Lecture 4-4: Raising a Concern Safely
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Safety as Love of Neighbour
- Lecture 1-2: Seeing Risk: A Simple Review
- Lecture 1-3: Policies, Culture and Who Is Responsible
- Lecture 1-4: Law, Insurance and Faith: How They Fit Together
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Risk Walk-Through
- Lecture 2-1: Why Protection Comes First
- Lecture 2-2: Everyday Habits: Two Adults, Open Spaces, Clear Roles
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing and Training People
- Lecture 2-4: Hearing a Concern: Reporting and Response
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Protection Promise
- Lecture 3-1: The Building: Exits, Access and Care of Space
- Lecture 3-2: Fire, Medical Emergencies and Drills
- Lecture 3-3: Events, Vehicles and Trips
- Lecture 3-4: Disaster, Security and Hard Days
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: An Emergency Page
- Lecture 4-1: Personal Information, Photos and Records
- Lecture 4-2: Online Safety and Digital Tools
- Lecture 4-3: Money Controls and Transparency
- Lecture 4-4: Raising a Concern Safely
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: An Information and Money Check
- Lecture 5-1: What Insurance Is and Is Not
- Lecture 5-2: Reading a Policy and Asking Good Questions
- Lecture 5-3: General Principles of Non-profit and Religious-Body Compliance
- Lecture 5-4: Contracts, Rentals and Partners
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Compliance Checklist
Sooner or later, someone in almost every community sees something that troubles them. A figure that does not add up. A leader who spends the community's money on himself. A gift that was meant for the poor and went elsewhere. A volunteer who is too close to a young person. A pastor who treats the people who depend on him in a way that frightens them. The person who sees it is often the least powerful: a volunteer, a new member, a part-time worker, a widow who is helped by the church, a young person. They know that to speak may cost them. They also know that to stay silent may cost someone else.
This lecture is about making it safe to speak, and about how to speak. It is for the one who has a concern, for the leader who receives it, and for the community that must decide in advance what it will do. It treats the person who is accused with dignity, and it states plainly that a concern is never settled quietly or buried. It concerns money and conduct in general; a concern about a child or a vulnerable person follows the route in lecture 2-4 and is passed on the same day.
This lecture is not legal advice. Laws on reporting, on protection of those who speak up, on defamation and on employment differ by country, region and year, and there may be duties to report to an authority. Check locally, and ask a qualified person (a lawyer, an adviser from your denomination, a safeguarding or compliance officer).
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain why a community needs a known, safe way to raise concerns, and how this serves love of neighbour.
- Describe the power gap that makes speaking hard, and who is most affected by it.
- Set out steps for a person with a concern, and steps for a leader who receives one.
- Describe what "no retaliation" requires and how an outside check helps.
- Explain how a community treats the person who is accused, and why neither silence nor rumour is acceptable.
Have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather even reprove them." — Ephesians 5:11 (World English Bible) "For everyone who does evil hates the light, and doesn’t come to the light, lest his works would be exposed." — John 3:20 (WEB) "But he who does the truth comes to the light, that his works may be revealed, that they have been done in God.”" — John 3:21 (WEB) "Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate." — Proverbs 31:8 (WEB) "Don’t receive an accusation against an elder, except at the word of two or three witnesses." — 1 Timothy 5:19
WEB
Paul tells the church to have nothing to do with the works of darkness, and rather to expose them. John describes a mark of those who do wrong: they stay away from the light, for fear of what it will show. And the writer of Proverbs calls on the one who can speak to speak for those who cannot. These texts are not a licence for suspicion. The last verse, from Paul's advice to Timothy, shows the other side: an accusation against an is not simply received, but is tested by more than one witness. The lecture takes both: the light is welcome, and the accused has a right to be heard fairly.
1. Why a safe way to speak matters
A community that cannot hear a hard word is not safe, however kind it feels. When it is hard to raise a concern, three things tend to follow. The people who know most say least. A small wrong, which could have been put right early, grows. And when it does come out, it comes out in the worst way: through rumour, a quarrel, an outside report or a collapse of trust.
The community that makes it safe to speak is not looking for scandal. It is practising what John describes: coming to the light. A group that is willing to be seen has nothing to fear from being seen, and a group that is unwilling should ask why.
This is a matter of love. The person who raises a concern is often doing what Proverbs asks, speaking for people who cannot speak for themselves: the giver whose gift was misused, the member who is afraid, the child who has no words. To ignore or punish the one who speaks is to turn away from those they speak for.
2. The power gap
Leaders hold power, and often more than they know. A pastor or a director may decide who is hired, who is housed, who is given help, who serves and who is thanked. A volunteer whose place depends on the favour of a leader, a worker whose home goes with the job, a member who is helped with food or papers, a migrant who fears being reported, a young person, a widow, a new convert: each of these may find it very hard to say, "I think this is wrong."
That is the power gap, and it works whether or not the leader means it to. A leader who says "my door is always open" has not made it safe; people may be afraid to walk through it. To close the gap, the community must offer more than an open door. It must offer a route that does not depend on the goodwill of the person being spoken about.
In some cultures a direct word to a senior person is very hard. In some, speaking outside the family or the community is felt as betrayal. In some, a concern is raised first through an elder or a respected friend. Communities should find a way that fits the people but still ends in the same place: the concern is heard by someone who has the standing and the duty to act on it.
3. Before you speak: for the person with a concern
If you are the one who sees something, it may help to go through a few questions. They are not hurdles; they are a way to speak well.
- Is anyone in danger now? If a child or a vulnerable person may be harmed, do not wait and do not weigh. Follow the steps in lecture 2-4 the same day, and if there is immediate danger, call the local emergency number.
- What did I see, and what did I only hear? Write down, privately, the plain facts: what, when, where, how you came to know. Do not write guesses about motive.
- Is it my concern to raise, or is it an honest difference of view? A decision you disagree with is not necessarily a wrong. A decision you cannot explain, or that hides something, is a different matter.
- To whom should I speak? Choose someone who has the standing to act and who is not the person concerned: a named person in the community's own procedure, a senior leader not involved, a member of the board, a trusted denominational or umbrella contact, or an outside adviser. If the person you would speak to is involved, go above or beside them.
- Can I say it plainly and calmly? "I noticed this, on this date. I do not know the whole picture. I think someone should look."
- Am I willing to leave it with them? You raise it; you do not investigate it. You may be told little, because those who look into it have to protect the privacy of those concerned.
If the first person you tell does nothing, or tells you to keep quiet, that is not the end. A concern is not closed because one person did not want to hear it. Go to the next route, and if the matter is serious, to the outside authority.
4. When you are the leader who hears
A leader who receives a concern is receiving a gift. This is hard to remember when the concern is about you, a friend or the work you have given your life to. A few habits make the difference.
- Thank the person. Say it simply, and mean it. The first response teaches everyone else what will happen to them.
- Listen; do not defend. You do not need to answer at once. Ask them to say what they saw. Take a plain note.
- Do not promise secrecy you cannot keep. Say what you will do and whom you must tell.
- Do not investigate alone. If it is about money or conduct and you are close to the person, you are the wrong one to look into it. Tell the person or body responsible for the matter the same day or, for something small, within a short time that the community has agreed in advance.
- Protect the one who spoke. See the next section.
- Protect the one who is spoken about. See the section after.
- Tell the person what happens next, as far as you can. A person who hears nothing assumes nothing is happening.
- Do not settle it quietly. A quiet word, a payment, a transfer, a resignation or an agreement not to speak does not close a concern about money, abuse or serious misconduct. It hides it. Where the law or the community's own rules require a report to an authority, report. Check locally.
5. No retaliation
The promise that makes all the rest possible is that no one will suffer for raising a concern in good faith. That means no one will lose their place, their housing, their help, their standing or their friends because they spoke. It means that no one will be called disloyal, a troublemaker or a gossip for doing it. It means that leaders and members do not guess who spoke and treat them differently.
This promise needs to be written and said aloud before a concern arises, and it needs to be kept when one does. Some practical steps:
- Say it in the community's rules and on its notice board: "If you raise a concern in good faith, you will not be treated badly for it."
- Tell the one who speaks how you will keep their name known to as few as possible, while being honest that sometimes it cannot be kept from the person concerned.
- Watch, afterward, how the person is treated, and ask them. Retaliation is often quiet: not being asked, not being thanked, a place at the table that moves.
- Treat retaliation as itself a serious matter.
A concern raised in bad faith, knowing it to be false or to harm someone, is a different thing and is also taken seriously. But a community that starts by asking "why are they saying this?" will find it very hard to learn anything. It first asks "what is true?"
6. An outside check
Some concerns cannot be handled from within. The person concerned is the senior leader; the board is made up of the person's friends; the community is small and everyone is related; or the matter touches money or the law. An outside check is the answer. It is a person or body that does not depend on the people involved.
Examples are a denominational or umbrella body, a regional or national office, a senior leader from a neighbouring church, a qualified accountant, a lawyer, a safeguarding adviser, or, where the law requires, a public authority. A community that is not part of a larger body should know in advance whom it would call. It is much easier to ask when you are not in the middle of a crisis.
An outside check also helps the accused. If the matter is nothing, an independent person is better placed to say so than the person's friends. If it is something, the community has done what it should.
How church order, constitutions and the discipline of clergy work is the subject of the church order and law course. Employment questions, including ending a role, belong to the church staff course. Here we ask only that there be a way to speak and a route to someone independent.
7. Dignity for the person spoken about
The person who is spoken about is a neighbour too, and they are often a member of the community, a friend, a co-worker. Until the facts are known, they are neither guilty nor safe from question.
- Do not treat a concern as a conclusion. A concern is a reason to look. It is not a finding.
- Keep it to those who need to know. Gossip is a harm of its own. The proverbs on speech apply in both directions.
- Hear their account, through the proper route, in a fair way, and in good time. Paul's advice to Timothy about more than one witness is a protection against rumour and a single voice; it was never meant as a way of silencing people. Where a concern is serious and has been properly raised, a report to the proper authority is not delayed for the sake of a second witness.
- Where there is a risk to others, the person may be asked to step back from a role while the matter is looked into. That is not a punishment. It is a protection for everyone, including them. Pay, standing and process are handled under the church staff and church order and law courses.
- Treat them with courtesy, and do not announce an outcome before there is one.
If someone is found to have done wrong, the community's response is a matter for its proper process and, where there is a crime, for the authorities. Care for the person is not the same as hiding what they have done. Forgiveness is a Christian duty, but forgiveness is not a reason to pressure a harmed person to be silent, and it is not a substitute for protection and repayment.
8. Different sizes and structures
A house church with no one above the host (an invented example). A small group meets in a home, and a member notices that a fund for a sick neighbour has not reached the neighbour. The host is the one who holds the fund. The member does not know whom to tell. The group had agreed, when it began, on a "named friend", an experienced pastor from a nearby congregation, to whom anyone may take a worry about money or conduct. The member goes to the friend, who asks a few plain questions of the host and the group, and the money turns out to have been held in a drawer through a muddle. It is paid, a second person now holds the fund, and nobody left. If the answer had been different, the friend would have known what to do next. The route was set before it was needed.
A congregation with a board (an invented example). A part-time worker, whose small flat belongs to the church, sees that expenses paid to a leader do not match the dates of his travel. She is afraid of losing her home. The church has a written procedure, a named board member who is not the leader's friend, and a promise of no retaliation. She goes to the named person, who writes down what she says, thanks her and tells her what will happen next. The board asks an outside accountant to look. The finding is mixed: some expenses were wrongly recorded and one was not clear. The leader repays a small amount and agrees to a new way of working with a second signature. The worker keeps her flat and her work.
A mission agency or non-profit (an invented example). A field worker has a concern about how a local partner's funds are being used by a colleague, and the colleague is the field director. The agency has an independent contact, outside the field structure, whom anyone may reach by phone or message, and it has told every worker how. The contact passes it to the agency's board, which asks for an outside review.
In each case, no one needed to be brave beyond the ordinary. The way had been made. That is the work of the community: to make it ordinary to speak.
9. First steps for a small community
If you have little, choose three things:
- Name a person (or two) outside the leadership to whom a concern about money or conduct may go: a trusted pastor or elder from another congregation, a member of an umbrella body, an adviser.
- Write and say the promise of no retaliation, in a few lines.
- Agree who would be called in if the concern were about the senior leader.
The minimum for protecting children does not shrink with the size of the church. A concern about a child goes the same day by the route in lecture 2-4, however small the group.
Diagram 1. A route for a concern
In short
- A community that cannot hear a hard word is not safe; a safe way to speak serves those who cannot speak for themselves.
- Leaders hold power that people feel even when it is not meant; an open door is not enough, so offer a route that does not depend on the person concerned.
- The one with a concern writes plain facts, tells a named person who is not involved, and raises it without investigating.
- The leader thanks, listens, promises no secrecy, does not look into it alone, tells the person what happens next, and never settles it quietly.
- No one suffers for raising a concern in good faith; an outside check helps both the one who spoke and the one spoken about.
- The one spoken about keeps dignity: a concern is a reason to look, not a finding. This is not legal advice; check locally.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The power gap | Leaders hold power that makes it hard for volunteers, workers and the dependent to speak, whether or not the leader intends it. |
| No retaliation | No one loses place, help or standing for raising a concern in good faith; written and said before it is needed. |
| An outside check | A person or body that does not depend on those involved, which helps the one who spoke and the one spoken about. |
| Never settled quietly | A quiet word, a payment or a resignation does not close a concern about money or abuse; follow the proper authority. |
One sentence to remember Make it ordinary to speak: a named person, a promise of no retaliation, and a route to someone independent.
This week's action Write down the name of one person outside your leadership to whom a concern about money or conduct could go, and tell your leaders.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- If a volunteer in your community saw something troubling about money, to whom would they go? Does everyone know?
- Who in your community might find it hardest to raise a concern, and why? What would make it safer for them?
- When did you last thank someone for telling you something you did not want to hear? What did you say?
- If the concern were about your senior leader, which outside person or body could your community call?
- How can a community be fair to the person spoken about and still never settle a serious concern quietly?