FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society

Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation

Contents 31
STEL11E Public Theology: The Church, Politics, Economy and Society
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Public Life?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Faith in the Public Square
  1. Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
  2. Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
  3. Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
  4. Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Politics and Authority
  1. Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
  2. Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
  3. Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
  4. Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Economy and Work
  1. Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
  2. Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
  3. Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
  4. Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
Chapter 4 · Week 4: People and Neighbours
  1. Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
  3. Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
  4. Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Creation, Culture and Civil Society
  1. Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
  2. Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
  3. Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
  4. Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Chapter 6 · Week 6: The Church's Public Witness
  1. Lecture 6-1: Service, Advocacy and Witness
  2. Lecture 6-2: Public Witness in Different Settings
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Virtues of Public Witness
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Map of Where Believers Disagree: Course Synthesis
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Next Step in Public Witness

Jump to the key points ↓

28 min

Week 5 moves from the neighbour beside us to the shared world around us: the earth, culture, the many faiths in one street, and the associations that hold a society together. This lecture begins with the earth. Christians share the earth with people of other faiths and none, and almost everyone agrees that it matters. So creation care is a place where Christian witness can be both honest and humble. It is also a place where one word, dominion, has been argued over for a long time.

The lecture does three things. It reads what Genesis and the Psalms say about the earth. It describes how Catholic, Orthodox, evangelical and Reformed writers have spoken about creation, each in its own terms. And it sets out the argument between those who read the human calling mainly as dominion and those who read it mainly as care. It gives theological arguments only. It does not tell you what any government, company or household should do, and it does not settle questions that belong to science or to public policy.

What these 28 minutes give you

  • Say what Genesis 1:28, Genesis 2:15 and Psalm 24:1 each say, and keep what the text says apart from what traditions have drawn from it.
  • Describe in plain terms how Catholic, Orthodox, evangelical and Reformed writers have spoken about creation.
  • State the argument between dominion and care fairly, with the strength and the weak point of each reading.
  • Explain why creation care can be a place of shared witness with neighbours who do not share our faith.
  • Name the line between witness and domination as it applies to talk about the earth.

God blessed them. God said to them, “Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it. Have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the sky, and over every living thing that moves on the earth.”" — Genesis 1:28

World English Bible

Yahweh God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to cultivate and keep it." — Genesis 2:15

WEB

The earth is Yahweh’s, with its fullness; the world, and those who dwell therein." — Psalm 24:1

WEB

What the text says. In Genesis 1:28 God blesses the first humans and tells them to be fruitful, to fill the earth, to subdue it and to have dominion over the living things. In Genesis 2:15 the man is put in the garden to cultivate and keep it. In Psalm 24:1 the earth and everything in it belongs to Yahweh. The three passages come from different parts of Scripture and speak in different ways: one gives a blessing and a task, one a task inside a garden, one a statement of ownership.

A tradition's reading. Many Christians read these three together: the earth is God's, humans are given a place and a task inside it, and the task is to serve and guard as well as to use. Some readers put more weight on Genesis 1:28 and read it as a to develop the world and to make something of it. Others put more weight on Genesis 2:15 and Psalm 24:1 and read the calling as care for what is not ours. Many hold both and disagree about the balance.

Our judgement. The verses do not give a policy, a law or a list of duties, and no single verse decides the argument between dominion and care. What they give is a frame: the earth is a gift that belongs to God, and human beings are held to account for how they live in it. How that frame is applied to a particular river, field, forest or city is a further question, and it needs knowledge that Scripture does not supply.

1. Why the earth comes first

Weeks 2 to 4 asked how Christians stand toward authority, wealth and the neighbour. Week 5 asks how they stand toward the public world they share: the earth, culture, the many faiths of a plural society, and the groups that fill the space between a family and a state. The central claim of the course is that the church is called out of the world and sent for the world. The earth is the most basic part of the world to which the church is sent. People of every faith and of none eat from the same soil and drink from the same water. So this lecture asks what Christians have said, from their own sources, about a place that is shared with everyone.

The question also tests the line this week is built on, the line between witness and domination. Witness is speaking and living what we believe in a way others can see and weigh. Domination is using power, pressure or contempt to make others follow. A church can slip from one to the other even when the subject is as gentle as a garden. We shall come back to that at the end.

2. What Genesis and the Psalms say

Start with the text, as we do each week.

The first chapter of Genesis tells of creation in days, and after each stage God sees that it is good. At the end of the sixth day the text says that God saw everything that had been made, and it was very good.

"God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good. There was evening and there was morning, a sixth day." — Genesis 1:31 (WEB)

Notice the order. Before humans receive any task, the world is already called good by God. Its goodness is not given to it by human use. This is one reason many traditions say that creation has value to God apart from its usefulness to us.

Genesis 1:26-28 then says that human beings are made in God's image and are given dominion. The Hebrew verb that stands behind "have dominion" is radah, and the verb behind "subdue" is kabash. Both can describe rule, and kabash can carry a sense of force. Scholars and translators have discussed these words for a long time, and they do not all agree on how strong the words are or on how far Genesis 1 should be heard beside Genesis 2. What can be said with confidence is that the verses speak of human rule over living creatures, and that the same chapter has just said that humans are made in God's image. Many readers therefore ask what kind of rule an image-bearer of that God would practise.

Genesis 2:15 uses two other verbs. The first, avad, is commonly translated "cultivate" or "work", and in other places it can mean "serve". The second, shamar, is commonly translated "keep", and in other places it means "guard" or "watch over". The man is put in the garden to work it and to guard it. A garden is not a wild place and not a finished place. It is a place that needs human hands, and it is a place that can be damaged by them.

Psalm 24:1 is short and says something the other two do not: the earth is Yahweh's. Humans work in it and keep it, but they do not own it in the final sense. A tenant who keeps a house well and a tenant who wrecks it are both tenants, and the owner has a view about each. Psalm 104 also looks at the earth with delight. It speaks of the many works of God, all made in wisdom, and of an earth that is full of God's riches.

"Yahweh, how many are your works! In wisdom have you made them all. The earth is full of your riches." — Psalm 104:24 (WEB)

The New Testament adds one more strand. Paul speaks of creation as waiting. The creation, he says, was subjected to something that is not its own choice, and it hopes to be set free.

"For the creation waits with eager expectation for the children of God to be revealed. For the creation was subjected to vanity, not of its own will, but because of him who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself also will be delivered from the bondage of decay into the liberty of the glory of the children of God." — Romans 8:19-21 (WEB)

What this passage says is that creation is caught up in the story of redemption and does not sit outside it. What traditions draw from it varies: some hear that the non-human world will be renewed along with human beings and so that care for it is a kind of sign of hope; some caution that the passage is about the future that God brings and does not by itself instruct us about how to manage the present. Both readers agree that Paul does not describe creation as a stage prop.

3. How the traditions speak about creation

The traditions below are described in the way they describe themselves, and the descriptions are short on purpose. No one tradition has said all of this, and none is the model.

Catholic writing. Catholic teaching treats creation as a gift from God to all, and it ties care for creation to care for the poor and to the dignity of the human person. This is why it is joined with the idea you met in Week 3, that the goods of the earth are meant for all people. A papal letter of 2015, Laudato Si' (the title is the opening words of a song in praise of creatures; the subtitle speaks of the earth as a shared home), is a widely read recent example of this tradition speaking at length about the earth. The tradition also looks back to Francis of Assisi, in the thirteenth century, whose song of praise names the sun, the moon, water and fire as brothers and sisters in praise of the Creator. People inside and outside the Catholic Church have read the 2015 letter in different ways, and this course does not ask you to judge it.

Orthodox writing. Orthodox Christians often speak of creation through worship. Matter is not an enemy of the spirit; God made it, and in the the Word took flesh. In the bread, wine, oil and water are taken up and offered back to God in thanks. Some Orthodox writers describe the human calling as that of a priest of creation, one who receives the world as gift and gives thanks for it on its behalf. Basil of Caesarea, in the fourth century, preached a series of sermons on the days of creation that Orthodox, Catholic and many Protestant readers still read. Some Orthodox churches also keep 1 September as a day for prayer for creation. We state this as a general description and do not claim that every Orthodox community speaks in the same way.

Evangelical writing. Evangelical Christians are a large and varied group, and no one voice speaks for all. Many stress that creation is God's work and that care for it is a form of obedience and love of neighbour. A common phrase is creation care. Some evangelical writers emphasise , the idea that humans manage something that belongs to God. Others are wary of language that seems to treat nature as sacred in itself, because they hold that only God is to be worshipped, and they want to keep the worship of the Creator clear of the worship of what is made. Others again stress that human needs, especially those of the poor, must stay in view. These are differences of emphasis and sometimes of conviction, and an evangelical congregation may hold all of them in one room.

Reformed writing. The Reformed tradition, following John Calvin in the sixteenth century, often speaks of the created world as a place where God's glory can be seen, a kind of stage on which God's work is shown. Later Reformed writers, including Abraham Kuyper, speak of the , the idea that Genesis 1:28 gives humans a task of developing the world: tilling, building, making. For them the task is real and good, and it is to be done under the rule of Christ and not for ourselves. So the Reformed stress is often on both: a creation that belongs to God and a calling to work inside it. Reformed readers also differ among themselves on how this applies.

Others. Pentecostal and charismatic communities have a wide range of views. Some point to the Spirit hovering over the waters in Genesis 1 and speak of the Spirit's work in all creation. Others turn more to the expected renewal of all things. Communities that live close to the land, such as farmers, fishers and herders in many regions, often say that they learned care for creation from the work itself, and they sometimes find books on the subject odd, since to them it is ordinary life. (An invented example.) An in a farming village might say that her church does not have a "creation care programme", because every family already knows which fields are resting and which stream must not be fouled, and that this is simply what a Christian neighbour does.

Notice what these descriptions have in common. None of them says that creation is a machine for human use alone, and none says that creation is God. Each says in its own way that the earth is God's, that humans have a place and a task, and that they will be asked how they filled it.

4. Dominion and care

This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement is about how to read the human calling in Genesis 1:28 and 2:15.

One reading holds that dominion is the main word. On this view human beings are different from other creatures: only they bear God's image and are given rule. The strength of this view is that it takes the text's own word seriously, and it protects the special place of human beings. It guards against a way of thinking in which a human life counts for no more than any other organism, and against any teaching that treats the earth as a god. Its weak point is that dominion has been used to excuse harm, and its critics ask how a rule that damages the thing ruled can be the rule of an image-bearer of God. A second reading holds that care is the main word. On this view the calling is to serve and guard, and dominion is a kind of kingship that follows the pattern of a God who serves. The strength of this view is that it joins Genesis 1 to Genesis 2 and to Psalm 24, and it matches the many passages in which creatures praise God and are cared for by God. Its weak point is that critics ask whether it can slide into treating human needs, especially the needs of the poor, as smaller than they are, and whether the language of service is stretched to cover a view the text does not state.

A third reading holds that both words are needed and that the real question is what to do when they pull apart: when a good use of land, water or animals for human flourishing seems to cost the flourishing of other creatures. The strength of this view is its honesty about a real tension. Its weak point is that it can leave a reader without an answer, and different people who hold it will give different answers in different cases.

This course does not ask you to choose among these. It asks that you can state each fairly, say what each protects, and say where each is weak. It also asks you to notice that none of the three says that creation is of no account to God.

5. A historical argument and the replies

In 1967 a historian, Lynn White Jr., published an essay arguing that ideas of human dominion in Western Christianity helped to shape attitudes that lie behind later damage to the earth. The essay was widely read and widely answered. Some Christian writers accepted part of it and said that the churches had indeed too often heard Genesis 1:28 and not Genesis 2:15. Others replied that the argument over-simplified a long history, that other factors were at work, and that the same traditions had also produced voices of care, such as those named above. Historians and theologians still discuss it. For this lecture the point is only that the question is old and serious, and that fair people have answered it in different ways.

6. A worked example

(An invented example.) A congregation in a small town owns a piece of land behind its building. For years it has been a car park and a patch of grass. A member suggests that it be used for a community garden. Another suggests keeping the car park, because older members find walking difficult. A third suggests selling part of it to fund a food programme. A fourth says the land should be left alone as a place of quiet.

Here is what theological questions can and cannot do.

They can help the congregation ask: Whose land is this, and what do we owe the One who gave it? (Psalm 24:1). What does it mean to keep it well? (Genesis 2:15). Who is not in the room, such as the older members, the neighbours, the poor, the children who will inherit it? They can help the church give thanks for the land, and be honest about its own motives.

They cannot say which of the four proposals is correct. That depends on money, local law, soil, the needs of the people and what the neighbours want. Two faithful congregations might make different choices. A church that says "Genesis 2:15 requires a garden" has asked a verse to settle a question the verse does not settle.

7. Where witness can become domination

We began with the line between witness and domination, and here is how it applies.

Creation care is a place where Christians share concerns with many neighbours: people of other faiths, people of no faith, and people who describe the matter in very different words. That is a gift. It means a church can work beside others without first agreeing about everything. Witness here looks like honest work, humility about how little any one group knows, and a willingness to say why a Christian cares and to listen to why others do.

Domination can enter in several ways. It can happen when a church treats care for the earth as a test of whether someone is a real Christian, and so makes a verdict on a person's faith out of a disagreement about a practical question. It can happen when a church speaks about those who disagree with contempt, as if only the foolish or the wicked could hold another view. And it can happen when a church claims that its own view is the only Christian one, and so silences the believers who read Genesis differently. The course asks you to avoid all three. Doubt about a policy question is not unbelief, and a person's view on how to live on the earth is not a measure of their devotion to God.

A last caution. This lecture has said nothing about environmental science, because the course does not teach it, and nothing about what any government should do. A Christian may take careful advice from people who have studied these questions, in the same way as on any other question that needs knowledge, and follow local law and the written rules of their community where they apply.


Diagram 1. Three texts, three emphases

Dominion and care: three texts, three emphases The text, what traditions have drawn, and the weak point of each reading Genesis 1:28 Blessing, task, dominion. Stresses: the human place and the calling to develop the world. Weak: dominion has been used to excuse harm. Genesis 2:15 Cultivate and keep the garden. Stresses: service and guarding; a task inside a given place. Weak: may shrink human needs, especially the needs of the poor. Psalm 24:1 The earth is Yahweh's. Stresses: God owns; humans are held to account. Weak: it gives no method for a particular field or river. Both words together Many readers hold dominion and care together and ask what a rule that images a serving God would look like. They differ on what to do when the two pull apart. Witness, not domination No verse settles a local choice. Do not make a view about the earth a test of another person's faith, and do not speak of those who differ with contempt.

In short

  • Genesis 1:28, Genesis 2:15 and Psalm 24:1 give a frame: the earth is God's, and humans have a task in it.
  • Dominion and care are both words of the text; readers differ on the balance and on what to do when they pull apart.
  • Catholic, Orthodox, evangelical and Reformed traditions each speak of creation in their own terms; none says that creation is God or only a tool.
  • Theological questions help a church ask what it owes and who is not heard; they do not decide a local choice.
  • Creation care can be shared witness with neighbours of other faiths and none.
  • Witness turns into domination when a view about the earth becomes a test of another person's faith.
Front Back
Genesis 1:28 and 2:15 One gives blessing and dominion; the other gives cultivating and keeping. Readers weigh them differently.
Psalm 24:1 The earth is Yahweh's; humans work in it and are held to account for how.
Dominion or care Dominion protects the human place but has been used to excuse harm; care joins the texts but may shrink human needs. Many hold both.
Witness and domination Witness speaks and lives its faith openly and humbly; domination makes a view about the earth a test of faith or treats others with contempt.

One sentence to remember The earth is God's, we have a task in it, and we may speak about that task without turning a disagreement into a verdict on someone's faith.

This week's action Choose one place you use daily (a field, a street, a kitchen, a workplace) and ask of it the three questions: whose is it, how do I keep it, and who is not in the room.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What is the difference between what Genesis 2:15 says and what a tradition draws from it? Give one example of each from this lecture.
  • Choose one of the traditions described (Catholic, Orthodox, evangelical, Reformed). How does it join creation to something else, such as worship, the poor or the cultural mandate?
  • State the dominion reading and the care reading in their strongest forms. Where is each weak?
  • In the invented example of the land behind the church, which two questions from the lecture would you ask first? Why can no verse settle the choice?
  • How can a church work with neighbours who do not share its faith on a question about the earth, without moving from witness to domination?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.