Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab — Rewriting Questions and Planning Your Moves
Contents 29
- Lecture 1-1: What a Crowd Cannot Do
- Lecture 1-2: Host and Shepherd, Not Resident Expert
- Lecture 1-3: Covenant and Size — the Unglamorous Infrastructure
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab — Diagnose Your Group
- Lecture 2-1: The Anatomy of a Gathering
- Lecture 2-2: Opening Well
- Lecture 2-3: Closing Well and Following Through
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab — Build a Session Plan
- Lecture 3-1: Open Questions and Closed Questions
- Lecture 3-2: Silence and the Quiet Member
- Lecture 3-3: The Dominant Talker and the Tangent
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab — Rewriting Questions and Planning Your Moves
- Lecture 4-1: The Inductive Method — Seeing Before Concluding
- Lecture 4-2: Prepared, Not Performing
- Lecture 4-3: Sitting With a Hard Text
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab — Build a Full Inductive Study
- Lecture 5-1: Praying Together, and What Confidentiality Actually Means
- Lecture 5-2: Noticing, and Following Up Without Becoming Surveillance
- Lecture 5-3: The Leader's Limits
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab — A Disclosure You Did Not See Coming
- Lecture 6-1: Naming the Kind of Conflict You Actually Have
- Lecture 6-2: Difficult Personalities, Named Fairly
- Lecture 6-3: When and How to Escalate
- Lecture 6-4: Practice Lab — A Live, Escalating Conflict
The first three lectures in this chapter gave you the vocabulary — open, closed, leading, falsely open — the discipline of holding silence, and a way to redirect a dominant talker or a tangent without shaming anyone. None of that is useful until it has been practiced on something concrete. This lecture gives you two hands-on exercises: repairing a genuinely bad set of discussion questions, and building a specific, personal plan for the two problems — silence and a dominant voice — as they actually show up in a group you know.
What these 11 minutes give you
- Rewrite five closed, leading, or yes/no discussion questions into genuinely open ones, applying the principles from 3-1.
- Name at least one specific silence-handling technique from 3-2 you will use, tailored to a real group.
- Name at least one specific redirection move from 3-3 you will use, tailored to a real person or pattern you know.
- Produce a short, usable written plan you could actually take into your next meeting.
Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out.
Proverbs 20:5, World English Bible
This Practice Lab draws on the Scripture already given in 3-1 through 3-3 rather than introducing new passages. As a reminder of the anchor text behind this chapter's approach to questions:
Revisit that verse alongside James 1:19 and Proverbs 18:13 as you work through the exercises below.
1. Exercise 1: rewrite a bad set of five
Below are five discussion questions, deliberately written the way a tired or untrained leader actually writes them, for a hypothetical passage: the story of Martha and Mary (Luke 10:38-42), where Martha is distracted by much serving and Mary sits at Jesus' feet listening, and Jesus tells Martha that Mary "has chosen the good part."
- Was Martha wrong to be distracted by her preparations? (closed — yes/no, verdict obvious)
- Don't you think Jesus is clearly telling us that spending time with him matters more than busy service? (leading — the conclusion is built into the question)
- Did Mary make the better choice? (closed — yes/no, and the text's own wording makes the "correct" answer feel obvious)
- What's the main lesson we're supposed to learn from this story? (falsely open — invites the group to guess the leader's one intended takeaway)
- Should we all try to be more like Mary? (closed — yes/no, and moralizes before the group has explored the tension in the story)
Before rewriting, notice what these five questions have in common: every one of them either supplies its own answer or assumes the group already agrees on what the "right" response is, which means none of them actually requires the group to think. Using the before/after method from 3-1 — ask what is there before asking what it means, and make sure a genuinely different honest answer is possible — rewrite all five. A worked example for the first is provided; write your own for the remaining four before checking it against the discussion below.
Worked rewrite
Worked example, question 1: "What do you imagine Martha was feeling as she worked in the kitchen while Mary sat with Jesus? Have you ever felt that way in a moment when you were 'doing the responsible thing' while someone else got to do the thing that felt more meaningful?" This keeps the door open to sympathy for Martha — the text itself does not say her hospitality was wrong, only that she was "anxious and troubled about many things" — rather than assuming from the outset that Martha's choice was simply a mistake.
Write your own open rewrites for questions 2 through 5 now, then compare your instincts against these questions: Does your rewrite supply an answer, or genuinely leave room for more than one honest response? Does it ask the group to notice something in the text before asking what it means? Would two people in your actual group plausibly answer it differently?
2. Exercise 2: your silence-and-redirection plan
Think of a real group you currently lead, have led, or expect to lead soon. Write brief, specific answers to the following, using your own group rather than a hypothetical one:
- Silence. When your group goes quiet after a question, what do you currently tend to do? Which one specific technique from 3-2 — counting to ten, relaxing your gaze, naming the pause out loud, repeating rather than rephrasing — will you commit to trying at your next meeting, and how will you remind yourself in the moment (a note on your Bible, a phrase you say to yourself)?
- The quiet member. Is there a specific person in your group who rarely speaks? If so, what is one thing you know about why — shyness, unfamiliarity with the format, a slower processing pace, something else — and which approach from 3-2 (advance invitation, turn-and-talk, or simply giving them the same unhurried silence as everyone else) fits that specific person best?
- The dominant voice or the tangent. Is there a specific person or pattern in your group that tends to take over, or a topic that tends to pull the group off course? Name it honestly. Which redirection technique from 3-3 will you try first, and write out, word for word, what you would actually say.
- The threshold for a private conversation. If the pattern you just named does not improve after you try your chosen technique for a few weeks, what would tell you it has crossed from "handle it in the room" to "needs a private conversation"? Write the specific sign you will watch for.
3. What this exercise is and is not
This lab is not asking you to solve every group dynamics problem you will ever face. It is asking you to leave this chapter with one rewritten set of questions you can reuse as a model, and one concrete, personal, written plan for the two problems this chapter named — rather than only the general knowledge that silence and dominant talkers are things leaders deal with. A plan written now, before the pressure of the actual moment, is far more likely to survive contact with a real meeting than good intentions formed in the room itself.
In short
- A bad discussion question can nearly always be rewritten by asking what is there before asking what it means, and by checking whether more than one honest answer is genuinely possible.
- A written, specific plan — made in advance, for your real group — is more reliable under pressure than good intentions formed in the moment.
- The threshold for moving a pattern from "handle it in the room" to "needs a private conversation" should be decided ahead of time, not improvised when frustration is already high.
- This lab is a starting model to reuse, not a claim that every group dynamics problem has now been solved.
One-sentence summary: This lab turns the vocabulary and techniques of 3-1 through 3-3 into a rewritten set of questions and a written, personal plan for silence and redirection that you can actually carry into your next meeting.
Terms to remember: (review) open question, holding silence, acknowledge-then-redirect.
Carry forward to Chapter 4: this chapter dealt with how a leader asks and manages a conversation. Chapter 4 turns to what the group is actually reading together, and how to lead people to see a text rather than simply announcing what it means.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the five Martha-and-Mary questions was hardest for you to rewrite, and why?
- Reread your worked plan from Exercise 2. Does the redirect line you wrote sound like something you could actually say out loud, or does it sound better on paper than it would feel in the room?
- What did naming a specific person or pattern honestly, in writing, feel like — easier or harder than you expected?
- If you shared your plan with a co-leader or mentor, what part would you most want their feedback on?
- Looking back across 3-1 through 3-3, which single skill — open questions, holding silence, or redirection — do you think will take the longest for you personally to actually practice well?