Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
The church moved from a just war theory that restricted violence to a holy war idea in which fighting itself earned spiritual reward.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The church moved from a just war theory that restricted violence to a holy war idea in which fighting itself earned spiritual reward.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The lecture uses this verse because it was read in every church in 1095. The lecture asks how a church that read it every year came to preach what it preached.
But I tell you, love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you." Matthew 5:44 · World English Bible
From about the year 1000, Europe grew in food and in people. Younger sons of knights were trained to fight but had no land to inherit. The church had spent a century trying to contain local warfare with the Peace of God and the Truce of God. In 1095 it found those knights something to fight. The papacy was also newly confident, and Urban II was a reform pope.
In 1071 the Byzantine army was destroyed at Manzikert, and most of Anatolia was lost within a decade. In 1095 the emperor Alexios I sent envoys to Urban. He asked for mercenaries, under Byzantine command, to recover Anatolia. What arrived was an independent army with its own leaders and a religious mandate to take Jerusalem. That mismatch poisoned relations from the start.
Fighting is a permitted evil. The three criteria are legitimate authority, just cause and right intention, and each one restricts violence. Penance is still owed.
Fighting is itself a religious act that earns reward. Urban's offer was that the journey to Jerusalem counted as full satisfaction of the penance owed.
Crusaders were seen as pilgrims who happened to be armed. They took the cross as a vow, wore it as a pilgrim's badge and had a pilgrim's legal protections. Pilgrimage was already an established penitential act, so an army attached to it inherited its merit. Augustine's framework asked under what conditions this evil may be permitted. The new framework asked how much good it earns.
Going on crusade was ruinously expensive, and a knight often had to sell or mortgage land. The motives included devotion and fear of hell, the pull of Jerusalem, land and plunder, loyalty and shame, and a new sense of Christendom. A purely cynical enterprise could not have moved so many people so far at such a cost. The problem was not that the piety was fake, but what the piety had been told to do.
One popular account presents the crusades as unprovoked Western aggression. Another presents them as a defensive response to centuries of Islamic conquest. Islamic expansion had taken Syria, Egypt, North Africa, Spain and Sicily, and the Seljuk advance was real and recent. But the First Crusade marched past what was threatened to take a city no living Western Christian had ruled. The lecture says readers will not agree on this point.
Nothing was formally rescinded. A new category was added that the old framework had no defence against.
When your church asks what a good action earns, are the limits on that action still being heard?
Augustine's just war was designed to restrict violence, and it never said fighting is good for the soldier's soul. At Clermont, fighting became meritorious, and armed pilgrimage carried that merit. Nothing was repealed, but the restrictions no longer restrained.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.