FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 6

Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate

Since the eighteenth century, scholars have read the Bible with the tools used on any ancient document. The doctrine of Scripture has answered in several voices, and the inerrancy debate is one this course cannot settle for you.

The History of Christian Doctrine

12 cards 18 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • Describe, in outline, what historical-critical method proposed to do differently from earlier biblical scholarship, and name at least one major result associated with it (such as the Documentary Hypothesis).
  • Explain the fundamentalist-modernist controversy's central stakes as J. Gresham Machen framed them, and identify at least two institutional consequences that followed from it in American Protestantism.
  • State what the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978) actually affirms and denies, including at least one qualification it builds into the term "inerrancy" itself.
  • Explain why Catholic and mainline Protestant statements on Scripture's authority that avoid the word "inerrancy" do not, on that basis alone, necessarily deny everything the Chicago Statement affirms.
A different challenge

From outside the household

Earlier challenges in this chapter came from inside the church. Starting in the eighteenth century, scholars proposed reading the Bible as historians read any ancient document, asking about sources, authorship, dates and consistency without assuming its supernatural claims settled those questions. This was a challenge from a method that did not need theology's permission to proceed. The doctrine of Scripture has been answering it, in more than one voice, for two and a half centuries.

Key idea The provocation was the bracketing of the question of divine origin.
Scripture

Why John 17:17?

The lecture says every position it describes affirms this verse without reservation. It uses the verse to show that the dispute is not whether God's word is true, but what claiming that truthfulness commits a reader to when the text is read against modern inquiry.

Sanctify them in your truth. Your word is truth." John 17:17 · World English Bible
Historical criticism

Semler to Wellhausen

Spinoza and Richard Simon raised historical questions in the seventeenth century, but the method became a settled discipline mainly in the eighteenth and nineteenth, especially in German universities. Semler distinguished the word of God from Scripture as a historically conditioned collection of documents. By the late nineteenth century Julius Wellhausen had assembled source-critical work into the Documentary Hypothesis, which holds that the first five books were compiled from four sources, labelled J, E, D and P. Much of this work was done by believing Christians.

Key idea It was not, in its own self-understanding, an attack on faith.
Fundamentalist-modernist controversy

Defence and withdrawal

Between 1910 and 1915 a series of pamphlets called The Fundamentals defended what its authors took to be the core of Christian belief. J. Gresham Machen's Christianity and Liberalism in 1923 argued that liberal theology was in substance a different religion. After the 1925 Scopes Trial, conservative Protestants increasingly built separate seminaries, agencies and denominations. Neo-evangelical leaders such as Carl F. H. Henry and the founders of Fuller Seminary in 1947 tried to reverse that withdrawal.

Key idea This is where the vocabulary of the next section comes from.
Chicago Statement

Inerrancy with qualifications

The Chicago Statement of 1978 affirms that Scripture, in the original autographs, is without error in all it teaches. It denies that inerrancy requires modern technical precision. It also says inerrancy is not negated by ordinary phenomenal language such as the sun "rising", by irregularities of grammar or spelling, by round numbers, by free citation of the Old Testament, or by non-chronological ordering. The drafters intended a genre-sensitive claim: Scripture is true in what it actually intends to assert.

Key idea Both those who invoke the word as a licence to read every genre alike and those who dismiss it as meaning that are using a narrower version than the text.
At a glance

Views of Scripture's truthfulness

Evangelical (Chicago)

Inerrancy of the original autographs with genre-sensitive qualifications, a term worth defending because it is more specific than general reliability.

Catholic (Dei Verbum)

Scripture teaches without error the truth God wanted for our salvation. Catholics debate whether this is equivalent to Chicago or narrower.

Mainline Protestant

Full authority and truthfulness for faith and life, often using "authority" or "infallibility" and declining the word "inerrancy".

Reading statements

Vocabulary is not proof

Avoiding the word "inerrancy" can reflect substantive caution about historical-critical findings, or simply a wish not to carry the word's American controversy history. Neither motive alone proves a church denies everything the Chicago Statement affirms. Some traditions intend a more limited claim, and others intend something close to the same claim in different words. The lecture also notes progressive evangelical voices who think the qualifications do not go far enough, and others who hold a stricter reading.

Key idea Read a tradition's actual statement rather than inferring its content from its words.
Think about it

Truth and what it commits you to

Nobody in this argument denies that God's word is true.

What does affirming that truthfulness commit you to when the text is read against modern historical and scientific findings?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Historical-critical method read the Bible like other ancient documents, and the fundamentalist-modernist controversy and the Chicago Statement of 1978 followed. Evangelical, Catholic and mainline traditions all affirm that God's word is true and differ on what that commits a reader to. Describe each in its own words, not by vocabulary alone.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12