Lecture 3-5: The Professionalization of the Pastorate and the Church-Growth Movement
Contents 66
- Lecture 1-1: The Shepherd as the Controlling Image
- Lecture 1-2: Provision, Guidance, and Indictment - Psalm 23 and Ezekiel 34
- Lecture 1-3: The Good Shepherd and the Hired Hand
- Lecture 1-4: One Office, Three Names
- Lecture 1-5: Word, Sacrament, and Rule as Shepherding
- Lecture 1-6: Shepherding Toward Maturity
- Lecture 2-1: Leadership Before Office - Patriarchs and Judges
- Lecture 2-2: One Shepherd, Too Heavy a Burden - Moses and Jethro
- Lecture 2-3: Shepherd-King, Not Priest-King
- Lecture 2-4: The Prophet as a Check on the Shepherd-King
- Lecture 2-5: Jesus Reconstitutes the Flock
- Lecture 2-6: Handing Off the Shepherd's Staff
- Lecture 3-1: Bishop and Elder in the Post-Apostolic Church
- Lecture 3-2: Two Patristic Pastoral Theologies: Chrysostom and Augustine
- Lecture 3-3: The Reformation and the Priesthood of All Believers
- Lecture 3-4: Richard Baxter and The Reformed Pastor
- Lecture 3-5: The Professionalization of the Pastorate and the Church-Growth Movement
- Lecture 3-6: The Pastorate Today — Inherited Pressures, an Unchanged Standard
- Lecture 4-1: The Inward Call and the Outward Call
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Qualification Lists — 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1
- Lecture 4-3: Not a Recent Convert — Tested Time and the Means of Grace
- Lecture 4-4: When Pastoral Authority Is Abused
- Lecture 4-5: Managing One's Own Household
- Lecture 5-1: Why Polity Is a Theological Question
- Lecture 5-2: The Episcopal Case
- Lecture 5-3: The Presbyterian Case
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregational Case
- Lecture 5-5: Comparing the Three Traditions Fairly
- Lecture 6-1: The Pulpit and the House: One Ministry of the Word
- Lecture 6-2: Leading Worship as an Act of Shepherding
- Lecture 6-3: What the Apostles Refused to Delegate
- Lecture 6-4: Teaching Them to Observe: Building a Discipleship Pathway
- Lecture 6-5: Redeeming the Time: A Theology of Pastoral Time Management
- Lecture 7-1: Why the Shepherd Goes Out
- Lecture 7-2: The Kinds of Visits
- Lecture 7-3: Listening Before Speaking
- Lecture 7-4: Boundaries That Protect the Visit
- Lecture 7-5: Multiplying Visitation Through Lay Care Teams
- Lecture 8-1: Naming and Claiming a Child
- Lecture 8-2: Marriage as Covenant
- Lecture 8-3: Accompanying the Sick
- Lecture 8-4: At the Deathbed
- Lecture 8-5: Grief Does Not End at the Graveside
- Lecture 9-1: The Pastor's Role and Its Limit in Crisis
- Lecture 9-2: Depression, Anxiety, and Suicide Risk
- Lecture 9-3: Addiction and Domestic Violence - When Good Intentions Harm
- Lecture 9-4: Building a Referral Network Before the Crisis Comes
- Lecture 10-1: Gaining, Not Expelling - The Purpose of Church Discipline
- Lecture 10-2: The Graduated Steps of Matthew 18
- Lecture 10-3: When Discipline Is Weaponized
- Lecture 10-4: Restoration After Discipline Has Run Its Course
- Lecture 11-1: Administration as Stewardship, Not Distraction
- Lecture 11-2: Financial Transparency as Trust and Testimony
- Lecture 11-3: A Theology of Church Meetings and Decision-Making
- Lecture 11-4: Facilities as Servants of Ministry
- Lecture 11-5: Administration and Spiritual Vitality Together
- Lecture 12-1: Equipping the Saints: The Theological Basis for Lay Leadership
- Lecture 12-2: Multiplying Leaders: A Process for Identifying and Training
- Lecture 12-3: What Makes a Team a Team: Shared Authority and Mutual Accountability
- Lecture 12-4: Letting Go Well: Delegation and the Pastor's Redefined Role
- Lecture 13-1: What a Congregation Owes a Pastor's Family
- Lecture 13-2: The Pastor's Body and Mind: A Theology of Ministerial Health
- Lecture 13-3: Finishing the Course: The Shape of a Pastoral Career
- Lecture 13-4: Growth That Outlasts Active Ministry
- Lecture 13-5: The Crown That Does Not Fade: Closing the Course
Between Baxter's seventeenth-century Kidderminster and today lie roughly three and a half centuries, and this lecture cannot survey all of them. It focuses instead on two connected twentieth-century developments that reshaped what many congregations, and many pastors themselves, expect the office to look like: the rise of a "professional clergy" model borrowing its self-understanding from the credentialed professions (medicine, law, business management), and the church-growth and megachurch movements that, from roughly the 1970s onward, offered numerical growth as both a measurable goal and, for some proponents, a de facto measure of pastoral and institutional faithfulness.
Neither development is treated here as simply a corruption to be dismissed, nor as an unambiguous improvement over what came before. Both answered real problems — professionalization offered accountability and defined competence in an era when pastoral training had been wildly inconsistent; church-growth methodology offered genuinely useful, often overdue attention to whether a congregation's structures and communication were actually reaching the people around it. This lecture's task is to state what each movement got right, engage the sharpest critique made of the second, and let a student weigh both rather than adopt either uncritically.
What these 13 minutes give you
- Describe what the "professional clergy" model borrowed from the credentialed professions, and name at least one real problem this borrowing addressed.
- Summarize the church-growth movement's core claims about measurable growth and congregational strategy.
- State Eugene Peterson's "shopkeeper" critique of consumer-shaped ministry in its strongest form, and state a more sympathetic assessment of church-growth methodology in its strongest form.
- Apply 1 Corinthians 10:23's distinction between "lawful" and "profitable" to evaluating a pastoral method that is not itself sinful but may still be unwise.
'All things are lawful for me,' but not all things are profitable. 'All things are lawful for me,' but not all things build up." — 1 Corinthians 10:23
World English Bible
1. The professional clergy model
Over the course of the twentieth century, especially in North America, pastoral training increasingly took the institutional shape of graduate professional education: an accredited seminary degree (the Master of Divinity became the standard credential), denominational ordination examinations modeled loosely on licensing, and continuing-education expectations resembling those of physicians or attorneys. This shift addressed a genuine problem. Pastoral competence before this period had often depended entirely on an individual congregation's or bishop's own judgment, with wide and sometimes damaging variation in how much theological, pastoral, or practical preparation a minister actually had before taking a pulpit. Standardized professional training raised a reliable floor of competence — biblical languages, church history, methods, and supervised practical experience became expected rather than optional.
The borrowing carried a cost alongside the benefit, though this lecture states it carefully rather than treating it as an inevitable corruption. A professional model tends to import, often without anyone deciding to import it, that profession's characteristic understanding of the relationship between provider and client: a bounded, credentialed service relationship, evaluated by outcomes and expertise, rather than the covenantal, un-bounded shepherd-flock relationship this course's opening chapters argued Scripture actually describes. A doctor's competence is separable from the doctor's character in a way this course has argued a pastor's competence is not (chapter 4 develops this at length regarding qualifications). The professional model does not force that separation, but it makes the separation easier to drift into without noticing.
2. The church-growth movement's claims
The church-growth movement, associated with figures such as Donald McGavran and institutionalized through resources like the Fuller Institute of Church Growth, argued that congregations should study, measure, and deliberately adapt their methods — worship style, communication, organizational structure, outreach strategy — toward the specific goal of reaching more people effectively with the gospel, using the tools of organizational and sociological analysis to do so rigorously rather than by inherited habit alone. This is, on its own terms, a defensible and in places overdue corrective: a congregation whose methods have calcified for reasons of nostalgia rather than faithfulness is not automatically being more spiritual by refusing to examine whether its practices actually communicate to the people around it. The megachurch movement that followed, and popularized much of this thinking in the 1980s and 1990s, applied similar logic at much larger institutional scale, with attention to facilities, programming, and communication strategy that many smaller and mid-sized congregations subsequently borrowed from, whether or not they adopted the megachurch model wholesale.
3. Peterson's "shopkeeper" critique
Eugene Peterson's The Contemplative Pastor offers the most quoted critique of where this logic can lead. Peterson's central complaint is that American culture, and American pastors along with it, had come to treat congregations as consumers and pastors as something close to shopkeepers competing for those consumers' attention and loyalty — a pastor's success measured, functionally, by whether the "store" (the congregation) is growing, in a way that quietly substitutes market logic for the shepherd logic this course has argued Scripture actually gives. Peterson's specific concern is not that any use of organizational thinking is illegitimate, but that numerical growth, treated as the primary or default measure of pastoral faithfulness, can reward exactly the wrong things — a pastor who tells people what they want to hear, structures worship around comfort and consumer preference, and avoids the kind of costly, unpopular fidelity to a text or a hard pastoral task that this course's earlier chapters (Baxter's diligence, the prophets' courage in chapter 2) have held up as the real standard.
Stated in its strongest form, Peterson's argument is theological, not merely a matter of taste about program style: if success is defined by what draws and retains the largest number of consumers, a pastor will be systematically rewarded for exactly the accommodations Scripture's own shepherd texts warn against, and punished for exactly the kind of unpopular faithfulness Ezekiel 34 and John 10 both commend.
4. A more sympathetic assessment
A fair hearing for church-growth methodology, stated in its own strongest form, notes that many congregations that never adopted a single consumer-driven compromise nonetheless benefited enormously from taking seriously whether their Sunday service, their signage, their small-group structure, or their outreach genuinely served visitors and newcomers rather than only insiders long accustomed to unexplained jargon and unwelcoming habits. Growth, on this reading, is not automatically evidence of compromise; a congregation that removes real, unnecessary barriers to hearing the gospel and grows as a result has not thereby proven itself shallow. Some of the sharpest church-growth practitioners themselves distinguished carefully between adapting methods (music style, service length, communication clarity) and compromising message (softening the actual content of the gospel to avoid offense), and argued the first is simply wise of the same evangelistic urgency Paul shows in adapting his approach between the Pentecost crowd and the Areopagus.
5. "Lawful" and "profitable"
1 Corinthians 10:23 gives this lecture its best available tool for holding both assessments together without collapsing them into either uncritical or blanket rejection. Paul's distinction — "all things are lawful... but not all things are profitable" — does not treat every debated practice as either forbidden or required; it asks a further question after the first one is settled. A given church-growth method (a particular worship style, a particular facility investment, a particular communication strategy) may be entirely "lawful" — nothing in Scripture forbids it — while still needing to be tested against whether it actually "builds up" a specific congregation in its specific context, or whether it has quietly begun serving consumer comfort at the expense of the costlier fidelity this course's shepherd model requires. This is a case-by-case pastoral judgment, not a rule that can be settled once for every congregation everywhere, and a pastor should recognize that a method's popularity or its association with growth is not, by itself, evidence either for or against whether it is profitable in this .
In short
- In the twentieth century, pastoral training became professional: graduate degrees, ordination examinations and continuing education. This raised a reliable floor of competence.
- The cost is that a professional model can bring in a provider-and-client view of ministry, in place of the covenant shepherd-and-flock relationship.
- The church-growth movement urged congregations to study and adapt their methods to reach more people. The lecture calls this a defensible and in places overdue corrective.
- Eugene Peterson's "shopkeeper" critique warns that treating numerical growth as the main measure rewards telling people what they want to hear.
- Using 1 Corinthians 10:23, a method may be "lawful" yet still must be tested for whether it "builds up" in this congregation.
Topic: This lecture weighs the professional clergy model and the church-growth movement, giving what each got right and the strongest critique of each.
Remember: Both movements answered real problems, and a method being lawful does not settle whether it is profitable.
Caution: The lecture does not call either movement a corruption or an improvement. Peterson does not say organizational thinking is illegitimate, and growth is not automatically a sign of compromise.
One line to carry into ministry: Test each method case by case: it may be allowed, but does it build up this congregation without serving consumer comfort?
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Name one real benefit and one real risk of the professional clergy model, using your own words rather than the lecture's.
- Peterson's critique targets treating numerical growth as the default measure of pastoral faithfulness. Is there a different measure you think congregations more often actually use in practice, and is it any better?
- State the sympathetic case for church-growth methodology in a way you think a thoughtful proponent of it would recognize as fair, before you state any disagreement with it.
- Apply 1 Corinthians 10:23 to a specific, concrete ministry method (worship style, building project, communication strategy, or another example of your choosing). What would make that method "profitable" in one congregation and not in another?