Lecture 3-4: The Contextualization Spectrum — C1 Through C6
The C1-C6 scale describes how much of a surrounding religious culture Christ-centered communities keep.
Missiology: The Theology and Practice of Christian Mission
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.
The C1-C6 scale describes how much of a surrounding religious culture Christ-centered communities keep.
Missiology: The Theology and Practice of Christian Mission
옆으로 넘기거나 화살표 키를 쓰세요 →
A missionary among a Muslim-majority population faces a practical question. How much of the surrounding culture's religious language, forms, and communal identity may a believer keep? At what point does keeping it stop being contextualization and become compromise? John Travis, under a pseudonym in a 1998 article, proposed a six-point scale called C1-C6 to describe the range of answers found in practice.
A traditional church using a language and style foreign to the surrounding culture, such as a colonial-era church still using a European language and Western music.
The same as C1 but in the local language. The forms, buildings, music, and terms for God and worship remain culturally foreign.
Begins borrowing culturally appropriate but religiously neutral forms, such as local music, dress, and art, while avoiding explicitly Islamic forms and vocabulary.
Adopts biblically permissible Islamic forms such as prayer postures, fasting, and some vocabulary for God. Believers may identify as Muslim culturally in limited ways but see themselves as followers of Christ.
Believers continue to identify socially and legally as Muslims while holding Jesus as Lord and Savior, in a way they see as consistent with their identity.
Secret believers who worship underground and make no public identification with Christ because open identification would mean imprisonment or death.
Travis built the scale to describe existing church-planting practice among Muslim-background believers. It reports what missiologists and national believers were doing, not a menu for each missionary. Its Islamic-specific categories do not transfer cleanly to Hindu or Buddhist settings. There a missiologist borrows the logic but builds a scale for that context's own religious forms.
Phil Parshall was an experienced missionary among Muslims and one of contextualization's own pioneers. As early as the 1990s he warned that keeping the label Muslim risked more than strategic accommodation. It could obscure that following Christ requires a change of ultimate allegiance, and it could suggest that no real break with Islam's core claims about Christ has happened.
Defenders work mostly in the most restrictive Muslim contexts, where a public break can mean family disownment, legal persecution, or death. They argue from 1 Corinthians 9:22, where Paul became all things to all people. Remaining formally in one's birth community while holding a transformed allegiance to Christ is, they say, closer to Paul than a demand to take on a foreign-coded identity. They ask whether the label, rather than the substance of faith, should be the test.
The lecture notes that capable, godly practitioners on both sides cite the same New Testament texts.
What might it tell us that serious people on both sides read the same verses and reach opposite conclusions?
C1-C6 describes how much of a surrounding religious culture believers keep, from foreign forms to secret faith. It was built for Muslim-background contexts and does not transfer cleanly elsewhere. The debate over C5 is real and the lecture does not resolve it.