FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM405E Serving Together: Volunteers in the Local Church

Lecture 5-2: When a Volunteer Tells You Something Hard

Contents 31
LM405E Serving Together: Volunteers in the Local Church
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Volunteer Is a Person, Not a Pair of Hands
  1. Introduction: A Volunteer Is a Person, Not a Pair of Hands
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Why We Serve
  1. Lecture 1-1: Service as a Response to Grace
  2. Lecture 1-2: Why People Come and Why They Leave
  3. Lecture 1-3: Asking Well
  4. Lecture 1-4: Volunteers, Staff and Clergy
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Why I Began to Serve
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Finding the Right Place
  1. Lecture 2-1: Writing a Role Description
  2. Lecture 2-2: Listening and Matching
  3. Lecture 2-3: Screening and Safeguarding for Roles
  4. Lecture 2-4: Young and Older Volunteers
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Role Description in One Page
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Starting Well
  1. Lecture 3-1: The First Month
  2. Lecture 3-2: Learning Alongside
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Volunteer Handbook
  4. Lecture 3-4: Serving in Worship: Liturgical and Free-Church Roles
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A First-Month Plan
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Working Together
  1. Lecture 4-1: Rotas, Cover and Rest
  2. Lecture 4-2: Communication and Digital Boundaries
  3. Lecture 4-3: Thanks and Recognition
  4. Lecture 4-4: Money, Expenses and Gifts
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, A Thank-You Said Well
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Care and Limits
  1. Lecture 5-1: Recognising Weariness
  2. Lecture 5-2: When a Volunteer Tells You Something Hard
  3. Lecture 5-3: Difficult Conversations and Changing a Role
  4. Lecture 5-4: When Things Go Wrong: Complaints, Misconduct and Concerns
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What to Say to a Weary Volunteer
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Rest and Release
  1. Lecture 6-1: Rest as Structure
  2. Lecture 6-2: Releasing Well
  3. Lecture 6-3: A Serving Culture
  4. Lecture 6-4: Reviewing a Volunteer Programme Without Counting People
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, Review Your Volunteer Programme

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Sooner or later, a volunteer will tell you something heavy. It may come in the car park after the meeting, in the middle of a washing-up, or in a message late at night. The person may speak of a marriage that is failing, a debt, a diagnosis, an old wrong, or a fear. They may say it quickly and look away.

You did not train for this, and you are not required to be trained. But what you do in the next five minutes and the next five days matters a great deal. This lecture gives three moves: listen, keep, pass on. It also names the things a person in your position must not do, and it says plainly where confidence ends.

The lecture does not teach listening skills; they belong to LM205E, Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care. It does not give legal advice; duties to report differ by country and community, and your written policy and local law decide them. It is about the ethic of the person who is trusted with something and is not meant to carry it alone.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Describe the three moves of listen, keep and pass on, and say why what is told is entrusted and not owned.
  • Explain the order in which a confidence is widened, and why consent decides each step.
  • Say, in outline, where confidence has limits, and what to do when danger is immediate.
  • Name five things not to do when a volunteer tells you something hard.

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13

World English Bible

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

WEB

But a certain Samaritan, as he traveled, came where he was. When he saw him, he was moved with compassion, came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him. On the next day, when he departed, he took out two denarii, and gave them to the host, and said to him, ‘Take care of him. Whatever you spend beyond that, I will repay you when I return.’" — Luke 10:33-35

WEB

Proverbs speaks of a person who can be trusted. Paul speaks of burdens that are shared. The Samaritan does something we can copy exactly: he stops, he cares for the immediate need, he brings the man to a place where care can continue, and he arranges for it to be paid. Then he goes on with his journey. He does not take the man home to be his own responsibility for ever.

1. What is told is entrusted, not owned

When a volunteer tells you something hard, they are not giving you information. They are entrusting something to you. The difference matters. Information can be used; something entrusted can only be kept, and returned.

That one idea answers most of the questions that follow. You may not use the story to make a point in a sermon, to explain a person's behaviour to a colleague, or to ask for prayer at the next meeting, without the person's agreement. It does not belong to you. You are its guardian for as long as they wish.

The book of Proverbs puts it bluntly: "One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." Gossip is not only malicious talk. It is also well-meant talk: "I am telling you so that you can pray." Well-meant sharing is the most common way a confidence is broken in a church.

2. Move one: listen

When the person begins, let them. This is the first thing you do and often the only thing that is needed.

  • Stop what you are doing, and if possible move somewhere private where you can be seen but not heard. In a church, a side room with the door open is better than a closed office.
  • Do not hurry them and do not fill the silence.
  • Say little. "Thank you for telling me." "That sounds very hard." "I am listening."
  • Do not make it about you. Not "I went through the same", not "I know exactly".

You are not required to understand it all. You are required to stay in the room. The deeper skills of listening are taught in LM205E; here it is enough to say that listening is already care, and that many people need nothing more than to be heard once by someone who does not flinch.

3. Move two: keep

Keeping means two things: not telling, and not using. Start with a simple rule for the widening of a confidence.

  1. It stays with you first. Not with your spouse, your friend or your co-leader.
  2. Then, if help is needed, the pastor or priest. In many communities this is the natural next person, because the community has given them the care of souls. Even here, tell the volunteer you will do so, and what you will say.
  3. Then a named few, if the person agrees. For example, a small care team, or one person who will give practical help.
  4. It widens beyond that only with the person's consent. And each step needs a fresh yes, not a general permission given once.

(An invented example.) Lucia, who leads the welcome team, tells the coordinator that her husband has lost his job and that they are behind with the rent. The coordinator does not mention it to the council, does not hint at it at the next meeting, and does not tell Lucia's friend on the team. She asks Lucia: "May I tell Father Anselm? I would not tell anyone else. Or would you rather tell him yourself?" Lucia chooses to speak to him herself, and the coordinator offers to go with her. The coordinator also asks if Lucia would like to hear about a community food bank, and does not press when she says not yet.

Prayer requests are the commonest leak. In many communities it is normal to say "please pray for X" in a group. Do not do this with something told to you in confidence, however tenderly it is said. Ask the person: "Would you like me to ask others to pray? What may I say?" If they say no, you can still pray yourself. Prayer in secret breaks no confidence.

A word about traditions. In some communities a priest hears confession under a strict seal, and that is a separate matter from the ordinary conversation of this lecture. A volunteer coordinator is not a confessor, and the seal of the confessional does not extend to a talk in the church hall. Do not say "this is like confession" or imply a protection you cannot give. In other communities, leaders talk freely about what members tell them, and a volunteer may assume that nothing is private. Whatever your community's custom, say clearly at the start what you will and will not do with what you hear.

4. Move three: pass on

You are not meant to carry it alone, and you are not the right person to solve it. The third move is to help the person reach those who can help.

The Samaritan is a model here. He gives first aid: he binds the wounds. Then he brings the man to an inn, where someone else can look after him, and he pays toward the care. He stays long enough to make sure the handover is safe ("Take care of him"), and he promises to return. He notices, he stays, and he passes on.

In practice, passing on might mean:

  • The pastor or priest, for spiritual care, and for a community's own resources.
  • A doctor, for the body.
  • A counsellor or a mental health service.
  • A food bank, a legal aid clinic, a shelter, a debt advice service, according to what the need is.
  • A trusted friend or family member, if the person wants one.

You do not have to know every service in your town. You can say "I do not know, but I will find out and tell you", and then do it. A short, up-to-date list of local help, kept by the congregation and checked each year, saves this task from being done in a panic.

When the person agrees to a step, ask afterwards how it went. Not to check up on them, but because the thing was important to them, and someone who asks later shows that they listened.

5. Five things not to do

Do not diagnose. "It sounds like you are depressed" or "this is the narcissist in your marriage" are claims you cannot make. They may feel clarifying, but they turn a person into a case.

Do not judge. The person has trusted you with the worst of their situation. If you moralise, they will not tell you the next thing, or anyone.

Do not try to solve it. A volunteer who tells you of a marriage in trouble does not need you to repair the marriage. Giving advice about matters you cannot see from the inside often does harm.

Do not promise what you cannot keep. "I will never tell anyone" is a promise you may have to break, and if you break it, the person has been told a lie. Say instead: "I will keep this between us. The one exception is if I fear that you or someone else is in danger. If that happens I will tell you first, as far as I can."

Do not quietly take them out of service. This is the commonest mistake of kind people. "She has enough on her plate, so I will not ask her to read this month" may be a mercy, but if it is done without a word, it is a decision made for the person. They may have wanted to keep serving as one of the few ordinary things in a hard season. Ask: "Would you like to carry on, take a lighter load, or rest for a while? Whatever you choose is all right."

6. Where confidence has limits

Keeping a confidence is a strong duty, but it is not unlimited. In outline, there are three cases where you cannot keep it to yourself.

  1. Danger to life. A person tells you that they intend to end their life or that someone's life is in danger. This is not a matter to hold. If the danger is immediate, call the local emergency number. Stay with the person if it is safe, and do not leave a person at risk alone while you look for help.
  2. Abuse. A person, especially a child or a vulnerable adult, tells you that they are being hurt, or you learn that someone is. This goes to the safeguarding lead or the person your written policy names, and, where the law or your policy requires it, to the authorities, promptly. Do not investigate, and do not confront the person accused. Lecture 5-4 covers this.
  3. Serious harm to others. A person says they will harm someone else, or reveals a serious wrong that is continuing.

What is required varies. Some countries require certain people to report certain things. Others leave it to policy. Communities differ on who must be told and in what order. This course does not tell you the law. It tells you to find out, before the day comes, what your community's written policy says and what your local law requires of you, and to ask the pastor, priest or board to make sure those are known. When the moment arrives, you will not be learning them for the first time.

If a limit applies, tell the person what you must do, if it is safe to do so, before you do it: "I am worried about your safety, and I cannot keep this to myself. I want to tell the pastor now, and I would like you to be there." Telling them is a form of respect, and it often keeps the relationship.

7. Pass on only what the person wants, and ask afterwards

Outside the limits, the principle is simple. What you pass on is what the person wants passed on, to the people they have agreed to, in the words they have approved. Where possible, let them say it. Where it is easier for you to do it, agree the sentence first.

Afterwards, go back. Ask: "Was that all right? Is there anything you want changed?" You may find that the person is relieved, or that they regret telling the pastor. Either way, the asking restores some control to the person who, in telling you, felt they had lost it.

8. Records

A coordinator may be tempted to write notes. Be careful. Written notes about a person's health, marriage, money or faith can be lost, seen by the wrong person or required by law to be disclosed in some places. Write down only what your community's policy says to write, keep it where the policy says, and do not keep private files on people's troubles. A short factual line, such as "talked on 12 March; referred to pastor with consent", is usually enough. Follow local data-protection law and your written policy.

9. In a parish and in a free church

In a parish with a priest and a parish council, the lines of pass-on are usually clear: the priest, the , a parish care team, the safeguarding contact. The risk is that the volunteer is told "I will let Father know" without having agreed to it. In a small free church, the pastor may be the only paid person and also the friend, so telling the pastor can feel like telling everyone. There the risk is that everything goes to one person. In both, the ethic holds: the person decides what is passed on, within the limits above, and the community has someone to pass it on to who is not you.


Diagram 1. Listen, keep, pass on

When a Volunteer Tells You Something Hard What is told is entrusted, not owned 1 Listen Stop. Go somewhere private. Say little. Stay. "Thank you for telling me." 2 Keep Do not tell. Do not use. Ask before any prayer request is shared. 3 Pass on Help the person reach those who can help. Ask afterwards how it went. How far a confidence widens, and only with consent at each step You first then the pastor or priest then a named few, if the person agrees wider only with a fresh yes Limits: danger to life, abuse, serious harm to others Immediate danger: local emergency number. Otherwise: follow written policy and local law.

In short

  • Three moves: listen, keep, pass on. What a volunteer tells you is entrusted to you, not owned by you.
  • A confidence widens in order: you first, then the pastor or priest, then a named few, and further only with the person's fresh consent.
  • Ask before sharing anything, even as a prayer request. Well-meant sharing is the commonest way a confidence is broken.
  • Do not diagnose, judge, solve, promise secrecy you cannot keep, or quietly take the person out of service.
  • Confidence has limits: danger to life, abuse, serious harm to others. In immediate danger call the local emergency number; follow written policy and local law.
  • Pass on only what the person wants passed on, and ask afterwards how it went.
Front Back
The three moves Listen. Keep. Pass on. You notice, you stay, and you help the person reach those who can help.
Order of widening You first, then the pastor or priest, then a named few, then further only with a fresh yes.
Five things not to do Diagnose, judge, solve, promise what you cannot keep, quietly remove the person from service.
Limits of confidence Danger to life, abuse, serious harm to others. Emergency number if urgent; written policy and local law otherwise.

One sentence to remember What a volunteer tells you is entrusted to you, so you keep it, you do not carry it alone, and you pass on only what they agree to.

This week's action Find out whether your community has a written policy on confidences and reporting, and write a short list of five local services you could suggest to a volunteer in need.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What is the difference between information and something entrusted? How would it change what you do the next time a volunteer confides in you?
  • Why is "please pray for her" one of the commonest ways a confidence is broken? How could you ask for prayer in a way that keeps the person's trust?
  • In the story of the Samaritan, where do you see noticing, staying and passing on?
  • What is a promise you could safely make at the beginning of a confidence, and what is a promise you should not make?
  • Does your community have a written policy about reporting and a list of local help? If you do not know, who could you ask this week?
  • Why might a kind person quietly take a struggling volunteer off the rota, and what could be said instead?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.