Defenders work mostly in the most restrictive Muslim contexts, where a public break can mean family disownment, legal persecution, or death. They argue from 1 Corinthians 9:22, where Paul became all things to all people. Remaining formally in one's birth community while holding a transformed allegiance to Christ is, they say, closer to Paul than a demand to take on a foreign-coded identity. They ask whether the label, rather than the substance of faith, should be the test.
Key idea Substance of allegiance, not only the label.