FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH101E Early Church History

Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH101E Early Church History
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Early Church History Is, and Why We Study It
  1. Introduction: What Early Church History Is, and Why We Study It
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: The Birth and Expansion of the Early Church
  1. Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
  3. Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
  4. Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Age of Persecution and Martyrdom
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
  2. Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
  3. Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
  4. Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Heresy, Orthodoxy, and the Church's Answer
  1. Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
  2. Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
  3. Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Constantinian Turn and the Imperial Church
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
  2. Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
  4. Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Early Councils and the Trinitarian and Christological Controversies
  1. Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
  2. Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
  3. Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
  4. Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Monastic Movement and the Spirituality of the Church
  1. Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
  2. Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
  3. Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
  4. Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Augustine and the Shaping of Western Theology
  1. Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
  4. Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Rise of the Papacy and the Mission to the Germanic Peoples
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Year the Empire Ended, and the Work That Did Not
  2. Lecture 8-2: Gregory the Great — Administration as Pastoral Care
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Franks and the Popes — an Alliance and Its Price
  4. Lecture 8-4: Christendom — a Society Entirely Inside the Church

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

Around 360, Jerome wrote a sentence about the state of the church that has never been improved on: the whole world groaned and was astonished to find itself Arian.

He was exaggerating, as he usually was. But not by much. Thirty-five years after Nicaea had settled the question, the emperor was on the other side, most of the Eastern bishops had signed formulas that avoided homoousios, councils at Rimini and Seleucia had produced a compromise creed saying the Son was simply "like" the Father, and Athanasius was in the desert again.

This lecture is about how a position that had lost won anyway. It is the least tidy part of the course and the most instructive, because it is the clearest case in Christian history of the church taking half a century to understand what it had already said.

It also has to finish the doctrine. Nicaea had said almost nothing about the Holy Spirit — its creed ends "and in the Holy Spirit", full stop. When the Son's divinity was settled, the same question arrived about the Spirit, and it had to be answered before there was a doctrine of the Trinity at all.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Describe the political reverses Athanasius suffered after Nicaea and state the theological conviction that held him to his position.
  • Explain who the *Pneumatomachi* were, what they conceded and what they denied, and why their position could not stand.
  • Explain the Cappadocians' distinction between *ousia* and *hypostasis*, and why it was the breakthrough that ended the deadlock.
  • State what the Council of Constantinople in 381 did, what it said about the Spirit, and — precisely — what it did *not* say.

Now the Lord is the Spirit and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty." — 2 Corinthians 3:17

World English Bible

A verse the fourth century found very useful and very difficult. It identifies the Spirit with "the Lord" in a way that resists reducing him to an impersonal force — and it does so in passing, in an argument about something else, which is how most of the New Testament's evidence about the Spirit arrives.

1. Athanasius against the world

Athanasius became bishop of Alexandria in 328, three years after Nicaea, and was exiled five times in the next forty-five years — by Constantine, by Constantius, by Julian, and by Valens. He spent something like seventeen years of his episcopate away from his city, some of it hiding among the monks of the Egyptian desert, who protected him.

Two things are worth being honest about.

The charges against him were not all theological. Athanasius was a formidable and sometimes ruthless church politician, accused by his enemies of violence and intimidation in Egypt. Some of the accusations were fabricated; historians differ on how many. He was not a gentle man, and the picture of a serene saint persecuted by wicked emperors is not what the sources support.

And he was right, and he did not move. Through five exiles, four emperors and thirty-five years in which his position looked finished, he kept writing — letters, treatises, festal letters to his diocese — arguing the same thing. The tag Athanasius contra mundum, Athanasius against the world, is later, but it fits.

His conviction never changed from lecture 5-1: if the Son is a creature, salvation has not happened. Everything else was negotiable to him and that was not.

2. Why it took fifty-six years

The usual account — Nicaea settled it, then wicked emperors imposed , then the church recovered — is too simple. Three things were actually going on.

The word had not been secured. Homoousios was unscriptural, previously condemned, and could be misread as saying Father and Son are merely two names for one thing. That is a real danger — it is the error called Sabellianism or modalism — and the Eastern bishops who resisted the word were often defending the genuine distinction of Father and Son, not attacking the Son's divinity.

The vocabulary was ambiguous. Ousia and hypostasis had been used interchangeably. So "three hypostaseis" could mean three individual existences (correct) or three beings (three Gods). And "one hypostasis" could mean one being (correct) or one person (modalism). Both sides could hear the other side confessing a heresy while saying something orthodox. Until that was fixed, no formula could hold.

And the politics were relentless. Emperors wanted settlement and repeatedly imposed compromise formulas that used vaguer language — the Son is "like" the Father, without saying in what respect. Constantius pressed the Homoian formula across the empire in 359–360; that is the moment Jerome was describing.

So the delay was not simple corruption. The church spent half a century discovering that it had agreed all along and had no words to say so.

3. The new question: is the Spirit God?

While that was unresolved, a second front opened.

A group whose opponents called them Pneumatomachi — "fighters against the Spirit" — accepted the Nicene position on the Son and refused to extend it to the Spirit. Note what they conceded: they did not deny the Spirit's work, or his gifts, or his presence in the church. They denied that he is God in the same sense the Father and the Son are, treating him instead as the highest of God's ministering creatures, or as a divine energy rather than one who can be worshipped.

Athanasius, in letters to Serapion written from exile in the 350s, made the same move he had made about the Son. The argument is again about salvation, and it is worth stating carefully because it is not obvious.

Christians hold that the Spirit is what makes a person holy — that is his work, and that through him believers are joined to Christ and share in God's own life. But a creature cannot make anyone share in God, because a creature does not have God's life to give. If the Spirit is created, then he cannot do what the church says he does. And there is the same argument from practice: the church baptises into the name of Father, Son and Holy Spirit, one name for three, which is either idolatrous or decisive.

Basil of Caesarea then wrote On the Holy Spirit (around 375), the fullest treatment, and did something tactically interesting: he argued the Spirit's full divinity largely without using the word homoousios of him, relying instead on the church's practice of glorifying the Spirit "with" the Father and the Son in worship. He was trying to win people, not just to win.

4. The Cappadocian breakthrough

The deadlock was broken by three people from Cappadocia in central Asia Minor: Basil of Caesarea, his friend Gregory of Nazianzus, and his younger brother Gregory of Nyssa.

One name should be added that the standard account leaves out. Macrina, Basil's and Gregory of Nyssa's sister, founded the ascetic community on the family estate that shaped both of them, and Gregory of Nyssa wrote both a Life of Macrina and a dialogue, On the Soul and the Resurrection, in which she is the teacher and he is the pupil being corrected. Whatever allowance is made for literary convention, he presents his sister as his theological superior, and this course will not repeat an account of the Cappadocians in which she does not appear.

The breakthrough was terminological, and it was decisive. They fixed the two words that had been used interchangeably:

Two Greek words

  • Ousia — what something is. The answer to "what?" God is one ousia.
  • Hypostasis — a concrete, distinct existence. The answer to "who?" God is three hypostaseis.

So: one ousia, three hypostaseis. One what, three whos.

That formula does two jobs at once, which is why it ended the argument. Against tritheism it says there is only one divine being. Against modalism it says Father, Son and Spirit are genuinely distinct, not three masks on one actor. And it lets the Eastern bishops who had feared homoousios accept it, because it is now clear that the word asserts one ousia and not one hypostasis.

The Cappadocians added a further move: the three are distinguished by their relations — the Father unbegotten, the Son begotten, the Spirit proceeding — and by nothing else. There is no difference of power, will, or rank. The whole distinction lies in relation of origin.

Gregory of Nazianzus is also the one who states the limit of the whole enterprise most clearly. He says that when he thinks of the One he is illuminated by the splendour of the Three, and when he distinguishes the Three he is carried back to the One. That is not an explanation. It is a report that the mind cannot hold both at once — which is the chapter's principle in a sentence.

5. Constantinople, 381

Theodosius, newly emperor and firmly Nicene, summoned a council to Constantinople in 381.

Be accurate about what it was. Around 150 bishops attended, all from the East; no Western bishops were present and the bishop of Rome was not represented. It was, at the time, an imperial council of the Eastern church. It came to be recognised as the second later, and its authority was affirmed at Chalcedon in 451.

What it did:

  • Reaffirmed the faith of Nicaea, and the creed associated with the council — the one recited in most churches today — expands the Nicene text considerably, particularly on the Spirit. The exact relationship between the council and that text is debated by scholars; it is first quoted as the council's creed at Chalcedon seventy years later.
  • Confessed the divinity of the Holy Spirit — and how it does so is important. The creed does not call the Spirit homoousios. It says he is "the Lord and giver of life, who proceeds from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified, who spoke through the prophets." The Spirit's divinity is asserted by saying he is worshipped, not by applying the technical term. That was a deliberate accommodation to people who could accept the substance and not the word.
  • Condemned Apollinarianism — the view that in Christ the divine Word took the place of a human mind. Gregory of Nazianzus's answer to it is the sentence lecture 5-3 turns on: what is not assumed is not healed.

And one thing it did not say. The creed states that the Spirit proceeds from the Father. It does not say "and the Son". The Latin is a later Western addition, and lecture 5-4 follows what happened when it was made.

6. What was actually achieved

By 381 the church had a doctrine of the : one God in three, with a vocabulary precise enough to say it and to exclude the alternatives.

Notice what that vocabulary does and does not do. It does not explain how one being exists as three, and the Cappadocians say plainly that it cannot be explained — Gregory of Nazianzus's image is of a mind swinging between the One and the Three and never resting. What the formula does is mark out the places where the road ends: not three Gods, not one God in three costumes, not a hierarchy with a creature at the bottom.

The creeds fence the mystery rather than explain it. The Trinity is not a solution to a problem; it is the shortest description of the God the church had been worshipping, baptising into and praying to since Pentecost, written down at last because people had begun saying it was something else.

And the fifty-six years are the lesson. The church did not have this in hand and lose it. It worked it out, slowly, in public, mostly while losing.


From Nicaea to Constantinople — Fifty-Six Years The delay was not simply corruption. The church had no words for what it meant. THE PROBLEM WHAT RESOLVED IT 325–360 the reverses Emperors impose vaguer creeds; Athanasius exiled five times He does not move, and keeps writing from the desert The words the real deadlock Ousia and hypostasis used alike, so each side heard heresy The Cappadocians fix them: one what, three whos The Spirit the second front His work granted, his divinity denied — a ministering creature A creature cannot give God's life. And we are baptised into him 381 Constantinople 150 bishops, all from the East. Ecumenical only in hindsight The Lord and giver of life — divinity asserted by worship Not said note it now The creed says the Spirit proceeds from the Father It does not say "and the Son". That is added later, in the West The church did not have this in hand and lose it. It worked it out in public, mostly while losing.

Diagram 1. Summary table

Stage What happened Contribution
After Nicaea Athanasius exiled five times; emperors impose vaguer formulas He refuses to move, and keeps arguing from salvation
The deadlock Ousia and hypostasis used interchangeably, so both sides hear heresy Nothing could hold until the vocabulary was fixed
The Spirit The Pneumatomachi grant his work and deny his divinity Athanasius and Basil: a creature cannot give God's own life
The breakthrough The Cappadocians — with Macrina behind them — fix the terms One ousia, three hypostaseis; distinguished only by relation
Constantinople 381 150 Eastern bishops; Apollinarianism condemned The Spirit confessed as Lord and giver of life, worshipped with the Father and Son

5. Going to the Sources

  • Athanasius, Letters to Serapion on the Holy Spirit — the argument for the Spirit's divinity, written from exile, and the model for everything after it.
  • Basil of Caesarea, On the Holy Spirit — the fullest treatment, and a lesson in arguing for a conclusion without insisting on the opponent's least favourite word.
  • Gregory of Nazianzus, Theological Orations (Orations 27–31) — the best theology written in this century, and the fifth is on the Spirit. Oration 27 opens by saying that not everyone should be doing this in public all the time, which is worth reading in a period like ours.
  • Gregory of Nyssa, Life of Macrina and On the Soul and the Resurrection — his sister as his teacher.
  • The Creed of Constantinople (381) — read the third article slowly and notice that the word homoousios is not applied to the Spirit, and that "and the Son" is not there.

In short

  • After Nicaea, the Nicene side lost politically. Athanasius was exiled five times and held to one conviction: if the Son is a creature, salvation has not happened. The lecture also notes he was a ruthless church politician.
  • The delay had three causes: the word homoousios was unsecured, the words ousia and hypostasis were used interchangeably, and emperors pressed vague compromise formulas.
  • The Pneumatomachi accepted the Son's divinity but not the Spirit's. Athanasius argued from salvation, and Basil argued from worship, largely without applying homoousios to the Spirit.
  • The Cappadocians, Basil, Gregory of Nazianzus and Gregory of Nyssa, fixed the vocabulary: one ousia (what), three hypostaseis (who). The lecture also names their sister Macrina.
  • Constantinople in 381 was an Eastern council. It affirmed the Spirit's divinity by saying he is worshipped, condemned Apollinarianism and said the Spirit proceeds from the Father, with no "and the Son."

Topic: How the church spent fifty-six years working out the Trinity, from the Nicene setback to the Spirit's divinity at Constantinople in 381.

Remember: One ousia, three hypostaseis: one what, three whos. This vocabulary does not explain the mystery. It marks where the road ends.

Caution: The lecture does not say the church held the answer all along and lost it. It says the church worked it out slowly, mostly while losing. The Filioque is a later Western addition.

One line to carry into ministry: When people seem to confess opposite errors, check whether they are using the same words differently before concluding they disagree.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • For thirty-five years the orthodox position looked defeated. What does that ask of someone who is currently in a minority in their own church — and how would they tell whether they were Athanasius or simply stubborn?
  • Basil argued the Spirit's divinity while avoiding the word his opponents could not accept. When is that wisdom and when is it evasion?
  • The Cappadocians solved a theological crisis by defining two words. What does that suggest about how many current disagreements are actually about vocabulary?
  • Gregory of Nyssa presents his sister as his teacher. Who taught the people who taught you, and does your tradition's account of its own history name them?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.