Lecture 5-4: Reading with Others: Humility and Honest Disagreement
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What an Apocalypse Is
- Lecture 1-2: Three Genres in One Book
- Lecture 1-3: The Grammar of Symbols, Numbers and Images
- Lecture 1-4: Visions: Order, Repetition, Heaven and Earth
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: An Invented Apocalyptic Fragment
- Lecture 2-1: Echo, Not Quotation
- Lecture 2-2: Daniel 7 and Revelation: Beasts and the Son of Man
- Lecture 2-3: Ezekiel, Zechariah, Isaiah and the Exodus: the Materials of the Pictures
- Lecture 2-4: Psalms, Worship and the Temple in Revelation
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Tracing an Echo
- Lecture 3-1: The Design of the Book
- Lecture 3-2: The Seven Letters: Form and Cities
- Lecture 3-3: Heaven's Worship and the Lamb (Revelation 4-5)
- Lecture 3-4: Letters to Real Churches: Reading Tone and Warning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Analysing a Letter to a Church
- Lecture 4-1: Reading Seals, Trumpets and Bowls
- Lecture 4-2: The Dragon, the Beasts and the Number
- Lecture 4-3: Babylon and the Wedding of the Lamb
- Lecture 4-4: Witness, Martyrdom and Victory
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading an Image
- Lecture 5-1: The First Readers' World: Asia Minor under Rome
- Lecture 5-2: Four Ways of Reading, and the Blends
- Lecture 5-3: Revelation in the Churches: Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant
- Lecture 5-4: Reading with Others: Humility and Honest Disagreement
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Comparing Readings
The last lecture showed how many ways the churches have read Revelation. This one asks a practical question: what do we do with that fact when we sit beside someone who reads differently? It may be a brother in your own congregation, a sister in another church, a teacher you respect, or a relative who is certain and loud.
Disagreement about Revelation has broken friendships and divided congregations. It has also, at its best, taught people to listen. The difference lies less in who is right than in how people hold their views. This lecture offers four things: a short list of what the four classic readings all protect; a skill called steel-manning, which is the opposite of attacking a weak version of another's view; a few habits for staying in fellowship; and a plain statement of what Christians can say together about the Lamb's victory.
What these 16 minutes give you
- Say what each of the four classic readings protects, and why these are all things a Christian wants protected.
- Explain *steel-manning* and use it on a view you do not hold.
- Name three habits that keep fellowship alive across a difference over Revelation.
- Tell the difference between a disagreement about interpretation and a disagreement about what the church confesses.
- State a few things that Christians of all four readings can say together.
He who testifies these things says, “Yes, I come quickly.” Amen! Yes, come, Lord Jesus." — Revelation 22:20
World English Bible
The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with all the saints. Amen." — Revelation 22:21
WEB
The book ends with a prayer and a blessing. It does not end with a chart. The prayer is for the Lord to come, and the blessing is for "all the saints", not for those who read it one way. The closing words are a fair guide to the spirit in which the book may be discussed.
1. What each reading protects
Lecture 5-2 set out the four readings and what each tries to guard. They are worth gathering in one place, because they show that the disagreement is not between those who love the Bible and those who do not.
| Reading | What it protects | Why a Christian might want it protected |
|---|---|---|
| Preterist | The book as a real letter to real people | Scripture was given to people in history, and we honour it by hearing it as they heard it |
| Historicist | God's rule over the whole sweep of history | God has not left the long story of the church to chance |
| Futurist | A real return, a real judgement and a real new creation | Christian hope is for something to come, not only for a mood in the heart |
| Idealist | The book for every age and every church | Revelation must never be tied to one generation's fears |
Notice that all four are good things. A person who says "I hold the futurist reading" is likely, at bottom, to be saying "I care that Christ will really return." A person who says "I hold the idealist reading" is likely to be saying "I care that no one should be able to turn this book into a weapon." The quarrel is seldom between good and bad. It is more often between two goods, each afraid to lose the other.
2. Steel-manning: the opposite of straw
Most of us have met the habit of straw-manning: restating another person's view in its weakest form so that it is easy to knock down. "They think the whole book is just a poem" is a straw man if the person in fact holds a careful idealist reading. The opposite habit is called steel-manning: stating the other person's view in its strongest honest form, and so well that its holder says, "Yes, that is what I think, and you put it better than I do."
Steel-manning is not agreement. You may state a view fairly and still hold a different one. It is also not flattery. It does not mean pretending a difficulty is not there; the best steel-man includes the difficulty that the holder admits.
Here is a short exercise, with an invented person. (An invented example.) Suppose a friend, Tobias, holds a historicist reading and says, in a discussion, "I think the visions follow the history of the church in order." A weak reply is: "So you think you can read the newspaper in the book?" A steel-man reply is: "You are saying that the book is a prophecy that spans a long time, that God is in charge of the whole story, and that the repeated word to 'prophesy again' means the vision reaches beyond John's day. You are aware that interpreters have disagreed about which events match which visions, and that is a difficulty you take seriously. Have I put it fairly?"
The second reply takes more effort. It also does something the first never can: it shows Tobias that he has been heard, and it lets the conversation go on.
3. A way to practise
Four steps are enough for a first try.
- Listen until you can summarise. Do not reply until you can restate the other person's view to their satisfaction.
- State their reasons. What texts do they lean on? What worry do they have about other readings?
- State their difficulty, if they will accept it. Most careful holders already know where the view is weak.
- Then, and only then, say where you differ. You may find that the difference is smaller than you feared, or that it is exactly where you thought it was.
4. Habits for staying in fellowship
Hold your reading with an open hand. A view may be held firmly and still be held loosely. The question to ask yourself is not "am I sure?" but "what would count as a good reason to change my mind?" If you cannot name one, you may be holding a reading as though it were a creed.
Separate the Lamb's victory from the chart. What churches have confessed together for centuries is that Christ will come again, that the dead will be raised, that God will judge and make all things new. How and when the events in Revelation fit into that is a question for study, and the answers differ. Do not treat a disagreement about order as a disagreement about the gospel.
Share a table before a debate. Eat, pray and worship with the other person before you argue with them. A person who has been welcomed will hear a challenge more kindly.
Watch your tone about "those who get it wrong". The Bible warns against adding to or taking from the book (22:18-19). That is about tampering with its words, not about holding a different view of its meaning. It is an unkind misuse to turn it against a fellow reader.
5. Disagreement over interpretation, and over confession
It helps to ask: is this disagreement about how to read a text, or about something the church confesses? The two are not the same.
When two Christians disagree about whether the beast of chapter 13 refers mainly to first-century Rome or to a power of the future, they disagree about interpretation. Churches have usually allowed room for that. When a person denies that Christ will return, or that the dead will rise, or that God will make all things new, the disagreement is of another kind, because those are things the church has long confessed together. In practice it is wise to keep the first sort of disagreement as a discussion among friends, and to bring the second sort to the teachers and the confession of your church.
A caution
Not every disagreement that is called "interpretation" is only that. Some teachers use a reading of Revelation to demand money, to set a date, to frighten people, or to pull them away from their families and churches. These are not harmless differences of view, and we turn to them in lecture 6-3. If someone's teaching on the book is hurting you or someone you know, speak to a pastor, priest or other person you trust.
6. How much should it matter?
This is a point where readers will not agree about how much a disagreement over Revelation should matter. Some hold that, since the book concerns the end and the hope of the church, a person's reading is important enough that fellowship needs agreement on it, and a congregation should teach one view clearly. They point to the real harm that vague teaching can do, and to the way a people is formed by what it hears. Others hold that, since sincere and learned Christians have read the book in different ways from the earliest centuries, congregations can welcome those who differ and that the weight belongs on what all confess. They point to the history of division over this very question, and to the love Christ commanded. Each of these groups wants to protect the church.
What this course requires is less than either side requires. It asks that your view of Revelation be held in a way that leaves you able to pray with someone who holds another, and that you not treat a question of order as a question of salvation.
7. What we can say together
When the four readings are laid side by side, a good deal remains that a member of any of them can say with a clear conscience:
- Jesus Christ is Lord, and the Lamb who was killed is worthy of worship.
- The Lamb has already won a victory, and his people share in it by faithful witness.
- Evil will not have the last word. Death, mourning and pain are not part of the world's end.
- Christ will come. The book ends with a prayer for his coming and a promise of it.
- The call to the church is to worship, to witness and to endure, whatever the future holds.
- The book is given for comfort and courage, and not for terror.
These are the same claims that run through the whole course. A congregation that can say them together has a firm place to stand while its members go on studying and disagreeing.
Diagram 1. From four readings to one table
Diagram 2. Text, background, interpretation
| Level | Example |
|---|---|
| The text says | A prayer, "Come, Lord Jesus", and a blessing on all the saints (22:20-21) |
| The background adds | The first readers heard this as the close of a letter, in the form of a blessing |
| Interpretation | Which reading is best; how far a disagreement should matter in a congregation |
In short
- Each of the four readings protects something a Christian wants protected, so the quarrel is often between two goods.
- Steel-manning states another's view in its strongest honest form; it is not agreement and not flattery.
- Hold your reading with an open hand, separate the Lamb's victory from the chart, and share a table before a debate.
- Keep disagreement over interpretation apart from disagreement over what the church confesses together.
- All four readings can say that the Lamb is worthy and has won, that Christ will come, and that the church is to worship, witness and endure.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Steel-manning | Stating another's view in its strongest honest form, so that its holder says "yes, that is it". |
| What the readings protect | A real letter; God's rule over history; a real return; the book for every age. |
| Interpretation or confession? | Interpretation: how to read a text. Confession: what the church holds together, such as Christ's return. |
| What we say together | The Lamb is worthy and has won; Christ will come; worship, witness and endure. |
One sentence to remember You can disagree about the order of the visions and still pray the last prayer of the book together.
This week's action Restate a view you do not hold until you could say, "That is how its holder would put it."
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that the quarrel is "seldom between good and bad"? Do you agree?
- Choose a reading you do not hold. Say what it protects, in words its holder would accept.
- Why is steel-manning harder than it looks? What might make you reluctant to do it?
- Which of the habits for staying in fellowship would be hardest in your own community?
- What is the difference between a disagreement about interpretation and a disagreement about what the church confesses? Give an invented example of each.
- Which of the six things we can say together would you most want to say to a frightened person?