FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People

Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics

Contents 31
PT709E Youth Ministry Foundations: Walking Beside Young People
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
  1. Introduction: Companions, Not Projects
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Place of Youth Ministry
  1. Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
  2. Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
  4. Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Young People's World
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
  2. Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
  3. Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
  4. Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
Chapter 3 · Week 3: The Adult Who Stays
  1. Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
  2. Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
  3. Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
  4. Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Gatherings, Groups and Trips
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
  2. Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
  3. Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
  4. Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Living the Faith
  1. Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
  2. Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
  3. Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
  4. Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Walking With Families and Moving On
  1. Lecture 6-1: Working With Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Transitions and Leaving
  3. Lecture 6-3: Caring for the Team
  4. Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Review on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

On a Friday evening a girl of fifteen puts a folded slip of paper in the question box that stands by the door (an invented example). When the leader opens the box at the end, the slip reads: "Why does the church say what it says about two people of the same sex who love each other? My cousin is one of them and my aunt says she is going to hell." Beneath it are three other slips. One asks about a war on the news. One asks whether it is a sin to try alcohol at a party. One says only, "What if God isn't real?"

A youth leader who works long enough will open such a box. The questions are not unusual. They are the questions young people carry between school, the screen in their pocket and the table at home. The leader has about a minute to decide what to do, and whatever they decide will teach the young people something far larger than the answer: whether it is safe to ask.

This lecture is about how to talk about hard things with young people. It does not settle what any community should teach on sexuality, politics, violence or substances. Communities and traditions disagree, and a youth leader is not the one who decides the teaching of the church. It teaches how to speak with dignity and honesty, how to decide who should speak and when, and how to keep faith with parents and young people at once. The adolescent mind and mental health belong to PT706E; here the focus is on the practice of the conversation.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Explain why how a hard question is received matters more than the first answer given.
  • Describe five habits that make a hard conversation safe: no shame, honest limits, no graphic detail, no hidden teaching, and the right person.
  • Say what a leader may do when they do not know the answer, or when the question belongs to parents or clergy.
  • State fairly the different views on where hard topics should be addressed, and what this course requires.
  • Recognise when a question is a sign that a young person is in difficulty, and respond by noticing, staying and passing on.

but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15

World English Bible

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1

WEB

The scribes and the Pharisees brought a woman taken in adultery. Having set her in the midst, they told him, “Teacher, we found this woman in adultery, in the very act. Now in our law, Moses commanded us to stone such women. What then do you say about her?”" — John 8:3-5

WEB

Jesus, standing up, saw her and said, “Woman, where are your accusers? Did no one condemn you?” She said, “No one, Lord.” Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go your way. From now on, sin no more.”" — John 8:10-11

WEB

Ephesians 4:15 joins two things that people often separate: truth and love, spoken together. Proverbs 15:1 says how tone decides whether a conversation heats or cools. The story in John 8 is not about youth ministry, and it is not a rule about how to teach on any topic. But it shows how Jesus treated a person who had been made into a public case: the crowd wanted an answer to a question about her, and he turned, looked at her, asked her a question, and spoke to her as a person. It is a pattern for the way a leader may treat a young person whose question has put them in the middle of a room.

1. First, how the question is received

A young person who asks a hard question has already done something brave. They have decided that someone might listen. In their experience, adults often react to hard questions in one of four ways: alarm ("Where did you hear that?"), a lecture (a long answer that ignores what was asked), a joke to escape, or a closed door ("We don't talk about that here"). Each one answers a different question from the one asked. All of them tell the young person that the topic is dangerous and that they should take it elsewhere. Where they take it is often to a screen, to a friend with no more knowledge than they have, or to nobody.

A gentler reception has three parts, and all three come before the content of the answer.

  1. Thank the person for asking. "That is a real question, and I am glad you asked it." This costs nothing and changes the room.
  2. Slow down. A hard question does not need a fast answer. "Let me think about that" is an honest sentence.
  3. Find out what is behind it. "What made you think of that?" A question about hell may be a question about a grandmother who has died. A question about war may come from a young person whose relatives live in a place where there is fighting. A question about alcohol may come from a home where it is a problem. The words are rarely the whole question.

Proverbs 15:1 puts the matter in one line. The way a hard question is received is more powerful than the answer, and much more likely to be remembered.

2. Five habits for a hard conversation

1. Shame no one for a question. No question is stupid, and no young person is bad for asking. This does not mean every answer is right. It means the person is safe even when the idea is mistaken. A leader who says, "I'm shocked you would ask that" has taught fifteen young people never to ask again. If a question is asked to provoke, answer calmly. Provocation seeks a reaction, and a calm answer often ends it.

2. Be honest about the limits of what you know and what you may say. Say "I do not know" when you do not know. Say "That is a question for your parents" or "Let us ask our priest or pastor" when it is. Say "Our community teaches this" when you are speaking for the community and "I think this" when you are speaking for yourself, and do not blur the two. A young person trusts a leader who says, "Here is what my church teaches, here is where other Christians think differently, and here is where I am not sure." That is not weakness. It is the habit of a teacher who is telling the truth.

3. Leave out the graphic. Young people do not need detail to be told the truth. Sexual matters, violence, abuse, self-harm and drug use can all be spoken of with dignity and without description. Name what is needed, in plain and respectful words, and stop. If the group begins to compete in shocking details, say gently, "We do not need the details to talk about this," and bring the talk back. Do not describe methods of self-harm or suicide at all. If someone raises them, take the young person aside afterward.

4. Do no teaching in secret. What a youth leader teaches to young people on matters touching family values should not be a surprise to their parents. Parents entrust their children to a community and have a right to know in general terms what is taught. The simplest way is to tell them: a letter or a brief meeting at the start of a term that says, "This term we will talk about friendships and relationships, about handling pressure, and about how Christians think about money and power. Here is the outline. Come and speak with us." Parents may disagree; some may ask for their child to be excused. Listen. A leader who is ready to explain is rarely a leader who has anything to hide.

5. Choose the right person. Not every adult in the community should answer every question. Some topics are best handled by a pastor, priest, catechist or youth worker with training and the trust of the community. Others belong at home. Some are best met in a group, and others privately. A young person's question may be best answered by a trusted adult of the same sex or by a doctor, a counsellor or a teacher. A good leader knows when to say, "This is bigger than I should handle alone. Let me find the right person to help." That is not a failure of nerve. It is the same habit that makes a youth worker one adult among several.

3. The topics

It is useful to look at the topics that arise, one by one, not to give a view but to name the posture.

Sexuality and relationships. Young people live among many views and many messages. A leader's task is not to compete with them in loudness but to offer a community where the subject can be spoken of with respect. When you state what your community teaches, state it plainly, without contempt for anyone who lives differently, and without presenting it as the only view young people will meet. Treat every young person as a person made in God's image, including those who are unsure of themselves, those who are attracted to someone of the same sex, and those whose families do not live as the church teaches. A young person who senses that they must hide who they are to belong will leave; one who senses contempt will leave faster. Questions about one's own body, about pressure, about a relationship that frightens them, or about something that has been done to them are not a topic for discussion in the group. They are a young person asking for help: see the last section.

Politics. Politics may mean elections, a national dispute, a war, race, nation, migration, or the way a government treats a group. Young people are often more engaged than adults suppose, and are shaped by what is said at home. A youth leader should not use the group to recruit for a party or to pronounce on a current dispute as though the faith settled it. It is right to speak of justice, mercy and truth as Scripture does, to teach young people to listen to those who disagree, and to take seriously the troubles of members whose families are touched by conflict. A young person may disagree with their parents on a political question, and the leader's task is not to take a side in the family.

Doubt. Lecture 4-2 spoke of doubt in the small group. It belongs here too, because "What if God isn't real?" is the hardest question many young people ask. Thank, ask, wait, answer honestly, or say you will find out.

Violence. Young people may meet violence through the news, a game, a school, a neighbourhood or a home. Some have lived through it. Speak with care. Do not describe cruel acts. Do not assume that a young person's calm means they are untouched. Allow silence. If a young person has been hurt or fears being hurt, that is a matter for notice, stay and pass on.

Substances. Young people meet alcohol, tobacco, vaping and drugs in different ways in different places. In some countries drinking is part of family and festival life, and in others it is forbidden by law or faith. Say what your community teaches and why, in plain words, without alarm. Avoid exaggeration, which young people detect at once and which makes the rest of what you say harder to believe. Do not treat a young person who has tried something as beyond hope. If you fear a young person is in danger, tell the person responsible.

4. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that the hardest topics, especially sexuality, belong at home and with clergy, not in a youth gathering. Their strongest reason is that these matters touch the deepest convictions of a family, and a youth leader who speaks on them takes a place that belongs to parents. A young person's questions should be carried to the people who know the whole child. Others hold that the youth group is exactly where such questions should be met, because young people are meeting these matters already, from every voice but the church's, and a silent church is also a teacher. Their strongest reason is that a young person who cannot ask in a safe place will ask in an unsafe one. Many communities do both: some topics at home and with clergy, some in the group, a few in a special series with parents informed beforehand. This course does not choose between them. It requires less than any one of them requires: honesty and dignity, no graphic detail, parents informed of what is taught, and no young person shamed for a question. A community that does these four, whichever place it chooses, will not harm the young people in its care. A community that fails any of them will, even with the best of aims.

5. When you do not know

The most useful sentence in this lecture may be "I do not know." It is not an escape. It is true more often than leaders admit, and it models the honesty you ask of young people. Follow it with a promise you can keep: "I will find out and tell you next week," or "I will ask our pastor and we can talk with her together." Then keep the promise.

When the right person is a parent, say it kindly. "That is something your mum or dad will have a view on, and I would like you to talk to them. If it would help, I can talk to them with you." Do not hand a young person back to a home where it may not be safe to ask. If you suspect it is not safe, that is itself a thing to pass on.

When the right person is a pastor or priest, offer to arrange it. A young person who is told "ask your priest" and is left to do so alone may never go. A young person who is told "I will ask whether he can see you on Thursday, and I can come" may go.

6. When the question is a signal

Most questions are what they seem: curiosity, searching, an attempt to understand. Some are not. A young person may ask a general question that is really about themselves: "What happens to someone who hurts themselves?" "If somebody tells you a secret, do you have to tell?" "Is it wrong when an older person touches you?" The framing is a test. It asks whether the adult can be trusted with the real thing.

If you meet such a question, remember notice, stay, pass on. Notice that the question may be about the young person. Stay: stay calm, stay kind, and do not interrogate. Let them know you are glad they asked. Do not promise to keep a secret; if something harmful is happening, you cannot. Then pass on what you have heard to the person responsible in your community, and follow the written policy and local law. If anyone is in immediate danger, call the local emergency number. Lecture 3-3 describes this in detail. A youth leader is not a counsellor, doctor or police officer, and does not need to be. The leader's task is to be the adult who heard, and who did not look away.


Diagram 1. A hard question arrives: the path of the first minute

When a Hard Question Arrives Receive it first. Then decide who should answer, and where. 1 Thank, slow down, ask what is behind it "That is a real question. What made you think of it?" 2 Is the question about the young person, or about someone in danger? The words may not be the whole question. Listen for what the framing is testing. Possibly yes Notice. Stay calm and kind. Promise no secrecy. Tell the person responsible; follow written policy and local law. Immediate danger: call the local emergency number. A real question about the world Say whether you speak for the community or for yourself. Use plain words. No graphic detail. Shame nobody. Say "I do not know" when it is true. 3 Who is the right person? You, now; parents; pastor or priest; a doctor or counsellor. Offer to arrange it and to come. Always Parents know in general what is taught. The door stays open for the next question. Four requirements, whichever place a community chooses for hard topics: honesty and dignity, no graphic detail, parents informed, no one shamed for a question.

In short

  • How a hard question is received decides whether young people ask again; thank, slow down and find out what is behind it.
  • Five habits: shame no one for a question, be honest about limits, leave out the graphic, teach nothing in secret, and choose the right person.
  • Say whether you speak for the community or for yourself, and say "I do not know" when it is true, with a promise you keep.
  • Communities differ on where hard topics belong; this course requires honesty and dignity, no graphic detail, parents informed and no one shamed.
  • Some questions are really about the asker; notice, stay and pass on, promise no secrecy, and call the local emergency number for immediate danger.
  • John 8 shows Jesus turning from a crowd's question about a woman to speak to her as a person.
Front Back
Receiving a hard question Thank the person, slow down, and ask what is behind it before answering.
Five habits No shame, honest limits, no graphic detail, no secret teaching, the right person.
When you do not know Say so, promise to find out, and keep the promise.
A question that is a signal Notice, stay, pass on; promise no secrecy; emergency number for immediate danger.

One sentence to remember Before you answer a hard question, make it safe to have asked it.

This week's action Write the sentence you would say aloud to thank a young person for a hard question, and say it to yourself three times.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Recall a time when, as a young person, you asked an adult a hard question. How was it received? What did you learn about whether to ask again?
  • Of the four common reactions (alarm, a lecture, a joke, a closed door), which is your own first reaction under pressure? What could help you to pause?
  • Your community has a view on at least one of the topics in this lecture. Can you state it plainly, in a sentence, without contempt for anyone who sees it differently? Try it aloud.
  • How would you tell parents what will be talked about this term? What would you do if a parent disagreed or asked that their child be excused?
  • Who in your community is the right person to ask about each of the topics, if you do not know? Have you ever asked them?
  • Why is the question "If somebody tells you a secret, do you have to tell?" worth listening to carefully? What would you say?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.