweep of church history, in order | "Again over many peoples" (10:11); the pattern of kingdoms in Daniel | First readers could not see it; schemes have been revised; each age finds itself near the end | God's rule over the whole of history |
| Futurist | Mostly events before and at the end | The coming, resurrection and renewal are not yet; the book is prophecy (1:3); the final prayer | Little for the first readers; risk of news-matching; "soon" needs explaining | The real return, judgement and renewal |
| Idealist | The lasting conflict of the Lamb and evil in every age | Symbolic genre; repeated images; self-explaining pictures (1:20) | Can seem too general; can thin out the setting and the future hope | The book for every age |
7. Blended readings
Few thoughtful readers hold any one of these in a pure form. Most blend them. A reader may take the letters and the opening visions as first-century words, the central visions as pictures that recur in every age, and the final chapters as a real hope for the end. Another may hold that the book has a first-century meaning, a meaning through the church's history, and a meaning at the end, which are layered and not rivals. Scholars use various names for such mixtures, and they do not agree on the best name.
A blend can be wise, but it needs checking. It is easy to take the strongest reason from each reading and to ignore each one's difficulty, ending with a reading that is stronger than any of its parts. So ask of any blend: what is it taking from each, and what does it do about the difficulty of each?
A word that applies to all four
Each reading is an interpretation of the text. None is the text. A reader who holds one should be able to say what would count as a reason to doubt it. The surest sign of a mature reader is the ability to state a rival view so that its holder says, "That is my view."
8. Choosing, and not choosing
This is a point where readers will not agree about which of the four is right. Preterist readers will say that the book's first hearers, and the plain sense of "soon", must set the bounds. Historicist readers will say that the book is a prophecy of a long span, as the call to prophesy "again" shows. Futurist readers will say that the book's great promises are not yet fulfilled and must not be turned into past history. Idealist readers will say that the book is a set of pictures meant to be heard in every age, and that every timetable fails the genre. Each can show textual reasons, and each can show a weakness.
What this course requires is less than any of them requires. It asks you to read the genre with care (week 1), to follow the echoes of the Old Testament (week 2), to listen to the text in the setting of its first hearers (lecture 5-1), to notice where your own reading has a difficulty, and to refuse date-setting and news-matching on any reading. All four readings, rightly held, say that Christ is Lord, that the Lamb has won, and that the church is called to worship and endure. You can say all of that without choosing.
Diagram 1. Four ways of reading, one book
Diagram 2. Text, background, interpretation
| Level | Example |
|---|---|
| The text says | The things "must happen soon" (1:1); John must prophesy "again" over many peoples (10:11) |
| The background adds | Prophets spoke of God's day as near; Daniel pictures successive kingdoms; the cities were Roman |
| Interpretation | Whether "soon" means near in time, sudden in coming, or certain; whether "again" widens the scene to all history |
In short
- The four classic readings are preterist (then), historicist (along the way), futurist (yet to come) and idealist (in every age).
- Each has real textual reasons and real difficulties; no one view is the plain sense of the whole book.
- Each guards something: a real letter, God's rule over history, a real future hope, or a book for every age.
- Most thoughtful readers blend; a blend should be checked for what it takes from each and what it ignores.
- All four can say that Christ is Lord, the Lamb has won and the church is called to worship and endure.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Preterist | Mostly the first readers' world; guards the book as a real letter. Difficulty: the end of the book. |
| Historicist | The sweep of church history; guards God's rule over history. Difficulty: schemes keep changing. |
| Futurist | Mostly events at the end; guards a real future hope. Difficulty: little for the first readers; news-matching. |
| Idealist | The lasting conflict in every age; guards the book for every generation. Difficulty: can be too general. |
One sentence to remember Each reading holds something true and carries a difficulty; the honest reader knows both.
This week's action Write one sentence stating a reading you do not hold in the words its holders would use.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four readings did you meet first, in a church or a book? How did it shape what you expected from Revelation?
- State one reading in a way its holders would call fair. What did you have to leave out to do it?
- The lecture says each reading has "reasons" and "weaknesses". Why is it useful to know the weakness of the view you prefer?
- What does each reading protect? Is there something you want protected that your own reading does not?
- What is the danger of a blend that takes the strongest reason from each reading?
- What can all four readings say together, without anyone having to give way?