Lecture 5-2: Hus, the Chalice and a Broken Promise
Contents 21
- Lecture 1-1: How East and West Became Strangers
- Lecture 1-2: Iconoclasm — Images, Empire and the Incarnation
- Lecture 1-3: One Word in the Creed — the Filioque
- Lecture 1-4: 1054, and What Made It Permanent
- Lecture 2-1: From Just War to Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: What the Crusades Cost
- Lecture 2-3: Poverty as Protest
- Lecture 2-4: Francis and Dominic
- Lecture 3-1: Faith Seeking Understanding
- Lecture 3-2: The Aristotle Shock
- Lecture 3-3: Aquinas and the Summa
- Lecture 3-4: The University
- Lecture 4-1: Avignon, and Then Two Popes
- Lecture 4-2: The Church That Nearly Got a Constitution
- Lecture 4-3: The Black Death
- Lecture 4-4: Going Around the Institution
Jan Hus went to the Council of Constance in 1414 holding a safe conduct from Sigismund, king of the Romans and soon to be emperor. He went voluntarily, to explain himself, believing he could show that the charges against him were false.
He was arrested within weeks, kept in chains for months, tried on a list of articles that included several he denied holding, refused a hearing on his own terms, and burned alive on 6 July 1415. His ashes were thrown into the Rhine so that nothing would remain to be venerated.
The council held that a safe conduct given to a suspected heretic did not bind. It was a legally arguable position and it was catastrophic, and a hundred and six years later a friar named Martin Luther, travelling to Worms under an imperial safe conduct, was warned by his friends not to go, because everyone in Germany remembered what a safe conduct had been worth at Constance.
This lecture is about Hus: what he actually taught, what the chalice meant, why Constance killed him, and what his death produced.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain how Wycliffe's writings reached Bohemia and what Hus took from them and what he did not.
- State the core of Hus's doctrine of the church and how it differed from the conventional account.
- Explain utraquism and why the cup carried social as well as theological meaning.
- Narrate the trial at Constance and assess the consequences of the broken safe conduct and of Hus's death.
For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, “Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.” In the same way he also took the cup, after supper, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.”" — 1 Corinthians 11:23–25
World English Bible
Read the passage and notice what it does not do: it does not distinguish between who receives the bread and who receives the cup. That observation started a war.
1. How Wycliffe reached Prague
Ideas travel by ordinary means, and this one travelled by a marriage.
In 1382 Anne of Bohemia married Richard II of England, and the two courts opened to each other. Bohemian students began coming to Oxford, and they carried Wycliffe's books home. By the first years of the fifteenth century his philosophical works were being copied and taught at the Charles University in Prague, and his theological works followed.
They landed in ground that was already prepared. Bohemia had its own reform preaching tradition, in Czech, going back a generation — Jan Milíč, Matěj of Janov — attacking clerical wealth and for frequent communion. And it had a national tension: the university and much of the church hierarchy were dominated by Germans, while the reforming party was Czech. Reform and Czech identity fused, and that fusion explains most of what follows.
Jan Hus (c. 1372–1415) was a peasant's son who became a priest, a master of the university, and from 1402 the preacher at the Bethlehem Chapel in Prague, a large hall built specifically for preaching in Czech to ordinary people. He preached there for a decade to crowds of up to three thousand.
2. What Hus took from Wycliffe, and what he refused
This distinction matters and is regularly got wrong.
What he took: the doctrine of the church. In his On the Church (1413), heavily indebted to Wycliffe, Hus argues that the true church is the body of the predestined, of which is the head. The pope is not the head of the church; he is at most its chief administrator, and if he is not among the predestined he is not even that. A pope who commands what is contrary to Christ is not to be obeyed.
Follow the political charge in this. Hus was writing after thirty-five years of schism. He was not speculating about a hypothetical bad pope; he was living under three of them.
What he refused: Wycliffe's Eucharist. Hus never denied . He said so repeatedly at Constance, and there is no evidence he was lying. He was condemned in part for articles he explicitly denied holding, and this is one of them.
That refusal is important for two reasons. It shows Hus was not simply Wycliffe's translator; he took what he judged sound and left what he did not. And it means his execution rests, in part, on a charge that was false.
His practical preaching went after what his hearers could see: clerical wealth, immorality among the clergy, simony. In 1412 he attacked the preaching of a crusade indulgence — the Pisan pope John XXIII was raising money for a war against Naples by selling remission of sin.
Stop on that. In 1412, a hundred and five years before Luther's theses, a university preacher denounced the sale of indulgences to fund a papal war, and was excommunicated for it. The sequence of events in 1517 was not without precedent. What was different was the printing press and a prince who would not hand Luther over.
3. The chalice
The most visible Hussite practice was not Hus's own idea, and it arrived while he was already at Constance.
Medieval Western practice had come to give the laity only the bread at communion; the cup was reserved to the priest. There were practical reasons — the risk of spilling the consecrated wine — and a theology to support it, the doctrine of concomitance: since the whole Christ is present under each species, a lay person receiving the bread receives Christ entirely and loses nothing.
In 1414 Jakoubek of Stříbro, a Prague master, argued from 1 Corinthians 11 and John 6 that communion in both kinds — sub utraque specie, hence utraquism — was Christ's own institution for all Christians, and began to give the cup to the laity. Hus, consulted in prison, approved.
Now understand why a cup started a war, because the theology alone will not explain it.
The reservation of the cup was the single most visible, weekly, physical marker of the difference between clergy and laity. Everyone in the building could see who drank and who did not. Give the cup to the laity and you have not merely changed a rubric; you have removed the most legible sign in the culture that the clergy are a separate order of Christian.
That is why the chalice, and not any doctrinal formula, became the emblem painted on Hussite banners. It was a picture of a claim about who the church is, and it could be understood by people who could not read.
4. Constance
Hus was summoned to the council of lecture 4-2 — the council that was, at that very moment, doing the most constitutionally daring thing the medieval church ever did.
Hold both facts together, because the pairing is the lesson. The same assembly that declared a council superior to the pope, ended a thirty-nine-year schism and passed Frequens, burned Jan Hus. Constance was not a reforming parliament in a modern sense. It was a council of bishops solving a jurisdictional emergency, and it dealt with heresy the way councils of bishops did — and it may have burned Hus partly because it needed to prove its orthodoxy while doing something unprecedented.
The proceedings:
- He came under Sigismund's safe conduct and was arrested about three weeks after arriving.
- He was imprisoned for months, some of it in a Dominican convent by the lake and some in a castle, in conditions that broke his health.
- He asked to defend his positions in open disputation and was refused. What he was offered was a list of articles drawn from his works — some accurately, some not — and a demand that he abjure all of them.
- He refused to abjure the ones he did not hold, on the ground that swearing he had held and now renounced an opinion he had never held would be a lie before God. He offered repeatedly to recant anything shown from Scripture to be wrong.
- Sigismund, present, allowed the council to proceed. The council held that faith need not be kept with a heretic.
- He was degraded from the priesthood, crowned with a paper hat painted with demons, led out and burned on 6 July 1415. Witnesses record him singing.
The council was probably within its own law and it was catastrophically wrong, and the two statements are not in tension. That is what makes the episode worth studying rather than merely deploring: an institution acting correctly by its own procedures can destroy its own credibility, and there is no procedural safeguard against that.
5. What Hus's death produced
A war. Bohemia did not accept it. In 1419 a crowd threw members of the Prague city council out of a window — the first Defenestration of Prague — and the Hussite wars began. Under Jan Žižka, a one-eyed and later blind commander with a genius for tactics, Bohemian peasant armies with wagon-forts and early firearms defeated five successive called against them between 1420 and 1431.
A concession. In 1436 the Compacts of Basel granted the Bohemians communion in both kinds. The Hussites are the only medieval dissenting movement that won a formal concession from the church, and they won it with artillery. That fact sat in Europe's memory for a century.
A church that still exists. Not everyone wanted a war. The pacifist strand, shaped by the lay theologian Petr Chelčický — who rejected violence, oaths and social hierarchy altogether — produced in 1457 the Unitas Fratrum, the Unity of the Brethren. It survived persecution and near-extinction, was refounded in Saxony in 1722 as the Moravian Church, and sent missionaries around the world.
And there is a specific English-language postscript. In 1735, on a ship to Georgia, an anxious Anglican priest named John Wesley watched a group of Moravians sing calmly through a storm that terrified him, and it began the crisis that led to his conversion at Aldersgate in 1738. The line from Hus's ashes to the Methodist movement runs through those passengers.
And a name Luther had to accept. At the Leipzig Disputation in 1519, Johann Eck manoeuvred Luther into admitting that some articles condemned at Constance were "most Christian" — which meant conceding that a general council had erred and that he agreed with a convicted heretic. Luther went away, read Hus properly, and wrote to a friend: we are all Hussites without knowing it.
6. What actually happened here
Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong, and was told to recant instead. That is the whole of it, and it is why the case has never stopped being cited.
He died believing he was a Catholic priest wrongly accused, and he was substantially right about that. The movement he did not intend to found outlived the council that killed him; the concession he never asked for was granted twenty-one years later; and the church his followers built is still sending missionaries.
Reformers who die without seeing reform are not failures. They are the seed — and in this case the seed was sown by the men who lit the fire, since a movement that might have been contained became, at the moment of that broken promise, something Bohemia was willing to fight five crusades over.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Wycliffe | Hus | |
|---|---|---|
| The church | The congregation of the predestined | The same — with Christ alone as its head |
| The pope | Eventually called Antichrist | Chief administrator at most; not to be obeyed against Christ |
| Transubstantiation | Denied it — and lost his protectors | Affirmed it, and was condemned for denying it anyway |
| Scripture | God's law, above church legislation | The standard he asked to be judged by, and was refused |
| The cup | Not his issue | Approved utraquism from prison; it became the movement's emblem |
| End | Died in bed; bones burned 1428 | Burned alive, 1415, under a safe conduct |
| Legacy | The English Bible; the Lollards underground | A war, a concession, and a church that still exists |
5. Going to the Sources
- The letters of Jan Hus from prison at Constance — written knowing what was coming. Among the finest things in this course.
- Peter of Mladoňovice, An Account of the Trial and Condemnation of Master Jan Hus — by an eyewitness who was in the room.
- Hus, On the Church, chapters 1–7 — the doctrine he was actually condemned for.
- Petr Chelčický, The Net of Faith — the pacifist Hussite answer to the wars, and the root of the Unitas Fratrum.
In short
- Wycliffe's writings reached Prague after the marriage of Anne of Bohemia and Richard II in 1382. Reform and Czech identity fused, in a university and church dominated by Germans.
- Hus took Wycliffe's doctrine of the church as the body of the predestined with Christ as head, but never denied transubstantiation. He was condemned partly for articles he denied holding.
- In 1412 Hus attacked a crusade indulgence, a hundred and five years before Luther's theses. He was excommunicated for it.
- Utraquism gave the cup to the laity, citing 1 Corinthians 11 and John 6. Withholding it had been the most visible weekly sign of the divide between clergy and laity.
- At Constance, Hus was arrested despite a safe conduct, refused open disputation, offered to recant anything shown wrong from Scripture, and was burned on 6 July 1415.
- His death led to the Hussite wars, the 1436 Compacts of Basel granting both kinds, and the Unity of the Brethren, later the Moravian Church, which influenced John Wesley.
Topic: Jan Hus's teaching, the meaning of the chalice, his trial and execution at Constance, and what his death produced.
Remember: Hus asked to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong and was told to recant instead. That is why his case is still cited.
Caution: The lecture notes Constance was probably within its own law and still catastrophically wrong, and that Hus did not hold all the articles charged. He was not simply Wycliffe's translator.
One line to carry into ministry: Keep faith with those who come to you in good faith, since an institution that follows its own rules can still destroy its own credibility.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Hus was condemned partly for articles he denied holding. Why does that particular injustice do so much more damage to an institution than a straightforwardly harsh but accurate judgement would?
- The council was probably within its own law when it ruled that faith need not be kept with a heretic. What follows about the relationship between an institution's procedures and its credibility?
- The chalice was a picture of a claim, legible to people who could not read. What in your own church's practice functions that way, and what claim does it picture?
- Constance ended a schism and burned a man in the same years. If you had to give a single verdict on that council, what would it be — and what does the difficulty of answering tell you?