Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: What "History of Doctrine" Is, and What Newman and Pelikan Add to It
- Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops
- Lecture 1-3: How the New Testament Canon Was Formed
- Lecture 1-4: Creeds Before the Creeds — The Rule of Faith
- Lecture 2-1: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
- Lecture 2-2: From Nicaea to Constantinople — The Cappadocian Settlement
- Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology
- Lecture 2-4: Post-Reformation Challenges and the Twentieth-Century Trinitarian Revival
- Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save
- Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument
- Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology
- Lecture 3-4: Modern Christology
- Lecture 4-1: The Pelagian Controversy
- Lecture 4-2: Grace in the Medieval Church
- Lecture 4-3: The Reformation and Justification by Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Arminian Controversy
- Lecture 5-1: The Donatist Controversy and Augustine's Answer
- Lecture 5-2: Medieval Ecclesiology — Seven Sacraments and the Rise of Papal Primacy
- Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
- Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
- Lecture 6-1: Theopneustos — The Early Church's Doctrine of Inspiration
- Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute
- Lecture 6-3: Sola Scriptura and Trent's Answer — What Each Side Actually Claimed
- Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
- Lecture 7-1: The Earliest Millennium — Papias, Justin, and Irenaeus
- Lecture 7-2: Augustine and the Church-Age Reading
- Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism
- Lecture 7-4: Dispensationalism and the Modern Landscape
Every challenge this chapter has traced so far came from inside the church's own household — a grammatical ambiguity in its own founding text, a dispute among its own theologians about tradition, a Reformation and a Counter-Reformation both arguing from a shared conviction that Scripture is God's word. The challenge this lecture covers is different in kind. Starting in the eighteenth century, scholars proposed reading the Bible the way historians read any other ancient document — asking about sources, authorship, dates, and internal consistency using the same critical tools applied to Homer or Herodotus, without assuming in advance that its supernatural claims settled those historical questions. That was not a challenge from a rival theology. It was a challenge from a method that did not, on its own terms, need theology's permission to proceed. The doctrine of Scripture has been answering that challenge, in more than one voice, for two and a half centuries — and this lecture, like 6-2, ends on a live dispute this course cannot settle for you.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Describe, in outline, what historical-critical method proposed to do differently from earlier biblical scholarship, and name at least one major result associated with it (such as the Documentary Hypothesis).
- Explain the fundamentalist-modernist controversy's central stakes as J. Gresham Machen framed them, and identify at least two institutional consequences that followed from it in American Protestantism.
- State what the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978) actually affirms and denies, including at least one qualification it builds into the term "inerrancy" itself.
- Explain why Catholic and mainline Protestant statements on Scripture's authority that avoid the word "inerrancy" do not, on that basis alone, necessarily deny everything the Chicago Statement affirms.
Sanctify them in your truth. Your word is truth." — John 17:17
World English Bible
Every position this lecture describes — evangelical, Catholic, and mainline Protestant alike — affirms this verse without reservation. The live dispute this lecture teaches is not whether God's word is true, which nobody in this argument denies, but what claiming that truthfulness commits a reader to when the text is read against the findings of modern historical and scientific inquiry.
1. A challenge from outside the household
Earlier critical readers existed before the eighteenth century — the philosopher Baruch Spinoza and the French Oratorian priest Richard Simon had both, in the seventeenth century, already raised pointed historical questions about Mosaic authorship of the and the composite character of some biblical books, and both paid a real institutional cost for it. But the method became a settled, widely practiced discipline mainly in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, especially in German universities. Johann Salomo Semler, in the mid-eighteenth century, drew a distinction that would prove enormously consequential: between "the word of God" as a theological reality and "Scripture" as a historically conditioned collection of documents, not every part of which he thought carried equal or permanent authority. By the late nineteenth century, Julius Wellhausen had assembled source-critical work on the Pentateuch — building on predecessors going back decades — into the fullest statement of what became known as the : the theory that the first five books of the Bible were compiled from four earlier source traditions, conventionally labeled J, E, D, and P, written at different times and later combined by editors. Parallel work on the New Testament asked similar source and form-critical questions about the Gospels' composition and the historical reliability of specific narratives.
None of this scholarship was, in its own self-understanding, an attack on Christian faith as such — much of it was practiced by believing Christians who thought historical rigor and Christian conviction compatible. But it did something no earlier controversy in this chapter had done: it proposed a method that, by design, bracketed the question of Scripture's divine origin while doing its historical work, on the premise that historical questions should be settled by historical evidence rather than by theological commitment either for or against . That bracketing was itself the provocation. A method that did not need to ask "is this God's word" before answering "who wrote this and when" looked, to many church leaders across several traditions, like a method that had already decided the theological question was irrelevant to serious scholarship — whether or not any individual practitioner intended that implication.
2. The fundamentalist-modernist controversy
American Protestantism's sharpest reaction to this challenge came in the early twentieth century. Between 1910 and 1915, a series of pamphlets called The Fundamentals, funded by conservative laymen and written by a range of scholars, defended what their authors took to be the non-negotiable core of Christian belief — including the inspiration and authority of Scripture — against what they saw as 's accommodations to modern criticism and modern philosophy alike. The Presbyterian scholar J. Gresham Machen gave the controversy its sharpest theological statement in Christianity and Liberalism (1923), arguing that liberal Protestant theology was not a modernized version of historic Christianity at all but, in substance, a different religion using inherited Christian vocabulary — a claim liberal theologians naturally rejected, but one that at least had the of refusing to treat the disagreement as a mere difference of emphasis.
The controversy reached the American public most visibly through the 1925 Scopes Trial in Tennessee, over a state law banning the teaching of evolution in public schools. Whatever the trial's narrow legal outcome, its media coverage — especially H. L. Mencken's widely read, deeply unsympathetic dispatches — left a lasting popular association between theological conservatism generally and anti-intellectualism, an association many later evangelical scholars have spent decades trying to complicate or correct, with mixed public success. In the controversy's institutional aftermath, conservative Protestants increasingly built separate seminaries, mission agencies, and denominations rather than continuing to contest control of the mainline institutions, a real retreat that later "neo-evangelical" leaders — Carl F. H. Henry and the founders of Fuller Theological Seminary in 1947 chief among them — explicitly tried to reverse, arguing that theological conservatism need not mean cultural and intellectual withdrawal. Chapter 8 picks this thread back up as part of the twentieth century's wider doctrinal landscape; this lecture needs it now only to explain where the vocabulary of the next section comes from.
3. The Chicago Statement (1978)
Out of that evangelical trajectory, and specifically to answer perceived erosion of a high view of Scripture within evangelicalism's own institutions, several hundred scholars gathered as the International Council on Biblical and produced the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy in 1978 — a series of affirmations and denials meant to define the term "inerrancy" with more precision than its popular use usually carries. The Statement affirms that Scripture, in the original autographs, is without error or fault in all it teaches, but it builds real qualifications into that claim that popular usage — on both sides of later arguments about the term — regularly misses. The Statement explicitly denies that inerrancy requires adherence to modern standards of technical precision, denies that it is negated by the Bible's use of ordinary phenomenal language (describing the sun "rising," for instance), by irregularities of grammar or spelling, by round numbers or free citation of the Old Testament in the New, or by the ordering of events in a non-chronological or thematic rather than strictly sequential arrangement. In other words, the Statement's own drafters intended a genre-sensitive claim — Scripture is true in what it actually intends to assert, read according to the kind of literature it is — rather than a claim that every biblical sentence must meet a flattened, uniformly literal, twentieth-century-scientific standard of precision. Readers who invoke "inerrancy" as license to read every genre the same way, and readers who dismiss the term as necessarily meaning exactly that flattened standard, are both working from a version narrower than the document's own text.
4. Fair statements of the alternatives
Catholic teaching, reaffirmed at the Second Vatican Council in the 1965 constitution Dei Verbum, states that the books of Scripture "teach firmly, faithfully, and without error that truth which God wanted put into sacred writings for the sake of our salvation" (§11) — a formula some read as functionally equivalent in substance to the Chicago Statement's affirmation, differently worded, and others read as a narrower claim, restricting inerrancy specifically to salvific truth rather than to every historical or scientific assertion the text happens to make along the way. Which reading is correct is itself debated among Catholic theologians, which is worth knowing before assuming Dei Verbum settles the question either way.
Many mainline and ecumenical Protestant confessional statements prefer vocabulary like Scripture's "authority," "" — a term some of these traditions use more narrowly than "inerrancy," restricted specifically to matters of faith and practice rather than every incidental historical or scientific detail — or simply its "truthfulness" for the purposes for which it was given, deliberately avoiding the specific word "inerrancy." Part of that avoidance is substantive theological caution about historical-critical findings some of these traditions take seriously; part of it, on a fair reading, is simply not wanting the word's specific American evangelical controversy history and its narrower technical baggage attached to a different tradition's own confessional language. Neither motive by itself proves that a denomination using "infallible" instead of "inerrant" is denying everything the Chicago Statement affirms — some clearly do intend a substantively different, more limited claim about Scripture's reliability, others intend something close to the same substantive claim in different words, and telling the two apart requires reading a given tradition's actual statement rather than inferring its content from vocabulary alone.
Four views of Scripture
This is a point where readers will not agree. At least four positions are alive among Christians reading this course today. Evangelicals who hold the Chicago Statement's definition affirm inerrancy of the original autographs with the genre-sensitive qualifications described above, and regard the term as worth defending precisely because it names something more specific than "the Bible is generally reliable." Catholic teaching under Dei Verbum affirms Scripture's error-free teaching of saving truth, with real internal debate over how far that guarantee extends into non-salvific historical and scientific statements. Mainline and ecumenical Protestant traditions typically affirm Scripture's full authority and truthfulness for faith and life while declining the specific word "inerrancy," for reasons ranging from substantive disagreement with historical-critical implications some drafters accepted to simple discomfort with the term's particular American controversy history. And within evangelicalism itself, more progressive voices have at times argued that even the Chicago Statement's qualifications do not go far enough to accommodate what historical-critical scholarship has actually found, while some outside any of these three camps continue to hold a stricter, less genre-sensitive reading of inerrancy than the 1978 Statement itself defines. A reader from any of these traditions should be able to recognize their own actual position, not a flattened version of it, somewhere in this paragraph.
5. Going to the Sources
- The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978), the nineteen Articles of Affirmation and Denial produced by the International Council on Biblical Inerrancy, widely reprinted online (e.g. by the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals and several seminary libraries) — read Articles XII and XIII specifically for the genre-sensitivity qualifications this lecture describes.
- Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation), 1965, §11 — available at vatican.va — for the Catholic formula this lecture compares to the Chicago Statement's own language.
In short
- Modern historical-critical method reads the Bible like other ancient documents and sets aside its divine origin while doing historical work. Examples are Semler's distinction and Wellhausen's Documentary Hypothesis (sources J, E, D and P).
- In the fundamentalist-modernist controversy, The Fundamentals and Machen's Christianity and Liberalism defended core belief. Conservatives built separate institutions, and neo-evangelicals such as Carl Henry and Fuller Seminary tried to reverse that withdrawal.
- The Chicago Statement (1978) affirms inerrancy in the original autographs. It denies that this requires modern technical precision and allows ordinary language, round numbers and thematic order.
- Dei Verbum 11 says Scripture teaches without error the truth God wanted for salvation. Catholics debate whether that equals Chicago or is narrower.
- Mainline Protestants often say "authority" or "infallibility." Different words do not automatically mean denial, so read each statement itself.
Topic: This lecture traces how modern criticism challenged the doctrine of Scripture and compares evangelical, Catholic and mainline answers to the question of inerrancy.
Remember: All the positions affirm that God's word is true (John 17:17). They differ on what that truthfulness commits a reader to.
Caution: Do not assume a different word, such as "infallible" instead of "inerrant," means a church denies everything the Chicago Statement affirms. Read the actual statement.
One line to carry into ministry: Describe each tradition's view of Scripture's truthfulness in its own words, and do not judge it by vocabulary alone.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Before this lecture, had you encountered the specific qualifications the Chicago Statement builds into "inerrancy" (genre-sensitivity, phenomenal language, round numbers, non-chronological ordering)? Does knowing them change how you would define the term to someone unfamiliar with the debate?
- J. Gresham Machen argued liberal Protestant theology was, in substance, a different religion rather than a modernized version of historic Christianity. State the strongest version of the position Machen was arguing against, in a form a thoughtful liberal Protestant theologian of his own era would recognize as fair.
- Compare the Chicago Statement's Article XII qualifications to *Dei Verbum* §11's "without error" formula. Do you find these two documents closer together or further apart than their differing vocabulary suggests at first glance? Defend your reading with the actual wording.
- This lecture named at least four live positions among Christians today on Scripture's inerrancy or infallibility. Which of the four had you not previously considered a serious, good-faith theological position, and what in this lecture's account of it, if anything, changed that?