FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT4E Christian Counseling

Lecture 4-4: The Craft of a Counseling Question

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 64
PT4E Christian Counseling
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What Christian Counseling Is, and Why This Training Matters
  1. Introduction: What Christian Counseling Is, and Why This Training Matters
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Foundations - A Biblical Anthropology for Counseling
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Image of God as the Starting Point for Counseling
  2. Lecture 1-2: Body and Soul — A Unified Person, Not a Ghost in a Machine
  3. Lecture 1-3: Sin, Suffering, and Sickness — Telling Them Apart Without Flattening Any of Them
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Heart as the Seat of Thought, Desire, and Worship
  5. Lecture 1-5: Chapter Synthesis — Conformity to Christ as the Goal of Counseling
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The History and Models of Christian Counseling
  1. Lecture 2-1: The History of Pastoral Care, from the Desert to the Reformation
  2. Lecture 2-2: Nouthetic Counseling and the Sufficiency of Scripture
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Integration Movement and Common-Grace Wisdom
  4. Lecture 2-4: Other Models — Levels of Explanation and Later Biblical Counseling
  5. Lecture 2-5: Fair Comparison and Pastoral Wisdom
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Counselor's Character and Preparation
  1. Lecture 3-1: Counseling as an Extension of Ordinary Pastoral Care
  2. Lecture 3-2: Self-Awareness and the Counselor's Own Blind Spots
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Counselor's Own Spirituality
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Counselor's Actual Preparation
  5. Lecture 3-5: Chapter Synthesis — Humility and the Recognition of Limits
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Counseling Relationship - Listening, Empathy, and Questions
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Incarnational Shape of the Counseling Relationship
  2. Lecture 4-2: Deep Listening — Hearing Content, Emotion, and Meaning Together
  3. Lecture 4-3: Empathy — Its Theology and Its Practice
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Craft of a Counseling Question
  5. Lecture 4-5: The Structure of a Counseling Session — From Opening to Close
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Process of Biblical Change - Sin, Grace, and Sanctification
  1. Lecture 5-1: Biblical Repentance versus Behavior Modification
  2. Lecture 5-2: Sin as Idolatry — the Heart's Disordered Worship
  3. Lecture 5-3: Grace as the Sole Engine of Change
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Gradual, Non-Linear Shape of Sanctification
  5. Lecture 5-5: Chapter Synthesis — Pursuing New Creation Without Manufacturing Urgency
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Counseling Ethics and the Boundaries of Competence
  1. Lecture 6-1: Confidentiality — Its Principle and Its Limits
  2. Lecture 6-2: Dual Relationships — Counseling Someone You Already Know
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Counselor's Power and Its Abuse
  4. Lecture 6-4: The Standards and Practice of Referral
  5. Lecture 6-5: Case Notes and Supervision
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Pastoral Counseling for Anxiety and Depression
  1. Lecture 7-1: A Holistic Framework for Anxiety and Depression
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Theology of Anxiety — Worry and Trust
  3. Lecture 7-3: Pastoral Accompaniment Through Depression
  4. Lecture 7-4: Cognitive Distortions and Biblical Truth
  5. Lecture 7-5: Partnering with Medical and Clinical Professionals
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Marriage and Family Counseling
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Roots of Marital Conflict
  2. Lecture 8-2: Biblical Communication and Conflict Resolution in Marriage
  3. Lecture 8-3: Forgiveness and Reconciliation
  4. Lecture 8-4: Parent-Child Relationships — Discipline and Nurture
  5. Lecture 8-5: Pastoral Care for Unusual Family Situations
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Counseling Addiction and Recovery
  1. Lecture 9-1: A Balanced Framework for Addiction — Sin, Disease, or Both
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Addictive Cycle and the Idolatry Beneath It
  3. Lecture 9-3: The Recovery Journey — Stages of Change and a Realistic Theology of Relapse
  4. Lecture 9-4: A Theological Assessment of Recovery Communities and Twelve-Step Programs
  5. Lecture 9-5: Caring for the Families of Addicted Persons — Codependency, Boundaries, and Hope
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Trauma, Loss, and Crisis Counseling
  1. Lecture 10-1: Understanding Trauma — How It Marks Both Body and Mind
  2. Lecture 10-2: Crisis Intervention — Safety, Stabilization, Connection
  3. Lecture 10-3: Grief Counseling — Walking With Loss
  4. Lecture 10-4: Suicide Risk Counseling — Assessing Risk and Having the Conversation
  5. Lecture 10-5: Post-Traumatic Growth — A Theology of Growth That Does Not Rush
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Counseling Children and Adolescents
  1. Lecture 11-1: Developmental Understanding of Children and Adolescents
  2. Lecture 11-2: Distinctive Methods for Counseling Children — Play and Story
  3. Lecture 11-3: Adolescent Counseling — Identity, Autonomy, and Normal Struggle
  4. Lecture 11-4: Partnering with Parents and the Ethics of Counseling Minors
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Counseling and the Church Community - Training Lay Counselors
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Priesthood of All Believers and the Theology of Lay Counseling
  2. Lecture 12-2: Identifying and Training Lay Counselors
  3. Lecture 12-3: Organizing Distributed Care — Small Groups, Structure, and James 5:16
  4. Lecture 12-4: The Limits of Lay Counseling and Program-Wide Supervision
Chapter 13 · Chapter 13: The Counselor's Self-Care and Lifelong Growth
  1. Lecture 13-1: Counselor Burnout and Compassion Fatigue
  2. Lecture 13-2: Vicarious Trauma — Carrying What Was Never the Counselor's Own
  3. Lecture 13-3: The Counselor's Continuing Growth — A Lifelong Learner's Posture
  4. Lecture 13-4: Spiritual Replenishment — Grace as the Counselor's Own Resource
  5. Lecture 13-5: Course Synthesis — The Counselor as Shepherd

Jump to the key points ↓

18 min

Listening and empathy, the previous two lectures argued, are what a counselor's presence looks like while another person is speaking. This lecture takes up what a counselor does with their own words: specifically, the counseling question, which is arguably the single most-used tool in any counseling session and, this lecture will argue, one of the most often misused. A well-formed question moves a person from vague distress toward specific insight; a poorly formed one can shut a conversation down, put a person on the defensive, or - worse - function as an accusation dressed up in the grammar of a question, all while the counselor asking it believes they are simply gathering information.

Proverbs 17:3 supplies this lecture's anchor, and its imagery is deliberately chosen: "the refining pot is for silver, and the furnace for gold, but Yahweh tests the hearts." Refining is not accusation - the refiner does not already know, with certainty, exactly what will be found in the ore, and the process of refining is itself how the metal's true content becomes known, to the refiner and often to the ore's own owner as well. A good counseling question does something structurally similar: it does not presume to already know what is in a person's heart and simply confirm it, but genuinely explores what is there, in a process the person being questioned is invited to participate in rather than merely submit to. The lecture argues that this posture - genuine exploration rather than presumed conclusion - is what separates a counseling question from an accusation, regardless of how gently the accusation is phrased.

What these 18 minutes give you

  • Distinguish open from closed questions, and state when each is the more appropriate tool in a counseling conversation.
  • Identify a question that functions as an accusation disguised in interrogative grammar, and explain the mechanism by which such questions damage a counseling relationship even when the counselor's underlying concern is legitimate.
  • Explain how Proverbs 17:3's image of refining supplies a model for questions that probe without presuming to already know the answer.
  • Apply at least one named clinical framework for question-asking (from the motivational interviewing literature) to a counseling scenario, while stating what a Christian counselor retrieves from it and what remains distinctly theological about the goal of the questioning.

The refining pot is for silver, and the furnace for gold, but Yahweh tests the hearts." — Proverbs 17:3

World English Bible

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5

WEB

1. Open versus closed questions

A closed question invites a short, bounded answer - often yes, no, or a single fact - and narrows a conversation to whatever the counselor has already anticipated as the relevant options. "Have you talked to your husband about this?" is closed; it can be answered in one word, and it presupposes that the relevant next step is a conversation with the husband, which may or may not be where the counselee's own thinking actually is.

An open question invites the counselee to shape the answer's scope and direction. "What's kept you from bringing this up with him?" opens space for an answer the counselor has not already anticipated - fear, exhaustion, a belief that it would not help, a conviction that raising it would make things worse, or something the counselor has not yet imagined. Open questions do more of the actual exploratory work this chapter's organizing principle has in view; closed questions are not wrong, and are often exactly right for confirming a specific fact quickly ("has this happened before?"), but a counseling conversation made up mostly of closed questions will tend to feel, and often actually be, an interrogation rather than an exploration.

A rough but useful discipline: default to open questions when the goal is understanding a person's situation, feelings, or reasoning, and reserve closed questions for confirming specific facts once enough has already been opened up to know which facts matter.

2. The question that is really an accusation

The most serious failure this lecture addresses is not the overuse of closed questions but a specific and common pattern: a question whose grammatical form is interrogative but whose actual function is to state a conclusion the counselor has already reached, phrased so as to appear open while in fact inviting only one acceptable answer. "Don't you think you're being a little unforgiving?" is grammatically a question but functionally an accusation - it does not explore whether unforgiveness is present, it asserts it, and dares the counselee to disagree. "Why would you do that to your family?" asks "why" in form but presumes, in substance, both that the action was wrong and that the person owes an account of it on the spot, before any actual exploration of what happened or why.

These accusatory questions are damaging for a reason that goes beyond simple unkindness: they close down exactly the exploration a genuine question exists to open. A person asked "don't you think you're being unforgiving?" faces a binary trap - agree, and accept a conclusion reached without them; or disagree, and be cast as defensive, which itself seems to confirm the original accusation. Neither response actually advances understanding of what the person's own experience of forgiveness or unforgiveness has been. Proverbs 18:13's warning against answering before hearing applies here in an inverted form: this is a counselor asking before hearing, having already supplied the answer inside the question's own grammar.

It is worth being honest that a counselor asking an accusatory question is often not being cruel; they have often correctly perceived something real (genuine unforgiveness, a genuinely harmful pattern) and are reaching, understandably, for a way to name it. The craft this lecture is teaching is not to suppress that perception but to convert it into a genuinely open question that tests the perception rather than announcing it: not "don't you think you're being unforgiving?" but "what would it look like, in your own mind, to actually forgive him for this?" - a question that still moves toward the same territory (forgiveness, or its absence) without presuming, before the person has spoken, exactly what will be found there.

3. Proverbs 17:3 as a model for probing without presuming

The refining imagery in Proverbs 17:3 rewards closer attention. A refiner places ore in the furnace not because the ore's content is already fully known and the furnace merely displays it publicly, but because heat is genuinely how impurity and precious metal are separated from each other - the process itself does real work, uncovering something that was not simply obvious beforehand even to someone examining the ore closely. Applied to a counseling question: a good question is not a device for confirming what the counselor already believes about a person's heart; it is a genuine instrument for discovering, together with the person being questioned, what is actually there.

This has a direct practical consequence. A counselor convinced, from outside evidence, that a counselee is harboring resentment should not ask a question designed only to extract a confession of resentment already assumed to exist. The counselor should ask a question that genuinely tests the hypothesis and remains open to being wrong about it, or right about it in a different shape than expected - perhaps the person's felt experience is closer to grief than resentment, or closer to fear of confrontation than to anger itself. Proverbs 17:3 attributes the ultimate testing of hearts to Yahweh himself ("but Yahweh tests the hearts") - a deliberate contrast with the refiner's furnace in the same verse, which suggests real caution: a counselor's questions can genuinely probe, but they do not carry the certainty that only God's own testing of the heart possesses. A counselor who asks questions with the confidence properly belonging only to divine heart-searching has overreached the tool's actual capacity.

4. A clinical parallel: motivational interviewing's open questions

The broader clinical literature on helping conversations has developed extensive, practical frameworks for exactly the skill this lecture is teaching. Motivational interviewing, developed by the clinical psychologists William R. Miller and Stephen Rollnick (first published as a coherent method in 1991 and developed across several subsequent editions), was designed originally for counseling around behavior change - substance use in particular - and organizes core listening and questioning skills under the acronym OARS: open questions, affirmations, reflections, and summaries. Miller and Rollnick's central insight, developed at length, is that a person is generally more persuaded by reasons for change that they articulate themselves in response to a well-placed open question than by reasons a counselor supplies to them directly - what the method calls "change talk," language the person themselves generates that leans toward change, which a skilled questioner can notice, reflect, and gently amplify without ever supplying the conclusion on the person's behalf.

This is a genuinely useful clinical observation and directly supports the case this lecture has been making theologically from a different angle: a question that lets a person arrive at their own articulation of what needs to change (rather than a counselor's conclusion imposed on them) tends to produce more durable movement than a conclusion delivered readymade. What a Christian counselor adds, and does not receive from the motivational-interviewing literature itself, is the goal toward which that movement is aimed. Miller and Rollnick's method is explicitly agnostic about what direction of change is being pursued - the technique works equally well pointed at any behavior change a client has chosen as their own goal. A Christian counselor's questions, by contrast, are asked in service of a specific goal chapter 1 already named: conformity to Christ (Colossians 1:28), not merely whatever change a person happens to want for themselves. A counselor can use OARS-style open questions and reflections as genuinely useful technique while remaining clear that the technique is being placed inside a theological aim the technique itself does not supply or require.

5. A worked example

Three ways to respond

Consider a counselee who says: "I know I'm supposed to forgive my sister, but I just can't seem to do it." Several possible counselor responses illustrate the distinctions this lecture has drawn.

Closed, fact-gathering: "Have you told her you forgive her?" - useful for confirming a specific fact, but it skips past the "can't seem to" entirely.

Accusatory, disguised as a question: "Don't you think holding onto this is going to hurt you more than her?" - presumes the conclusion (that she is "holding onto it" and that this presumed grudge is the problem) before exploring what "can't seem to" actually means to this person.

Open, genuinely exploratory: "What does 'can't seem to' feel like, when you try?" or "What do you think is happening inside you in the moment you try and it doesn't happen?" - both questions genuinely do not know in advance what will be found (a besetting fear, a belief that forgiving would mean excusing real harm, an old wound reopened by a smaller recent one) and invite the counselee to do the work of discovering and naming it, with the counselor's help, rather than receiving the counselor's conclusion about it.

The third kind of question is harder to construct in the moment than the first two, which is exactly why this lecture treats questioning as a craft requiring deliberate practice rather than an ability every well-meaning counselor already has by default.


Three Responses to "I Can't Seem to Forgive Her" Proverbs 17:3 — refining tests, it does not merely confirm Closed "Have you told her you forgive her?" — confirms one fact, skips the "can't seem to" Useful for confirming a specific fact once enough has already been opened up Accusatory "Don't you think holding onto this will hurt you more than her?" — presumes the conclusion Traps: agree with a conclusion not yet earned, or disagree and look defensive Open and Exploratory "What happens inside you in the moment you try and it doesn't work?" Genuinely does not know in advance what will be found — refines rather than confirms "Yahweh tests the hearts" (Proverbs 17:3) — a counselor's questions probe; they do not carry that certainty

In short

  • Open questions invite a person to shape the direction of their own answer and do the exploratory work central to counseling; closed questions confirm specific facts efficiently but, used as a default, turn a conversation into an interrogation.
  • A question that presumes its own conclusion - an accusation disguised in interrogative grammar - traps the person being asked and forecloses the genuine exploration a question exists to open, even when the underlying concern behind it is legitimate.
  • Proverbs 17:3's refining imagery models a question that genuinely tests rather than merely confirms, while its second half ("Yahweh tests the hearts") cautions against a counselor's questions claiming the certainty that belongs only to God's own searching of the heart.
  • Motivational interviewing's OARS framework (Miller and Rollnick) gives concrete, practiced form to open questioning and shows that self-articulated reasons for change tend to be more durable than conclusions supplied by the counselor - a genuinely useful technique that a Christian counselor places inside the theological goal of conformity to Christ, which the technique itself does not supply.
  • A good counseling question can be constructed, in practice, by taking a correct but accusatory instinct and rephrasing it as a genuine, open exploration of the same territory.

Topic: A good counseling question explores what is in a person's heart; it does not hide a conclusion inside a question.

Remember: Use open questions to understand. Turn a correct hunch into a real question that could prove wrong.

Caution: A counselor's questions do not carry the certainty that belongs to God, who tests the hearts. Motivational interviewing is useful technique, but it does not supply the Christian goal of conformity to Christ.

One line to carry into ministry: Ask about what you do not already think you know.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Write down a question you have actually asked someone in a moment of concern for them. Is it open or closed? Does it, on reflection, carry a hidden conclusion inside its grammar?
  • This lecture argues that a counselor who has correctly perceived something real (genuine resentment, a harmful pattern) should still convert that perception into a genuinely open question rather than an accusatory one. Does converting a correct perception into an open question risk losing the directness that a situation sometimes needs? When, if ever, is direct, non-question confrontation the more faithful response than a question at all?
  • Motivational interviewing is agnostic about the direction of change it helps a person reach. What specific risk does that agnosticism create if its open-question technique is imported into Christian counseling without also importing chapter 1's goal of conformity to Christ?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.