Lecture 4-4: The Craft of a Counseling Question
The counseling question is the most-used tool in a session and one of the most misused. A good one explores; it does not hide a conclusion.
Christian Counseling
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
The counseling question is the most-used tool in a session and one of the most misused. A good one explores; it does not hide a conclusion.
Christian Counseling
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
The counseling question is arguably the most-used tool in any session. A well-formed question moves a person from vague distress toward specific insight. A poorly formed one can shut a conversation down or put a person on the defensive. Worse, it can work as an accusation in the grammar of a question, while the counselor believes they are only gathering information.
The lecture says this verse is its anchor. The refiner does not already know exactly what the ore holds, and the process itself shows it. The lecture uses this image for a question that explores instead of presuming. It also uses the second half, that Yahweh tests the hearts, as a caution about a counselor's certainty.
The refining pot is for silver, and the furnace for gold, but Yahweh tests the hearts." Proverbs 17:3 · World English Bible
Invites a short answer, often yes, no or one fact. Have you talked to your husband about this? It is good for confirming a fact quickly, but a conversation of mostly closed questions becomes an interrogation.
Lets the person shape the answer. What has kept you from bringing this up with him? It makes room for an answer the counselor had not expected. Default to open questions to understand; keep closed ones for confirming facts.
Some questions are interrogative in form but state a conclusion the counselor has already reached. Don't you think you're being a little unforgiving? asserts unforgiveness and dares the person to disagree. The person faces a trap: agree with a conclusion reached without them, or disagree and look defensive. The craft is to turn the perception into a real question, such as: what would it look like, in your own mind, to forgive him?
The lecture says this warning against answering before hearing applies here in an inverted form. The counselor is asking before hearing, having already supplied the answer inside the question's own grammar.
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." Proverbs 18:13 · WEB
William Miller and Stephen Rollnick developed motivational interviewing, which organizes skills under the acronym OARS: open questions, affirmations, reflections and summaries. Their central insight is that people are more persuaded by reasons for change that they state themselves than by reasons a counselor supplies. What a Christian counselor adds is the goal: conformity to Christ, which the method itself does not supply.
Closed: Have you told her you forgive her? This skips past the can't seem to. Accusatory: Don't you think holding onto this will hurt you more than her? This presumes the conclusion.
What does can't seem to feel like when you try? This does not know in advance what it will find, such as a fear, a belief that forgiving means excusing real harm, or an old wound, and it invites the person to name it.
The lecture asks you to write down a question you have really asked someone out of concern.
Was it open or closed? Does it carry a hidden conclusion inside its grammar?
A good counseling question explores what is in a person's heart; it does not hide a conclusion inside a question. Use open questions to understand, and turn a correct hunch into a real question that could prove wrong. A counselor's questions do not carry the certainty that belongs to God. Ask about what you do not already think you know.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.