FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

← Full lecture

CH401E · Chapter 8

Lecture 8-1: The Enlightenment's Challenge and the Rise of Liberal Theology

The Enlightenment questioned whether any inherited authority should bind belief. Schleiermacher answered by grounding doctrine in religious feeling, and liberal theology then reshaped the doctrine of the atonement.

The History of Christian Doctrine

12 cards 21 min full lecture

Swipe or use the arrow keys →

What you will learn
  • State the Enlightenment's central challenge to inherited doctrinal authority in its own strongest form, not as a caricature of shallow rationalism.
  • Explain what Friedrich Schleiermacher meant by grounding theology in the "feeling of absolute dependence," and why that move counted as a genuine alternative foundation for doctrine rather than merely an attack on it.
  • Trace what nineteenth-century liberal Protestant theology, working from Schleiermacher's method, did to the doctrine of the atonement — specifically the rise of moral-influence and moral-example readings of the cross, and their relationship to the models chapter 3 already traced.
  • Explain why this lecture's account of "liberal theology" is a description of a specific historical method with a specific history, not a slur, and why serious theologians on more than one side of later disputes have claimed or rejected the label for different reasons.
The challenge

A different kind of pressure

Earlier controversies disputed a reading of Scripture, a reading of grace, or which authority interprets an agreed deposit of revelation. The Enlightenment asked why any inherited authority should still bind a rational person's belief at all. At its strongest, it said a claim is credible in proportion to the evidence an honest inquirer could verify. A claim's age, its institutional backing, or the number who have always believed it are not evidence by themselves.

Key idea It contested the kind of reason a conclusion may rest on, not a conclusion.
Kant

Reason limited to possible experience

In the Critique of Pure Reason (1781), Kant argued that reason's competence is limited to possible experience. Traditional metaphysical arguments for God and the soul therefore cannot deliver the certain knowledge they claim. Kant did not conclude that religion was worthless, and in 1793 he relocated its ground to practical, moral reason. Doctrines resting on claimed historical revelation, such as the incarnation and the resurrection, then looked uncertifiable to a generation of students trained on him.

Key idea Many serious, believing theologians took this challenge seriously.
Schleiermacher

The feeling of absolute dependence

Schleiermacher's On Religion (1799) told educated skeptics that they had misidentified what religion is. It is neither a set of metaphysical claims nor a moral code, but a distinct, immediate awareness of one's total dependence on something beyond oneself. In The Christian Faith he built a doctrinal system outward from this starting point. Doctrines became descriptions of the Christian shape this feeling takes once Jesus Christ, with his unclouded God-consciousness, has awakened it.

Key idea He believed he had found the one ground the challenge could not touch.
At a glance

Three objective models of the cross

Ransom or Christus Victor

Christ's death and resurrection are a decisive victory over sin, death and the powers that held humanity captive.

Satisfaction (Anselm)

Sin incurs a debt of honour to God that only a God-man can adequately pay.

Penal substitution

Christ bore the actual legal penalty for sin in the sinner's place.

The atonement

The moral-influence account

Liberal Protestant theology, from a medieval precedent in Abelard through Ritschl and Rashdall, developed a different account. The cross saves by revealing, with unmatched clarity, the depth of God's love for sinful humanity, and its effect is the changed heart of those who behold it. Its supporters regarded debt, honour and legal penalty as categories borrowed from law courts and feudal structures. All three objective models share the claim that something actually changes between God and humanity independent of any individual's response.

Key idea On Schleiermacher's terms the shift follows naturally from his method.
Fair assessment

Its strongest case and its cost

Many liberal theologians found penal substitution's picture of a Father who must be legally satisfied before he can forgive hard to reconcile with God's free, prior initiative in love. They could point to texts such as 1 John 4:9-10 that a purely transactional reading can seem to underread. The standard criticism is that a purely moral-influence account struggles to explain why the cross specifically would be necessary, rather than any sufficiently moving act of sacrificial love. The lecture does not resolve this, since chapter 3 did not adjudicate among the objective models either.

Key idea Liberal names a specific historical method, not a slur.
Scripture

Why Romans 1:19-20?

The lecture uses it as Paul's claim about natural knowledge of God. It says the Enlightenment and Schleiermacher each go further than the text itself does, in different directions.

For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made, even his everlasting power and divinity; that they may be without excuse." Romans 1:19-20 · World English Bible
Think about it

Does feeling escape the challenge?

Schleiermacher believed an appeal to immediate religious feeling gave doctrine a ground the Enlightenment challenge could not touch.

Does an appeal to immediate religious feeling actually escape that challenge, or does it just relocate the same evidentiary question to a different kind of claim?

One card to remember

If you remember nothing else

Schleiermacher moved doctrine's ground from revealed authority to religious self-consciousness, and the moral-influence view of the cross follows naturally from that method. The lecture does not say these theologians abandoned faith, and it does not choose among atonement models. Answer honest doubters by stating their challenge in its strongest form first, and treat the word liberal as a description of a method.

That is the outline, not the lecture.

These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.

Read the full lecture →

1 / 12