FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 3

Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness

Wesley's theology of grace and holiness became a system of preaching and small groups. The lecture also counts what it cost the revival and the Church of England.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 25 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Explain where the nickname "Methodist" came from, what Wesley was doing before 1738, and what Aldersgate did and did not change — including why historians disagree about its importance.
  • State Wesley's doctrine of prevenient grace accurately, and explain how it differs from Reformed teaching on election and from a simple claim that human beings are free.
  • Explain what Wesley meant by Christian perfection, why he kept restating it, and what pastoral damage the doctrine did when it was misheard.
  • Describe the machinery of Methodism — field preaching, classes and bands, lay preachers, the Conference — and explain how social holiness followed from Wesley's account of grace rather than being added to it.
Before 1738

An anxious Oxford priest

At Oxford the Wesleys gathered a few undergraduates for prayer, communion, Bible study, fasting and prison visits. Others called them Methodists, for the rigidity of their method. Everything Methodism became famous for was already there in embryo. The one thing missing was any confidence that it was working.

Key idea Method came first. Assurance came later.
Aldersgate

A heart strangely warmed

On 24 May 1738 Wesley felt that he trusted Christ alone and that his own sins were taken away. Its content is assurance, not the beginning of belief. He already believed justification by faith, but he lacked the confidence that it applied to him. Historians disagree about how much to make of it. Some read his real change as gradual, and others hold that the evening was decisive.

Key idea Aldersgate is contested, so do not treat it as settled.
Grace

Prevenient grace

Wesley agreed that the fall corrupts every faculty. He then held that no one is in that natural state, because God has given every person a measure of grace before any response. He called it preventing grace, from the older English sense of going before. It is a gift given to all on the ground of the atonement, not a natural ability that survived the fall.

Key idea Free will is restored as grace, not asserted as nature.
At a glance

Two readings of grace

Reformed position

God's saving grace is given to those he has chosen and is effective in them.

Wesleyan position

A prior grace is given to all, and saving grace can be resisted.

Scripture

Why Philippians 1:6?

The lecture calls this the verse Wesley's whole system hangs on. It notes that most of the sentence is about God, and that Wesley's insistence on cooperation concerns the middle of it.

being confident of this very thing, that he who began a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ." Philippians 1:6 · World English Bible
Holiness

Christian perfection

Wesley did not mean that a Christian stops being ignorant, tempted or weak, or ceases to need the atonement. He meant that the love of God and neighbour may so fill a person that nothing contrary to love remains in their intention. He kept restating it because it kept going wrong. Some claimed it and behaved badly, and some sincere Methodists despaired because they had not received it.

Key idea Perfect love is not sinlessness.
The machinery

Preaching, classes and a Conference

Field preaching began in April 1739, in districts where the parish system had not kept pace with population. From 1742 every member belonged to a class of about twelve that met weekly under a lay leader. Wesley also licensed lay preachers, who met annually as the Conference from 1744. The lecture adds that the class system was also one of mutual surveillance.

Key idea Wesley did not lure people out of the pews. He went where there were no pews.
Social holiness

Holiness is not pursued alone

Wesley held that holiness cannot be pursued alone and that Christianity is a communal exercise. The social consequences followed from his theology. Methodism ran free schools, lending funds for the poor, a dispensary and prison visitation. His Thoughts Upon Slavery of 1774 attacked the trade and the institution without hedging.

Key idea Social holiness followed from grace, not beside it.
At a glance

What it cost

The revival split

In 1739–41 Wesley published Free Grace against unconditional election. The revival divided into Wesleyan and Calvinistic Methodist wings.

Perfection misheard

In London in the early 1760s two preachers ran the doctrine into open fanaticism, and Wesley had to break with them.

A separation he denied

In 1784 Wesley ordained ministers for America himself. His brother Charles concluded the separation had already happened. The formal breach came after Wesley's death.

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

For Wesley, grace comes first to everyone and then expects real change in love. That change is pursued inside a community, never alone. The movement cost the revival its unity and the Church of England its fastest-growing religious movement.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13