FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH401E The History of Christian Doctrine

Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH401E The History of Christian Doctrine
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What the History of Doctrine Is, and Why a Doctrine Has a History
  1. Introduction: What the History of Doctrine Is, and Why a Doctrine Has a History
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Method, Canon, and Creed
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "History of Doctrine" Is, and What Newman and Pelikan Add to It
  2. Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops
  3. Lecture 1-3: How the New Testament Canon Was Formed
  4. Lecture 1-4: Creeds Before the Creeds — The Rule of Faith
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The History of Trinitarian Doctrine
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
  2. Lecture 2-2: From Nicaea to Constantinople — The Cappadocian Settlement
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology
  4. Lecture 2-4: Post-Reformation Challenges and the Twentieth-Century Trinitarian Revival
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The History of Christological Doctrine
  1. Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save
  2. Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument
  3. Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology
  4. Lecture 3-4: Modern Christology
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Sin and Grace — The History of Soteriology
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Pelagian Controversy
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grace in the Medieval Church
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Reformation and Justification by Faith
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Arminian Controversy
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Church and Its Sacraments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Donatist Controversy and Augustine's Answer
  2. Lecture 5-2: Medieval Ecclesiology — Seven Sacraments and the Rise of Papal Primacy
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Doctrine of Scripture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Theopneustos — The Early Church's Doctrine of Inspiration
  2. Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute
  3. Lecture 6-3: Sola Scriptura and Trent's Answer — What Each Side Actually Claimed
  4. Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The History of Eschatology
  1. Lecture 7-1: The Earliest Millennium — Papias, Justin, and Irenaeus
  2. Lecture 7-2: Augustine and the Church-Age Reading
  3. Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism
  4. Lecture 7-4: Dispensationalism and the Modern Landscape
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Modern Doctrinal Landscape
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Enlightenment's Challenge and the Rise of Liberal Theology
  2. Lecture 8-2: Neo-Orthodoxy's Answer
  3. Lecture 8-3: Twentieth-Century Diversification
  4. Lecture 8-4: The Evangelical Tradition, and the Task Still Ahead

Jump to the key points ↓

18 min

Lecture 1-1 introduced Newman's question — is a later doctrine a legitimate growth or a corruption? — without answering it. This lecture puts three actual answers on the table, in the order they entered the conversation: Newman's own organic-growth model, a sharp and once-enormously-influential counter-theory from Adolf von Harnack that says the whole development was corruption dressed as growth, and a more recent account that rejects the terms of that argument altogether. None of the three is presented here as the "textbook answer." You will use elements of all three, at different points, across the rest of this course, and this lecture's job is to make sure you can tell them apart when you reach for one.

What these 18 minutes give you

  • Restate Newman's organic-development model in your own words, including at least one of his proposed tests for distinguishing development from corruption.
  • State Harnack's "Hellenization" thesis accurately enough that a historian sympathetic to Harnack would recognize your summary as fair, and explain what evidence he thought supported it.
  • Describe a modern alternative to both Newman and Harnack (associated with Pelikan and, on the Trinity specifically, Lewis Ayres) that treats doctrinal development as disciplined exegetical labor rather than either straight-line growth or corruption by foreign philosophy.
  • Identify at least one weakness historians have raised against each of the three theories.

I have yet many things to tell you, but you can't bear them now. However when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth, for he will not speak from himself; but whatever he hears, he will speak. He will declare to you things that are coming." — John 16:12-13

World English Bible

Jesus tells his own disciples, on the night before his death, that there is more truth than they are currently able to bear — and promises a Spirit-guided process of being led "into all truth" that will continue after he is gone. Whatever else this text is doing, it gives the church itself, in Jesus's own words, a category for teaching that unfolds progressively rather than arriving all at once. Every theory of doctrinal development this lecture covers is, in some sense, an attempt to explain what "guided into all truth" looked like in practice over the centuries that followed — and the three theories disagree sharply about how much of that guidance was faithful continuation and how much, if any, was distortion.

1. Newman: development as organic growth

Lecture 1-1 already introduced the shape of Newman's 1845 argument: doctrine develops the way a living organism develops, an oak recognizably continuous with its acorn despite looking nothing like it. What that lecture did not cover in detail are Newman's actual tests for telling legitimate development from corruption — tools worth having by name, because later chapters will use versions of them without pausing to relabel them.

Among the tests Newman proposed: preservation of type (does the developed doctrine still recognizably serve the same function and hold the same place in the system as the earlier form?); continuity of principles (do the same underlying commitments generate both the earlier and later statement, or has a genuinely new principle been smuggled in?); logical sequence (can you trace an actual chain of reasoning, not merely a chronological sequence, from the earlier form to the later one?); and what Newman called chronic vigor — the observation that corruptions in his experience tend to be short-lived and unstable, while genuine developments tend to settle in and endure. Applied to the (which chapter 2 covers in full), Newman's tests would ask: does homoousios still serve the function the New Testament's language about Jesus's deity was already serving? Yes, argues Newman — it says with a precise technical vocabulary what "the Word was God" (John 1:1) was already claiming with ordinary vocabulary. Applied to, say, the medieval doctrine of , different readers — including different readers within this course's audience — will reach different verdicts, which is exactly the kind of live disagreement this course keeps surfacing rather than resolving for you.

The main criticism of Newman's model, made both by his contemporaries and by later historians, is that his tests are flexible enough to justify almost any development a sympathetic reader already wants to justify, and to condemn almost any development an unsympathetic reader already wants to condemn. An oak is not obviously the acorn's only possible legitimate outgrowth; a fungus can also grow from an acorn buried in wet soil, and Newman's biological metaphor does not, by itself, tell you which growth you are looking at.

2. Harnack: development as Hellenization

Where Newman wrote to defend continuity, the German liberal Protestant historian Adolf von Harnack wrote, at the end of the nineteenth century, to expose what he considered a rupture. In his massive History of Dogma (Dogmengeschichte, 1886-1889) and in the more accessible popular lectures later published as What Is Christianity? (1900), Harnack argued that the "simple gospel" Jesus actually preached — the fatherhood of God, the infinite value of the human soul, the higher righteousness and the command of love — was, in the centuries after the apostles, progressively overlaid and reshaped by Greek metaphysical categories foreign to Jesus's own Jewish and Galilean world. Harnack's famous, blunt formulation was that dogma, in its conception and development, is a work of the Greek spirit on the soil of the gospel — Christian doctrine, on this account, is what happens when a movement that began as ethical and existential (how should I live? what does God's fatherhood mean for me?) gets reprocessed through the technical vocabulary of Greek philosophy (being, substance, nature, person) until the original, simple message is buried under metaphysical machinery it never needed.

This is not a marginal or fringe claim historically — Harnack was among the most respected and productive historians of doctrine of his era, and his thesis shaped, directly or in reaction, most twentieth-century scholarship on early Christian doctrine that followed him, including much of what would try to refute him. Give it its full strength before naming what is wrong with it: Harnack could point to real evidence. Second- and third-century Christian writers, especially the Alexandrian tradition running through Clement and Origen, genuinely did borrow vocabulary and conceptual tools from Middle Platonism to explain Christian claims to an educated Greco-Roman audience — this is not in dispute, and chapter 2's discussion of the Apologists (in this course's companion course) documents exactly this borrowing. Harnack's inference from that fact — that the borrowing therefore corrupted rather than clarified the content — is the part later scholarship has most heavily contested.

The standard objections to Harnack, developed across the twentieth century, run in three directions. First, the "simple gospel" Harnack reconstructs behind the doctrine looks suspiciously like a nineteenth-century liberal Protestant ethical ideal projected backward onto Jesus — a criticism made forcefully by Harnack's own younger contemporary Albert Schweitzer, whose The Quest of the Historical Jesus (1906) argued that every generation's "historical Jesus" ends up looking like that generation's own values wearing first-century clothes. Second, the "Hellenization" Harnack treats as an outside corruption was already well underway inside the New Testament's own vocabulary — the Gospel of John's use of logos ("Word," John 1:1) draws on a term with a long Greek philosophical pedigree stretching back to Heraclitus and the Stoics, which means the borrowing of Greek categories to state Christian claims did not begin in the second century; it begins in Scripture itself. Third, and most damaging: careful study of exactly what the fourth-century councils actually argued about shows the disputed terms (homoousios, hypostasis, ousia) were used with meanings frequently borrowed from and then sharply revised against their pagan philosophical sources, not simply adopted wholesale — a distinction the next theory takes as its starting point.

3. A modern alternative: development as exegetical labor

The theory most influential in recent scholarship — associated with Pelikan's own later volumes and, on the Trinity specifically, with the historian Lewis Ayres's Nicaea and Its Legacy (2004) — rejects the choice Newman and Harnack both assume: that development must be either straight-line organic growth or corruption by an outside philosophical system. This account argues instead that fourth-century Trinitarian doctrine, in particular, was produced by sustained, disciplined, often highly technical of specific biblical texts, conducted by writers who used available philosophical vocabulary as tools while consistently subordinating that vocabulary to the biblical text rather than the reverse.

On this account, when the reached for the non-biblical term homoousios ("of the same essence") in 325, it was not importing Greek metaphysics to solve a problem Scripture itself could not solve — it was doing what any translator or teacher does when existing vocabulary keeps producing misunderstanding: reaching for a technical term precise enough to rule out a reading (Arius's, examined fully in lecture 2-1) that a plainer form of words had failed to exclude. The philosophical vocabulary is real, and its Greek pedigree is real, but its use in the councils is closer to a scalpel borrowed for a specific cut than to an ideology imported wholesale. Ayres's detailed studies of how fourth-century writers actually handled specific, contested biblical passages — Proverbs 8:22 ("The LORD possessed me in the beginning of his way"), used by Arians to argue the Son was created, and painstakingly re-exegeted by pro-Nicene writers verse by verse — supports this picture: the argument was fought, and largely won or lost, on exegetical ground, with philosophical vocabulary recruited as needed rather than driving the conclusion from outside.

This account does not simply split the difference between Newman and Harnack. It denies that "growth versus corruption" is even the right axis to plot the data on. The right question, on this view, is closer to: was the exegesis careful, sustained, and answerable to the text, or was it careless, discontinuous, and answerable mainly to outside pressure? That question can be asked, and answered with actual textual evidence, without first deciding whether you are a sympathetic Newmanite or a suspicious Harnackian.

4. Living with three theories at once

None of these three theories has driven the other two from the field. Working historians of doctrine today use Newman's vocabulary of "development" freely, treat Harnack's Hellenization thesis as a serious historical claim worth testing case by case rather than dismissing outright (some post-Nicene developments really do look more like the drift Harnack describes than the growth Newman describes — this course will flag candidates as they arise), and increasingly favor the exegesis-centered account for explaining how the major fourth- and fifth-century councils actually did their work. You will find all three registers used again in this course: "development" language in most chapters, an honest test of the Hellenization charge specifically where it is most often made (chapter 2's Trinity, chapter 3's Christology), and close attention to which biblical texts a controversy actually turned on, in the manner this lecture's third theory recommends.


Diagram 1. Three theories of doctrinal development, compared

Three Theories of Doctrinal Development All three still in use — not a solved question Newman (1845) Organic growth Oak from acorn Tests: preservation of type, continuity of principle, chronic vigor Critique: tests flex to fit any conclusion Mostly continuity Harnack (1886-1900) "Hellenization" Simple ethical gospel overlaid by Greek metaphysics Critique: "simple gospel" looks like 19th-c. liberal ideal read backward Mostly corruption Pelikan / Ayres (recent) Exegetical labor Philosophy as tool, not driver; text stays in charge Test: was the exegesis careful and sustained, or careless? Rejects the axis itself John 16:12-13 — a Spirit-guided process of being "guided into all truth" All three theories are attempts to explain what that guidance looked like historically — this course will use language from all three, tested case by case, chapter by chapter None of the three has driven the other two from the field

5. Going to the Sources

  • Adolf von Harnack, What Is Christianity? (1900 lectures, many free English editions at ccel.org), Lecture 1 — the most accessible statement of the Hellenization thesis in Harnack's own words, before you meet later chapters' tests of it against actual conciliar arguments.
  • Lewis Ayres, Nicaea and Its Legacy (2004), Introduction — the clearest modern statement of the exegesis-centered alternative to both Newman and Harnack; not freely available online, but excerpted in most seminary library holdings and widely summarized in academic reviews.

In short

  • Newman saw doctrine as organic growth. His tests include preservation of type, continuity of principles, logical sequence and chronic vigor, meaning that corruptions tend to be short-lived.
  • Critics say Newman's tests are flexible enough to justify or condemn almost any development, depending on the reader's sympathies.
  • Adolf von Harnack argued that a simple ethical gospel was overlaid by Greek metaphysics. Critics, including Albert Schweitzer, said his "simple gospel" looks like a nineteenth-century liberal ideal.
  • Critics also note that Greek vocabulary already appears in the New Testament, as with logos in John 1:1, and that the councils revised borrowed terms.
  • A recent view, linked to Pelikan and Lewis Ayres, treats development as careful exegesis (close study of the biblical text), with philosophy used as a tool. None of the three theories has won.

Topic: This lecture compares three theories of how doctrine develops: Newman's organic growth, Harnack's Hellenization, and the recent view of development as exegetical labor.

Remember: The recent view changes the question. Ask whether the exegesis was careful, sustained and answerable to the text, not only whether the change was growth or corruption.

Caution: The lecture does not crown a winner. Each theory has a weakness named by historians, and some later developments may look more like Harnack's drift than Newman's growth.

One line to carry into ministry: When someone says a doctrine was invented later, ask which biblical texts the argument actually turned on, and how carefully the church read them.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Restate Harnack's Hellenization thesis in a form a sympathetic historian would recognize as fair, before you decide whether you find it persuasive.
  • This lecture argues that Greek philosophical vocabulary (like *logos* in John 1:1) is already present inside the New Testament itself, not only in later councils. Does that observation weaken Harnack's argument, or does it simply move the "Hellenization" charge earlier than Harnack placed it?
  • The third theory asks whether a given development's exegesis was "careful and sustained" or "careless and discontinuous" rather than asking whether it was simply growth or corruption. Try applying that question, rather than Newman's or Harnack's, to a doctrinal development from your own tradition's history.
  • John 16:12-13 has Jesus telling his disciples there are things they "can't bear... now." What would it mean for a doctrine to have been true, but genuinely un-sayable, at an earlier point in church history — and how is that different from the doctrine simply not existing yet?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.