Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Chalcedon is usually taught as the triumphant conclusion of this course's doctrinal story: the church, after a century and a half, gets the person of Christ exactly right, and the creeds are complete.
That is true, and it leaves out the most consequential fact about the council. Chalcedon split the church, and the churches that left are still there.
The Coptic Orthodox Church of Egypt, the Syriac Orthodox Church, the Armenian Apostolic Church, the Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Churches, and the Malankara Church of India did not accept the Definition of 451. Together they are called the Oriental Orthodox, they number tens of millions, and they have spent fifteen centuries saying that they were misunderstood and misrepresented. Separately, the Church of the East — which rejected Ephesus in 431 — carried Christianity to Persia, India and China.
In the last fifty years, formal dialogues between these churches and the Catholic, Orthodox and Reformed communions have largely concluded that they were right about that — that the division rested substantially on incompatible uses of the same Greek words rather than on incompatible faiths.
This lecture teaches the doctrine and it teaches the division, because a course that celebrates 451 without mentioning what it cost is not teaching church history.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain why the christological question is a question about salvation — what Christ must be in order to save.
- State Nestorius's concern and Cyril's, explain the argument over *Theotokos* and *Christotokos*, and say what was actually at stake in the word.
- Explain Eutyches's position and why the church judged it destroys Christ's humanity.
- List the four negatives of the Chalcedonian Definition, explain what each excludes, and describe who rejected the council and what has since been agreed with them.
The Word became flesh, and lived among us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the one and only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." — John 1:14
World English Bible
The verse returns from lecture 3-1, now doing harder work. Against the Gnostics it had to establish that the flesh was real. Here the question is what kind of union the word became names — how one who is God can be, without ceasing to be God, a particular human being who got tired and was killed.
1. Why this is a question about salvation
By 381 the church had settled who God is. The next question was unavoidable: what happened in Jesus Christ?
It is not idle curiosity. The requirement comes from both ends at once.
He must be fully God, or he cannot save. That is Athanasius's argument from lecture 5-1, and it is settled.
He must be fully human, or what he saves is not us. This is the second half, and Gregory of Nazianzus put it in the sentence that governs the rest of this lecture, written against Apollinaris, who had said the divine Word took the place of a human mind in Christ:
What is not assumed is not healed.
If Christ had no human mind, human minds are not saved. If he had no human will, human wills are not saved. Whatever of us he did not take up, he did not heal. So the humanity must be complete — not a body with God inside it, but a human life, with a human mind, a human will, and human limitation.
And now the difficulty. Two complete things — full deity and full humanity — in one person, without either being diluted. Every christological heresy is a way of making that easier, by weakening one side or the other or by loosening the union.
Two schools approached it differently, and both were trying to protect something real.
- Antioch stressed the distinction of the two natures, and the reality of Christ's human experience — his growth, ignorance, fear and suffering as genuinely human.
- Alexandria stressed the unity of the person, and that the subject of the whole life is the Word — so that it is God who was born, God who suffered, God who died.
Each was guarding against the other's failure mode. Antioch feared a Christ whose humanity was swallowed; Alexandria feared a Christ who was two people in a partnership.
2. Ephesus, 431: Theotokos
Nestorius, an Antiochene monk who became archbishop of Constantinople in 428, objected to a title in popular use for Mary: Theotokos, God-bearer, or Mother of God. His argument was straightforward — Mary is a creature; a creature cannot be the source of the deity of the Word; she gave birth to the human being who was united to the Word. He proposed Christotokos, Christ-bearer, as more accurate.
Cyril of Alexandria saw immediately what was at stake, and it was not Mary.
The word is a christological term, not a Marian one. It answers the question: who was born? If the answer is "a man, to whom the Word was joined", then the Word did not become flesh; the Word moved in with someone. And then the crucifixion is the death of a man closely associated with God, not the death of God's Son — and the whole New Testament claim that God has entered our condition is gone.
So Cyril insisted that the one born of Mary is the eternal Word, now incarnate — one subject, one hypostasis, in two natures. He called it the : not a moral partnership, not the Word inhabiting a man, but the Word himself living a human life.
Two honest notes.
Protestant readers should notice that Theotokos has been accepted by the mainstream Reformers. Luther and Calvin both affirmed Mary as Mother of God in this christological sense. Disagreement between the traditions about Mary concerns much later developments, not this word. To reject Theotokos is to take Nestorius's side on a question about Christ.
And Nestorius may not have been a Nestorian. In 1895 a work of his was rediscovered in Syriac, the Bazaar of Heracleides, written in exile, in which he defends himself in terms many scholars find close to what Chalcedon would later say. He is revered as a teacher by the Assyrian Church of the East, which rejects the charge that he taught two persons in Christ. Whether he actually held the position condemned under his name is genuinely disputed.
The council itself was a scandal. Cyril opened proceedings at Ephesus before the Antiochene delegation under John of Antioch had arrived, and had Nestorius condemned. When John arrived, he convened a rival council and condemned Cyril. The emperor eventually arrested both. Two years later Cyril and John agreed a Formula of Reunion (433) which is notably more balanced than either party's rhetoric — it affirms Theotokos and speaks of two natures.
The doctrine was right. The process was disgraceful, and pretending otherwise teaches students to trust procedures that should not be trusted.
3. Eutyches, and the swing too far
Cyril's emphasis on unity could be pushed further than he pushed it, and it was.
Eutyches, an elderly and influential monk at Constantinople, held that after the union there is only one nature in Christ. His image, as his opponents reported it, was of a drop of wine falling into the sea: the humanity is genuinely there and is entirely absorbed. He was prepared to say that Christ's flesh was not of the same substance as ours.
That is fatal, for exactly Gregory's reason. If the humanity is absorbed, our humanity is not assumed, and therefore is not healed. Christ becomes a divine being wearing a human appearance — which is arriving from a new direction.
There followed the Second Council of Ephesus in 449, which acquitted Eutyches under heavy pressure from Alexandria and by procedural force — Pope Leo called it a latrocinium, a gang of robbers, and the name stuck. A new emperor called a new council two years later.
4. Chalcedon, 451: four words that are all negatives
Around 500 bishops met at Chalcedon, across the water from Constantinople. They had before them Cyril's letters and the Tome of Leo, a letter from the bishop of Rome setting out the Western position with characteristic Latin clarity: one person, two natures, each retaining its own properties and acting in communion with the other.
The bishops examined the Tome against Cyril's letters before accepting it — they did not simply defer to Rome — and then acclaimed it: Peter has spoken through Leo.
The Definition they produced confesses one and the same Christ, acknowledged in two natures:
- without confusion (asynchytōs) — the two are not blended into a third thing
- without change (atreptōs) — neither is converted into the other
- without division (adiairetōs) — the natures do not make two subjects
- without separation (achōristōs) — they are never apart
The first two exclude Eutyches. The second two exclude the position condemned as Nestorius's. And then the Definition adds that the properties of each nature are preserved, coming together in one person and one hypostasis.
Look at what that is. The most important sentence in Christian doctrine after the creed consists of four things the union is not, followed by an insistence that both natures are fully there. It offers no mechanism, no analogy, no account of how. It builds a fence around the mystery, marks the four roads that lead out of it, and stops.
That is not evasion. It is the church saying: this is what we have received, these are the ways of describing it that destroy it, and we do not claim to understand it.
5. The churches that left
Now the part the standard account omits.
Chalcedon's "in two natures" was, for many in Egypt, Syria and Armenia, a betrayal of Cyril. Cyril's own preferred formula had been "one incarnate nature of the God-Word" — mia physis — and for those who held to it, saying "in two natures" sounded like dividing Christ in the way Nestorius had. They were not Eutychians; they rejected Eutyches too. They held that the two natures, without any confusion or change, are united into one composite nature in the incarnate Word.
This is called miaphysitism, and it must be distinguished from Eutyches's , in which the humanity is absorbed. The two are routinely confused, including in textbooks, and the confusion is the entire problem.
Political and cultural factors made the split permanent — imperial coercion, Greek dominance resented in Coptic- and Syriac-speaking provinces, and later the Arab conquest putting these churches outside the empire altogether. They have continued for fifteen centuries as living churches with their own liturgies, saints and martyrs.
And here is what has happened recently. From the 1960s onward, formal dialogues between the Oriental Orthodox churches and the Eastern Orthodox, and separately with the Catholic Church, examined whether the difference was one of faith or of terminology. The agreed statements — the Eastern Orthodox–Oriental Orthodox agreements of 1989 and 1990 at Chambésy, and joint declarations signed by successive popes with Coptic, Syriac and Armenian patriarchs — concluded that the churches confess the same faith in Christ in different formulas. A parallel agreement was reached with the Assyrian Church of the East in 1994 over the Ephesus division.
None of these has produced full communion, and serious questions remain about councils and authority. But on the christological substance, the considered judgement of the churches themselves is that a division which has lasted fifteen hundred years and cost a great deal was substantially about words.
That is the most sobering fact in this chapter and it belongs at the end of it.
6. What the councils actually did
They fenced a mystery. Nicaea ruled out a created Son. Constantinople ruled out a created Spirit and a Christ without a human mind. Chalcedon ruled out a blended Christ and a divided one.
Not one of them explains anything. Every one of them tells you where the road stops.
The creeds fence the mystery rather than explain it — and lecture 5-3's hard addition is that the fence has to be built in words, words belong to languages, and languages do not map onto each other. The councils protected the faith. The vocabulary they protected it with divided the church, and it took until our own lifetime for the churches to sit down and check whether they had been disagreeing at all.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Nestorius (as condemned) | Eutyches | Chalcedon | The miaphysite churches | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The two natures | Kept apart; risk of two subjects | Humanity absorbed into deity | Two, in one person, four negatives | United into one composite nature |
| Mary | Christotokos | — | Theotokos confirmed | Theotokos affirmed |
| What is lost | God did not truly die for us | Our humanity is not assumed | — | Nothing, on the modern agreements |
| Condemned at | Ephesus, 431 | Chalcedon, 451 | — | Not heretics; a different formula |
| Living descendants | Assyrian Church of the East | None | Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant | Coptic, Syriac, Armenian, Ethiopian, Malankara |
5. Going to the Sources
- The Definition of Chalcedon — one paragraph. Read it aloud and count the negatives.
- The Tome of Leo — a few pages, and the clearest short statement of the Western position.
- Cyril of Alexandria, Second Letter to Nestorius — the letter the council of 431 approved. Cyril arguing rather than manoeuvring.
- Nestorius, The Bazaar of Heracleides — his own defence, rediscovered in 1895. Read it before deciding what he taught.
- The Chambésy agreed statements (1989, 1990) between the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox — a few pages, and the modern verdict on a fifteen-hundred-year division.
In short
- Christ must be fully God to save and fully human so that what is saved is us. Gregory of Nazianzus said: "What is not assumed is not healed." Antioch stressed the two natures, and Alexandria stressed the one person.
- Nestorius objected to Theotokos. Cyril answered that the word asks who was born, and the Word himself became flesh. Nestorius may not have taught what was condemned under his name, and scholars dispute it.
- Eutyches taught one nature after the union, with the humanity absorbed. The church judged this destroys Christ's humanity. The Second Council of Ephesus in 449 supported him and was called a gang of robbers.
- Chalcedon in 451 confessed one Christ in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division and without separation. It fences the mystery and offers no mechanism.
- Oriental Orthodox churches rejected Chalcedon. They hold miaphysitism, not Eutyches's monophysitism. Modern dialogues have judged the division substantially about terminology, though full communion has not followed.
Topic: How Ephesus and Chalcedon defined the person of Christ, and how the churches that rejected Chalcedon were later judged to share the same faith.
Remember: Chalcedon gives four negatives and affirms both natures fully in one person. It tells us where the road stops and does not explain how.
Caution: Miaphysitism is not Eutyches's monophysitism, and the two are often confused. Dialogue has not produced full communion, and questions about councils and authority remain.
One line to carry into ministry: Before treating a long-standing division as a difference of faith, check whether the two sides mean the same thing by different words.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- "What is not assumed is not healed." Work out what that implies about a part of human life you had not thought of as needing salvation.
- The doctrine settled at Ephesus was right and the council was a scandal. How should that affect the confidence with which anyone appeals to a council's authority?
- *Theotokos* is a statement about Christ. If your tradition is uneasy with the title, is the unease about this word or about later developments — and can you tell?
- The churches now largely agree that the split of 451 was substantially about terminology. What present division in the church might look like that in five hundred years?