Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
One added phrase in the creed, "and the Son", grew from a local defence of Christ's divinity into a dispute about who may change a creed.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
One added phrase in the creed, "and the Son", grew from a local defence of Christ's divinity into a dispute about who may change a creed.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The Council of Constantinople in 381 gave the church the words that the Holy Spirit "proceeds from the Father". The phrase comes almost directly from John 15:26. The Western church later recited "proceeds from the Father and the Son". That is the whole textual dispute, and everything else follows from it.
The lecture says both positions can be seen inside this verse. Christ sends the Spirit, and the Spirit proceeds from the Father. The East builds on the second clause, and the West on the first.
When the Counselor has come, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth, who proceeds from the Father, he will testify about me." John 15:26 · World English Bible
The Filioque became normal in Visigothic Spain, usually dated to the Third Council of Toledo in 589. The Visigoths had been Arian, holding that the Son is a creature. Adding "and from the Son" put the Son clearly on the Father's side of the line between God and creation. It was aimed at Arians in Toledo, not at bishops in Constantinople.
The phrase reached Charlemagne's court, where Frankish theologians wanted to show the Greeks were doctrinally deficient. Pope Leo III agreed with the doctrine but refused to alter the words of an ecumenical creed. He had the creed inscribed in Greek and Latin on two silver shields in St Peter's. Rome held that line for two centuries, and the phrase appears in the creed at Rome only around 1014.
The Father alone is the single source of the Godhead. Photius argued that adding the Son gives two sources, or blurs the difference between the Persons.
Latin theology starts from the unity of the divine essence. The Persons are their relations, and the Spirit is the love proceeding between Father and Son, as in Augustine.
The Greek verb ekporeuesthai means proceeding from an ultimate origin. In that strict sense, Catholic theology also holds that the Spirit proceeds from the Father alone, as the Vatican stated in 1995. The Latin procedere is broader, and can mean simply to come forth from. Some Orthodox theologians find this reassuring. Others say the picture of God still differs.
The Council of Ephesus in 431 forbade any creed other than the one the church already confessed. The East read this to mean that the creed belongs to the whole church, and no part may alter it alone. The Filioque was altered without any ecumenical council. To the East this was a claim of jurisdiction. So the question became who decides: a council of the whole church, or the successor of Peter.
The word entered the creed for a good pastoral reason, and Rome resisted it for two centuries on principle. The East guarded a creed that belongs to everyone, and the West guarded the full divinity of the Son. Each ended up hearing the other's guarding as an attack. The question changed from whether this is true to who is entitled to say it.
Leo III held the doctrine but denied himself the amendment.
Before changing words that a whole community says together, who has the authority to change them, and who should be consulted?
The Filioque began in Spain in 589 as a defence of the Son's divinity. Rome held back for two centuries. The dispute turned less on whether the phrase is true than on who has authority to put it in the creed.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.