Lecture 10-1: Gaining, Not Expelling - The Purpose of Church Discipline
Contents 66
- Lecture 1-1: The Shepherd as the Controlling Image
- Lecture 1-2: Provision, Guidance, and Indictment - Psalm 23 and Ezekiel 34
- Lecture 1-3: The Good Shepherd and the Hired Hand
- Lecture 1-4: One Office, Three Names
- Lecture 1-5: Word, Sacrament, and Rule as Shepherding
- Lecture 1-6: Shepherding Toward Maturity
- Lecture 2-1: Leadership Before Office - Patriarchs and Judges
- Lecture 2-2: One Shepherd, Too Heavy a Burden - Moses and Jethro
- Lecture 2-3: Shepherd-King, Not Priest-King
- Lecture 2-4: The Prophet as a Check on the Shepherd-King
- Lecture 2-5: Jesus Reconstitutes the Flock
- Lecture 2-6: Handing Off the Shepherd's Staff
- Lecture 3-1: Bishop and Elder in the Post-Apostolic Church
- Lecture 3-2: Two Patristic Pastoral Theologies: Chrysostom and Augustine
- Lecture 3-3: The Reformation and the Priesthood of All Believers
- Lecture 3-4: Richard Baxter and The Reformed Pastor
- Lecture 3-5: The Professionalization of the Pastorate and the Church-Growth Movement
- Lecture 3-6: The Pastorate Today — Inherited Pressures, an Unchanged Standard
- Lecture 4-1: The Inward Call and the Outward Call
- Lecture 4-2: Reading the Qualification Lists — 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1
- Lecture 4-3: Not a Recent Convert — Tested Time and the Means of Grace
- Lecture 4-4: When Pastoral Authority Is Abused
- Lecture 4-5: Managing One's Own Household
- Lecture 5-1: Why Polity Is a Theological Question
- Lecture 5-2: The Episcopal Case
- Lecture 5-3: The Presbyterian Case
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregational Case
- Lecture 5-5: Comparing the Three Traditions Fairly
- Lecture 6-1: The Pulpit and the House: One Ministry of the Word
- Lecture 6-2: Leading Worship as an Act of Shepherding
- Lecture 6-3: What the Apostles Refused to Delegate
- Lecture 6-4: Teaching Them to Observe: Building a Discipleship Pathway
- Lecture 6-5: Redeeming the Time: A Theology of Pastoral Time Management
- Lecture 7-1: Why the Shepherd Goes Out
- Lecture 7-2: The Kinds of Visits
- Lecture 7-3: Listening Before Speaking
- Lecture 7-4: Boundaries That Protect the Visit
- Lecture 7-5: Multiplying Visitation Through Lay Care Teams
- Lecture 8-1: Naming and Claiming a Child
- Lecture 8-2: Marriage as Covenant
- Lecture 8-3: Accompanying the Sick
- Lecture 8-4: At the Deathbed
- Lecture 8-5: Grief Does Not End at the Graveside
- Lecture 9-1: The Pastor's Role and Its Limit in Crisis
- Lecture 9-2: Depression, Anxiety, and Suicide Risk
- Lecture 9-3: Addiction and Domestic Violence - When Good Intentions Harm
- Lecture 9-4: Building a Referral Network Before the Crisis Comes
- Lecture 10-1: Gaining, Not Expelling - The Purpose of Church Discipline
- Lecture 10-2: The Graduated Steps of Matthew 18
- Lecture 10-3: When Discipline Is Weaponized
- Lecture 10-4: Restoration After Discipline Has Run Its Course
- Lecture 11-1: Administration as Stewardship, Not Distraction
- Lecture 11-2: Financial Transparency as Trust and Testimony
- Lecture 11-3: A Theology of Church Meetings and Decision-Making
- Lecture 11-4: Facilities as Servants of Ministry
- Lecture 11-5: Administration and Spiritual Vitality Together
- Lecture 12-1: Equipping the Saints: The Theological Basis for Lay Leadership
- Lecture 12-2: Multiplying Leaders: A Process for Identifying and Training
- Lecture 12-3: What Makes a Team a Team: Shared Authority and Mutual Accountability
- Lecture 12-4: Letting Go Well: Delegation and the Pastor's Redefined Role
- Lecture 13-1: What a Congregation Owes a Pastor's Family
- Lecture 13-2: The Pastor's Body and Mind: A Theology of Ministerial Health
- Lecture 13-3: Finishing the Course: The Shape of a Pastoral Career
- Lecture 13-4: Growth That Outlasts Active Ministry
- Lecture 13-5: The Crown That Does Not Fade: Closing the Course
Ask most churchgoers what "church discipline" means, and the word that will come up most often is punishment: someone did something wrong, and the church is going to do something about it. This lecture argues that this common association, while understandable, gets the purpose backward from the very text that establishes the practice. Matthew 18:15 does not describe a process for punishing wrongdoing. It describes a process for gaining back a brother — recovering a relationship the sin has damaged, aimed at the sinning person's restoration to full fellowship, not their removal from it. Every later lecture in this chapter, including the one that names real abuses of discipline, measures faithfulness against this single standard: does a given practice actually aim at gaining the person, or has it stopped being that and become something else wearing the same name.
What these 10 minutes give you
- State Matthew 18:15's purpose language ("you have gained back your brother") as the text's own definition of what discipline is for.
- Distinguish discipline aimed at restoration from discipline aimed at punishment, and explain why the difference is not merely a matter of tone.
- Engage Jonathan Leeman's argument that discipline protects the church's witness and the individual's restoration together, rather than treating these as competing goals.
- Identify at least one way an ordinary reader's assumptions about "discipline" as punishment can distort how Matthew 18 is read and applied.
If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother." — Matthew 18:15
World English Bible
1. "Gained back," not "dealt with"
The verb Matthew uses at the end of verse 15 deserves more attention than it typically receives in popular treatments of . The outcome of a successful first conversation is not that the offense has been "addressed" or "handled" — language that could describe punishment just as easily as reconciliation. The outcome is that the brother has been gained, a word that assumes something was at risk of being lost and has instead been kept. This is the language of a relationship recovered, not an infraction processed. Jonathan Leeman's contemporary treatment in Church Discipline takes this as the interpretive key for the whole passage: discipline exists, in his phrase, to protect the church's witness to the gospel and to restore the sinning individual, and these two purposes are not competitors requiring a church to choose which one it cares about more. A church that disciplines to protect its witness while genuinely hoping for the offender's return is doing exactly what Matthew 18 describes. A church that disciplines only to protect its reputation, indifferent to whether the person is restored, or a church that avoids discipline entirely to spare feelings, indifferent to what unaddressed sin does to its witness, have each let go of one half of what this text holds together.
2. Why punishment is the wrong frame from the start
It is worth being explicit about what is lost when discipline is framed primarily as punishment, because the two frames produce genuinely different practices, not just different vocabulary for the same practice. A punishment frame measures success by whether the offense received a proportionate consequence; a restoration frame measures success by whether the relationship was recovered, and treats even a full recovery achieved slowly, with no formal "consequence" beyond the conversations themselves, as a complete success — arguably the ideal outcome, since Matthew 18:15 envisions the process ending at the first, private step whenever possible. A punishment frame has little interior reason to prefer privacy over publicity, since punishment often gains deterrent value from being visible; a restoration frame has every reason to keep the process as private as it can remain, since publicity itself becomes a form of harm to a relationship still being sought rather than already lost. Lecture 10-2 develops this second point at length. It is introduced here because the graduated structure Matthew 18 prescribes only makes sense once discipline's purpose is correctly identified as restoration rather than punishment; a punitive reading of the passage has no obvious reason for verse 15's insistence on starting alone, between the two people, before anyone else is told.
3. A caution against reading this lecture too cleanly
Not a simple slogan
The elegance of this distinction — punishment bad, restoration good — is itself worth pausing over, because a distinction this clean can become a slogan detached from the harder work of actually applying it. Restoration language has, in practice, sometimes been used to excuse delaying real accountability (a topic lecture 10-3 takes up directly), just as punishment language has sometimes named a legitimate concern — that unaddressed sin causes ongoing harm to others and that some consequence, such as removal from a leadership role, is a genuinely restorative and protective step, not merely punitive. The purpose stated in Matthew 18:15 should govern how this chapter reads every later question, but it is not a formula that resolves every hard case by itself, and this lecture does not claim it does.
(See the two-frames diagram in section 2, this lecture's central visual argument.)
In short
- Many people hear "church discipline" as punishment. The lecture says Matthew 18:15 aims at something else: "you have gained back your brother."
- "Gained" suggests something at risk of being lost and now kept. It describes a recovered relationship, not a handled offense.
- Jonathan Leeman holds that discipline protects the church's witness and restores the sinning person. These two aims do not compete.
- A punishment frame measures success by a fitting consequence. A restoration frame measures success by the relationship recovered, and so prefers privacy.
- Verse 15 begins alone, between two people. A punitive reading has no reason for that.
- The lecture warns that "restoration, not punishment" is not a formula for every hard case. Restoration language can excuse delay, and some consequences protect others.
Topic: This lecture explains that the purpose of church discipline in Matthew 18:15 is to gain back a brother, not to punish.
Remember: Matthew 18:15 defines success as the brother gained back, so a process that aims at something else has stopped being this kind of discipline.
Caution: The lecture does not say the distinction settles every hard case. Restoration language can delay accountability, and some consequences, such as leaving a leadership role, can protect people.
One line to carry into ministry: Before you begin any discipline conversation, ask whether you are hoping to gain this person back, and let that hope shape how you speak.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Before this lecture, did your own mental picture of "church discipline" lean toward punishment or toward restoration? What shaped that picture?
- Leeman argues that protecting the church's witness and restoring the individual are not competing goals. Can you imagine a real situation where a church might feel forced to choose between them? How would Matthew 18:15's own language help resolve that tension?
- Section 3 warns against treating "restoration, not punishment" as a slogan that resolves every hard case. Can you think of a situation where restoration language might be misused to avoid necessary accountability?
- Why might Matthew's choice of the word "gained" rather than a more neutral word like "addressed" or "corrected" matter for how a pastor actually conducts the first conversation in this process?