Lecture 11-4: Can the Church Use a Corporate Change Model?
Contents 59
- Lecture 1-1: Secular Leadership Theory and the Question It Does Not Ask
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dominion Mandate
- Lecture 1-3: What Biblical Leadership Is — Delegated Authority Under a Higher Authority
- Lecture 1-4: The Purpose of Leadership — Kingdom and Next Generation, Not Legacy
- Lecture 2-1: "It Shall Not Be So Among You" — Mark 10:42-45
- Lecture 2-2: Footwashing and Status Anxiety — John 13
- Lecture 2-3: The Kenosis Hymn — Philippians 2:5-11
- Lecture 2-4: What Servant Leadership Is Not
- Lecture 3-1: Leadership as One Gift Among Many
- Lecture 3-2: Spirit-Empowered Authority Versus Natural Charisma
- Lecture 3-3: The Fruit of the Spirit as Leadership Character
- Lecture 3-4: Case Studies — Stephen and Barnabas
- Lecture 4-1: Moses' Call — Resistance and an Unwilling Leader
- Lecture 4-2: Jethro's Counsel — The Theology of Delegation
- Lecture 4-3: Moses' Failure at Meribah — Private Frustration, Public Sin
- Lecture 4-4: Joshua's Succession — Transition as a Theological Event
- Lecture 4-5: Two Case Studies — David's Fall and Restoration, and Nehemiah's Crisis Leadership
- Lecture 5-1: Jesus' Method — Calling, Presence, Sending, and Correction
- Lecture 5-2: Peter's Denial and Restoration — Formation Through Foreknown Failure
- Lecture 5-3: Peter at Pentecost — What Changed and What Did Not
- Lecture 5-4: Paul — Called, Vouched For, and Built to Be Left
- Lecture 6-1: The Qualifications — Cataloging Character and Competence in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1
- Lecture 6-2: Gift Is Not Readiness — 1 Corinthians 12-13
- Lecture 6-3: The Leader's Shadow Side — Saul and David Under the Same Kind of Pressure
- Lecture 6-4: Warning Signs and the Danger of Standing Confidently
- Lecture 7-1: The Leader's Own Source: Solitude, Prayer, and Scripture
- Lecture 7-2: Calling: Inward Conviction and Outward Confirmation
- Lecture 7-3: Accountability Structures for Leaders
- Lecture 7-4: Burnout, Sabbath, and the Theology of Rest for Leaders
- Lecture 8-1: Vision as Received, Not Invented
- Lecture 8-2: The Hidden Process: Nehemiah's Grief, Prayer, and Assessment
- Lecture 8-3: Communicating Vision: Repetition, Symbol, and Story
- Lecture 8-4: The Ethics of Persuasion, and Vision That Fades
- Lecture 9-1: Emotional Intelligence and the Wisdom of Proverbs
- Lecture 9-2: Empathic Listening: What Job's Friends Got Right, and Then Wrong
- Lecture 9-3: Self-Regulation Under Pressure: Moses at Meribah Revisited
- Lecture 9-4: Relational Capital Across a Power Gap: David and Jonathan
- Lecture 10-1: How Teams Actually Form
- Lecture 10-2: Trust as Covenant, Not Transaction
- Lecture 10-3: Building a Team of Different People, on Purpose
- Lecture 10-4: Delegation Is a Spectrum, Not a Switch
- Lecture 11-1: Conflict as an Opportunity for Reconciliation
- Lecture 11-2: Matthew 18 and the Discipline of Confrontation
- Lecture 11-3: What a Leader Owes People Who Are Afraid
- Lecture 11-4: Can the Church Use a Corporate Change Model?
- Lecture 11-5: Crisis Leadership — Composure and Communication
- Lecture 12-1: The Four-Generation Standard
- Lecture 12-2: Designing Formation That Reproduces Leaders
- Lecture 12-3: Modeling — Teaching by Being Watched
- Lecture 12-4: Three Mentoring Pairs Compared
- Lecture 12-5: Coaching Through Questions
- Lecture 13-1: A Reusable Leadership Pipeline
- Lecture 13-2: Leading Across Generations
- Lecture 13-3: Women in Church Leadership — Two Positions, Fairly Stated
- Lecture 13-4: Leadership Across Cultural, Marketplace, and Digital Boundaries
John Kotter's eight-step model of organizational change — establish urgency, build a guiding coalition, form a strategic vision, enlist volunteers, remove barriers, generate short-term wins, sustain acceleration, and institute change — has become one of the most widely taught frameworks in change management since Kotter first published it in 1996, and it has found its way, directly or by imitation, into a great deal of contemporary church-leadership writing and practice.[^1] This lecture engages the model critically and directly rather than either adopting it uncritically as a leadership tool the church should simply borrow, or rejecting it wholesale as inherently incompatible with ministry. It also names, explicitly, that this is contested ground: serious, thoughtful Christian leaders disagree with one another about how directly a model like Kotter's should be used in a church, and this lecture states the disagreement rather than resolving it.
What these 13 minutes give you
- State Kotter's eight-step model in outline and identify at least two of its steps that seem genuinely useful and theologically uncontroversial for church leadership.
- Explain, using 1 Corinthians 3:6-9, the specific theological objection to importing a corporate change model into the church without modification.
- Name at least one real practical theologian or church leader representing a more favorable view of using such models, and one representing a more cautious view, along with their strongest arguments.
- Identify a leadership-centered assumption embedded in typical change-management language, and explain what 1 Corinthians 3 offers as a corrective to it.
1 Corinthians 3:6-9 (World English Bible): "I planted. Apollos watered. But God gave the increase. So then neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters, but God who gives the increase. Now he who plants and he who waters are the same, but each will receive his own reward according to his own labor. For we are God's fellow workers. You are God's farming, God's building."
1. What Kotter's model claims, and what it gets right
Kotter's model was developed from studying corporate transformations that failed, and it argues failures typically trace to skipping or rushing one of eight necessary steps: (1) establishing a sense of urgency, so people understand why change is needed before being asked to change; (2) building a coalition with enough credibility and authority to lead the change, rather than relying on one leader alone; (3) forming a clear strategic vision for the change; (4) enlisting a volunteer army who buy in and communicate the vision further; (5) removing structural barriers that block the change; (6) generating short-term wins that build momentum and credibility; (7) sustaining acceleration rather than declaring victory too early; and (8) instituting the change into the organization's actual culture so it does not revert once attention moves elsewhere.
Read charitably, several of these steps describe something a leader in any organization, including a church, genuinely needs to attend to, and this course does not treat them as theologically suspect merely for being secular in origin. The observation that change announced without a shared sense of why it matters tends to fail is not a claim in tension with anything Scripture teaches — Nehemiah's own approach to rebuilding Jerusalem's walls (Chapter 8's treatment of Nehemiah's vision formation) already models something like establishing urgency and building a coalition before attempting the work. Short-term wins building momentum, and change reverting once it is declared complete and attention moves on, are observable patterns a leader ignores at real cost.
2. The theological objection
The objection this lecture takes most seriously is not that the model's individual steps are false, but that its underlying picture of how change happens and who is responsible for it is a poor fit for what the church actually is. Kotter's model, like most corporate change-management literature, is built around the assumption that change is something a leader (or leadership coalition) causes through the correct sequence of deliberate actions — get the steps right, in the right order, and the transformation follows as a more or less mechanical consequence of good execution. 1 Corinthians 3:6-9 offers a sharply different picture of causation in the church's own growth and change: Paul plants, Apollos waters, "but God gave the increase" (v. 6) — and Paul's conclusion is not merely that God's role is important alongside the human roles, but that "neither he who plants is anything, nor he who waters" (v. 7) compared to the God who actually causes the growth. Applied to organizational change, this suggests that a leader who runs every step of a change model correctly and still sees no real transformation has not necessarily failed at execution — the church's actual growth and change is not, finally, a leader-caused mechanical outcome the way a corporate transformation model implicitly assumes it to be.
This is a real tension, not a merely verbal one, and it is worth stating plainly rather than resolving too quickly in either direction: a change model built around human agency and sequence risks training a leader to think of the church's transformation as something the leader ultimately produces through correct method, which 1 Corinthians 3 directly denies; but the alternative extreme — treating any deliberate planning or structure around change as itself a lack of faith in God's sovereign action — risks using theology to excuse genuine pastoral negligence, since Paul himself is describing planting and watering, real deliberate labor, not passivity.
3. This is a point where readers will not agree
Two views of change models
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some practical theologians and church leaders use models like Kotter's fairly directly, treating them as useful, theologically neutral tools for organizing what a leader was always going to need to do anyway — communicate why change matters, build support, sequence the work — without claiming the model itself explains how spiritual transformation occurs. Andy Stanley's writing on organizational leadership for churches (e.g., Deep and Wide) represents this more favorable instinct: relatively direct borrowing from organizational leadership literature, on the conviction that good organizational practice and genuine spiritual dependence on God are not in tension, since God ordinarily works through, not around, competent human effort. Others, more often writing from a Reformed or missional-ecclesiology tradition — Alan Roxburgh and Fred Romanuk's account of the "missional leader," for instance, or Edwin Friedman's systems-theory-influenced critique of quick-fix leadership technique generally — argue that the church's organic, Spirit-dependent nature makes a corporate change model a poor fit at best and a subtly distorting one at worst, because the model's internal logic trains leaders to think mechanistically about a process Scripture describes as fundamentally God's own work, even when the leader using the model would explicitly deny thinking that way if asked directly.
This lecture does not resolve the disagreement, and a quiz question on this material should not require a single answer only one of these traditions could give — the disagreement is over how directly a genuinely useful descriptive tool should be adopted into a theological account of change the tool itself does not, and cannot, provide.
4. A corrective, not a replacement
Whatever position a reader lands on, 1 Corinthians 3:9's naming of believers as "God's fellow workers" — not God's replacements, and not autonomous agents operating alongside a passive God — offers a useful corrective to any change-management language, Kotter's included: a leader using such a model well will narrate the change, even while executing every step diligently, in terms that keep God as the one who ultimately gives the increase, rather than in terms that quietly credit the method itself. This is less a resolution of the contested question than a discipline that both sides of the disagreement can, in practice, agree to hold.
In short
- John Kotter's eight-step change model (1996) is widely taught, including in church leadership. The lecture engages it critically and says this ground is contested.
- Several steps, such as establishing urgency, building a coalition and securing short-term wins, are useful and not in tension with Scripture. Nehemiah already shows something like them.
- The theological objection: the model assumes the leader causes change by correct method. 1 Corinthians 3:6-9 says Paul planted, Apollos watered, and God gave the increase.
- Andy Stanley favors fairly direct borrowing. Alan Roxburgh and Fred Romanuk, and Edwin Friedman, are more cautious. The lecture does not pick a winner.
- Both sides can keep the discipline of narrating change as something God gave, since believers are "God's fellow workers" (v. 9).
Topic: The lecture asks whether the church can use a corporate change model such as Kotter's, and sets out two views.
Remember: Useful planning and dependence on God do not have to compete. Paul describes real labor, planting and watering, while God gives the increase.
Caution: The lecture does not settle the dispute. Using theology to excuse poor planning is a risk, and so is thinking the method produces the change.
One line to carry into ministry: Plan and work diligently, and when you speak of the result, give credit to God who gave the increase.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of Kotter's eight steps do you find least theologically controversial, and which, if any, seems most likely to encourage the leader-centered thinking 1 Corinthians 3 warns against?
- The lecture says both extremes are real risks: mechanistic leader-centered change-management thinking on one side, and using theology to excuse genuine negligence on the other. Which risk do you personally find more tempting, and why?
- Andy Stanley and Alan Roxburgh represent two real, serious positions on this question. Try to state each position in a form its own advocate would recognize as fair, before saying which you find more persuasive.
- What would it look like, practically, for a leader to use a change model's steps diligently while still narrating the outcome, honestly and not just as a verbal habit, as something God gave rather than something the method produced?