Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
You will often be told there were ten persecutions. There were not.
The number comes from Christian writers of the fourth and fifth centuries who were counting backwards over a period that had just ended, and who found ten a satisfying figure because there had been ten plagues in Egypt. Augustine, who knew the count and knew where it came from, said plainly that he thought it arbitrary — other people counted differently, and he did not see how anyone could fix the number.
The count is not just imprecise. It hides the thing that actually matters, which is that persecution changed in kind over two and a half centuries. It began as local violence with an emperor's approval, became a standing legal principle applied when somebody complained, and ended as a coordinated administrative operation across an entire empire. Those are three different things, and the last one is genuinely new in the ancient world.
This lecture follows that change, and asks what the church became through it.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain why ultimate loyalty to Christ and the loyalty required by the imperial cult could not both be given, and state the issue precisely enough to avoid the usual overstatements.
- Explain how the imperial cult worked as a mechanism of political cohesion rather than as a set of beliefs.
- Classify the persecutions into local, administrative and empire-wide types, name representative emperors for each, and explain why the traditional count of ten is not a historical description.
- Describe the aim and the outcome of Diocletian's persecution, and explain what the whole experience did to the church's understanding of itself.
Then they will deliver you up to oppression, and will kill you. You will be hated by all of the nations for my name's sake." — Matthew 24:9
World English Bible
Read the last four words carefully: for my name's sake. The legal question Pliny put to Trajan was whether the name itself was punishable, and Trajan's answer settled it. The gospel saying and the Roman legal problem land on the same phrase, which is either a coincidence or is not.
1. The one thing that could not be shared
Roman religion was additive. A new god could always be fitted in beside the others, and normally was. The empire's religious policy, to the extent it had one, was to keep adding.
Christianity could not be added, and the reason is not that Christians were stubborn. It is that the confession at the centre of the faith is exclusive by construction. If Jesus is Lord in the sense the church meant — the one through whom everything was made, the one to whom final allegiance is owed — then there is no arrangement in which he is one of several. The claim does not have a version that shares.
What the conflict was about
Be precise about where the collision actually sat, because this is where most accounts overreach.
- It was not a dispute about the emperor's divinity. Educated Romans held a range of views on that, and nobody was required to hold one.
- It was not about paying taxes, obeying the law, or serving the state. Christian writers went out of their way to insist they did all three and prayed for the emperor, and they appear to have been telling the truth.
- It was about a specific act of worship — sacrifice, incense, an oath by the emperor's genius — that functioned as the visible sign of belonging to the community.
So the incompatibility was narrow and total at once. Christians could give the emperor everything except worship, and worship was the only thing being asked for.
2. How the imperial cult actually worked
The imperial cult is easy to caricature as megalomania. It was closer to infrastructure.
Rome ruled dozens of peoples with different languages, laws, gods and histories. There was no shared religion, no shared literature, and for most people no shared language. What there was, in every province, was the cult of Rome and the emperor: temples, festivals, games, priesthoods, and local elites competing for the honour of funding them.
This gave the empire something it badly needed — one act that everybody, everywhere, could perform, which said "I am part of this." Participation was the point. Sincerity was not measured and would have been impossible to measure.
Two consequences follow, and both matter for this chapter.
First, refusing was legible to everyone. A person who would not sacrifice was not making an obscure theological objection; they were doing something a market trader could interpret at a glance.
Second, the local elites who funded the cult had a direct stake in it. Persecution was often driven from below, by people whose own standing was bound up with the festivals — which is part of why it flared in some cities and never touched others.
3. Three kinds of persecution
Here is the that replaces the count of ten.
Type one: local and occasional. Nero, and possibly Domitian.
Tacitus reports that after the great fire of Rome in 64 Nero blamed the Christians and executed them with notorious cruelty — as torches, in animal skins, in the arena. It was appalling and it was confined to the city of Rome. There is no evidence of an empire-wide policy, and no evidence it continued after Nero.
Domitian is traditionally the second persecutor. The evidence is much weaker than the tradition suggests: it rests largely on later Christian writers, and historians of the period, Brian Jones among them, have questioned whether there was a persecution of Christians as such at all rather than a few political prosecutions later reinterpreted. Treat it as uncertain.
What defines this type: no legal framework, no continuity, driven by a ruler's decision or a local crisis.
Type two: administrative and reactive. Trajan through the second century.
Around 112 Trajan gave Pliny a rule, and that rule stood for roughly 140 years. Christians are not to be sought out. Anonymous accusations are not to be admitted. But if they are accused, and convicted, and refuse to recant, they are punished; if they recant and sacrifice, they go free.
Look at what this is. It is not a persecution and it is not toleration. It is a standing legal liability that activates only when a neighbour complains. A Christian could live a whole life unmolested and be dead within a week if the wrong person took offence.
That regime produced the martyrs of Lyons and Vienne in 177 under Marcus Aurelius — a case that began with mob violence and drew in the governor — and, in North Africa around 203, Perpetua and Felicity. Perpetua was a young woman of good family who kept a diary in prison; Felicity was a slave who gave birth days before they were killed. Their account is partly in Perpetua's own words and is one of the very few first-person texts by a woman from the ancient world. A persecuting edict of Septimius Severus is often cited as the trigger; the evidence for it is thin and modern historians largely doubt it.
What defines this type: a legal principle exists, it is applied inconsistently, and the initiative comes from below.
Type three: empire-wide and administrative. Decius, Valerian, Diocletian.
In 250 Decius did something genuinely new. He ordered every inhabitant of the empire to sacrifice and to obtain a certificate — a libellus — signed by a commission confirming it. Around forty-five of these certificates survive on papyrus from Egypt, ordinary documents in ordinary handwriting, which is why we know how the system worked.
Note carefully what the order was. It did not name Christians. J. B. Rives has argued that Decius was attempting something positive — universal religious participation across an empire under enormous military pressure — and that Christians were caught because the requirement was universal, not because it was aimed at them. Others read it as targeting them in effect if not in wording. Either way the result was the same: for the first time, being ignored was not an option. Everyone had to produce a document.
The church was devastated, and not mainly by executions. Enormous numbers of Christians complied. Some sacrificed. Others bought certificates without sacrificing, or had a slave or a relative do it for them. Lecture 2-4 takes up what the church did about them, because the answer very nearly split it.
Valerian in 257–258 went after the structure rather than the population: clergy first, then the cemeteries, then confiscation of property from Christians of rank. Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, was executed in 258.
Then it stopped. Valerian's son Gallienus restored the church's property in 260, and there followed about forty years in which Christianity grew openly, built buildings, and became a visible institution in most cities of the empire.
4. The last one, and why it failed
Diocletian's persecution began in 303 and is the only one that deserves the name of a total effort.
Four edicts, in stages. Destroy church buildings, surrender and burn the scriptures, and strip Christians of rank. Then arrest the clergy. Then compel the clergy to sacrifice. Then, in 304, compel everyone.
The aim was not to kill Christians. It was to dismantle the church as an institution — its property, its books, its leadership, and its capacity to reproduce itself. That was intelligent, and it was aimed at exactly the right targets.
It failed, for reasons worth naming precisely rather than piously.
- It was not enforced evenly. In the East, under Diocletian and Galerius, it was severe and prolonged. In Gaul and Britain, under Constantius, it seems to have amounted to little more than pulling down some buildings. An empire-wide policy requires an empire-wide will, and the tetrarchy did not have one.
- The church was too large and too embedded. After forty years of open growth, it had property, respectable members, and congregations in most cities. You cannot quietly remove an institution that a substantial minority of your population belongs to.
- It cost more than it gained. Galerius, dying and having got nothing for eight years of it, issued an edict of toleration in 311 that conceded the point and asked Christians to pray for him.
And it left a wound. Clergy who handed over scriptures to be burned were called traditores, "handers-over" — the word behind "traitor". When it was all over, the question of whether such men were still really bishops, and whether the sacraments they performed were valid, tore the North African church apart for a century. That is the Donatist controversy, and Augustine will be dealing with it in chapter 7. The persecution's most lasting damage to the church was inflicted after it ended, by the church, on itself.
5. What it made the church into
Persecution did not destroy the church, but the sentence "persecution strengthened the church" is too easy, so here is what can actually be said.
It made the boundary visible. A church in which membership might cost you your life is a church whose members have decided something. The metaphor the sources reach for is refining — heat, and what is left.
It gave the church a memory with people in it. Chapter 1 ended with a community whose life could be carried in the memory. This chapter adds names to that memory: Polycarp, Justin, Perpetua, Felicity, Cyprian. Lecture 2-4 takes up what the church did with them.
It taught the church that it was not the empire's. This is the one that matters most for the rest of the course. The church spent three centuries learning, at cost, that its life did not depend on the state's approval — and in chapter 4 it will receive that approval and have to remember what it learned. It did not remember very well. But the memory was there, and in chapter 6 is largely made of it.
And one thing that should be said because it is true and is usually left out. During the great plague that swept the empire in the 250s, Dionysius of Alexandria described Christians staying in the city to nurse the sick — their own and other people's — while others fled, and dying of it in numbers. Cyprian organised the same thing in Carthage, for a population that had recently been for his people's blood. That is not martyrdom in the technical sense. It is the same refusal seen from the other side: these were people who would not do certain things, and would not stop doing certain others.
6. What the empire could not require
Two and a half centuries, three kinds of pressure, and one constant. The state never asked Christians to stop believing. It asked them to act like everyone else, and told them the act meant nothing.
That is the hardest form the demand can take, because it offers a way out that costs nothing except the truth. A community is defined by what it will not do — and the church of these centuries found out what it was by finding out that a pinch of incense was not nothing.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Type | Emperors | The mechanism | The result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local and occasional | Nero (64); Domitian, doubted | A scapegoat for a local disaster; no law behind it | Terrible in one city, over when the emperor was |
| Administrative and reactive | Trajan onward; Marcus Aurelius; the Severan period | The name is punishable, but nobody is hunted | Martyrs at Lyons, Carthage and elsewhere; long quiet stretches between |
| Empire-wide | Decius (250); Valerian (257–258) | Universal sacrifice with certificates; then clergy and property | Mass compliance, and the crisis of the lapsed |
| Total | Diocletian (303–311) | Four edicts against buildings, books, clergy and rank | Uneven enforcement, failure, and the traditores quarrel |
5. Going to the Sources
- Tacitus, Annals 15.44 — a hostile Roman historian on Nero and the Christians. Read what he thinks of Nero and what he thinks of the Christians, and notice they are not the same.
- The libelli of 250 — several are translated in source collections. Two or three sentences each, and they are the most chilling documents in this lecture precisely because they are so dull.
- The Passion of Perpetua and Felicity — an hour to read. Most of it is a young woman's own account of her imprisonment, her father, and her dreams.
- Lactantius, On the Deaths of the Persecutors — a contemporary of Diocletian's persecution, writing with fury and satisfaction. A primary source and an object lesson in how the church wrote about its enemies once it was safe.
- Augustine, City of God 18.52 — one page, in which he examines the count of ten persecutions and declines to accept it.
In short
- The "ten persecutions" is not a historical description. Augustine thought the count arbitrary. Persecution changed in kind over two and a half centuries.
- Christianity could not be added to Rome's gods. Christians gave the emperor everything except worship, and the imperial cult asked for one act everyone could perform to show belonging.
- Three types: local (Nero in Rome, Domitian uncertain), administrative (Trajan's rule, active only when a neighbour complained) and empire-wide (Decius, Valerian, Diocletian).
- Decius ordered everyone to sacrifice and obtain a certificate, a libellus, and many Christians complied. Diocletian tried to dismantle the church as an institution but enforced unevenly and failed. Galerius granted toleration in 311.
- The worst damage came after: the traditores dispute split the North African church. Persecution made the boundary visible and taught the church it was not the empire's.
Topic: This lecture traces how persecution changed from local riots to an empire-wide administrative operation, and what it did to the church.
Remember: The state never asked Christians to stop believing. It asked them to perform a public act of worship like everyone else, and it told them the act meant nothing.
Caution: The lecture does not say persecution simply strengthened the church. It also warns against the tidy count of ten, and it treats the Domitian persecution as uncertain.
One line to carry into ministry: Give your rulers everything except worship, and remember that a church's worst wounds after pressure can be the ones it inflicts on itself.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The count of ten persecutions is tidy, memorable and wrong. What does it cost a church to hold a simplified version of its own history — and what does it gain?
- Trajan's rule meant a Christian could live unmolested for decades and be executed within a week. What does living under a *latent* threat do to a community, as against an active one?
- Under Decius, huge numbers of Christians complied. Before reading lecture 2-4: what should the church have done with them?
- Diocletian's persecution failed partly because the church was by then too embedded to remove. Is that a comfort or a warning?