FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH101E Early Church History

Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH101E Early Church History
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Early Church History Is, and Why We Study It
  1. Introduction: What Early Church History Is, and Why We Study It
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Birth and Expansion of the Early Church
  1. Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
  3. Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Age of Persecution and Martyrdom
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
  2. Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
  3. Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
  4. Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Heresy, Orthodoxy, and the Church's Answer
  1. Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
  2. Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
  3. Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Constantinian Turn and the Imperial Church
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
  2. Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
  4. Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Early Councils and the Trinitarian and Christological Controversies
  1. Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
  2. Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
  3. Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
  4. Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Monastic Movement and the Spirituality of the Church
  1. Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
  2. Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
  3. Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
  4. Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Augustine and the Shaping of Western Theology
  1. Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
  4. Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Rise of the Papacy and the Mission to the Germanic Peoples
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Year the Empire Ended, and the Work That Did Not
  2. Lecture 8-2: Gregory the Great — Administration as Pastoral Care
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Franks and the Popes — an Alliance and Its Price
  4. Lecture 8-4: Christendom — a Society Entirely Inside the Church

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

Around the year 400, a priest in Gaul named Vigilantius wrote against the veneration of relics and the practice of keeping vigil at martyrs' tombs. He thought it was superstition dressed as devotion, and he said so.

Jerome answered him in a pamphlet of extraordinary venom, calling him Dormitantius — "Sleepy" instead of "Watchful" — and accusing him of reviving pagan errors.

Keep that exchange in view for the whole lecture, because it settles something at the start. The argument in this lecture is not a Protestant argument invented in the sixteenth century and read back into the fourth. It was already being had, inside the church, by people on both sides, within a century of Constantine. What the Reformation did was take one of two positions that were both already ancient.

This lecture is about what entered the church when the crowds did. It is the lecture in this course where a Protestant frame is hardest for a Protestant writer to see, and where Catholic and Orthodox readers are most likely to find their own tradition described as a decline by someone who has not asked them. So it will do three things: describe what actually developed, state what each tradition says about it in the form that tradition would accept, and mark clearly the places where the popular account is not supported by the evidence at all.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • Describe the concrete forms in which non-Christian practice is said to have entered the church — festivals and the cult of the saints above all — and assess how far "syncretism" is an accurate description in each case.
  • Describe the shift from the worship of the persecuted church to the ceremonial of the imperial church, in relics, architecture and the standing of the clergy, and state what is genuinely new and what is not.
  • Explain the moral crisis produced by clerical careerism and by baptism without conversion.
  • Explain the paradox that this period's worldliness produced the monastic movement as its own reaction.

Don't be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what is the good, well-pleasing, and perfect will of God." — Romans 12:2

World English Bible

The verse this lecture is usually preached from. Read the second half as carefully as the first: the goal is discernment — proving what the will of God is — not separation for its own sake. Paul assumes that telling the difference is difficult and requires a changed mind, which is a more demanding instruction than simply refusing whatever the surrounding culture does.

1. The question this lecture is actually asking

Every church that has ever entered a new culture has had to decide what to do with what it found there. Some things can be taken up and filled with different content. Some things carry their old content with them no matter what is done to them. And the line between the two is not obvious in advance and is usually only agreed on afterwards, by the winners.

That is not a fourth-century problem. It is the permanent problem of Christian mission, and lecture 2-3 already met it as the argument between Justin and Tertullian.

So the question here is not "did the church accommodate?" It did, and so does yours. The question is which accommodations were faithful, which were not, and by what standard anyone can tell.

2. The festivals: one strong case, one that collapses

Christmas, and the Sol Invictus question. The familiar claim is that 25 December was the festival of Sol Invictus, the Unconquered Sun, and that the church put Christ's birth there to absorb it.

This is a real hypothesis with real evidence, and it is also seriously contested. Here is the state of it.

Date of Christmas

The first document to attest a Christian celebration of Christ's birth on 25 December is a Roman almanac of the year 354 — and the same document also records the birthday of the Unconquered Sun on that date. So both are attested first in the same source, at the same moment, which makes the direction of borrowing much harder to establish than the popular version assumes. The imperial cult of Sol Invictus was promoted by Aurelian in 274; it is not obviously ancient.

Against the borrowing thesis stands the calculation hypothesis, argued by Thomas Talley and Susan Roll among others. It runs like this. An early tradition held that Christ died on 25 March. A further ancient idea held that great figures died on the same date as their conception. Nine months from 25 March gives 25 December. On this account the date is arrived at by reckoning, not by — and there is second- and third-century evidence for the March date independent of any December feast.

Specialists are genuinely divided, and some now argue for influence in the opposite direction. State the honest position: nobody has settled it, and a course that asserts the sun-god origin as fact is repeating a textbook claim rather than reporting the evidence.

Where Easter comes from

Easter, and a claim that does not survive contact. Here the popular account is simply wrong, and it is worth showing why because the error is instructive.

Easter is not a Christianised spring festival. It is Pascha, and it comes directly from Passover — the oldest Christian annual observance there is, celebrated long before Constantine and long before there was any question of absorbing anything. Lecture 3-4 already met the evidence: Polycarp travelled to Rome in the 150s to argue about when to keep it, which means it was already old and universal.

Where does the idea come from? From one language. The English word "Easter" may derive from a goddess named Ēostre, mentioned once, in passing, by Bede in the eighth century. In Greek, Latin, French, Spanish, Italian, Russian and most other languages the festival is simply called some form of Pascha. An etymological curiosity in one northern European language has generated a worldwide claim about the origins of the central Christian feast.

That is a useful lesson about this whole subject. A resemblance is not a derivation, and the fact that a claim is widely repeated tells you nothing about whether anyone has checked it.

3. The saints: a real development, and an argument about what kind

Something genuinely changed here, and it needs describing before it is judged.

Chapter 2 left the church gathering at martyrs' tombs on the anniversary of a death, it the martyr's birthday, and reading the account of the martyrdom. That practice did not stop when the persecutions ended. It grew: shrines were built over the graves, pilgrims travelled to them, churches were built to house remains, and Christians began asking the martyrs to pray for them.

The popular account of this is what Peter Brown named the "two-tiered model" — the idea that there was a pure, spiritual Christianity of the educated, into which the superstitions of the newly converted masses seeped upward, dragging paganism in with them.

Brown's The Cult of the Saints dismantled that model, and it is the most important book behind this lecture. His evidence is that the cult of the saints was not driven from below by the ignorant. It was promoted, organised and theologically defended by bishops — by Ambrose, by Augustine, by Paulinus of Nola, the most educated men in the church. And its content was not a continuation of pagan practice but something the ancient world had specifically avoided: the deliberate mixing of the living and the dead, tombs brought inside cities and under altars, when Roman custom had kept the dead firmly outside the walls. Far from being paganism carried in, it broke one of the strongest taboos of the surrounding culture.

That does not settle the theological question. It changes what the theological question is about.

Saints: two views

Here is where the traditions divide, each stated as its own holders state it.

  • Catholic and Orthodox: the saints are alive in Christ, and asking a saint to pray for you is the same thing as asking a fellow Christian to pray for you, which nobody thinks idolatrous. The honour paid to a saint (douleia) is categorically different from the worship owed to God alone (latreia), and the distinction is not a technicality but the whole point; it was formalised against the iconoclasts at the Second in 787. Whatever popular practice may sometimes look like, the church's teaching has never permitted the worship of a creature.
  • Protestant: the distinction is coherent on paper and, in practice, has repeatedly failed to hold. Where the saint is the one prayed to, where the shrine is the place healing is sought, and where a particular saint owns a trade or a town, the functional structure resembles what the surrounding religion had, whatever the theology says. And Christ's sole mediation is the doctrine at risk.

Both of these are serious positions held by serious people, and this course is not going to pretend one of them is simply the historical finding. What it can say is that the argument is old, that it was internal before it was denominational — Vigilantius against Jerome, in about 400 — and that both sides then said roughly what both sides say now.

4. Relics, buildings and ceremonial

Relics. The remains of martyrs were divided, moved, enshrined and eventually placed under altars, where in Catholic and Orthodox practice they remain. Ambrose's discovery of the bodies of two martyrs in Milan in 386, and his use of them in a political confrontation with the imperial court, is the best-documented instance and shows the practice already fully developed and already useful.

That relics were also forged, traded and used to make money is not a Protestant allegation; it is complained about by contemporaries. Augustine wrote with disgust about wandering monks selling fake relics of martyrs. The abuse and the devotion grew together, which is what usually happens.

Buildings. Lecture 4-1 noted the important point: Christians building in public chose the basilica, the civic assembly hall, not the temple. A temple housed a god and the worshippers stayed outside; a basilica held a gathering. The single largest architectural decision of this period preserved the shape of the house-church assembly at a larger scale.

Ceremonial. Incense, lamps, processions, and distinctive dress for the clergy all belong to this period, and they do come from the manners of the imperial court. It is worth being precise, though, because the usual description is too dramatic. Christian vestments are not a priestly costume invented to overawe anyone; they are ordinary late-Roman formal clothing that the clergy went on wearing after everyone else's fashions changed. The chasuble began as a travelling cloak. What happened was not the adoption of a sacred uniform but the freezing of a secular one.

Something real is still lost in the shift, and it can be named exactly: worship in the persecuted church was an assembly, and imperial ceremonial introduces distance — a sanctuary the people do not enter, a rite performed in front of them rather than by them. Whether that distance is reverence or estrangement is, again, precisely where the traditions differ.

5. Clergy and baptism: where the criticism is unarguable

On two points there is no serious dispute in any tradition, because the fourth-century church said them about itself.

Ministry became a career. Lecture 4-2 gave the first documented instance ten years in. By the later fourth century, contested episcopal elections in major cities involved money, mobs and occasional deaths. Gregory of Nazianzus resigned the see of Constantinople in disgust and wrote about the experience with a bitterness that has not dated.

Baptism became routine, and then optional in a strange way. Two opposite distortions ran at once. Many were baptised without much conversion, because it was expected. Others delayed baptism for years — Constantine to his deathbed, Augustine into his thirties — precisely because post-baptismal sin was still taken with the seriousness chapter 2 described, so it seemed prudent to wait. A church with both problems at once has lost hold of what the rite is for.

6. And then the reaction

Now the paradox, and it is the reason this chapter does not end in despair.

The same church that produced this produced its own critics, in enormous numbers, immediately. John Chrysostom preached in Constantinople against wealth so relentlessly that he was deposed and exiled for it. Jerome left Rome for a cave in Bethlehem and was rude about ecclesiastical society for the rest of his life. Basil built a hospital. And in Egypt, men and women went into the desert — chapter 6's subject — for reasons the earliest sources make explicit: because a church that everybody could join without cost was no longer a place where a whole life could be given.

is the fourth century's judgement on the fourth century, made from inside, by people who did not leave the church. A body genuinely absorbed by its culture does not generate that.

7. Where this reaches you

This lecture's argument lands directly on any congregation working where Christianity is not the ancestral religion.

Your church makes the fourth century's decision constantly. What happens at a funeral when the family's customs include observances for the dead? What about the harvest festival, the naming ceremony, the local calendar, the music? Every one of those is the question of what can be filled with new content and what carries its old content with it.

Two things worth carrying from this lecture into that decision.

The fourth-century church mostly chose absorption, and it was not obviously wrong. The alternative was a religion that remained permanently foreign, and where missions have insisted on that, the result has often been converts alienated from their own families over things that were culture rather than cult.

And the safeguards it lacked are nameable. What went wrong was not accommodation as such but accommodation without teaching — crowds received without , practices adopted without anyone explaining what they now meant. The church of the third century put candidates through up to three years of preparation. The church of the fifth baptised whole villages. The difference is not a difference of principle about culture; it is a difference in whether anyone was taught.

8. Both halves

The costs in this lecture are real. Worship acquired a distance it had not had. Devotion acquired forms that some of the church has never accepted and that were being argued about within a century. Ministry acquired a career ladder. Membership stopped meaning what it had meant.

And in the same decades the same church gathered a whole society's poor onto its registers, and produced Basil, Chrysostom, Ambrose, Jerome, Augustine and the desert.

Freedom cost the church things persecution never could, and bought it things persecution never could. What this lecture adds is that the church knew it at the time. It did not sleepwalk. It argued — Vigilantius against Jerome, Chrysostom against his congregation, Antony against the whole arrangement by walking away from it. The disagreements in this lecture are not a later church's verdict on an earlier one. They are the fourth century's own.


Paganism in the Church? Five Charges Examined One collapses, one is contested, two are developments, one is admitted by everyone THE USUAL CHARGE WHAT THE EVIDENCE SUPPORTS Christmas contested Taken over from the feast of the Unconquered Sun Both first attested in the same document, 354. Unsettled Easter the charge fails A pagan spring festival that the church absorbed It is Pascha, from Passover. The claim is one word in English The saints a real development Old patron gods returning as superstition from below Driven by bishops, and it broke Roman taboo, not continued it Ceremonial partly true Temple worship and priestly costume imported wholesale They built the civic hall, not the temple. Vestments are old coats Membership nobody disputes Baptism without conversion, ministry as a career Admitted by every tradition — and by the fourth century itself What failed was not accommodation. It was accommodation with nobody teaching anything.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Charge Status Who says otherwise
Christmas taken from Sol Invictus Genuinely contested; both dates first appear in the same 354 almanac Talley and Roll argue the date was calculated from 25 March
Easter taken from a pagan spring feast Fails. Pascha is from Passover and is the oldest Christian feast The claim rests on the English word alone; most languages say Pascha
The saints as returning patron gods A real development, but not what the charge describes Peter Brown: driven by bishops, and it broke Roman burial taboo
Ceremonial and vestments as pagan priesthood Partly true, and misdescribed The basilica is civic, not a temple; vestments are frozen ordinary dress
Baptism without conversion; ministry as a career Not disputed by anyone The fourth century said it about itself, loudly

5. Going to the Sources

  • Jerome, Against Vigilantius — the fourth-century argument about relics, conducted with no restraint at all. Read it for the fact that the argument existed, and for how it was conducted.
  • The Chronograph of 354 — the Roman almanac that first records Christmas on 25 December, and the birthday of the Unconquered Sun on the same day. The single document at the centre of the festival question.
  • John Chrysostom, homilies on wealth and poverty — a bishop of the imperial capital telling a rich congregation what he thinks of them, and losing his see over it.
  • Augustine, On the Work of Monks — including his complaint about men selling fake relics of martyrs.
  • Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 42, his farewell to Constantinople — a resignation speech about church politics, from 381, that reads as though it were written yesterday.

In short

  • The argument about what entered the church with the crowds was already held inside the church. Vigilantius and Jerome argued about relics around 400. Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant readers each see the period differently.
  • Christmas is contested: the Sol Invictus borrowing thesis and the calculation hypothesis both have defenders. Easter comes from Pascha, which grew from Passover. The "pagan Easter" claim rests on one English word.
  • Peter Brown showed that bishops promoted the cult of the saints, and it broke the Roman taboo against mixing the living and the dead. Catholic and Orthodox see honour, not worship. Protestants fear the distinction fails in practice.
  • Relics, basilicas and ceremonial grew together. Vestments were ordinary Roman clothing that stayed fixed. The lecture notes that distance entered worship, and traditions differ on whether that is reverence or estrangement.
  • Careerism among clergy and baptism without conversion are criticised in every tradition. The same church produced Chrysostom, Jerome, Basil and the monks as its own reaction.

Topic: What developed in the church after the crowds arrived, and how far "pagan influence" describes it fairly.

Remember: The question is not whether the church accommodated culture, which it did, but which accommodations were faithful and by what standard anyone can tell.

Caution: A resemblance is not a derivation. The lecture does not claim that Christmas has a settled origin, and it does not pick a winner between Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant views of the saints.

One line to carry into ministry: Accommodate local culture only with teaching, because the fourth-century problem was crowds received and practices adopted without anyone explaining what they now meant.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The Easter claim collapses on inspection but is repeated everywhere. What else do you believe about church history because you have heard it often?
  • Peter Brown showed the cult of the saints was driven by bishops rather than by uneducated crowds. Does that change the theological question, and if so how?
  • State the Catholic and Orthodox defence of asking a saint's prayers in a form its holders would accept. Then state the Protestant objection in a form *its* holders would accept. Which did you find harder?
  • The lecture argues the fourth century's failure was accommodation without teaching. What is your congregation currently absorbing from its surroundings that nobody has explained to anyone?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.