Lecture 5-3: Difficult Conversations and Changing a Role
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Service as a Response to Grace
- Lecture 1-2: Why People Come and Why They Leave
- Lecture 1-3: Asking Well
- Lecture 1-4: Volunteers, Staff and Clergy
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Why I Began to Serve
- Lecture 2-1: Writing a Role Description
- Lecture 2-2: Listening and Matching
- Lecture 2-3: Screening and Safeguarding for Roles
- Lecture 2-4: Young and Older Volunteers
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Role Description in One Page
- Lecture 3-1: The First Month
- Lecture 3-2: Learning Alongside
- Lecture 3-3: The Volunteer Handbook
- Lecture 3-4: Serving in Worship: Liturgical and Free-Church Roles
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A First-Month Plan
- Lecture 4-1: Rotas, Cover and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Communication and Digital Boundaries
- Lecture 4-3: Thanks and Recognition
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Expenses and Gifts
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, A Thank-You Said Well
- Lecture 5-1: Recognising Weariness
- Lecture 5-2: When a Volunteer Tells You Something Hard
- Lecture 5-3: Difficult Conversations and Changing a Role
- Lecture 5-4: When Things Go Wrong: Complaints, Misconduct and Concerns
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What to Say to a Weary Volunteer
Most people in charge of volunteers will do almost anything to avoid one kind of conversation: the one that says "this is not working." They hint. They change the rota quietly. They stop asking. They hope the person will notice and leave. Meanwhile the person does notice, feels it, and does not know why.
Silence in these cases is not kindness. It is often the more painful choice, because the volunteer is left to guess. This lecture describes three situations that call for a conversation, a way of holding it that aims to keep the person, and the ways forward that protect dignity: a change of role, a rest, or a good ending. It also says where the conversation is not yours to hold alone.
The lecture does not teach a method of counselling or conflict resolution in general. Listening skills belong to LM205E, Listening Well: Foundations of Lay Pastoral Care, and the character of the leader who has to speak belongs to LM401E, Lay Leadership. Here the task is narrower: what a person in charge of volunteers says, in what order, and when to stop and hand the matter on.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Tell apart three situations: a role that does not fit, repeated broken commitments, and a line crossed.
- Follow a six-step order for a private conversation, and speak about the work, not the person's worth.
- Describe three ways forward and say why each protects dignity.
- State fairly the two views on strictness and forbearance, and say what this course requires on safety matters.
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15
World English Bible
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1
WEB
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
WEB
The first passage is about a brother who sins against you, and it is not about every difficulty in a rota. It still teaches a pattern that fits well: go first, go alone, and go with the aim of "gaining back" the person. The second asks for gentleness, with a look at oneself. The third joins two things that are often pulled apart: truth and love.
1. Three kinds of difficulty
Not every difficulty is the same, and the right response depends on the kind. There are three that a person in charge meets often.
A role that does not fit. The volunteer is willing, but the work is wrong for them. A shy person has been put on the welcome desk. A person who loves children has no patience for paperwork. A fine reader has become anxious about the microphone. Nobody has done wrong. The fault, if there is one, lies in how the placement was made (see lecture 2-2).
Repeated broken commitments. The person agrees and then does not come, or comes late, or leaves the job half done. It happens again after a gentle word. This may be carelessness. It may be trouble the person has not told you about. It may be weariness (lecture 5-1). You do not yet know which, and that is the reason to speak.
A line crossed. The person has done something the handbook says not to do: shared private information, sent a private message to a young person, taken a photograph without permission, handled money alone, been rude to someone served. Some lines are about manners and good order. Some are about safety.
Keep these three apart in your mind. The first is about placement, the second about commitment and care, the third about a rule. A role mismatch should never be treated as a failing of character. A line crossed should never be treated as a mere mismatch.
2. Speak about the work, not about the person's worth
Whatever the situation, a basic discipline applies: speak about the work, and say what you saw.
"You are unreliable" is a judgement of the person. "The last three Thursdays the room was not open at six, and the children waited outside" is an account of what happened. The second can be answered. The first can only be defended against.
Say what you saw, not what you think it means. Not "you obviously do not care", but "I noticed that you have missed four weeks, and I wondered what was happening." Leave a space for the other person to supply the reason you could not guess.
3. Begin in private, with the aim of keeping the person
Matthew 18:15 says "go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." Three points can be taken from it, with a caution.
The caution first: the verse is about a sin against you, and it belongs to a longer passage about the life of the community. A role that does not fit is not a sin, and a missed rota is not necessarily one. We are borrowing a pattern, not applying a command, and the course says so honestly. The pattern is a good one.
The points are these. Go to the person first, not to other volunteers and not to the pastor in order to complain. Go alone, so that the person is not put on trial before an audience. And go to gain the person back: the aim of the conversation is to keep a brother or sister, not to win a point or clear a name.
There is one large exception. If the matter is about safety, especially of children or vulnerable people, do not go alone and do not begin with a private word. See "Safety matters are not for you alone" below.
4. A conversation in six steps
This order is a help to memory, not a script. Adapt it to the person and the place.
1. Choose the time and the place. In private, in a place where you will not be interrupted, not just before the person is due to serve, and not in the car park. Give notice: "Can we meet on Tuesday for half an hour? I would like to talk about how things are going." Say what it is about, so that the person is not left to fear the worst. Offer them the choice to bring a friend or companion, if the culture or the person would find it easier.
2. Say what you care about. Begin with the person and the work you value. "You have served this community for two years and I am glad of it. I want to talk because I want this to go well for you."
3. State the facts. Name what you saw, briefly and without adjectives. "On three of the last five Sundays you arrived after the doors were opened."
4. Listen. This step is the one most often skipped. Ask, "What is it like from your side?" and wait. The reason may change everything: a new shift at work, a sick parent, a feeling that nobody welcomed them. If what you hear is heavy, move into the three moves of lecture 5-2.
5. Decide the way forward together. Offer options and let the person choose where possible: a different role, a lighter load, a rest, a fresh start with clearer expectations, or an ending. "What would help?" is better than "Here is what you will do."
6. Meet again. Agree a date to look back, perhaps in a month. This tells the person that you are not abandoning them, and gives the change time to work. If nothing has changed, you will have a basis to go further.
(An invented example.) Samuel looks after the sound desk. For six weeks the sound has been late and the notices have been drowned out. The coordinator meets him on a Tuesday and says, "I am glad you have given the Sunday mornings to this for a year. On the last five Sundays the sound has been late, and I want to understand it." Samuel says, quietly, that he cannot follow the new mixer, and has been too embarrassed to ask. Nobody trained him on it. The coordinator says that this is a gap in the training, not in him. They agree that he will have two sessions with another operator, and that if he does not enjoy it after a month, he may move to the welcome team, where he already has friends. They meet again in four weeks. Nobody has been blamed, and a volunteer has been kept.
5. Three ways forward
The conversation may end in one of three outcomes. Each can protect dignity.
A change of role. The person moves to work that suits them better, or to a smaller version of the same work. Say plainly that this is a better fit, and not a demotion. The new role needs to be real, not a place to put someone out of the way. A change of role, done well, is often the best result for everyone.
A rest. If the cause is weariness or a hard season, offer a pause with a clear way back, as in lecture 5-1. A rest should not be a polite way to dismiss a person; if it is, say so honestly.
A good ending. Sometimes the right thing is for the person to stop. The role does not fit, the commitment cannot be kept, or the relationship in this work has broken down. A good ending thanks the person specifically, says what is true about their contribution, handles the practical return of keys and papers kindly, and keeps the door open to friendship and to other ways of taking part in the community's life. Lecture 6-2 looks at this in detail. A volunteer who leaves well is not a failure, and neither is the person in charge.
In all three, the dignity of the person is protected by the same things: privacy, plain words about the work, a real choice where there is one, and no talk behind their back.
6. Safety matters are not for you alone
Some lines crossed are not matters of taste. If a person has been alone with a child against the rule, sent private messages to a young person, behaved in a way that frightens or hurts, or put someone at risk, do not decide alone, and do not begin with a private conversation with the person.
Tell the pastor, the priest, or the safeguarding lead named in your written policy, the same day. They will say what happens next and who speaks to the person. The reason is protection of the child or vulnerable person, of the volunteer who has been accused, and of you. A private word from you can warn a person who should not be warned, can put a child at more risk, and can damage a later investigation.
If anyone is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number first. Lecture 5-4 deals with complaints and concerns in more detail.
On safety matters, procedure comes first. Kindness does not mean skipping the procedure; it means that the procedure is followed gently and fairly.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. When a volunteer repeatedly fails, how strict should a community be? One view holds that clear rules, applied evenly and with consequences, are a form of love. They protect the vulnerable, they are fair to every volunteer, and they stop a favoured person from escaping what others must obey. Leaders who are too soft, on this view, end up unfair to everyone else and sometimes dangerous to those they serve. Some traditions with a strong sense of order and office hold this view, and many safeguarding professionals would add that a rule not enforced is no rule at all. The other view holds that a community is a family of forgiven people, that patience should be long, and that a person's failures deserve the same mercy the community itself has received. Leaders who are too strict, on this view, lose the very people who most need to belong, and make service a test of performance. Pastoral traditions that stress restoration, reconciliation and long patience hold this view, and many leaders in small communities, who know that the person they correct will sit beside them next Sunday, would add that harshness damages the whole body.
Each position, in its strongest form, is trying to protect something real: the vulnerable on one side, the person who has failed on the other. What this course requires is less than either side would ask for and more than either would leave to chance. On matters of safety, procedure comes first, whatever the person's history or standing. On other matters, speak early, kindly and plainly, before a small problem grows, and allow a change of role as a way of keeping the person. Decisions about discipline, suspension or removal follow your community's written policy and local law, and are taken by those the policy names, not by one volunteer coordinator alone.
8. Differences of culture
Cultures differ on how directly a hard thing may be said. In some places, directness is a mark of respect and a vague hint is an insult. In others, a direct word to a person in front of anyone, or even alone, is shaming, and the matter is raised through an , a friend of the family or a gentle story. Neither is wrong.
What the course asks is two things at once. The substance must be clear: the person must be able to understand what is being asked, or the conversation has failed. And dignity must be kept: no humiliation, no audience, no threat. In an indirect culture, you may need a go-between, a longer start, a meal together first. In a direct one, a shorter path may feel more honest. Ask a trusted person from the culture how it is usually done, and do not assume that your own way is the neutral one.
9. In a parish and in a free church
In a parish with paid staff and a council, there is usually a clear person to take a matter to, and procedures for who may serve in what role, particularly in the . A change of role may require the priest's decision, and it should be taken with the volunteer. In a small free church, the same person may be pastor, friend and employer of the other staff, and a difficult conversation with a volunteer may feel like a conflict among relatives. In both, name who decides, name who is present, write down only what policy says to write, and remember that the person will be in the same room on Sunday.
Diagram 1. A conversation in six steps, and when to stop
Diagram 2. Three ways forward
| Way | What it is | What protects dignity |
|---|---|---|
| Change of role | A better-fitting or smaller role | Said plainly as a better fit, and the new role is real |
| A rest | A pause with a clear way back | Not a polite dismissal; the way back is described |
| A good ending | The person stops serving here | Specific thanks, kind handover, the door left open |
In short
- Three difficulties: a role that does not fit, repeated broken commitments, and a line crossed. Treat each differently.
- Speak about the work and what you saw, not about the person's worth. Begin in private, with the aim of keeping the person.
- Six steps: choose time and place, say what you care about, state the facts, listen, decide together, meet again.
- Three ways forward protect dignity: a change of role, a rest, or a good ending.
- Safety matters are not for you alone: tell the pastor, priest or safeguarding lead the same day, and call the local emergency number if anyone is in danger.
- On safety, procedure comes first. Otherwise speak early, kindly and plainly, and follow the community's written policy.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three difficulties | A role that does not fit; repeated broken commitments; a line crossed. |
| Six steps | Time and place; what I care about; the facts; listen; decide together; meet again. |
| Three ways forward | Change of role; a rest; a good ending. Each protects dignity. |
| Matthew 18:15 pattern | Go first, go alone, go to gain the person back. Not for safety matters. |
One sentence to remember Say what you saw about the work, listen to the answer, and aim to keep the person, but never handle a safety matter alone.
This week's action Think of one conversation you have been putting off. Write the three facts you would state, without adjectives, and the question you would ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why do kind people avoid saying "this is not working"? What does the volunteer experience while they wait?
- Which of the three difficulties (a role that does not fit, broken commitments, a line crossed) have you seen? How was each handled?
- Rewrite "You are unreliable" as an account of what happened, in two sentences, without any adjective.
- Matthew 18:15 is about a sin against you. Is it fair to borrow its pattern for a role that does not fit? What is gained and what is risked?
- State the case for strictness and the case for patience as a believer of the other side would put them. What do both want to protect?
- How is a hard word best given in your own culture or community? Whom would you ask?