FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 4

Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds

The argument about what entered the church with the crowds was already held inside the church around 400, and the popular account is often wrong.

Early Church History

12 cards 25 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe the concrete forms in which non-Christian practice is said to have entered the church — festivals and the cult of the saints above all — and assess how far "syncretism" is an accurate description in each case.
  • Describe the shift from the worship of the persecuted church to the ceremonial of the imperial church, in relics, architecture and the standing of the clergy, and state what is genuinely new and what is not.
  • Explain the moral crisis produced by clerical careerism and by baptism without conversion.
  • Explain the paradox that this period's worldliness produced the monastic movement as its own reaction.
The question

Which accommodations were faithful?

Around 400 the priest Vigilantius wrote against relics and vigils at martyrs' tombs, and Jerome answered him in a pamphlet of great venom. So the argument is not a sixteenth-century Protestant invention read back into the fourth century. The permanent question for any church entering a new culture is which accommodations were faithful, and by what standard anyone can tell.

Key idea The church did accommodate, and so does yours.
Scripture

Why Romans 12:2?

The lecture uses this verse because its goal is discernment, proving what the will of God is, and not separation for its own sake. It notes that this is more demanding than simply refusing what the culture does.

Don't be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what is the good, well-pleasing, and perfect will of God." Romans 12:2 · World English Bible
At a glance

Christmas and Easter

Christmas: contested

A Roman almanac of 354 first attests both the Christian celebration and the birthday of the Unconquered Sun on 25 December. Talley and Roll argue the date was calculated from 25 March. Nobody has settled it.

Easter: the claim fails

Easter is Pascha, from Passover, and it is the oldest Christian annual observance. The pagan-origin idea rests on one English word, which may come from Bede's mention of a goddess.

The saints

Driven by bishops

Peter Brown dismantled the two-tiered model, in which superstition seeped up from the ignorant masses. The cult of the saints was promoted and defended by bishops such as Ambrose, Augustine and Paulinus of Nola. It also broke a strong Roman taboo by bringing tombs inside cities and under altars. That does not settle the theological question, but it changes what the question is about.

Key idea Far from paganism carried in, it broke a Roman taboo.
At a glance

Two views of the saints

Catholic and Orthodox

Saints are alive in Christ, and asking for their prayers is like asking a fellow Christian. Honour (douleia) is different in kind from worship (latreia), which is owed to God alone.

Protestant

The distinction is coherent on paper but has repeatedly failed to hold in practice, and Christ's sole mediation is the doctrine at risk.

Ceremonial

Buildings, vestments and distance

Christians chose the basilica, a civic hall, not the temple. Vestments were ordinary late-Roman formal clothing that clergy went on wearing after fashions changed, and the chasuble began as a travelling cloak. What was genuinely lost is that worship in the persecuted church was an assembly, while imperial ceremonial introduced distance. Whether that distance is reverence or estrangement is where the traditions differ.

Key idea A frozen secular uniform, not a sacred one.
Admitted by all

Careers and baptism

Ministry became a career, and by the later fourth century episcopal elections in major cities involved money, mobs and occasional deaths. Baptism became routine for many, while others delayed it for years, such as Constantine to his deathbed and Augustine into his thirties. Out of the same church came Chrysostom, Jerome, Basil and the monks. The lecture calls monasticism the fourth century's judgement on itself.

Key idea A church with both problems at once has lost hold of what the rite is for.
Think about it

What is being absorbed?

The lecture says what failed was accommodation with nobody teaching anything.

What is your congregation currently absorbing from its surroundings that nobody has explained to anyone?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A resemblance is not a derivation, and a claim that is widely repeated has not necessarily been checked. The fourth-century church mostly chose absorption, and the lecture says that was not obviously wrong. What it lacked was teaching: the third century prepared candidates for up to three years, and the fifth baptised whole villages.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12