Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
- Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
- Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
- Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
- Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
- Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
- Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
- Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
- Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
- Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
- Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
- Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
- Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
- Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
- Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
- Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
- Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
- Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
- Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
- Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
- Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
- Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
- Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
- Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
- Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
- Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
- Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
John Wesley was an Oxford fellow, an Anglican priest, the son and grandson of clergy, and by his own reckoning a failure at the Christian religion until he was thirty-four. He had fasted, prayed at fixed hours, visited prisons, kept a diary of his hourly conduct in cipher, and sailed to Georgia as a missionary. None of it produced what he was looking for, and the Georgia mission ended with him leaving the colony ahead of a lawsuit.
What he did in the fifty-three years after that reorganised English-speaking Protestantism. He rode something like a quarter of a million miles on horseback, preached perhaps forty thousand times, built a lay preaching corps and a national system of small groups, and left behind a movement that by the time of his death in 1791 had over seventy thousand members in Britain and was growing faster in America.
This lecture is about the theology that made that possible and about the two things it cost: a doctrinal fight with his closest colleague that split the revival in half, and a separation from the Church of England that Wesley denied he was making right up to the point where he made it.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain where the nickname "Methodist" came from, what Wesley was doing before 1738, and what Aldersgate did and did not change — including why historians disagree about its importance.
- State Wesley's doctrine of prevenient grace accurately, and explain how it differs from Reformed teaching on election and from a simple claim that human beings are free.
- Explain what Wesley meant by Christian perfection, why he kept restating it, and what pastoral damage the doctrine did when it was misheard.
- Describe the machinery of Methodism — field preaching, classes and bands, lay preachers, the Conference — and explain how social holiness followed from Wesley's account of grace rather than being added to it.
being confident of this very thing, that he who began a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ." — Philippians 1:6
World English Bible
This is the verse Wesley's whole system hangs on, and it is worth noting how much of the sentence is about God. He began it; he will complete it. Wesley's insistence that the believer must cooperate is an insistence about the middle of that sentence, not about either end. Read anything in this lecture that sounds like human achievement back against this verse.
1. The Holy Club, and why the nickname stuck
At Oxford in the late 1720s Charles Wesley gathered a few undergraduates for a disciplined regime of prayer, communion, Bible study, fasting, and visits to the prison and the workhouse. John joined and quickly took it over; George Whitefield, a servitor paying his way by waiting on wealthier students, joined in 1732.
Other students called them the Holy Club, Bible Moths, Sacramentarians, and — the name that lasted — Methodists, for the rigidity of their method. It was an insult about scheduling.
What is worth noticing is that everything Methodism later became famous for is already here in embryo: small groups, disciplined self-examination, prison and poor relief, communion taken far more often than the period's custom. The one thing missing is any confidence that it was working. Wesley's Oxford diaries are the record of a man auditing his own soul and always finding a deficit.
Georgia (1735–1737) made the deficit undeniable. He went as a missionary to the colonists and, he hoped, to the Native peoples; he ran the parish at Savannah with a rigour that offended nearly everyone; he mishandled a courtship badly enough to be sued after he refused communion to the woman in question; and he came home. His journal entry on the return voyage is famous and worth reading whole: I went to America to convert the Indians; but oh, who shall convert me?
2. Aldersgate, and how much to make of it
On the evening of 24 May 1738 Wesley went unwillingly to a religious society meeting in Aldersgate Street, London, where someone was reading aloud from Luther's preface to Romans. He wrote:
About a quarter before nine, while he was describing the change which God works in the heart through faith in Christ, I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ, , for salvation; and an assurance was given me that he had taken away my sins, even mine, and saved me from the law of sin and death.
Two things about that sentence. First, its content is assurance, not the beginning of belief. Wesley believed the doctrine of by faith before Aldersgate; what he lacked, and what Peter Böhler had told him to seek, was the confidence that it applied to him. Second, the emphasis falls on even mine. That is what the Moravians had that he did not.
How to read Aldersgate
Now a caution, because this is a place where the tidy story is ours and not history's. Methodist tradition made Aldersgate the hinge of the world — a datable evangelical conversion, the birthday of a movement. Historians have been chipping at that for a century, and with reason. Wesley's own later journals record long stretches in which he doubted whether he had any faith at all; within months he was writing that he was not a Christian. He edited the Aldersgate passage in later editions. And he never preached about it. Some scholars now read his real transition as gradual, spread across the Georgia failure, the Moravian influence, Aldersgate and the field preaching of 1739. Others hold that the evening genuinely was decisive and that later doubts do not undo it.
You do not have to settle this. You do have to know that it is contested, because a course that hands you Aldersgate as an unambiguous conversion is handing you a tradition's self-portrait as a fact.
3. Prevenient grace: the argument, stated carefully
Wesley's most consequential theological move is a doctrine of grace that is neither the Reformed account nor a claim that people are naturally free to choose God.
Start from where he agrees with Geneva. Wesley held that human beings are fallen, that is total in the sense that it corrupts every faculty, and that no one in their natural state can turn to God or want to. That is not a soft anthropology; Wesley's sermon is severe.
The move comes next. Wesley held that no one is in that natural state, because God has already given to every human being, prior to and independent of any response, a measure of grace that partially restores the capacity to respond. He called it preventing grace, in the older English sense of going before — hence . It is what lies behind conscience, behind the first uneasiness about one's own life, behind the stirring that precedes any deliberate seeking. It is not a natural human ability that survived the fall. It is a gift, given to all, on the ground of the atonement.
Two consequences follow, and both are load-bearing.
Free will is restored as grace, not asserted as nature. Wesley can therefore say both "salvation is entirely of grace" and "you may refuse it," which to a Reformed critic sounds like wanting the argument both ways and to a Wesleyan is the whole point.
The gospel becomes addressable to everyone. If grace already precedes the preacher into every hearer, then preaching to a crowd of illiterate miners at five in the morning is not a lottery. That is why Wesley's theology is the theology of a man who preached forty thousand times.
Grace and free will
How this differs from Reformed teaching. Chapter 1 dealt with Dort and the Remonstrants and this course discusses that dispute properly there, so here it is enough to be precise and fair. The Reformed position is that God's saving grace is given to those he has chosen and is effective in them; the Wesleyan position is that a prior grace is given to all and that saving grace can be resisted. Each side has serious biblical and pastoral arguments, and neither side is outside the Christian faith. Wesley himself said of the Calvinist Whitefield's followers that they would meet in heaven. He also fought them for thirty years, which tells you something about how humans hold both of those at once.
The break was public. Whitefield and Wesley had been co-workers; in 1739–41 Wesley preached and published Free Grace, a direct attack on unconditional , and Whitefield replied at length. The revival split into Wesleyan (Arminian) and Calvinistic Methodist wings — the latter surviving in Wales as the Calvinistic Methodist Church, still there. The first great cost of Wesley's theology was that the awakening he led could not stay in one body.
4. Christian perfection: what he meant, and what happened when people misheard
The doctrine Wesley called the great depositum committed to the Methodists is also the one that caused him the most trouble.
What he meant. Not that a Christian stops being ignorant, mistaken, tempted or weak. Not that a Christian becomes incapable of falling. Not that a Christian ceases to need the atonement — Wesley was explicit that the perfect still need Christ every moment. What he meant is that the love of God and neighbour may so fill a person that nothing contrary to love remains in their intention: no deliberate, willing choice of sin. He called it perfect love, and he insisted it was a work of God given in an instant and pursued over a lifetime, both.
Why he kept restating it. Because it kept going wrong. Some followers claimed perfection and behaved badly, which discredited the doctrine and its neighbours. Some claimed perfection and meant that they could no longer sin whatever they did — the old antinomian error, which Wesley loathed. Some sincere Methodists, having been told this was available, spent years in misery because they had not received it, and concluded that they were failures. Wesley's A Plain Account of Christian Perfection went through repeated editions across forty years, each one adding a further denial of something people had taken him to mean. In London in the early 1760s two of his own preachers, Thomas Maxfield and George Bell, ran the doctrine into open fanaticism — Bell announced the world would end on 28 February 1763 — and Wesley had to break with them and watch a large part of his London society leave with them.
The honest verdict. The doctrine names something real: the New Testament does not treat sin as a permanent condition to be managed, and a Christianity with no expectation of actual change is a Christianity in trouble. It is also a doctrine that hands an unreliable judge — the believer's own sense of their inner state — a very large question, which is precisely the problem lecture 3-1 identified in Pietism as a whole. Wesley knew this. His remedy was to route the claim through a small group of people who knew you well and were permitted to disagree with you, which brings us to the machinery.
5. The machinery
Wesley was a great organiser, and the organisation is at least as much of his legacy as the theology.
Field preaching (from April 1739). Whitefield, not Wesley, started this, preaching to the colliers at Kingswood outside Bristol; he handed the work to a deeply reluctant Wesley, who thought preaching outside a church building close to indecent and then did it for fifty years. It mattered because the parish system had not kept pace with population: the new mining and industrial districts had populations no parish church could hold and, in places, no parish church at all. Wesley did not lure people out of the pews. He went where there were no pews.
Classes and bands. From 1742, every member of a Methodist society belonged to a class of about twelve, meeting weekly under a lay leader, in which each person gave an account of their spiritual and practical life over the past week. The class ticket, renewed quarterly, was the actual membership of Methodism. Bands were smaller, voluntary and more searching. This is Spener's ecclesiola turned into a national system with a personnel structure — and it is worth being candid that it was also a system of mutual surveillance. Members who would not give an account lost their ticket. That produced formidable discipline; it also produced the pressures every accountability structure produces, including the incentive to report the answer that ends the conversation.
Lay preachers and the Conference. Wesley licensed unordained men — and, from the 1760s and with visible reluctance, a small number of women, notably Sarah Crosby and Mary Bosanquet — to preach. The itinerant preachers were assigned to circuits and moved every year or two. From 1744 they met annually as the Conference. This is a parallel church inside the Church of England, and everyone could see it.
Social holiness. Wesley's famous line is that the gospel of Christ knows no religion but social, no holiness but social holiness — and it does not mean what a modern reader hears. He was not primarily saying "religion has social consequences"; he was saying that holiness cannot be pursued alone, that Christianity is a communal exercise and solitary religion is a contradiction. The social consequences were nonetheless enormous, and they followed from the theology: if grace precedes the gospel into every human being, then the miner, the prisoner and the enslaved person are already objects of God's dealing before anyone arrives to preach at them. Methodism ran free schools, lending funds for the poor, a dispensary, prison visitation and a publishing operation that put cheap books into working-class hands.
And on slavery Wesley was clear where Whitefield was not. His Thoughts Upon Slavery (1774) is a flat, unhedged attack on the trade and the institution, and the last letter he wrote, six days before his death in 1791, was to William Wilberforce, urging him not to give up. This is the same movement, four decades apart, in which lecture 3-4's Whitefield campaigned to legalise slavery in Georgia. Hold both.
6. What it cost the institution
Wesley lived and died insisting he was a priest of the Church of England and that Methodists should not separate. He also, over fifty years, built a movement with its own preachers, its own membership discipline, its own annual governing body, its own hymnbook and its own buildings, and in 1784 he ordained ministers for America himself — an act only a bishop could perform, and the point at which his brother Charles concluded the separation had already happened.
The Church of England, for its part, largely resisted him: pulpits closed, mobs occasionally encouraged, bishops hostile. Both facts are true and they compound. The formal breach came after his death.
That is the chapter's principle running exactly as stated. The fire came from below — from the coalfields, from lay preachers, from women leading classes. It cost the Church of England the fastest-growing religious movement in the country, and it cost Methodism the sacramental parish life Wesley himself never wanted to leave.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Term | What Wesley meant | What it is not | Where you see it in practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prevenient grace | Grace given to all before any response, restoring the power to answer | Not a natural freedom the fall left intact | Preaching to anyone, anywhere, without sorting the crowd |
| Assurance | The Spirit's witness that God's forgiveness applies to me | Not the beginning of belief; Wesley believed the doctrine already | Aldersgate, 1738 — and Wesley's later seasons of doubt |
| Christian perfection | Love so filling a person that nothing contrary to love remains in the intention | Not sinlessness, not immunity from error, not independence of Christ | A Plain Account, revised for forty years as people misheard it |
| Social holiness | Holiness cannot be pursued alone; Christianity is communal | Not merely "faith has social effects" | Classes of twelve, bands, quarterly tickets |
| The world is my parish | A defence of preaching outside parish boundaries when challenged | Not a slogan of global ambition | Kingswood colliers, 1739; fifty years of itineration |
5. Going to the Sources
- Wesley, A Plain Account of Christian Perfection (final edition 1777). Short. Read it and list every claim Wesley denies that people attributed to him; the list is the doctrine's real history.
- Wesley, Free Grace (sermon, 1739) together with Whitefield's Letter to the Reverend Mr. John Wesley (1740). The two documents that split the English revival, each by a friend of the other. Read them in that order.
- Wesley, Thoughts Upon Slavery (1774), and his letter to William Wilberforce of 24 February 1791. Two pages together. Set them beside lecture 3-4's account of Whitefield and Georgia.
- Wesley's Journal, 24 May 1738 and 2 April 1739. The warmed heart and the first field sermon. Read the second and notice how much Wesley disliked what he was doing.
- The Methodist Rules of the Band Societies (1738) and General Rules (1743). One page each. This is what membership actually required.
In short
- Wesley was an anxious Oxford priest. At Aldersgate in 1738 he gained assurance that Christ's forgiveness applied to him. Historians disagree whether this was his life's hinge or one step in a gradual change.
- Wesley taught prevenient grace (grace that "goes before"): God gives every person a gift, grounded in the atonement, that restores the power to respond. It is not natural free will.
- Reformed Christians hold that saving grace is given to the elect. The dispute with Whitefield split the revival into Wesleyan and Calvinistic Methodist wings.
- Christian perfection meant love filling a person so that no deliberate choice of sin remains. It did not mean sinlessness. Misheard, it led to pride, despair and fanaticism.
- Methodism's machinery included field preaching, classes and bands, lay preachers and the Conference. Social holiness meant holiness cannot be pursued alone, and it led to schools, loans and prison visits.
- Wesley opposed slavery plainly. He denied separating from the Church of England, yet his ordinations in 1784 made the separation real.
Topic: This lecture explains Wesley's theology of grace and holiness, the system of small groups and preaching that carried it, and what the movement cost the revival and the Church of England.
Remember: For Wesley, grace comes first to everyone and then expects real change in love, and that change is pursued inside a community, never alone.
Caution: Christian perfection is not sinlessness, and Aldersgate is not an agreed account of conversion. Reformed and Wesleyan readers each have serious biblical arguments, and neither is outside the Christian faith.
One line to carry into ministry: Pair high hopes for real change with a small group of honest friends who may disagree with you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- State prevenient grace so that a Reformed reader would agree you had stated it fairly, and then state the Reformed doctrine of election so that a Wesleyan would agree. Which was harder, and why?
- Aldersgate is either the hinge of Wesley's life or one moment in a long transition, and the sources support both readings. What is at stake for a tradition in insisting on the first?
- The class meeting required each member to give an account of their week to twelve people. Name what such a structure produces that nothing else produces — and name what it makes people say that is not true.
- Wesley denied to the end that he was separating from the Church of England while doing every specific thing a separation consists of. Is that dishonesty, self-deception, or something a renewal movement cannot avoid?