Lecture 11-4: Can the Church Use a Corporate Change Model?
Useful tool, or a picture of change that does not fit the church?
Christian Leadership: Theology, Character, and Practice
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.
Useful tool, or a picture of change that does not fit the church?
Christian Leadership: Theology, Character, and Practice
Swipe or use the arrow keys →
John Kotter published his eight-step model of organizational change in 1996. It has become one of the most widely taught frameworks in change management, and it appears in a great deal of church-leadership writing. This lecture does not adopt it without question, and it does not reject it completely. It also says plainly that this is contested ground, where serious Christian leaders disagree.
Kotter studied corporate changes that failed. He argued that failure usually comes from skipping or rushing one of eight steps: urgency, a guiding coalition, a clear vision, volunteers who buy in, removing barriers, short-term wins, sustaining acceleration, and building the change into the culture. Each step has a purpose. For example, the last step is there so that the change does not go back to the old way when attention moves elsewhere.
Read in a fair way, several steps describe what any leader needs to watch, including a church leader. The lecture does not call them suspect only because they come from outside the church. Change announced without a shared sense of why it matters tends to fail, and this is not in tension with Scripture. Nehemiah's rebuilding of the walls already shows something like urgency and a coalition. A leader who ignores short-term wins or reversion pays a real price.
The strongest objection is not that the steps are false. It is that the model's picture of how change happens does not fit what the church is. Corporate models assume that a leader or leadership team causes change by doing the right steps in the right order. 1 Corinthians 3:6-9 gives a different picture: Paul plants, Apollos waters, and God gives the increase. A leader who runs every step well and still sees no transformation has not necessarily failed at execution.
The lecture names a real tension and warns against leaving it too quickly. A model built on human agency and sequence can train a leader to think the church's change is something the leader produces by method. But the opposite extreme is also a danger. Treating all planning as a lack of faith can excuse real pastoral negligence. Paul describes planting and watering, which is deliberate labor, not passivity.
Some leaders use such models fairly directly, as neutral tools for what a leader needed to do anyway: explain why change matters, build support, and sequence the work. Andy Stanley's Deep and Wide is named as an example. The conviction is that God works through, not around, competent human effort.
Others, such as Alan Roxburgh and Fred Romanuk, and Edwin Friedman, say the church's Spirit-dependent nature makes a corporate model a poor fit. They argue its logic trains leaders to think mechanically about a process Scripture describes as God's own work.
Whatever position a reader takes, 1 Corinthians 3:9 calls believers "God's fellow workers". They are not God's replacements, and they are not independent agents beside a passive God. This corrects any change-management language, Kotter's included. A leader who uses a model well will tell the story of the change in a way that keeps God as the one who gives the increase, and will not quietly credit the method.
The lecture says both extremes are real risks: leader-centered change thinking, and using theology to excuse negligence.
Which risk do you find more tempting, and why?
Kotter's model has useful steps, and Nehemiah shows similar ideas. The theological concern is the idea that a leader causes change by correct method, while 1 Corinthians 3:6-9 says God gives the increase. Serious leaders disagree about how directly to use such models. Plan and work diligently, and when you speak of the result, give credit to God.
These cards are a short preview. Your reading is recorded only when you read the full lecture, and the chapter quiz and the exams test what the full lecture teaches.