FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM201E Leading a Small Group Well

Lecture 3-1: Open Questions and Closed Questions

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 29
LM201E Leading a Small Group Well
Chapter 0 · Introduction: The Room That Does the Work
  1. Lecture 0: The Room That Does the Work
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: What a Small Group Is For
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Crowd Cannot Do
  2. Lecture 1-2: Host and Shepherd, Not Resident Expert
  3. Lecture 1-3: Covenant and Size — the Unglamorous Infrastructure
  4. Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab — Diagnose Your Group
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Designing a Gathering
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Anatomy of a Gathering
  2. Lecture 2-2: Opening Well
  3. Lecture 2-3: Closing Well and Following Through
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab — Build a Session Plan
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: Facilitating Discussion
  1. Lecture 3-1: Open Questions and Closed Questions
  2. Lecture 3-2: Silence and the Quiet Member
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Dominant Talker and the Tangent
  4. Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab — Rewriting Questions and Planning Your Moves
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Reading Scripture Together
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Inductive Method — Seeing Before Concluding
  2. Lecture 4-2: Prepared, Not Performing
  3. Lecture 4-3: Sitting With a Hard Text
  4. Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab — Build a Full Inductive Study
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Prayer and Pastoral Care
  1. Lecture 5-1: Praying Together, and What Confidentiality Actually Means
  2. Lecture 5-2: Noticing, and Following Up Without Becoming Surveillance
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Leader's Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab — A Disclosure You Did Not See Coming
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Conflict and Difficult Group Dynamics
  1. Lecture 6-1: Naming the Kind of Conflict You Actually Have
  2. Lecture 6-2: Difficult Personalities, Named Fairly
  3. Lecture 6-3: When and How to Escalate
  4. Lecture 6-4: Practice Lab — A Live, Escalating Conflict
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Multiplying Leadership
  1. Lecture 7-1: Apprenticing a Co-Leader
  2. Lecture 7-2: Healthy Versus Unhealthy Reasons to Split a Group
  3. Lecture 7-3: Sending Off Well
  4. Lecture 7-4: Practice Lab — Drafting a 90-Day Apprenticeship Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

15 min

Ask a group "Was Peter afraid when he denied Jesus?" and you will get one of two responses. Most people will say "yes" and stop talking, because the question only has one honest answer and it has already been supplied inside the question itself. A very few will try to say more, guess that you wanted something deeper, and end up performing thoughtfulness rather than actually thinking. Either way, the question has done almost no work. Ask instead, "What do you think was going through Peter's mind in that courtyard?" and the room has something to actually do — notice details, disagree with each other, revise a first guess out loud.

The difference between those two questions is not politeness or style. It is structure. A closed question supplies its own answer and only asks the group to retrieve it; an open question hands the group a real space to reason inside. This lecture gives you the vocabulary and the habit of ear needed to tell the two apart on sight, because a leader who cannot hear the difference in their own mouth will keep asking closed questions while believing they are running a discussion.

What these 15 minutes give you

  • Define an open question and a closed question, and explain what makes a question "leading" as a separate defect from being merely closed.
  • Rewrite a closed or leading question into an open one, using the before/after method this lecture demonstrates.
  • Explain, using Malcolm Knowles' concept of andragogy, why adult learners in particular are underserved by lecture-style, closed-question teaching.
  • State why a room full of closed questions produces "a lecture with extra steps" rather than a discussion.

Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out.

Proverbs 20:5 (World English Bible):

1. Three kinds of question, not two

It helps to separate three things that get lumped together under "bad question": closed questions, leading questions, and — the one that looks like a virtue and usually isn't — the question with only one acceptable answer dressed up as open.

A closed question asks for a fact, a yes/no, or a single recall item. "Did Jesus heal the blind man in John 9?" "How many disciples were there?" These have their place — checking that everyone has the same facts in front of them before discussing what those facts mean — but a meeting built mostly out of them will feel like a quiz, not a conversation, because there is exactly one correct thing to say and everyone knows it.

A leading question is worse, because it disguises an answer as a question. "Don't you think it's clear that Jesus is showing us we need more faith here?" is not really a question at all; it is a conclusion wearing a question mark, and it invites agreement rather than thought. Group members are usually polite enough to supply the agreement asked for, which can look like a successful discussion to a leader who isn't listening carefully to what just happened: nobody actually thought anything through, they simply confirmed what the leader had already decided to say.

Open in name only

A falsely open question is the subtlest failure and the one experienced leaders still make. "What do you think this passage teaches us?" sounds wide open. In practice, if the leader has one specific lesson in mind and will steer, correct, or wait out every answer until someone lands on it, the question was never actually open — it was a guessing game with the leader as the answer key, and the group will eventually learn to play along rather than actually explore.

A genuinely open question invites real variation in the answer, and the leader means it. "What do you notice in this passage that surprises you?" "What would you have done if you were in Peter's position?" "Where do you see yourself in this story?" There is no single correct response the leader is withholding. Different group members can answer honestly and differently, and the leader's job is to receive what actually comes rather than to fish until the pre-written answer surfaces.

2. The observation/interpretation test

A simple diagnostic, useful in the moment a question is forming in your mind: does it ask what is there, or does it ask what it means, before the group has had a chance to look? "What do you notice about how many times this chapter repeats the word 'remember'?" is an observation question — it points attention at the text and lets the group discover something for itself. "What does this chapter teach us about spiritual amnesia?" skips straight to a conclusion, and unless the group has already done the noticing, the question is really asking them to guess the leader's interpretation rather than form their own. Proverbs 20:5 puts the underlying logic plainly: "Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out" (World English Bible). The water — the actual thought, insight, or hesitation sitting in a group member's mind — is already there. A closed or leading question does not draw it out; it only checks whether the member can recite what the leader already poured in. Drawing it out takes patience and a question shaped to invite it, not supply it.

3. Before and after: four rewrites

Concrete pairs make the difference easier to hear than any definition does.

  • Before: "Wasn't it wrong of the Pharisees to criticize Jesus for healing on the Sabbath?" — a leading question; the verdict is built in. After: "What do you think the Pharisees were actually worried about when they objected to Jesus healing on the Sabbath?" — invites the group to reconstruct a real position rather than simply condemn a strawman.

  • Before: "Did the prodigal son do the right thing by coming home?" — closed; yes/no with an obvious expected answer. After: "What do you imagine the son was thinking on the road back, before he knew how his father would react?" — opens a real, answerable-in-different-ways question.

  • Before: "What's the main lesson we should take from this parable?" — falsely open if the leader has one lesson already decided. After: "What in this parable stood out to you, and why?" followed later by "What do you think the parable is asking of its first hearers?" — genuinely open, and sequenced from observation toward interpretation rather than jumping straight to the leader's conclusion.

  • Before: "Do you agree that forgiveness is always required, no matter what?" — leading, and forces a position before the group has explored the actual difficulty. After: "What makes forgiveness hard in a situation like this one? Where have you seen it work, or not work?" — invites real, varied, honest answers, including ones that push back.

Notice what the "after" versions have in common: none of them are vaguer or softer than the "before" versions. They are not asking less of the group. They are asking a different, harder thing of the group — to actually think rather than to guess correctly — which is exactly the point.

4. Why adults in particular need this

Malcolm Knowles, writing on , argued that adults learn differently from children in ways that matter directly here. His concept of andragogy holds that adult learners come to a room already carrying real experience, want to connect new material to problems and situations they already recognize as theirs, and resist being treated as an empty container to be filled by an authority who already has the answer. A style of teaching built for a classroom of children being introduced to a subject for the first time — deliver the content, then check for recall — treats adults the same way, and adults notice. It is one reason a small-group meeting that is really a lecture in disguise, run entirely on closed and leading questions, produces polite disengagement rather than the reciprocal "one another" learning this course keeps returning to: the format itself is mismatched to who is actually in the room.

This does not mean an adult group needs no input from someone who has done real preparation — Chapter 4 will insist the leader still has to have done real homework before the meeting. It means that homework gets delivered as a question or a prompt that invites the group's own experience and reasoning to engage the text, not as an announcement the group is expected to accept and repeat back.

5. The cost of getting this wrong

A meeting run mostly on closed and leading questions is not merely a little duller than it could be. It is, functionally, a lecture with extra steps: information moves in one direction, from leader to group, and the question-and-answer format only adds the appearance of participation without its substance. Over weeks, a group trained this way stops offering real thoughts, because real thoughts have never actually been asked for — only the correct ones have. The skill this lecture is teaching is not a stylistic preference. It is the difference between a group that is thinking together and a group that is watching one person think out loud.

Four Kinds of Question Closed Asks for a fact or yes/no. "Did Jesus heal the blind man?" Fine for checking facts only. Leading Answer is built into the wording. "Don't you think it's clear that..." Invites agreement, not thought. Falsely Open Sounds open; leader has one answer in mind and steers to it. Becomes a guessing game. Genuinely Open Real variation possible; leader receives it. "What do you notice?" Draws out real thought (Prov 20:5). Only the bottom-right box does what a discussion actually needs.

In short

  • A closed question asks for a fact or yes/no; a leading question hides its answer inside the wording; a falsely open question sounds open but the leader is fishing for one predetermined answer; a genuinely open question invites real variation and the leader means it.
  • Proverbs 20:5 pictures real thought as "deep water" that has to be drawn out, not supplied — the leader's question is the tool that does the drawing.
  • Sequencing observation before interpretation ("what do you notice" before "what does it mean") keeps a question open rather than letting it collapse into the leader's pre-written conclusion.
  • Malcolm Knowles' andragogy holds that adult learners bring real experience and resist being treated as passive recipients, which is why closed, lecture-style teaching underserves them in particular.
  • A meeting run mostly on closed and leading questions is, functionally, a lecture with extra steps, not a discussion.

One-sentence summary: The leader's tool is a genuinely open question that draws out a group member's own thinking rather than a closed or leading question that only asks them to recite or agree with the leader's.

Terms to remember: open question, closed question, leading question, falsely open question, andragogy.

Carry forward to 3-2: this lecture assumed the group will actually answer once asked well. The next lecture deals with what happens when, even after a good question, nobody speaks.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a question you have asked in a group recently. Was it closed, leading, falsely open, or genuinely open? Be honest with yourself before you answer.
  • Proverbs 20:5 compares a person's inner thought to "deep water" that "a man of understanding will draw it out." What does that image suggest about how much patience drawing out a real answer actually takes?
  • Malcolm Knowles argued adults resist being treated as an empty container to be filled. Where have you personally felt talked *at* rather than *with* in a learning setting, religious or otherwise? What did that feel like?
  • Rewrite this closed question into an open one: "Was it right for Abraham to almost sacrifice Isaac?"
  • What is the hardest part, for you personally, of asking a genuinely open question and then actually waiting for whatever answer comes, rather than steering toward the one you had in mind?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.