FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 5

Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit

The church did not have the Trinity in hand and lose it. It worked it out slowly, in public, mostly while losing.

Early Church History

12 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe the political reverses Athanasius suffered after Nicaea and state the theological conviction that held him to his position.
  • Explain who the Pneumatomachi were, what they conceded and what they denied, and why their position could not stand.
  • Explain the Cappadocians' distinction between ousia and hypostasis, and why it was the breakthrough that ended the deadlock.
  • State what the Council of Constantinople in 381 did, what it said about the Spirit, and — precisely — what it did not say.
After Nicaea

Athanasius against the world

Athanasius became bishop of Alexandria in 328 and was exiled five times in the next forty-five years. He spent about seventeen years of his episcopate away from his city. He was a formidable and sometimes ruthless church politician, so the charges against him were not all theological. His conviction never changed: if the Son is a creature, salvation has not happened.

Key idea The picture of a serene saint persecuted by wicked emperors is not what the sources support.
Why so long

Three things going on

Homoousios had not been secured, and it could be misread as saying Father and Son are merely two names for one thing. Ousia and hypostasis were used interchangeably, so each side could hear the other confessing a heresy. Emperors also repeatedly imposed vaguer compromise formulas, such as the Son being "like" the Father.

Key idea The church spent half a century discovering it had agreed all along and had no words to say so.
The Spirit

A second front opens

The Pneumatomachi, "fighters against the Spirit," accepted the Nicene position on the Son but refused to extend it to the Spirit. They did not deny his work or his gifts. They denied that he is God in the same sense as the Father and the Son. Athanasius argued again from salvation: a creature cannot make anyone share in God's life.

Key idea Basil argued the Spirit's divinity largely from the church's practice of worshipping him with the Father and the Son.
Scripture

Why 2 Corinthians 3:17?

The lecture uses this verse because it identifies the Spirit with "the Lord," which resists reducing him to an impersonal force, and it does so in passing.

Now the Lord is the Spirit and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty." 2 Corinthians 3:17 · World English Bible
The breakthrough

One ousia, three hypostaseis

Basil of Caesarea, Gregory of Nazianzus and Gregory of Nyssa fixed two words that had been used interchangeably. Ousia is what something is, and God is one ousia. Hypostasis is a concrete, distinct existence, and God is three hypostaseis. The three are distinguished only by relation of origin: the Father unbegotten, the Son begotten, the Spirit proceeding.

Key idea One what, three whos. The lecture also names their sister Macrina.
At a glance

What the formula excludes

Against tritheism

There is only one divine being, one ousia.

Against modalism

Father, Son and Spirit are genuinely distinct, not three masks on one actor.

Constantinople, 381

What the council did

About 150 bishops attended, all from the East, and it was recognised as ecumenical later. The creed does not call the Spirit homoousios. It says he is worshipped and glorified with the Father and the Son, so his divinity is asserted by worship. The council also condemned Apollinarianism. The creed says the Spirit proceeds from the Father, with no "and the Son."

Key idea The Filioque is a later Western addition.
Think about it

Same words, different meanings?

Both sides could hear the other confessing a heresy while saying something orthodox.

Think of a current disagreement. Are the two sides using the same words in the same way?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

By 381 the church had a vocabulary that could say one God in three and exclude the alternatives. It does not explain how one being exists as three. It marks where the road ends: not three Gods, not one God in three costumes, not a hierarchy with a creature at the bottom.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12