FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 1

Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops

Three theories explain how doctrine develops: Newman's organic growth, Harnack's Hellenization and a recent view of development as exegetical labor. None has won, and you will use all three.

The History of Christian Doctrine

13 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Restate Newman's organic-development model in your own words, including at least one of his proposed tests for distinguishing development from corruption.
  • State Harnack's "Hellenization" thesis accurately enough that a historian sympathetic to Harnack would recognize your summary as fair, and explain what evidence he thought supported it.
  • Describe a modern alternative to both Newman and Harnack (associated with Pelikan and, on the Trinity specifically, Lewis Ayres) that treats doctrinal development as disciplined exegetical labor rather than either straight-line growth or corruption by foreign philosophy.
  • Identify at least one weakness historians have raised against each of the three theories.
Newman

Four tests for growth or corruption

Newman's organic model comes with named tests. Preservation of type asks whether the developed doctrine still serves the same function. Continuity of principles asks whether the same commitments generate both statements. Logical sequence asks for a real chain of reasoning, and chronic vigor holds that corruptions tend to be short-lived while genuine developments endure.

Key idea Later chapters use versions of these tests without relabeling them.
The criticism

A flexible test

The main criticism of Newman, made by his contemporaries and later historians, is that his tests are flexible enough to justify almost any development a sympathetic reader wants to justify. They can equally condemn any development an unsympathetic reader wants to condemn. An oak is not the acorn's only possible outgrowth, since a fungus can also grow from a buried acorn. The biological metaphor does not tell you which growth you are looking at.

Key idea The lecture applies the tests to homoousios, which it says restates John 1:1 in technical vocabulary.
Harnack

Dogma as the work of the Greek spirit

Adolf von Harnack argued that the simple gospel Jesus preached was overlaid by Greek metaphysical categories in the centuries after the apostles. He held that dogma, in its conception and development, is a work of the Greek spirit on the soil of the gospel. The lecture says this was not a fringe claim, since he was among the most respected historians of his era. His evidence was real: Clement, Origen and others did borrow from Middle Platonism to speak to educated Greeks.

Key idea The contested part is his inference that the borrowing corrupted rather than clarified.
Objections

Three objections to Harnack

A projected gospel

His simple gospel looks like a nineteenth-century liberal ethical ideal. Albert Schweitzer argued each generation's historical Jesus wears its own values.

Greek terms inside Scripture

John's use of logos draws on a word with a long Greek philosophical pedigree, so the borrowing begins in Scripture itself.

Terms were revised

The fourth-century terms, homoousios, hypostasis and ousia, were borrowed and then sharply revised against their pagan sources, not simply adopted.

Third theory

Development as exegetical labor

The recent view, linked to Pelikan's later volumes and to Lewis Ayres on the Trinity, rejects the choice between straight-line growth and corruption. It holds that fourth-century doctrine came from sustained, technical exegesis of specific biblical texts. Writers used philosophical vocabulary as tools while subordinating it to the text. Nicaea's use of homoousios is closer to a scalpel borrowed for a specific cut than to an imported ideology.

Key idea The fight over Proverbs 8:22 was won or lost on exegetical ground.
A new question

Change the axis

This account does not split the difference between Newman and Harnack. It denies that growth versus corruption is the right axis for the data. The right question is whether the exegesis was careful, sustained and answerable to the text, or careless, discontinuous and answerable mainly to outside pressure. That question can be answered with textual evidence, without first deciding whether you are a Newmanite or a Harnackian.

Key idea Ask about the quality of the exegesis.
In this course

Living with three theories

None of the three theories has driven out the others. Working historians use Newman's vocabulary of development freely and treat Harnack's thesis as a serious claim to test case by case. Some post-Nicene developments look more like Harnack's drift than Newman's growth, and the course will flag candidates. Increasingly historians favor the exegesis-centered account for how the great councils did their work.

Key idea Chapters 2 and 3 are where the Hellenization charge is most often made.
Scripture

Why John 16:12-13?

The lecture says Jesus gives the church a category for teaching that unfolds progressively, with the Spirit leading into all truth. Each of the three theories tries to explain what that guidance looked like in practice.

I have yet many things to tell you, but you can't bear them now. However when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth, for he will not speak from himself; but whatever he hears, he will speak. He will declare to you things that are coming." John 16:12-13 · World English Bible
Think about it

What can be true but not yet sayable?

In John 16:12-13 Jesus tells his disciples there are things they cannot bear yet.

What would it mean for a doctrine to be true but genuinely un-sayable at an earlier time, and how is that different from it not existing yet?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Newman saw doctrine as organic growth with named tests, though critics say they are too flexible. Harnack saw Greek metaphysics overlaying a simple gospel, though critics note Greek vocabulary already appears in the New Testament. The recent view asks whether the exegesis was careful and answerable to the text. When someone says a doctrine was invented later, ask which texts the argument turned on.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 13