Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: Building the System: Lutheran and Reformed Orthodoxy
- Lecture 1-2: Arminius, Dort, and the Doctrine of Grace
- Lecture 1-3: The Puritans: Holiness, Conscience, and the Crown
- Lecture 1-4: The Westminster Assembly and its Catechisms
- Lecture 2-1: The War That Discredited Holy War
- Lecture 2-2: Westphalia — A Peace Nobody Loved
- Lecture 2-3: Denominations — A Word for People You Cannot Destroy
- Lecture 2-4: An Errand into the Wilderness
- Lecture 3-1: The Revolt Against Cold Orthodoxy: Spener and Francke
- Lecture 3-2: Zinzendorf, Herrnhut and the Moravian Missions
- Lecture 3-3: John Wesley and the Methodists: Grace and Holiness
- Lecture 3-4: The First Great Awakening in North America
- Lecture 4-1: The Age of Reason and the Scientific Revolution
- Lecture 4-2: Deism and the Search for a God Nobody Has to Fight About
- Lecture 4-3: Biblical Criticism and the Quest for the Historical Jesus
- Lecture 4-4: Schleiermacher and the Liberal Century
- Lecture 5-1: William Carey and the Invention of the Missionary Society
- Lecture 5-2: Hudson Taylor, the China Inland Mission and the Cost of Going Inland
- Lecture 5-3: David Livingstone — Explorer, Abolitionist, Failed Pastor
- Lecture 5-4: Missions and Empire — The Argument That Will Not Settle
- Lecture 6-1: 1914 — The Year the Future Stopped Working
- Lecture 6-2: Barth's Romans and the Theology of the Word
- Lecture 6-3: The German Christians, the Confessing Church, and Barmen
- Lecture 6-4: Bonhoeffer — Costly Grace and Guilty Hands
- Lecture 7-1: Azusa Street, 1906
- Lecture 7-2: Spirit Baptism and Tongues: An Experience Becomes a Doctrine
- Lecture 7-3: The Second Wave: Renewal Inside the Old Churches
- Lecture 7-4: Why the South Grew
Dietrich Bonhoeffer is the most quoted Protestant theologian of the twentieth century and the most misused. He is claimed by pacifists and by advocates of just war, by evangelicals and by radical secular theologians, by political movements on the left and on the right, and by people who have read one sentence about cheap grace. Eberhard Bethge — his closest friend, his biographer, and the man to whom the prison letters were written — spent the rest of his life warning against exactly this.
So this lecture takes a particular line. It follows the life, because with Bonhoeffer the life is the argument. But it refuses two easy endings.
It refuses the martyr's halo, because Bonhoeffer would not wear it: the man who joined a conspiracy to kill a head of state did not tell himself he was innocent, and did not construct a theology that made him innocent. He called what he was doing guilt, and put it in God's hands.
And it refuses to make the story neat. If you are a pacifist, this lecture is not going to resolve your problem with him. It is going to show you that he did not resolve it either.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Trace how Bonhoeffer's theology moved from an academic account of the church to obedience and discipleship, and identify the experiences that pushed it.
- Contrast cheap grace and costly grace as Bonhoeffer defined them, and explain why he considered cheap grace a specifically ecclesial sin rather than an individual one.
- Explain the reasoning that took him into the conspiracy — his account of responsible action, of "becoming guilty", and of throwing himself on grace rather than justifying himself — and state the serious objections to it.
- Explain what he meant in the prison letters by a world come of age, religionless Christianity, and the man for others, and say why these are best read as questions rather than a finished position.
Then Jesus said to his disciples, “If anyone desires to come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me." — Matthew 16:24
World English Bible
Bonhoeffer built on this text and on the call narratives around it. His reading is uncomfortably plain: the verse describes a summons issued to a particular person, requiring a particular step, with a cost attached in advance. It is not a description of an inner attitude.
1. A career that kept refusing to be a career
Bonhoeffer was born in 1906 into the Berlin professional aristocracy — his father was Germany's leading psychiatrist, the household was cultured, sceptical and not especially religious, and his decision at fourteen to study theology surprised everybody. He finished his doctorate at Berlin at twenty-one with Sanctorum Communio, a dissertation on the church as a social reality, and his second thesis, Act and Being, three years later. Barth, when he eventually read the first, called it a theological miracle.
Two things then interrupted the obvious path.
New York, 1930–31. He spent a postgraduate year at Union Theological Seminary and was largely unimpressed by American academic theology, which he thought had stopped taking doctrine seriously. What he was impressed by happened outside the seminary. Through a fellow student, Frank Fisher, he began attending the Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem, taught in its Sunday school, and heard preaching in which the gospel was addressed to people under actual oppression. He also formed a close friendship with Jean Lasserre, a French pacifist, who put to him a question German theology had not: what does the Sermon on the Mount require of you, literally, if your country goes to war with his?
He came back with an interest in what one biographer called the view from below.
Finkenwalde, 1935–37. With the German church divided, the Confessing Church needed to train its own ordinands, and Bonhoeffer was given a seminary — first at Zingst on the Baltic, then at Finkenwalde in Pomerania. He ran it in a way his students found startling: shared meals, a common rule of daily worship and meditation, mutual confession, no private property to speak of. Some of them thought at first that he was importing into a Protestant church that had abolished it four centuries earlier.
Out of those two years came the two books everyone reads. Discipleship (Nachfolge, 1937) and Life Together (Gemeinsames Leben, 1939) are both, in the first instance, seminary documents — an account of what he was trying to teach and why. The Gestapo closed Finkenwalde in September 1937; the work continued semi-legally in "collective pastorates" until 1940. Of the roughly 150 men who passed through, a large number were later conscripted, and many were killed in the war.
2. Cheap grace
The first chapter of Discipleship is the most famous thing Bonhoeffer wrote, and its opening sentence names the enemy: cheap grace is the mortal enemy of our church, and we are fighting today for costly grace.
His definition is a list, and the list is precise:
the preaching of forgiveness without requiring repentance, baptism without , communion without confession, absolution without personal confession. Cheap grace is grace without discipleship, grace without the cross, grace without Jesus Christ, living and incarnate.
Notice three features of the argument that are usually missed.
It is a doctrine of the church, not of the individual. Bonhoeffer's charge is not that individual Germans were lazy believers. It is that the church had turned by faith into a principle — a general truth about how God is disposed towards sin — and that once grace is a principle rather than an event between a person and Christ, it costs nothing to apply and requires nothing of the applicant. He thought Lutheranism had done this to its own founder: Luther's discovery of grace came at the end of a life of costly obedience, and his heirs had kept the conclusion and thrown away the road to it.
It is not a demand for more effort. This is where the phrase is most often abused. Costly grace is not cheap grace plus works. Bonhoeffer's formula is that only the believer obeys and only the obedient believe — the two are not stages but a single act. Grace is costly because it cost God a death, and because it costs the person called their previous life; it is grace because it is given, not achieved. Preachers who use "costly grace" to demand more from a congregation while offering nothing have reversed him.
And it was written under a specific pressure. The German church in 1937 was preaching forgiveness at full volume while its own government was building camps. That is the context in which cheap grace is not a spiritual weakness but a collaboration.
The chapter's most quoted line — when Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die — is usually read as a call to martyrdom. In 1937 Bonhoeffer meant something more ordinary and more available: the death of the self that decides which of Christ's demands are reasonable.
3. The decision, and why it is not tidy
In June 1939, with war coming and conscription looming, Bonhoeffer accepted an invitation to the United States. He lasted twenty-six days. In a letter to Reinhold Niebuhr he wrote that he had made a mistake in coming, that he had to live through this difficult period of his nation's history with the Christian people of Germany, and that he would have no right to take part in the restoration of Christian life in Germany after the war if he did not share the trials of the time with his people. He went back on one of the last civilian crossings.
In 1940, through his brother-in-law Hans von Dohnanyi, he was brought into the Abwehr, German military intelligence, whose leadership under Admiral Canaris was a nest of the conspiracy against Hitler. Formally he was an agent using his ecumenical contacts abroad for the Reich. Actually he was a courier for the resistance — most famously at Sigtuna in Sweden in May 1942, where he met Bishop George Bell of Chichester and passed him the names of conspirators and a request that the Allies indicate what terms a post-Hitler German government might expect. The British government declined to reply. He was also involved in Operation 7, which got fourteen Jews out of Germany to Switzerland by classifying them as Abwehr agents.
He was arrested on 5 April 1943 — not for the plot, which was not yet discovered, but over the currency transfers used in Operation 7 and over the suspicion that his intelligence work was a device to keep him out of the army.
Now the hard part.
Bonhoeffer had come close to pacifism in the mid-1930s. He had wanted to go to India to see Gandhi. He had written in Discipleship an exposition of the Sermon on the Mount that takes "resist not evil" with complete seriousness. And he then joined a group of men planning to kill someone.
You cannot make that comfortable, and this lecture will not try. What can be said is what he himself said about it, which is not what people usually assume.
He did not claim it was right. In the Ethics manuscripts written during these years, Bonhoeffer developed an account of responsible action in which the person who acts responsibly in an evil situation does not keep clean hands and does not pretend to. He argued that a person who takes guilt on themselves in responsibility imputes that guilt to themselves and to no one else; that before others they may plead necessity and before their own conscience they may be acquitted, but that before God they hope for nothing but grace.
Read that carefully, because it is the opposite of a justification. He is not saying the killing would have been permissible. He is saying: this is guilt, I am taking it, I am not passing it to anyone else, and I have no defence except mercy. The category he reaches for is not "the lesser evil" — which acquits the actor — but confession.
He did not think he had a principle to stand on. In "After Ten Years", the essay he circulated among friends at Christmas 1942, he ran through the available positions — reason, principle, conscience, freedom, private virtue — and found each of them broken by what was happening. What was left, he wrote, was the responsible person, who tries to make their whole life an answer to the question and call of God, and who is ready to sacrifice all of those things when called to obedient action.
And he did not think he knew who he was. The poem "Who Am I?", written in Tegel prison in June 1944, sets the calm and dignified man the guards saw against the one he knew from inside — restless, longing, sick of it all, trembling with anger. It ends by handing the question over: whoever I am, thou knowest, O God, I am thine.
The scholarly objection
The scholarly objection you should know about. A minority of scholars — the fullest case is Bonhoeffer the Assassin? by Mark Thiessen Nation and colleagues — argue that the standard picture is wrong: that Bonhoeffer never repudiated the position of Discipleship, that there is no documentary evidence he planned or approved killing, and that his actual role was to carry information and rescue Jews. Most Bonhoeffer scholars, including those who worked on the critical edition, reject this reading and think it underrates how much he knew and endorsed. You should know that the argument exists and that it is made in good faith. Both sides, notice, are trying to answer the same question: is this a man whose life we can use as a rule?
This is the point where a lecture like this most easily goes wrong. The neat version says: Bonhoeffer the pacifist theologian discovered that love of neighbour required violence, and so pacifism was answered. That is elegant, and it is not what the sources support. He did not announce a change of position, publish a revised ethic, or tell his students that the Sermon on the Mount had been superseded. He acted, said it was guilt, and left the question open. If you find that unsatisfying, so did he.
He was silent about a great deal, and he was not silent about this. The Confessing Church, as lecture 6-3 showed, said almost nothing about the Jews. In the Ethics manuscripts Bonhoeffer drafted a confession of guilt in the church's own voice, which says that the church has seen the arbitrary use of brutal force and the suffering of countless innocent people, and has not raised its voice on their behalf — and that it is guilty of the lives of the weakest and most defenceless brothers and sisters of Jesus Christ. That was written for a church that had not asked him to write it.
4. The prison letters
Bonhoeffer spent eighteen months in Tegel military prison, writing to his parents, to his fiancée Maria von Wedemeyer, and — smuggled out by a sympathetic guard — to Bethge. After the 20 July 1944 plot failed and the conspirators' files were found at Zossen, he was moved to the Gestapo cellar, then Buchenwald, then Flossenbürg, where he was hanged on 9 April 1945, two weeks before the camp was liberated. An English fellow prisoner, Payne Best, reported his last recorded words: this is the end — for him, the beginning of life.
The letters from the spring and summer of 1944 contain the most argued-over pages in modern theology. Three phrases carry most of it.
A world come of age (mündige Welt). Bonhoeffer observes that in science, in politics, in ethics and even in religion, human beings have learned to manage without invoking God as an explanation. He refuses the usual clerical response — hunting for the gaps where people still feel helpless, and installing God there. A God who survives only in the gaps, he says, will be pushed further back with every advance; and that God, the God of the stopgap, deserves to be pushed back. The right response is to meet people at the centre of their strength, not the edge of their weakness.
Religionless Christianity. By "religion" he means roughly what Barth meant, with an added sociological edge: the inward, individualistic, other-worldly form Christianity has taken in the West, which addresses people as needy and treats faith as a compartment. He asks what Christ actually is for us today, in a world where that form no longer communicates. He did not answer it. He never got the chance, and what survives is an outline for a book he did not write.
The man for others. In that outline, from August 1944, the answer he was reaching for takes a shape: Jesus is there only for others, and faith is participation in his being; the church is the church only when it exists for others. Alongside it stands the sentence from the letter of 16 July 1944 that most sharply distinguishes him from a conventional theology of power: God lets himself be pushed out of the world onto a cross, and is weak and powerless in the world — and that, precisely, is the way and the only way in which God is with us and helps us.
A caution about all three. These are letters to a friend, written by a man who expected to revise them and did not survive to do it. Some 1960s theology treated them as a programme, and built a great deal on a few pages. Read them as what they are: the questions of a man who has been thinking hard for eighteen months in a cell, from a theologian who spent his last Sundays leading worship for other prisoners in the ordinary religious forms he was questioning.
5. What to carry out of this lecture
The chapter's principle was that it took a war to show that a theology of human progress had nothing to say to human ruin. Bonhoeffer is where that lands in a single life. He is not the proof of a system. He is a man who took the theology of chapters 6-2 and 6-3 as far as it would go into the world, discovered that going there cost him his innocence as well as his life, and refused to describe either loss as a victory.
Take him as the answer to a question and you will misuse him, whichever answer you were looking for. Take him as the record of a Christian who found no clean option and acted anyway, without excusing himself, and he is very hard to argue with.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Cheap grace | Costly grace | |
|---|---|---|
| Forgiveness | Preached as a general principle, requiring no repentance | Given to a person who is turning, and knows what they are leaving |
| Baptism | Administered without church discipline | Entry into a community that will hold the baptised to it |
| Communion | Approached without confession | Approached by people who have told each other the truth |
| Discipleship | Optional, interior, adjustable to circumstance | A summons to one person, requiring one step, priced in advance |
| Where the cost falls | Nowhere; that is the definition | On God at the cross first, and then on the one called |
| The church under a regime | Sings of grace while the camps are built | Confesses guilt for the weakest and pays for saying so |
| Its characteristic abuse | Quoting justification as a reason to require nothing | Quoting "costly" as a reason to demand more and give nothing |
5. Going to the Sources
- Bonhoeffer, Discipleship (Nachfolge, 1937), chapter 1, "Costly Grace" — eight pages, and everything in section 2 of this lecture is in them.
- Bonhoeffer, Life Together (1939), the chapters on the day together and on confession — the practical shape of Finkenwalde, and much more usable in an ordinary congregation than its reputation suggests.
- Bonhoeffer, Ethics, the sections "The Structure of Responsible Life" and "Guilt, Justification, Renewal" — where the account of taking guilt upon oneself is set out, and where the church's confession of guilt is drafted. Read these before you form a view on the conspiracy.
- Bonhoeffer, Letters and Papers from Prison, letters of 30 April, 8 June, 16 July and 21 July 1944, plus "After Ten Years" and the poem "Who Am I?" — perhaps forty pages, and the whole of the prison theology in outline.
- Eberhard Bethge, Dietrich Bonhoeffer: A Biography, and his essay "Dietrich Bonhoeffer and the Jews" — the friend's account, and the friend's warning against sanctifying him.
The critical edition, Dietrich Bonhoeffer Works in seventeen volumes, is in English and in most seminary libraries; its editorial introductions are the best short guides available.
In short
- Bonhoeffer's life is his argument. Early study in Berlin, a year in New York with Harlem preaching and a pacifist friend, and Finkenwalde seminary shaped his turn to obedience and discipleship.
- Cheap grace is forgiveness preached as a general principle, without repentance or discipleship. Costly grace is not cheap grace plus effort. Only the believer obeys, and only the obedient believe.
- He returned from the United States in 1939 and joined the resistance through the Abwehr. He called the guilt of that choice his own and hoped for nothing but grace. He did not call it right.
- Scholars disagree. A minority, including Mark Thiessen Nation, says he never left the position of Discipleship, while most reject that reading. The lecture says he never announced a changed ethic.
- The prison letters offer a world come of age, religionless Christianity and the man for others. They are questions from a man who did not live to revise them, not a finished programme.
Topic: This lecture follows Bonhoeffer from Finkenwalde to the prison letters and explains cheap grace, costly grace and responsible guilt.
Remember: Costly grace is grace as a call to a person, not a principle. It cost God a death and costs the called person their old life, and it is still given, not earned.
Caution: Do not use Bonhoeffer as a ready answer for pacifism or just war. He left the question open, and the prison letters are unfinished questions, not a programme.
One line to carry into ministry: Offer forgiveness to a person who is turning, not as a principle that asks nothing, and do not use "costly" to demand more while giving nothing.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Bonhoeffer said the responsible person takes guilt upon themselves and hopes only for grace. How does that differ from saying the action was the lesser evil — and why might the difference matter to the person doing it?
- Where in your own congregation is forgiveness offered as a principle rather than to a person? Describe the change that would make it costly, and name what that change would cost the church, not the individual.
- If Bonhoeffer never published a revised position on the Sermon on the Mount, on what basis can either a pacifist or a supporter of just war claim him? What would honest use of him look like from each side?
- "A God of the gaps will be pushed back with every advance." Identify a place where your own preaching or teaching depends on people's weakness rather than addressing them at the centre of their strength. What would it take to move it?