Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
What was lost was not agreement but the capacity to disagree and still stay in communion.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
What was lost was not agreement but the capacity to disagree and still stay in communion.
Early Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Around 810 Frankish theologians recited the creed with Filioque, "and the Son," and Charlemagne's court wanted Rome to endorse it. Pope Leo III agreed with the theology but refused to add the word. He had the creed engraved in Greek and Latin without the Filioque on two silver shields in St Peter's.
A precise metaphysical vocabulary: ousia, hypostasis, physis. Its centre of gravity was being, and its goal was theosis, sharing God's life by grace.
Tertullian built a vocabulary from legal terms: persona, substantia, satisfactio, meritum. Its centre was guilt and remedy, grace and free will, and the church's order.
The lecture warns that the Greek-Latin contrast is a matter of emphasis, and both traditions had both. The translation problem was real, though. Latin rendered hypostasis as substantia, which was also the rendering of ousia. The orthodox Greek formula "three hypostaseis" could reach Latin ears as three substances, meaning three Gods.
In the East the councils were convened by an emperor, and authority lay in the bishops gathered. In the West the bishop of Rome gained authority through the Petrine argument, through Leo's Tome at Chalcedon and, most of all, because there was no emperor in the West after 476. Canon 28 of Chalcedon gave Constantinople privileges equal to Rome's; Leo refused to ratify it.
The addition began in Spain, at councils of Toledo, and spread to the Franks. Rome resisted adding it to the creed for about two hundred years. One question is whether the theology is true: does the Spirit proceed from the Father and the Son, or from the Father alone? The harder question is who may change a creed that was the work of an ecumenical council.
The lecture uses this passage because Paul writes of unity right after telling the Ephesians to be diligent to keep it, which implies it can be lost.
There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all, and through all, and in us all." Ephesians 4:4–6 · World English Bible
Cyril and Methodius made a written form of Slavonic so the Bible and liturgy could be in the people's own tongue. The faith is received in the language of the receivers.
The Latin church worked through Latin, with Rome as the point of reference. It gave a common learned culture and universities, but a liturgy ordinary people did not speak.
Polycarp and the bishop of Rome disagreed about the date of Easter and stayed in communion.
Does your congregation still have the capacity to disagree with another tradition and stay in communion, and what keeps it alive?
Doctrine was genuinely at stake, but the differences did not have to be church-dividing. What changed was the capacity to disagree: two languages that no longer translated, two authorities that could not both be final, and a political situation in which every difference had a constituency. The fence the councils built was made of words.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.