FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH201E · Chapter 12

Lecture 12-3: Sausages and Disputations — Authority Shifts to the Council

A Lenten sausage meal in 1522 led to two public disputations. In both, Zurich's elected city council judged the argument and enacted the reform.

The History of the Reformation

11 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain what the Affair of the Sausages actually was, what question it was designed to force into the open, and why the physical act itself was minor while its intended meaning was not.
  • Describe the format and outcome of the First and Second Zurich Disputations (1523): who convened them, who judged the arguments, and what the council did as a result.
  • Define "magisterial Reformation" precisely, and explain why Zurich's council, not a bishop, functioning as the actual judge of a doctrinal dispute is the feature that earns the label.
March 1522

The Affair of the Sausages

On 9 March 1522 the printer Christoph Froschauer served smoked sausage during Lent at a meal Zwingli attended. Zwingli's later account says he did not eat the meat, though he was present. He defended the act in print in a treatise on the choice and freedom of foods.

Key idea The meal was a deliberate test case, and the argument mattered more than the sausage.
Scripture

Why Romans 14:3?

The lecture says this is Paul's own text on disputed eating, counselling mutual forbearance, which is more measured than either side of the sausage controversy fully modeled.

Don't let him who eats despise him who doesn't eat. Don't let him who doesn't eat judge him who eats, for God has accepted him." Romans 14:3 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why Colossians 2:20?

The lecture says Zwingli and his allies read this text as supporting their case against required fasting: a believer who has died with Christ is no longer under humanly imposed rules about food and days.

If you died with Christ from the elements of the world, why, as though living in the world, do you subject yourselves to ordinances?" Colossians 2:20 · WEB
At a glance

The real dispute over fasting

Zwingli

No scriptural command required abstaining from meat on specific days under penalty, so turning a voluntary discipline into binding law was an error.

Its defenders

Fasting had a long ascetical and pastoral tradition, and the church had legitimate authority to establish disciplines for the good of souls.

January 1523

The First Zurich Disputation

On 29 January 1523 the city council convened a public disputation in the city hall instead of deferring to the bishop's court. Zwingli prepared sixty-seven articles. The bishop's delegation, led by Johann Faber, argued the matter should go to a general council, and the council declared Zwingli had not been shown to be in error and should continue preaching.

Key idea In effect the council put its civic authority behind Zwingli's reform.
October 1523

The Second Zurich Disputation

Over eight hundred people reportedly attended. The council ruled that images should be removed and that the Mass should eventually be replaced with a memorial Lord's Supper. It phased the removals in gradually, a caution Zwingli supported over the objections of more impatient allies.

Key idea Zwingli preferred orderly, council-sanctioned change to action by individuals or mobs.
Authority moved

The magisterial Reformation

In both disputations the body that heard the arguments and decided was Zurich's elected city council, laymen in civic office, not a bishop or the pope. Reform that depends on the existing magistrate for its legal authorization is called the magisterial Reformation. Robert C. Walton argues Zwingli sought this outcome, while other scholars resist calling his aim fully theocratic.

Key idea Both readings agree the council judged and the council enacted.
One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

In Zurich an elected city council, not a bishop or the pope, judged the theological dispute and enacted reform, which is called the magisterial Reformation. The lecture does not treat the church's fasting discipline as mere legalism, and notes neither side in 1522 fully met Paul's balance in Romans 14.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 11