Lecture 6-1: Violence and Conquest — the Uncomfortable Texts
Contents 36
- Lecture 1-1: Scripture Is a Library, Not a Single Book
- Lecture 1-2: One Story Across Sixty-Six Books
- Lecture 1-3: Word of God, Words of Men, and a Translation
- Lecture 1-4: Why Most Attempts Stall in Leviticus
- Lecture 1-5: Genesis 1, Read Like It's the First Time
- Lecture 2-1: Hagah and Siach — What Scripture Means by Meditation
- Lecture 2-2: Meditation Is Not Emptying the Mind
- Lecture 2-3: A History of Meditation — From Lectio Divina to Modern Devotionals
- Lecture 2-4: The Four Movements of Meditation
- Lecture 2-5: A Simple Fifteen-Minute Frame
- Lecture 2-6: Thirty Minutes in Psalm 1
- Lecture 3-1: Observation — What Is Actually There
- Lecture 3-2: Interpretation — What the Author Meant
- Lecture 3-3: Application — What It Asks of Me
- Lecture 3-4: Avoiding Misapplication
- Lecture 3-5: Keeping a Notebook — The Practice of Margins
- Lecture 3-6: Mark 2, Start to Finish
- Lecture 4-1: Reading Narrative — Divine Action, Not a Model to Imitate
- Lecture 4-2: Reading Law
- Lecture 4-3: Reading the Prophets
- Lecture 4-4: Reading the Poetic Books — the Language of Emotion
- Lecture 4-5: Reading Gospels, Epistles, and Apocalyptic
- Lecture 4-6: One Theme Through Four Genres
- Lecture 5-1: Two Wheels — Meditation and Reading Through the Whole Bible
- Lecture 5-2: Choosing a Plan — 90 Days, One Year, Three Years
- Lecture 5-3: The Skill of Four Chapters a Day
- Lecture 5-4: Falling Behind — The Rules of Recovery
- Lecture 5-5: Genealogies, Sacrificial Law, and Numbers — Getting Through the Boring Parts
- Lecture 5-6: Build Your Own One-Year Reading Plan
Sooner or later, a reader working through the whole Bible reaches a passage that stops them cold. Joshua's armies take a city and leave nothing breathing. A psalmist asks God to smash an enemy's infants against the rocks. These are not obscure footnotes — they sit in the same books that give us the Exodus and the Psalter's songs of praise, and a reading practice that pretends they aren't there, or skips past them quickly and changes the subject, has not actually finished the job this course set out to do. This lecture does not offer a single tidy resolution, because none of the fair ones agree with each other. It offers a way to stay honest in front of the hardest texts in Scripture without either explaining them away or walking away from the book that contains them.
What these 14 minutes give you
- State why questioning a hard text can itself be a biblical posture rather than a lapse of faith, using Genesis 18:25 as the model.
- Summarize at least two named scholarly approaches to the conquest narratives and the imprecatory psalms, fairly, in each approach's own terms.
- Explain what an imprecatory psalm is and why Psalm 137:9 in particular is treated as one of the hardest verses in the Psalter.
- Identify why this is a place where thoughtful, faithful readers land differently, rather than a settled question with one correct answer.
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways," says Yahweh. — Isaiah 55:8
World English Bible
Be it far from you to do things like that, to kill the righteous with the wicked, so that the righteous should be like the wicked. May that be far from you. Shouldn't the Judge of all the earth do right?" — Genesis 18:25
WEB
Happy shall he be, who takes and dashes your little ones against the rock." — Psalm 137:9
WEB
Look closely at what Abraham is doing in Genesis 18:25. He is not accepting God's plan for Sodom in silence out of pious deference. He is pressing God directly — twice in that single verse, once as a flat statement ("may that be far from you") and once as a real question ("shouldn't the Judge of all the earth do right?"). Scripture records this not as a rebuke of Abraham for daring to ask, but as the opening move in an actual negotiation that continues for the rest of the chapter, with God answering each round. The pattern set here matters for this whole lecture: pressing God with a hard question about justice, out loud and by name, is itself something the Bible shows a person faithful to God doing.
1. Two kinds of hard text, one honest posture
This lecture holds two different kinds of difficulty side by side, and it is worth naming the difference before going further. The conquest narratives (Joshua's campaigns against the cities of Canaan, and the herem or "devotion to destruction" commands behind some of them) are difficulties in the biblical story — God is reported as directing or approving specific acts of warfare. The imprecatory psalms (prayers that call down disaster or violence on an enemy, of which Psalm 137:9 is the starkest example) are difficulties in biblical prayer — a worshiper, not God, is the one asking for violence. They raise related but distinct questions, and a fair treatment does not blur them into one problem with one answer.
What they share is this: both are the kind of text that a reader who has only skimmed a devotional highlight reel of the Bible has never had to sit with, and both produce the same instinct — flip past it, or read it very fast, or quietly decide it must not really mean what it says. This lecture asks for a different first move: read it slowly, admit plainly that it is hard, and then bring real scholarship to it rather than either private manufacture of an answer or private avoidance of the question.
2. The conquest narratives — two named approaches, held fairly
This is a point where readers will not agree. Faithful, careful readers of the conquest narratives land in more than one place, and this lecture will present two of the more prominent named approaches rather than pretend the matter is settled.
The divine-accommodation-to-a-specific-historical-judgment reading. On this approach, associated with scholars in the tradition of writers like Paul Copan (Is God a Moral Monster?) and, from a different angle, the "sliding scale" reading offered by William Webb, the conquest commands are read as directed at a specific ancient culture at a specific historical moment, described in the text itself as already under judgment for entrenched practices — including child sacrifice — that the surrounding narrative treats as the actual grounds for judgment (see, for instance, the language of the land "vomiting out" its inhabitants for their practices, used earlier in Leviticus 18:24-25). On this reading, the conquest texts describe a bounded act of judgment tied to particular people and a particular time, not a standing pattern for how God's people are meant to treat outsiders in every era — a claim these same interpreters point out the rest of Scripture, including the strong protections in the itself for the foreigner living among Israel, does not support as a general rule.
The canonical-trajectory-toward-Christ's-fulfillment reading. On this approach, associated with scholars working in a whole-Bible or "redemptive movement" hermeneutic — a lens close to what shaped Chapter 1's argument for reading Scripture as one unfolding story rather than sixty-six isolated units — the conquest narratives are read primarily as an early, provisional chapter in a story whose trajectory bends toward the New Testament's explicit refusal of holy war as a means of advancing God's kingdom (see Matthew 26:52, "all those who take the sword will die by the sword," and Ephesians 6:12, which relocates the church's real conflict to "against the spiritual forces of wickedness," not flesh and blood). On this reading, the conquest is not the Bible's final word on how God's people relate to those outside the ; it is one point on a trajectory whose destination is Christ's own explicit rejection of the sword as the church's weapon, and the Old Testament text is read in light of where that trajectory arrives, not detached from it.
These two approaches disagree about how much weight to place on the conquest narratives' original historical particularity versus their place in Scripture's larger arc, and a serious reader should recognize both as attempts by faithful scholars to take the text seriously rather than dismiss it — neither approach denies that the text says what it says, and neither treats the difficulty as something to be argued away rather than faced.
3. The imprecatory psalms — praying the anger out loud instead of acting on it
Psalm 137:9 has to be read inside the whole psalm, not lifted out of it. The psalm opens with exiles weeping by the rivers of Babylon, remembering Zion, unable to sing "the songs of Zion" for their captors' entertainment (Psalm 137:1-3). It is the psalm of a conquered, displaced, grieving people, and verse 9 is the raw edge of that grief turned toward the empire that did the conquering — not a policy proposal, and not a claim that the psalmist personally intends to act on it.
What matters practically for a modern reader is this: the psalm is a prayer, addressed to God, not an instruction to the reader to go and do likewise. Scripture includes it as an example of bringing the very worst of what a person feels — including a desire for violent vengeance a reader may be ashamed even to admit to feeling — into speech directed at God rather than into private plotting or public action. That the Bible records this prayer without editing it into something gentler is itself notable: it shows a God who receives the full, ugly truth of what a devastated people actually felt, rather than only the sanitized version they might have offered if they thought they were being watched.
4. What this lecture is not arguing
This lecture is not arguing that the difficulty disappears once explained, and it is not handing over one tidy resolution as though the matter were closed by the end of this page. It is arguing that two things can be true at once: Scripture can contain the hardest texts believers have to read, and a reader can hold onto both scholarly honesty and confidence in the character of God revealed elsewhere in the same book — supremely in Christ, who forgave his executioners from the cross (Luke 23:34) — while still admitting Isaiah 55:8 as the honest limit on how fully a finite reader will resolve every one of God's ways.
Diagram 1. Two kinds of hard text, two named approaches
In short
- Genesis 18:25 shows Abraham pressing God with a direct question about justice, modeling that questioning a hard text can be a faithful posture, not a lapse of faith.
- The conquest narratives and the imprecatory psalms are two distinct kinds of hard text — one a difficulty in the story, one a difficulty in prayer — and should not be collapsed into a single question.
- Faithful readers disagree on how to weigh the conquest narratives; this lecture named two approaches fairly: divine accommodation to a specific historical judgment, and a canonical trajectory toward Christ's fulfillment.
- Psalm 137:9 must be read inside the whole psalm, as a raw prayer of a grieving, displaced people addressed to God, not a policy the psalmist intends to act on.
- Isaiah 55:8 stands as an honest limit: some difficulty in these texts is not fully resolved by any explanation available to a finite reader.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Genesis 18:25 | Abraham questions God's justice directly - questioning a hard text can itself be a faithful posture. |
| Two named approaches to conquest | Divine accommodation to a specific historical judgment; canonical trajectory toward Christ's fulfillment. |
| Psalm 137:9 | A raw prayer of grief from a conquered, exiled people, addressed to God - not an instruction to the reader. |
| Isaiah 55:8 | "My thoughts are not your thoughts" - an honest limit on how fully these texts resolve for a finite reader. |
★ One sentence to remember Questioning a hard text out loud, to God, is not a failure of faith - it is what Abraham did, and what Scripture kept.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Before this lecture, how did you personally handle a hard text like Joshua's conquest narratives — read past it quickly, avoid the book, or something else?
- Genesis 18:25 shows Abraham questioning God's justice directly. Does it change anything for you to see this modeled as faithful rather than as a lapse?
- The lecture presents two named approaches to the conquest narratives without declaring one the winner. Which one, if either, seems closer to how you would want to think about these texts, and why?
- Psalm 137:9 is a prayer, not an instruction. Does reading it as an honest cry of grief change how uncomfortable the verse feels to you?
- Why do you think Scripture preserves a prayer this raw rather than editing it into something gentler?