FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order

There were not ten persecutions. Persecution changed in kind over two and a half centuries, from local violence to a standing legal liability to a coordinated empire-wide operation.

Early Church History

12 cards 22 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why ultimate loyalty to Christ and the loyalty required by the imperial cult could not both be given, and state the issue precisely enough to avoid the usual overstatements.
  • Explain how the imperial cult worked as a mechanism of political cohesion rather than as a set of beliefs.
  • Classify the persecutions into local, administrative and empire-wide types, name representative emperors for each, and explain why the traditional count of ten is not a historical description.
  • Describe the aim and the outcome of Diocletian's persecution, and explain what the whole experience did to the church's understanding of itself.
A myth to drop

There were not ten persecutions

The number ten comes from Christian writers of the fourth and fifth centuries counting backwards, who liked it because there were ten plagues in Egypt. Augustine thought it arbitrary. The count hides what matters, which is that persecution changed in kind. It began as local violence, became a standing legal principle applied when someone complained, and ended as a coordinated administrative operation across the whole empire.

Key idea Three different things, and the last was new in the ancient world.
Scripture

Why Matthew 24:9?

The lecture points to the phrase for my name's sake. The legal question Pliny put to Trajan was whether the name itself was punishable, and the gospel saying and the Roman legal problem land on the same phrase.

Then they will deliver you up to oppression, and will kill you. You will be hated by all of the nations for my name's sake." Matthew 24:9 · World English Bible
The conflict

The one thing that could not be shared

Roman religion was additive, and a new god could always be fitted in. Christianity could not be added, because the confession of Jesus as Lord has no version that shares. The conflict was not about the emperor's divinity or about taxes and obedience, since Christians insisted they paid and obeyed and prayed for the emperor. It was about a specific act of worship, such as sacrifice or incense, that was the visible sign of belonging.

Key idea Christians could give the emperor everything except worship, and worship was all that was asked.
The cult

Infrastructure, not megalomania

Rome ruled dozens of peoples with different languages, laws and gods. What every province shared was the cult of Rome and the emperor, with its temples, festivals and priesthoods. It gave the empire one act that everybody could perform to say I am part of this. Sincerity was not measured, so refusing was legible to everyone, and local elites who funded the cult had a stake in it.

Key idea Persecution was often driven from below.
At a glance

Three kinds of persecution

Local and occasional

Nero executed Christians after the fire of Rome in 64, but only in the city of Rome. The evidence for Domitian is much weaker and should be treated as uncertain.

Administrative and reactive

Trajan's rule to Pliny stood for about 140 years: do not seek Christians out, but punish those accused who refuse to recant. This produced Lyons in 177 and Perpetua and Felicity around 203.

Empire-wide

Decius in 250 ordered every inhabitant to sacrifice and obtain a certificate. Valerian in 257 and 258 went after clergy, cemeteries and property.

Diocletian

The last and total effort

From 303 four edicts aimed to dismantle the church as an institution: its buildings, books, leadership and capacity to reproduce. It failed because it was not enforced evenly, because the church was too large and embedded after forty years of open growth, and because it cost more than it gained. Galerius issued an edict of toleration in 311. Clergy who handed over scriptures were called traditores, and the question of whether their sacraments were valid tore the North African church apart.

Key idea The persecution's most lasting damage was inflicted after it ended, by the church on itself.
The result

What it made the church into

Persecution made the boundary visible, since membership that might cost your life means members have decided something. It gave the church a memory with names in it, such as Polycarp, Perpetua and Cyprian. And it taught the church that it was not the empire's. During the plague of the 250s Christians stayed to nurse the sick, their own and others, while many fled.

Key idea A community is defined by what it will not do.
Think about it

The pinch of incense

The state never asked Christians to stop believing. It asked them to act like everyone else, and told them the act meant nothing.

What small, apparently meaningless act does your own society ask of believers, and what would it cost to refuse?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Persecution moved from local riot to standing legal liability to empire-wide order under Decius, Valerian and Diocletian. It failed to destroy the church, and it taught the church that its life did not depend on the state's approval. The church found out what it was by finding out that a pinch of incense was not nothing.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12