FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH101E · Chapter 5

Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon

Chalcedon tells us where the road stops, not how. And the vocabulary that guarded the faith also divided the church for fifteen centuries.

Early Church History

12 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain why the christological question is a question about salvation — what Christ must be in order to save.
  • State Nestorius's concern and Cyril's, explain the argument over Theotokos and Christotokos, and say what was actually at stake in the word.
  • Explain Eutyches's position and why the church judged it destroys Christ's humanity.
  • List the four negatives of the Chalcedonian Definition, explain what each excludes, and describe who rejected the council and what has since been agreed with them.
Salvation

What is not assumed is not healed

Christ must be fully God or he cannot save. He must also be fully human, or what he saves is not us. Gregory of Nazianzus wrote against Apollinaris: "What is not assumed is not healed." If Christ had no human mind or will, human minds and wills are not saved. Every christological heresy is a way of making the union easier.

Key idea Two complete things in one person, with neither diluted.
Scripture

Why John 1:14?

The lecture uses this verse because it asks what kind of union the word "became" names: how one who is God can be, without ceasing to be God, a particular human being.

The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." John 1:14 · World English Bible
At a glance

Antioch and Alexandria

Antioch

Stressed the distinction of the two natures and the reality of Christ's human experience: growth, ignorance, fear and suffering as genuinely human. It feared a Christ whose humanity was swallowed.

Alexandria

Stressed the unity of the person, so that it is God who was born, suffered and died. It feared a Christ who was two people in a partnership.

Ephesus, 431

Theotokos

Nestorius objected to the title Theotokos, God-bearer, and proposed Christotokos, Christ-bearer. Cyril saw that the word is christological, not Marian: it asks who was born. If the answer is a man joined to the Word, then the Word did not become flesh. Cyril called the one subject in two natures the hypostatic union.

Key idea Nestorius may not have taught what was condemned under his name; scholars dispute it.
Eutyches

The swing too far

Eutyches held that after the union there is only one nature in Christ. As his opponents reported it, his image was a drop of wine absorbed in the sea. The church judged that if the humanity is absorbed, our humanity is not assumed and so not healed. The Second Council of Ephesus in 449 acquitted him under heavy pressure, and Pope Leo called it a gang of robbers.

Key idea Cyril's emphasis on unity could be pushed further than he pushed it.
Chalcedon, 451

Four negatives

The Definition confesses one Christ in two natures: without confusion, without change, without division and without separation. The first two exclude Eutyches, and the second two exclude the position condemned as Nestorius's. It adds that each nature's properties are preserved in one person and one hypostasis. It offers no mechanism or analogy.

Key idea It builds a fence around the mystery, marks the four roads out of it, and stops.
The churches that left

Miaphysite is not monophysite

Churches in Egypt, Syria, Armenia and elsewhere rejected "in two natures" because Cyril's own formula was "one incarnate nature of the God-Word." They hold that the two natures are united without confusion or change into one composite nature. This is miaphysitism, and it must be distinguished from Eutyches's monophysitism. Modern dialogues, including Chambesy in 1989 and 1990, concluded they confess the same faith in different formulas.

Key idea A fifteen-century division was judged substantially about words.
Think about it

A division five centuries from now

The churches now largely agree that the split of 451 was substantially about terminology.

What present division in the church might look like that in five hundred years?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Nicaea ruled out a created Son, Constantinople a created Spirit and a Christ without a human mind, and Chalcedon a blended Christ and a divided one. None explains anything; each says where the road stops. The fence had to be built in words, and the words divided the church.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12