Lecture 13-1: Stating the Dispute — Real Presence Against Memorial Sign
Luther and Zwingli agreed on a great deal. The whole dispute turned on what "is" means in "This is my body."
The History of the Reformation
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Luther and Zwingli agreed on a great deal. The whole dispute turned on what "is" means in "This is my body."
The History of the Reformation
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The lecture calls this the single clause the whole chapter argues over. Neither Luther nor Zwingli disputed that Jesus spoke these words; the dispute is about what "is" does in the sentence.
As they were eating, Jesus took bread, gave thanks for it, and broke it. He gave to the disciples, and said, 'Take, eat; this is my body.'" Matthew 26:26 · World English Bible
Both Luther and Zwingli rejected transubstantiation, the teaching that the inner substance of the bread and wine is converted into Christ's body and blood while the appearances stay the same. Both held that the Supper is a means of grace instituted by Christ himself. Both insisted that the bread and the cup be given to the laity. Neither treated the Supper as unimportant, which is part of why neither would smooth the disagreement over.
Luther held that where Scripture speaks plainly, the plain sense governs. For him, "This is my body" states a fact: Christ's true body and blood are really present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine, which remain bread and wine in their own substance. He called the mechanism a mystery he did not need to explain. Later writers coined the word "consubstantiation", and Luther himself avoided it.
Luther judged that once "is" is allowed to mean "signifies" because a literal reading is hard to square with how bodies occupy space, the same move becomes available against any hard statement of Scripture. He thought such a precedent would damage the authority of Scripture as a whole, the very authority the Reformation existed to defend.
Zwingli pointed to the New Testament's habit of using "is" to mean "represents", as in "I am the door" (John 10:9), "I am the vine" and "the seed is the word of God". He argued that Christ's real human body is in heaven and, being a body, occupies one place at a time. So the bread signifies Christ's body without that body moving onto the table.
On Zwingli's reading the Supper becomes an act of remembrance and public confession. The gathered congregation recalls Christ's sacrifice, examines its own faith and proclaims its unity as one body. The lecture says this relocates where the significance lies rather than emptying the Supper of it.
Christ's body and blood are truly present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine. The plain sense of Scripture governs, difficult or not.
The bread and cup represent Christ's body and blood, and his real human body remains in heaven. Scripture's own figures of speech settle the meaning of "is".
Lutheran theology continues to affirm the real, bodily presence as Luther stated it. The Reformed tradition holds a range of non-corporeal positions, and the lecture says Reformed and Zwinglian are not identical, since Calvin's account of a real spiritual presence received by faith is distinct from Zwingli's memorialism. Rome holds transubstantiation, a third position.
The lecture aims to state both positions so fairly that a member of the opposing camp would say, "Yes, that is what I believe."
Could you explain either Luther's or Zwingli's reading of "This is my body" in terms its own supporters would accept?
Luther and Zwingli agreed that the Supper is a means of grace and both rejected transubstantiation. They parted over what "is" means in "This is my body": Luther took it as real presence, Zwingli as "signifies". The lecture states each view in its own terms and asks nobody to concede.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.