Lecture 6-1: The Carer's Own Losses
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Grief in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Death, Funeral and Remembrance
- Lecture 1-3: Grief Is Love in Another Form
- Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Death and Loss
- Lecture 2-1: The First Days
- Lecture 2-2: The Funeral Season Beside the Family
- Lecture 2-3: Words That Hurt, Words That Help
- Lecture 2-4: Practical Help That Is Specific
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A First Visit
- Lecture 3-1: Sudden Death
- Lecture 3-2: Long Illness, and the Death of an Older Person
- Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth
- Lecture 3-4: Suicide Loss: Standing Beside Without Stigma
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Standing Differently for Different Losses
- Lecture 4-1: Grieving Children
- Lecture 4-2: Grieving Teenagers
- Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family
- Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Talking With a Child, Standing Between Relatives
- Lecture 5-1: Anniversaries and the Long Months
- Lecture 5-2: Long Accompaniment
- Lecture 5-3: When Grief Needs More Help: Noticing and Connecting
- Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases and an Anniversary Card
For five weeks this course has looked outward: at the bereaved, at the family, at the funeral, at the long months afterwards. This last week turns to the person who does the looking. A church carer is not a machine that takes in other people's sorrow and gives out comfort. A carer is a person who has lost people too, who will lose more, and who sits down beside a grieving family carrying a history of their own.
This lecture asks what happens to a carer's own grief when they care for the bereaved, how to notice when an old loss has been stirred, and how to take care of it, so that the carer neither hides it nor lays it on the family they came to help. The central claim of the course comes to its fullest form here: grief is not an illness; it is love in another form. A church carer is not a fixer but someone who stays beside. The carer does not hurry, does not prescribe stages, helps more by presence than by words, and connects to professionals when more help is needed. The carer has losses and limits too.
This course is not grief therapy, and it gives no medical or psychological advice. Nothing in this lecture asks you to tell your own story to anyone, and nothing asks you to work on a loss of your own. It asks you to know that you have one, to notice when it moves, and to know where you would take it.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Explain why a carer's own bereavements do not disappear when the carer begins to care for others, and why that is not a failure.
- Name some ways an old or recent loss can be stirred by caring for someone else, in the body, in feeling, in memory and in faith.
- Describe the difference between a loss that deepens a carer's presence and a loss that begins to take over the visit.
- Name three simple practices for protecting both the carer and the family: saying less about your own loss, choosing when to step back, and having someone to tell.
- Explain why a carer may need to say "not this one, not now" without shame, and how a team can make that easy.
- Describe how a carer in a small group and a carer in a large agency can each find someone to carry their own loss alongside them, and when a doctor or counsellor is the right next step.
Jesus wept." — John 11:35
World English Bible
Lord, all my desire is before you. My groaning is not hidden from you." — Psalm 38:9
WEB
Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of mercies and God of all comfort;" — 2 Corinthians 1:3
WEB
who comforts us in all our affliction, that we may be able to comfort those who are in any affliction, through the comfort with which we ourselves are comforted by God." — 2 Corinthians 1:4
WEB
Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God! For I shall still praise him for the saving help of his presence." — Psalm 42:5
WEB
John 11:35 is the shortest verse in the passage we met in Week 1: Jesus wept, at a grave, among people he loved. Whatever else is said about carers, the one who stayed beside the bereaved was himself moved to tears. Psalm 38:9 is the prayer of a person who has no need to explain a sorrow to God: all desire is before him, and the groaning is not hidden. A carer may pray that verse about their own heart as well as about the family's. In 2 Corinthians 1:3-4 Paul does not describe a comforter who has no pain. He describes people who comfort because they have been comforted, and who pass on what was given to them. A carer is first a person who receives. Psalm 42:5 is a person talking to their own soul, asking why it is cast down, and answering with hope; it does not pretend the soul is calm. None of these verses is an instruction to be strong. They are permission to be a person.
The carer is also bereaved
Almost everyone who sits beside a grieving family has been bereaved already. A grandparent died when the carer was a child. A friend moved away and never wrote, and that was a loss too. A pregnancy ended. A parent died long ago, or last year. A colleague was lost. A marriage ended, a country was left behind, a church was closed. Lecture 1-3 spoke of the many shapes of grief, and the carer's own life will have several of them in it.
Some of these losses are old and quiet. Some are recent and sore. Some the carer has never spoken of, because nobody asked, or because the community did not recognise them. Some were hard relationships, where the grief is mixed with anger or relief. None of them is cancelled by the fact that the carer now holds an office, a badge or a rota.
So the first thing to say plainly is that a carer's own grief is not a flaw in the carer. It is not a sign of weak faith, or of being unfit for the work. It is a sign that the carer loves, and has lived. Indeed, a carer who has lost people often finds that they can sit in silence more easily, because they know what words fail to do. That is one of the gifts of the work. But the same history can make a visit heavy, and a carer who does not know this may be taken by surprise.
What can be stirred
It is hard to list how an old loss will move, because people differ. What follows is a short list of things carers have often said after a visit, put in plain words. They are not stages, and nobody has all of them.
In the body. A tight chest in the doorway. Tiredness that feels too large for the hour. Difficulty sleeping that night. A lump in the throat when a certain song, or a certain kind of room, or the smell of a certain food, is present.
In feeling. Sudden tears that are not for the family in front of you. Anger at the family, or at someone else, that does not seem to fit. A numb flatness. A wish to be somewhere else. Envy that a family is surrounded by relatives when the carer's own loss was quiet. Relief, and then shame at the relief.
In memory. A scene from your own life returns without being called. You find yourself in the past while the family is in the present. You hear yourself about to say, "When my father died..." and stop.
In faith. An old question returns: Why was it not answered when I asked? A prayer you have said easily becomes difficult. A verse that comforted others sounds hollow in your own mouth.
None of these means that the carer is doing the work badly, and none needs to be hidden in shame. They are information. The carer's task is to notice them, and then to decide, calmly, what to do.
Deepening and taking over
There is a useful distinction, not a rule, between a loss that deepens a carer's presence and a loss that takes over the visit.
When a carer's own loss deepens presence, the carer feels something stir, lets it rest in the background, and stays focused on the family. The carer may find that they listen more slowly. They may find that they are less afraid of silence. Their own sorrow gives them a quiet respect for the family's sorrow. Afterwards they notice that they are tired, perhaps tearful, and they take care of that on their own time.
When a carer's own loss takes over, the visit starts to be about the carer. The carer talks about their own bereavement for long stretches. The carer compares ("I know exactly how you feel"), which no one can. The carer tries to fix the family's situation because they could not fix their own. The carer becomes angry on behalf of the family in a way the family did not ask for. Or the carer grows so anxious about their own tears that they cannot be present at all and leave quickly. Any of these can happen to a loving carer. None of them is a moral failure. But each one is a sign that the carer needs to step back, and that someone else should take the next visit.
It helps to ask three honest questions before and after a visit:
- Whose sorrow is mostly in the room, theirs or mine?
- Am I here because they need something, or because I need something?
- Do I want to talk because it would help them, or because I cannot bear the silence?
These questions are not meant to produce guilt. They are meant to give the carer a moment of honesty. The answers can change from one visit to another.
Saying less about your own loss
Carers often ask whether it is right to speak of their own loss to a grieving person. There is no single rule, and this course does not offer one. But some careful guidance can be given.
A brief, true sentence can be a gift. "I lost my mother some years ago. I do not know what this is like for you, but I know something of how heavy it can be." Said once, with a pause, it can tell a family that they are not alone, and then the carer returns the attention to them. It should not be a story. The family has not come to hear one, and they may feel they must now comfort the carer.
It is better to say less than more, for three reasons. First, a family in fresh grief has little room to hold another person's. Second, comparing can sound like a ranking ("mine was worse", or "mine was easier"), which no one wants. Third, a carer who is not sure how their own story will land should not use the family to find out. If you notice an urge to tell the whole story, treat it as a signal that you need a listener of your own, and keep the story for that person.
It is also right not to claim a loss you have not had. A carer who has never lost a child does not say, "I know how you feel." They say, "I cannot know how this is for you. I am here."
Stepping back, without shame
Sometimes the right thing is to say, "Not this one, not now." A carer who has recently lost someone may find that a particular family's loss is too near to their own, a similar death, a similar age, a similar relationship, a similar season. A carer who is beginning a new bereavement of their own should not take a bereaved family's care as a distraction from it. A carer who has just had a difficult funeral, or two in a row, may simply be too tired.
Stepping back is not abandoning the family. It is handing the next visit to someone else, with a warm word, and not leaving it to chance. It is much kinder to the family if a carer says to the team leader, "Could someone else take this family for the next month?" than if the carer goes on and does it badly, or stops answering the phone.
For this to work, a team must make it easy. That means three things. First, the leader says openly, at the start, that anyone may step back from any family at any time, without giving a reason, and nobody will ask. Second, the leader does not use the phrase "we are short of people" as a pressure to stay. Third, when a carer steps back, the team says thank you, as it would to anyone who has done good work.
A small group may have only two or three people who could visit. Then the answer may be that the group asks for help from outside: from a neighbouring congregation, from the area minister, from a volunteer from another church who has been trained. The group should not simply make the one person do it. That is the theme of lecture 6-2.
Having someone to tell
Every carer needs a person, or two, to whom they can tell the truth about their work. This is sometimes called supervision or debriefing, and sometimes it is only a friend. In a larger church or agency, there may be a formal arrangement. In a house church there may be only a trusted older member, or a minister from another congregation, or a friend who is a nurse. What matters is that the carer has:
- someone who is not part of the family or the case and who will keep what is said to themselves;
- someone who will listen without fixing, as the carer listens to others;
- a regular time, even if short, so that it does not depend on a crisis;
- and clear limits on what is said, because confidentiality still applies. A carer may speak of their own feelings and of how the work affects them without naming the family or giving details that would identify them. Where the carer must discuss details, for example with a supervisor who has the same duty of confidence, this should be agreed in advance, and the limits differ by country, region and role: check locally.
A carer's own minister, priest or spiritual director is a natural person to tell. So is a counsellor, if the carer wishes. Some carers pray with a partner after each visit. Some write a few lines in a private notebook that no one else will read, and destroy it or keep it safe as they see fit. Each of these is a way of letting grief out of the body so that it does not leak into the next visit.
When it is more than ordinary sorrow
Most of the time, a carer's own sorrow, stirred by someone else's, will rise and settle again. Sometimes it does not. A carer may find that for many weeks they cannot sleep, cannot eat, cannot stop crying, cannot take interest in anything, or feel they cannot go on. A carer may find that a loss they thought long past has returned with a weight they cannot carry. These things are not weakness. They are a sign that the carer is a person who needs the same help that the carer would suggest to someone else.
The advice of the course to the carer is the advice the carer would give: talk to a doctor or counsellor, and say, "It is not because I am weak. It is because this is heavy." The carer does not decide what the heaviness is, and does not name it. The mental-health course for church leaders explains how to notice when someone needs more than company, and that applies to carers too. If the carer ever finds themselves wishing to die, or wishing to join someone who has died, this is a matter for the crisis course, and the carer should tell a trusted person at once and not wait.
Small and large communities
(an invented example) A house church in a flat has about fifteen members. Last winter its most senior member, Mr Takahashi, died. Mrs Dlamini had been the one in the group who usually visited families in grief, and she had also been fond of Mr Takahashi. When a young father in the neighbourhood died a month later and his wife asked the group for help, Mrs Dlamini found she could not go. She said so to the host of the group, a retired nurse named Mrs Kowalczyk. Mrs Kowalczyk did not argue. She asked her own sister, who attended a larger church two streets away, whether anyone there might visit once a week with her. A visitor from that church came, and Mrs Kowalczyk went with her the first time, and then stopped going. Mrs Dlamini was asked only for one thing: to ring the visitor once a fortnight and say thank you. After three months she said, "I think I can take a visit now." The group had held her place for her.
(an invented example) A large mission agency has a staff care team of six people. A member of the team, Mr Oduya, was asked to follow up on the family of a colleague who had died. He realised, half an hour before the first call, that the colleague's age and situation were very like those of his own brother some years before. He did not go. He told the team leader, and the leader asked a second member to take the call. Mr Oduya then used the agency's regular debriefing time to talk, with no details, of what had risen in him. The agency's habit was that anyone on the team could say "I am too close to this" and a note would be entered, without comment, in the rota. In a large agency the strength is a system that makes stepping back ordinary; the risk is that no one notices a quiet carer who never asks.
In both places the same few things held: someone noticed, someone said it aloud, someone else took over, and the first carer was welcomed back later.
What the carer is not required to do
This lecture is not asking the carer to heal their own grief, or to finish it, or to be ready before they can help. People are never finished with their losses. It is not asking the carer to tell their story, to a group or a family. It is not asking the carer to be calm. It is asking only that the carer knows that they have losses, that these will sometimes move, and that they have a place to take them. A carer who knows that is already safer, and kinder, than one who believes they are untouched.
Summary of what to remember
A carer is a person who has lost people. Caring for the bereaved will sometimes stir those losses in the body, in feeling, in memory and in faith. This is not a failing. The carer notices, asks whose sorrow is in the room, says less about their own loss, steps back without shame when a visit is too near, and has someone to tell. When the weight is heavy for a long time, the carer seeks a doctor or counsellor, as they would suggest to anyone else.
6-1. When the carer's own loss is stirred
6-2. Deepening or taking over
In short
- A carer is a bereaved person too; their own losses do not vanish when they begin to care, and having them is not a failing.
- Caring for the grieving can stir old or recent losses in the body, in feeling, in memory and in faith.
- A loss that deepens presence is a gift; a loss that takes over the visit is a sign to step back.
- Say less about your own loss, never claim one you have not had, and keep your story for a listener of your own.
- Saying "not this one, not now" is not abandonment, and a team makes it easy by saying so first and by handing on warmly.
- Every carer needs someone to tell, within the limits of confidentiality (check locally); when the weight is heavy for long, see a doctor or counsellor; a wish to die goes to the crisis course.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The carer's own losses | Real, not a fault; they may be stirred in body, feeling, memory and faith. |
| Deepening or taking over | Attention stays on the family, or the visit becomes about the carer; the second is a sign to step back. |
| Three honest questions | Whose sorrow is in the room? Why am I here? Why do I want to talk? |
| Stepping back | "Not this one, not now"; hand on warmly; the team says thank you and does not ask why. |
| Someone to tell | A person outside the case who listens without fixing; confidentiality still applies, check locally. |
One sentence to remember The carer who knows they have losses of their own is safer and kinder than the one who believes they are untouched.
This week's action Write down, without names, the kinds of people you could go to if a visit stirred something in you, and the one you will ask first.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think in general terms (you need not say anything aloud) of the kinds of loss a carer in your community may already carry. Which of them would your community recognise, and which might it overlook?
- Which of the three questions (whose sorrow, why am I here, why do I want to talk) is hardest for you to answer honestly?
- Is there a kind of loss that you would find it hard to sit beside at present? How could your team make it easy to say "not this one, not now"?
- Who is the person, or who could be the person, to whom you can tell the truth about your work? What would you need to ask them?
- What does it ask of a team leader to say aloud, at the start, that anyone may step back without giving a reason?