Lecture 5-2: Hus, the Chalice and a Broken Promise
Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong, and was told to recant instead. His death produced a war, a concession and a church.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong, and was told to recant instead. His death produced a war, a concession and a church.
Medieval Church History
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Jan Hus went to the Council of Constance in 1414 with a safe conduct from Sigismund. He went voluntarily, to explain himself. He was arrested within weeks and kept in chains for months. He was tried on a list of articles that included several he denied holding, and he was burned alive on 6 July 1415. The council held that a safe conduct given to a suspected heretic did not bind.
The lecture uses this passage because it does not distinguish between who receives the bread and who receives the cup. The lecture says that observation started a war.
For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, “Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.” In the same way he also took the cup, after supper, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.”" 1 Corinthians 11:23–25 · World English Bible
In 1382 Anne of Bohemia married Richard II of England, and the two courts opened to each other. Bohemian students came to Oxford and carried Wycliffe's books home. Bohemia already had its own reform preaching in Czech, and the university and much of the church hierarchy were dominated by Germans, while the reforming party was Czech. Reform and Czech identity fused. From 1402 Hus preached in the Bethlehem Chapel, a hall built for preaching in Czech to ordinary people.
In On the Church (1413), Hus argues that the true church is the body of the predestined, and that Christ alone is its head. A pope who commands what is contrary to Christ is not to be obeyed.
Hus never denied transubstantiation. He said so repeatedly at Constance. He was condemned in part for articles he explicitly denied holding.
He attacked the preaching of a crusade indulgence and was excommunicated, a hundred and five years before Luther's theses.
Medieval Western practice gave the laity only the bread at communion. The cup was reserved to the priest. In 1414 Jakoubek of Stribro argued from 1 Corinthians 11 and John 6 that communion in both kinds, called utraquism, was Christ's own institution for all Christians. Hus approved from prison. The reservation of the cup was the most visible weekly sign of the difference between clergy and laity, so giving the cup to the laity removed that sign.
Hus was arrested about three weeks after arriving, and he was imprisoned for months. He asked to defend his positions in open disputation and was refused. He was offered a list of articles from his works and asked to abjure all of them. He refused to abjure the ones he did not hold, because to do so would be a lie before God. He offered to recant anything shown from Scripture to be wrong.
The lecture says the council was probably within its own law, and that it was catastrophically wrong. The two statements are not in tension. An institution acting correctly by its own procedures can destroy its own credibility. There is no procedural safeguard against that.
In 1419 a crowd threw members of the Prague city council out of a window, and the Hussite wars began. Bohemian armies under Jan Zizka defeated five crusades called against them between 1420 and 1431. In 1436 the Compacts of Basel granted the Bohemians communion in both kinds. The pacifist strand, shaped by Petr Chelcicky, produced the Unity of the Brethren in 1457. It was refounded in Saxony in 1722 as the Moravian Church.
In 1735, on a ship to Georgia, John Wesley watched a group of Moravians sing calmly through a storm. It began the crisis that led to his conversion at Aldersgate in 1738. At the Leipzig Disputation in 1519, Johann Eck led Luther into admitting that some articles condemned at Constance were most Christian. Luther then read Hus properly and wrote to a friend: we are all Hussites without knowing it.
Hus was condemned partly for articles he denied holding.
Why does that kind of injustice damage an institution more than a harsh but accurate judgement would?
Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong and was told to recant instead. That is why his case is still cited. He took Wycliffe's doctrine of the church but not his view of the Eucharist. His death led to the Hussite wars, the cup for the laity in Bohemia, and a church that still sends missionaries.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.