FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH202E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands

Bonhoeffer's life is his argument. He taught costly grace, joined a conspiracy without calling it innocent, and left his last questions unfinished.

The Church in the Modern World

13 cards 27 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Trace how Bonhoeffer's theology moved from an academic account of the church to obedience and discipleship, and identify the experiences that pushed it.
  • Contrast cheap grace and costly grace as Bonhoeffer defined them, and explain why he considered cheap grace a specifically ecclesial sin rather than an individual one.
  • Explain the reasoning that took him into the conspiracy — his account of responsible action, of "becoming guilty", and of throwing himself on grace rather than justifying himself — and state the serious objections to it.
  • Explain what he meant in the prison letters by a world come of age, religionless Christianity, and the man for others, and say why these are best read as questions rather than a finished position.
A contested figure

Two easy endings refused

Bonhoeffer is claimed by pacifists and by advocates of just war, by evangelicals and by radical secular theologians. His friend and biographer Eberhard Bethge spent the rest of his life warning against this. The lecture refuses the martyr's halo, because Bonhoeffer called what he was doing guilt and put it in God's hands. It also refuses a neat ending: it does not resolve the problem for pacifists, because he did not resolve it either.

Key idea Bonhoeffer is a record, not a ready answer.
Two interruptions

New York and Finkenwalde

In New York in 1930-31 Bonhoeffer attended the Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem and heard the gospel preached to people under real oppression. A French pacifist friend, Jean Lasserre, asked what the Sermon on the Mount requires if your country goes to war with his. At Finkenwalde from 1935 to 1937 he ran a seminary with shared meals, daily worship and mutual confession. Discipleship and Life Together both came out of those years.

Key idea Both books began as seminary documents.
Scripture

Why Matthew 16:24?

The lecture says Bonhoeffer built Discipleship on this text. His reading is plain: it describes a summons to a particular person, requiring a particular step, with the cost attached in advance, not an inner attitude.

Then Jesus said to his disciples, “If anyone desires to come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me." Matthew 16:24 · World English Bible
Cheap grace

A doctrine of the church, not the individual

Bonhoeffer defined cheap grace as forgiveness preached without repentance, baptism without discipline, and communion without confession. His charge was that the church had turned justification into a principle, so it costs nothing to apply and asks nothing of the applicant. Costly grace is not cheap grace plus works. Only the believer obeys, and only the obedient believe, so these form one act. It was written when the church preached forgiveness at full volume while its government built camps.

Key idea Costly grace is still given, not achieved.
At a glance

Cheap grace and costly grace

Cheap grace

Forgiveness as a general principle, requiring no repentance. Discipleship is optional and interior. The cost falls nowhere.

Costly grace

Forgiveness given to a person who is turning. Discipleship is a summons to one step, priced in advance. The cost falls on God at the cross first, then on the one called.

The decision

Guilt, not justification

In June 1939 Bonhoeffer went to the United States and lasted twenty-six days before returning to Germany. Through the Abwehr he became a courier for the resistance. The lecture says he did not claim his action was right. In his Ethics he argued that the person who acts responsibly in an evil situation does not keep clean hands. They take the guilt on themselves, impute it to no one else, and hope for nothing but grace. The category he reaches for is confession, not the lesser evil.

Key idea He took the guilt and had no defence except mercy.
At a glance

How scholars read the conspiracy

The standard picture

Most scholars, including those who worked on the critical edition, think he knew of and endorsed the plans against Hitler.

The minority case

Mark Thiessen Nation and colleagues argue he never left the position of Discipleship, and that his role was to carry information and rescue Jews. The lecture says it is made in good faith.

The prison letters

Questions, not a programme

In the letters of 1944 Bonhoeffer wrote of a world come of age, where people manage without God as an explanation. He refused to install God in the gaps of human weakness. He asked what Christ is for us today and called for a religionless Christianity. He sketched the man for others, and God pushed out of the world onto a cross. They are letters to a friend from a man who expected to revise them, and the lecture says to read them as questions.

Key idea Meet people at the centre of their strength, not their weakness.
Think about it

Principle or person?

Cheap grace offers forgiveness as a principle. Costly grace offers it to a person.

Where in your own congregation is forgiveness offered as a principle rather than to a person, and what would the change cost the church?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Costly grace is grace as a call to a person, not a principle. It cost God a death and costs the called person their old life, and it is still given, not earned. Bonhoeffer joined the conspiracy, called the guilt his own, and left the ethical question open. Do not use him as a ready answer for pacifism or just war.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13