FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH302E · Chapter 2

Lecture 2-3: Conversion by the Sword

In some places and times, baptism was joined to a ruler's army and to the law. A baptism obtained by penalty tells us what a ruler could command, not what a person believed.

Christian Missionaries in History: From the Apostles to Today

14 cards 20 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe, without gore, what was done to the Saxons under Charlemagne, and to peoples of the Baltic lands in the crusades.
  • Name at least two people at the time who objected to forced baptism and say what they argued.
  • Explain why a ruler's baptism did not by itself tell what the people believed.
  • Say what is the same and what is different in the baptism of Saxons, Bulgarians and Kyivans under their rulers.
  • State fairly where readers differ on whether such events belong to the history of mission.
Rulers and peoples

What a ruler's baptism shows

For a ruler, baptism could bring an alliance with a larger Christian power, trade, a literate class and standing among kings. For the people, the religion of the community was often tied to the ruler. Some followed with real conviction, some because refusing was dangerous, and some kept the old customs at home. A baptism in a chronicle tells us what a ruler did, not what each person believed.

Key idea Our sources rarely let us see whether a ruler was a believer, a statesman or both.
Scripture

Why Matthew 26:52?

The lecture uses this verse as Jesus' own words at his arrest. It says those who objected to forced baptism used texts like this, while others read the same Bible and drew other conclusions.

Then Jesus said to him, “Put your sword back into its place, for all those who take the sword will die by the sword." Matthew 26:52 · World English Bible
Scripture

Why John 18:36?

The lecture uses this verse as Jesus' own words at his trial. It says those who objected to forced baptism used texts like this, while others drew other conclusions.

Jesus answered, “My Kingdom is not of this world. If my Kingdom were of this world, then my servants would fight, that I wouldn’t be delivered to the Jews. But now my Kingdom is not from here.”" John 18:36 · WEB
Scripture

Why Philemon 1:14?

The lecture uses this verse because Paul says he will do nothing without Philemon's consent, so that the good is a free choice and not a forced one. The lecture calls it a standard that many of these cases did not reach.

But I was willing to do nothing without your consent, that your goodness would not be as of necessity, but of free will." Philemon 1:14 · WEB
The Saxons

Baptism under war and law

The Franks under Charlemagne fought the Saxons for many years in the late eighth century. The Frankish annals report that a large number of Saxons were put to death at Verden. A Frankish law made it a crime punishable by death to refuse baptism. We have very little in the Saxons' own words, because almost everything was written by people on the Frankish side.

Key idea What a Saxon farmer thought as he stood in a river for baptism has not been preserved.
An objector

Alcuin, a voice from inside

Alcuin was an English scholar at Charlemagne's court. In letters of the 790s he said that faith must be freely chosen. He urged that the Saxons be taught before they were baptised, and warned that heavy tithes would make the faith a burden. His voice did not stop the policy, and he did not leave the court.

Key idea He is an example of a person who objected without being able to change what happened.
The Baltic

The northern crusades

From the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the popes authorised crusades against pagan peoples around the Baltic Sea. A crusade was a war authorised by the church and offered to its fighters as a religious duty. Baptism followed defeat, and the arrival of new rulers meant new taxes and new lords. The records were mostly written by the conquerors.

Key idea Some who were baptised returned to the old rites.
Another objector

Paulus Vladimiri at Constance

Paulus Vladimiri, a Polish scholar, spoke at the Council of Constance in the early fifteenth century. He argued that non-Christian peoples have rights, that a war to compel belief is not a lawful way to bring people to faith, and that the Teutonic Order's wars against the Lithuanians were not just. The council did not end the Order's claims, but his argument is recorded.

Key idea As with Alcuin, his case was heard and did not carry the day.
At a glance

Where readers will not agree

The opposite of mission

Forced conversion was a corruption of mission, a political project that used religious words. Calling it the opposite keeps mission as a free invitation.

Part of its history

It was part of mission in its own time, because those who did it sincerely thought it served the salvation of souls.

Not a clear line then

The line was not clear to those who lived then, as Alcuin's letters show: some saw it, and others did not.

Think about it

Could they say no?

Paul's letter to Philemon sets a standard that the good done should be done freely.

Think of an invitation you have made or received to join something. Could the person have said no without cost?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

A baptism obtained by penalty tells us what a ruler could command, not what a person believed. The harm is named as harm, and the objectors, such as Alcuin and Paulus Vladimiri, are not forgotten. The same pattern, a ruler's baptism becoming a people's, appears in the Latin west and in Orthodox lands.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 14